Andrew Gordon (@accounting) header
Andrew Gordon (@accounting) profile picture

Crypto Tax Attorney & CPA | Helping 1,000+ clients crush crypto taxes & beat IRS audits | Chicago | Not legal advice | Book a call 👇

Chicago, IL
Joined July 2007
Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)Photo by Andrew Gordon (@accounting)
We could generate billions in crypto tax revenue from people who want to pay. They’re not hiding. They’re confused and scared of getting crushed for mistakes. 1099-DA Forms are putting the crypto industry in a terrible position: comply perfectly or risk penalties. There’s a solution: a Crypto Voluntary Disclosure Program. Let people come forward, pay tax + a manageable penalty, and move on. In the past, a voluntary disclosure program allowed people to come forward, report their assets, pay a small penalty and tax, and move on. We need the same type of program for the crypto industry. #CryptoTaxes #Crypto #GordonLaw
13
13
3
64
20,563
Selling crypto to get into the Anthropic IPO this week? That sale is taxable. Hypothetical, 1 BTC sold at $64,000: Bought at $30,000 in 2023: $34,000 gain, $5,100 federal tax at 15% Bought at $100,000 in 2025: $36,000 loss Same price, same day. Pick your lot before you sell.
1
4
1,048
California voters just banned new taxes on owning crypto (Prop 42). Illinois passed a 0.2% tax on moving or storing it via a broker, from July 2027. Withdraw $50K of BTC to your wallet: California: $0 Illinois: $100 if your exchange charges a fee Where would you keep yours?
1
2
1,138
Bitcoin is near $64K. Bought in the last year at a higher price? Sell and it's a short-term loss. ST losses offset ST gains first, and those are taxed like wages. Hypothetical: $10k ST loss vs $10k ST gain in the 24% bracket = $2,400 saved. Harvesting before Dec 31?
2
460
Trump is talking about replacing the federal income tax with tariffs again. If you sold crypto in 2026, here's what that means for you: Nothing. Yet. A comment isn't a law. Repealing the income tax would take an act of Congress. Your 2026 return is still due April 15, 2027. Every crypto sale, swap, and spend from this year still goes on Form 8949. And brokers will send 1099-DAs that report your proceeds to the IRS. Here's the trap I'm worried about. Someone hears "no more income tax" and decides to sit on their return. Hypothetical: a $30,000 long-term crypto gain in 2026, taxed at 15%. That's $4,500 of tax. File and pay late, and the combined penalty is generally 5% of the unpaid tax per month. Five months late = about $1,125 on top of the $4,500. Plus interest. All while waiting on a law that doesn't exist. Can't pay in full? File anyway. The late-filing penalty is about 10x the late-payment one. What I'd do instead: 1. Pull your full 2026 exchange and wallet history now 2. Match your cost basis before the 1099-DAs show up 3. Harvest losses before Dec 31 if you have them 4. File on time, even if you think the rules might change And if you've missed prior years, don't wait for a repeal to save you. I helped write Section 502 of H.R. 10357, a proposed low-penalty path for fixing honest crypto mistakes. It isn't law yet. Today's rules are the ones that apply. Would you change your filing plans because of a headline?
1
10
5,530
Crypto tax isn't hard because of the rates. It's hard because buying a $5 coffee with BTC is a taxable sale. Sen. Lummis has proposed a $300 small-purchase exemption. Others have too. None has passed. Should a $5 coffee really go on your tax return?
9
2
18
5,270
Stablecoin supply fell $14.2B in 30 days, its steepest drop since 2022, per Glassnode. Swapped USDT for USDC? Cashed USDC out? Each one is a sale. Gain is usually near $0, but it still goes on your return. Your broker may not report small stablecoin sales. You still have to.
2
2
568
The IRS CEO just said this about 2027: "Things that we could get to only 3% of the opportunity, we're going to get into 100." Frank Bisignano was talking about AI. He calls it "super intelligence." He said it should help the government collect more revenue. Here's what that means if there's a crypto mistake on an old return. For 2025 sales, brokers started sending the IRS Form 1099-DA. Matching those forms against returns used to be limited by people and time. That's exactly the kind of limit AI could remove. Hypothetical: You left $40,000 of short-term crypto gains off your 2025 return. If it all lands in the 22% bracket, that's $8,800 of federal tax. If the IRS finds it first, you can owe a 20% accuracy-related penalty on top. That's another $1,760. Plus interest. If you fix it first, with an amended return filed before the IRS contacts you, it's generally a "qualified amended return." That penalty usually doesn't apply. You still owe the tax and the interest. There are exceptions, including some IRS summonses sent to exchanges, so talk to a pro before you amend. Same mistake. Different bill. The only difference is who found it first. What I'd do before year-end: 1. Pull every 1099-DA and your full exchange history for 2025. 2. Compare the proceeds to what you actually reported. 3. Find your real cost basis before you assume the worst. 4. If something's missing, amend before a letter shows up. This is why I helped write Section 502 of H.R. 10357, a proposed low-penalty path for people who made honest crypto mistakes. It's not law yet. Today, a clean amended return is still the best move you have. Would you rather fix it now, or wait to see if the IRS finds it first?
1
2
4
2,578
Yesterday I posted that Illinois' Digital Asset Tax Act can charge 0.2% just for moving your own crypto. One reply summed it up: "being taxed for moving your own money is wild." Illinois doesn't tax you for moving cash from checking to savings. Why should crypto be different?
1
6
659
I run a crypto tax firm in Illinois. My state passed a tax that can charge you just for moving your own crypto. Not on gains. On the full value. It's called the Digital Asset Tax Act. It puts a 0.2% tax on the value of a digital asset when an Illinois customer exchanges, transfers, or stores it through a broker. No sale required. No profit required. Hypothetical: You hold $50,000 of Bitcoin on an exchange and withdraw it to your own wallet. Under the state's proposed rules, that can be a taxable transfer when the exchange charges for it. That's $100 of Illinois tax. You made $0. You swap $50,000 of ETH into SOL at a loss. Another $100. Your federal return shows a loss. Illinois still gets paid. It was set to start Jan. 1, 2027. The state agreed to pause it until July 1, 2027, and the court signed off, while the lawsuits play out. This month the U.S. Justice Department, the U.S. Chamber, SIFMA, a16z, Paradigm, and Uniswap all filed in support of the challenge. No court has ruled on the merits yet. If you live in Illinois: 1. Make sure every exchange has your current address. Brokers use it to decide if the tax applies. 2. Keep your own transfer log, not just your trade history. 3. If a broker doesn't collect it, you may have to report and pay it yourself. 4. Already planning to move coins to self-custody? On the current schedule, a move before July 1, 2027 lands before the tax starts. That date could still change, and self-custody means guarding your own keys. Talk to a pro before you restructure anything. Federal tax mostly cares about your gains. This one charges you for moving. Should a state be able to tax a transfer between your own accounts?
8
1
1
20
5,454
The IRS just set the 2027 401(k) limit at $25,500. Hypothetical single filer, $75k salary: $75,000 - $25,500 pre-tax 401(k) - $16,600 standard deduction = $32,900 taxable The 0% capital gains band runs to $51,050. That's $18,150 of long-term crypto gains at 0%. Maxing yours?
1
2
639
A 22-year-old asking how bad it is to never file taxes went viral. Lots of replies said relax. Crypto changes that. Exchanges now send the IRS a 1099-DA. Sold $20k of BTC at a loss, basis box blank? The IRS sees $20k of proceeds. Don't file and it can treat it all as gain.
1
7
1,267
A proposed UK law would let HMRC demand tax info from "anything" that holds it. Advisers say that could include AI chats. U.S. tax-advice privilege (§7525) covers only some advice from tax pros like CPAs and EAs. A chatbot isn't one. Asking AI to "optimize" your crypto gains?
1
462
Square just finished turning on Bitcoin payments for eligible U.S. merchants. If you run a business and keep those sales in Bitcoin, you now have two tax events, not one. Most owners will only see the first. When a customer pays you in Bitcoin, that's business income. You report it at the dollar value at the moment you got paid, same as a card sale. That dollar value becomes your cost basis in the coins. When you later sell or spend them, that's a second event: a capital gain or loss. Hypothetical: a coffee shop, run as a sole proprietorship, keeps $10,000 of November sales in Bitcoin. That's $10,000 of business income for 2026, even if the coins are never sold. In March, Bitcoin is up 20% and the owner sells for $12,000. That's a $2,000 short-term gain on top. Now flip it. Bitcoin drops 40% and the owner sells for $6,000. The $10,000 still counted toward profit, and toward self-employment tax. The $4,000 is a capital loss. With no other gains, only $3,000 offsets ordinary income this year. The rest carries forward. And that loss doesn't reduce self-employment tax at all. If you turn this on: 1. Choose dollars or Bitcoin on purpose. Dollars is the default, and it means no second event. 2. Record every Bitcoin-paid sale as revenue at its dollar value. 3. Treat each payment as its own lot. Square says later sales go on a 1099-DA, but the payments you receive don't, so keep your own records. 4. Set aside the tax in dollars, not Bitcoin. Square's fees are 0% through Dec 31. The tax isn't. Business owners: would you keep your sales in Bitcoin?
1
1
450
Answers to yesterday's quiz: 1. Swap ETH for SOL: Y. A swap is a sale. 2. BTC between your own wallets: N. 3. Coffee with BTC: Y. Spending is selling. 4. Buy BTC with dollars: N. That just sets your basis. 5. Property tax with BTC: Y. How many did you get right?
Taxable or not taxable? 1. Swap ETH for SOL 2. Move BTC between your own wallets 3. Buy a coffee with BTC 4. Buy BTC with dollars 5. Pay your property tax with BTC Reply Y or N for each. Answers tomorrow.
3
3
619
A crypto gain can't push all your income into a higher bracket. Hypothetical, 2027, single: $46,050 of ordinary taxable income, plus a $10,000 long-term gain. $5,000 of the gain is taxed at 0%. $5,000 at 15%. Tax on the gain: $750, not $1,500. Thought it worked differently?
1
495
Miami-Dade just announced homeowners can pay property taxes in Bitcoin. Here's the part the headlines left out. Paying with Bitcoin isn't paying with cash. To the IRS, it's selling Bitcoin. Every time you spend crypto, you report a gain or loss: what the coins were worth when you spent them, minus what you paid. Hypothetical: your property tax bill is $8,000. Florida gives a 4% discount if you pay in November, so you owe $7,680. You pay with Bitcoin you bought years ago for $2,000. That's a $5,680 long-term capital gain. At 15%, about $852 of federal tax for paying a tax. Now flip it. Say you also hold Bitcoin bought near the top. The coins you spend are worth $7,680 but cost you $10,000. Pay with those and you lock in a $2,320 capital loss instead (short-term if held a year or less). Same bill. One way you report a $5,680 gain. The other, a $2,320 loss. The county gets $7,680 either way. Your Bitcoin is converted to dollars the moment you pay. Before you pay any bill with crypto: 1. Pick the coins on purpose, and pay from the wallet or account that holds them. For coins at a broker, you can identify the lot in your own records through Dec 31, 2026. 2. Save the receipt with the date, time and dollar amount. 3. Report it on Form 8949 like any other sale. 4. The property tax can still be an itemized deduction, subject to the SALT cap. Florida has no state income tax. The federal bill still applies. Would you pay your property taxes in Bitcoin?
4
7
2,072
Taxable or not taxable? 1. Swap ETH for SOL 2. Move BTC between your own wallets 3. Buy a coffee with BTC 4. Buy BTC with dollars 5. Pay your property tax with BTC Reply Y or N for each. Answers tomorrow.
3
1
3
1,690
Bitcoin is around $74,000 this morning after a hot CPI print. Two people sell 1 BTC today, same exchange, same price. One reports a $44,000 gain. The other reports a $26,000 loss. The only difference is which coin they told the IRS they sold. Hypothetical: you hold 2 BTC in one exchange account. Coin A: bought in 2023 for $30,000. Coin B: bought in December 2024 for $100,000. You sell 1 BTC for $74,000. Do nothing and the default is FIFO: first in, first out. Coin A is treated as sold. That's a $44,000 long-term gain. Identify Coin B instead and it's a $26,000 long-term loss. That loss offsets other gains, then up to $3,000 of wages, and the rest carries forward. Now the part almost nobody knows. For coins held at a broker, the rules say you tell the broker which lot you're selling, at or before the sale. Most exchanges weren't ready. So Notice 2025-7, extended by Notice 2026-20, lets you identify the lot in your own records instead. That relief ends December 31, 2026. Unless the IRS extends it again, 2027 sales need the lot picked with your broker. Before you sell this year: 1. Write down the lot (purchase date and price) before you hit sell. 2. Keep that note with your tax records. 3. Lots only count in the account they sit in. 4. Check whether your exchange now lets you pick lots or set a standing order. Do you know which coins your exchange thinks you sold?
3
1
9
7,007
Got an IRS Letter 6174 about crypto? Don't stop at your Wage and Income Transcript. That transcript lists information returns, like 1099s. It isn't where John Doe summons data shows up. Here's why that matters. In 2017, a court ordered Coinbase to turn over records on more than 14,000 accounts with at least $20,000 of activity in a year. That meant names, addresses, and transaction records. Not 1099s. Courts later authorized John Doe summonses to Kraken, Circle (including Poloniex), and SFOX. The Poloniex part surprises people. Poloniex stopped serving U.S. customers in 2019. In 2021, a court still authorized the IRS to seek Circle and Poloniex records for 2016 through 2020. You may not be able to download that history anymore. The IRS had a court order to go after it. Letter 6174 is educational, and you don't have to respond. That doesn't mean the IRS has nothing on you. Hypothetical: you sold $40,000 of Bitcoin on Poloniex in 2018. No 1099 ever arrived, and your transcript is clean. The letter still showed up. The reason may be in a summons file, not on a form. Do this instead: 1. Download CSVs or API history from every exchange you ever used, including ones that left the U.S. 2. Search old emails for statements you exported years ago. 3. Rebuild your cost basis from those records. 4. Compare your returns against what a summons could have shown. Find a gap? Talk to a pro before you amend. Have you pulled the records from exchanges you can no longer log into?
1
1
3
933
Memecoin down 95% and still holding? No deduction yet. In the IRS's view, a token that still trades isn't "worthless" (CCA 202302011). Hypothetical: $10,000 in, $500 now. Sell before Dec 31 and you lock in a $9,500 capital loss. Selling or holding the bag?
2
1,012