Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans) header
Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans) profile picture

Ethereum community member and ETH investor

Joined April 2012
Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)Photo by Ryan Berckmans ⟠ (@ryanberckmans)
Ryan Berckmans ⟠ retweeted
Don't listen to the doomers. If you have cash on hand to get spot long great SoV tokens and/or revenue-generating DeFi businesses, you can make a killing right now. Sure, maybe we go lower, but at these levels, there are amazing entries for 6-12 months out from now. Maybe as little as 3 months. Buy peak fear is generally rewarded in this asset class.
22
20
2
246
19,011
The bear is ordinary, but this time *is* actually different. The whole world is coming onchain now. Don't F this up by overindexing on the short term.
8
7
1
87
2,915
Many people will be emotionally committed to a V-shaped recovery, instead of to the thesis. Your job is to not be one of them.
8
1
31
2,112
Ryan Berckmans ⟠ retweeted
HSBC, one of the world's largest banks with over $3 trillion in assets, has launched a tokenized class of its Hong Kong dollar money market fund on @ethereum, the only blockchain at launch. Customers can subscribe in the HSBC HK App from HK$100, using HSBC RedCoin, the bank's HKD stablecoin. The fund's explanatory memorandum describes the offering as "enabling permissioned activity on public blockchains." Ethereum is the home of onchain finance.
28
132
21
625
36,249
ETHBTC is showing resilience in these BTC/crypto crashes because eth's best days are ahead of us. We're on track to become the ubiquitous global hub. Onchain is winning. Lion's share is on eth. We'll continue growing L1 & L2 and ship frames and PQ. Future's extremely bright.
14
17
1
183
4,669
Prioritizing PQ ASAP (pqai27) is the best strategy for us because risk minimization is what makes ethereum special. Upgrading eth to be fully PQ is a huge job. FOCIL takes us much further from PQ. So it should be revamped or removed from Hegota. Simple, but not socially easy.
Quick take from my side after reading the recent posts from @potuz_eth, @ethlabs_org, @mikeneuder and @soispoke on PQAI. Definitely recommend reading all of them. Links below. Very short summary: Potuz and Ethlabs want to go all in on PQ and only ship what's really needed. Mike thinks rushing PQ is premature, but agrees that hardening the clients is super important. Thomas wants to parallelise and keep shipping non-PQ features like FOCIL. I think pqai will come with all kinds of threats, and AI getting better at finding bugs is the one we already experience. The PQ changes alone are already a lot of new code: new signatures, leanVM, much bigger messages on the p2p layer, new key handling. Every line of that needs to be understood by someone, tested and hardened. That's risky enough already, so I'd rather not add more features on top. For people hunting bugs, it makes a big difference whether a fork is Frames or Frames + FOCIL. More code means more to understand and test, more interactions, and that doesn't really parallelise. So I could see the PQ work being done as "slim" feature forks (Frames, leanVM, DC), with FOCIL coming back once we know what PQ consensus looks like. The only things I'd ship alongside are hardening and simplifications. I think in times where AI gets crazy good at breaking things, that kind of work will be very welcome. My comment: ethereum-magicians.org/t/tho… Potuz: potuz.net/posts/pq/ Ethlabs: ethereum-magicians.org/t/an-… Mike: hackmd.io/@mikeneuder/though… Thomas: ethereum-magicians.org/t/tho…
3
5
49
1,879
Ryan Berckmans ⟠ retweeted
Thoughts on pqai, Hegota, and FOCIL tldr: Let’s accelerate pqai without rushing or stopping everything else. We can parallelise workstreams to keep shipping EIPs that are ready while the cryptography, designs, and specs for PQ are being worked on and finalised. We need to accelerate Ethereum’s transition to post-quantum, post-AI cryptography. Let’s take this as a given. There are two ways to think about what we need to do to enable this acceleration. 1) We deprioritise everything that is not pqai critical. That means all the features we were planning to ship have to wait until after we switch to hash-based cryptography across all layers of the protocol. To me, the downside of this approach is that we put all our eggs in one basket: if we end up taking 3 years to ship pqai, then Ethereum doesn’t move, at all, for 3 years. That’s “full sequential” mode, and it doesn’t account for important parameters, including how ready features are and what skillsets we have among researchers and client teams (e.g., not everyone is a PQ expert). The only case in which this is inevitable is if we find out that there is an actual break in our cryptography. In that case, I would argue we should be ready to make choices that go far beyond pq2027 ones, and have a concrete plan for what we need to do if we have to ship a minimal, ugly, emergency fork in a couple of weeks. 2) We parallelise. We keep working on the core, minimal features that were already SFI’d by core devs and the community, while accelerating our transition to pqai. To me, this second approach makes sense when you look at where the forks are: - Glamsterdam is delayed: most of the work is reaching out and making sure smart contracts don’t break because of repricing EIPs. - Hegota is in its devnet phase and can keep progressing with FOCIL and Frames in the meantime. Some core devs in all client teams have already worked on these features, they are specced, and now it comes down to “making it work” on the implementation side. - Importantly, the major PQ/AI upgrades are not yet ready: the specs and the cryptography are not frozen (teapawt.net/soispoke/status/212091…). On the CL side, we don’t even know exactly what we mean by “PQ consensus” yet. Is it PQ Gasper? PQ Decoupled Consensus? With or without aggregation (and leanVM)? We need a lot more eyes on it, but it’s not realistic to think that all core devs across all teams would be able to chime in and accelerate progress there. Process-wise, I think it’s also important not to DFI features before we even know what we are going for. For example, we will realistically need more time to ship PQ DC than PQ Gasper, and we should ideally settle on which option to go for before making decisions about Hegota. In other words, the scenario I want to avoid is people DFI’ing features like FOCIL (and others) to get a false sense of security (“we deleted features, so surely we can go faster”), when the reality is more complex and nuanced. I also think these decisions hurt ACD’s credibility, and that we need a strong ACD the ecosystem can rely on, especially during times of uncertainty. Zooming in - On the EL, my opinion is that we need Frames for PQ (the only nuances are about how “light” Frames should be). In practice, we could also take the ugly/sequential approach there and ship another transaction type. But given the readiness of Frames, what they would unlock in Hegota and in the future (plus the fact that they’re already SFI’d, of course), there is no reason to settle for a hacky alternative. - On the CL, we can apply the same type of thinking. For FOCIL, I think the most reasonable path is to derisk it as much as possible so we ensure it is (1) forward compatible with PQ, and (2) minimal enough that it doesn’t delay Hegota and/or take up too many resources from nodes (bandwidth/compute) at a time when we need those for PQ. FOCIL in Hegota The good news is that FOCIL is well suited for this, because of two core properties: - Extensibility: We can fine-tune FOCIL to determine its transaction coverage. I think of it in terms of tiers: if we just want to cover regular/legacy transactions, we get FOCIL in its minimal form (lowest complexity, lowest node resource consumption). On the other hand, if we want FOCIL to cover all types of Frame transactions now and in the future, FOCIL becomes more complex and consumes more resources. In between, FOCIL can cover a limited set of Frame transactions. - Boundedness: Inclusion lists are amongst the easiest objects to deal with in the protocol. They’re bounded in terms of both size (8 kB) and gas limit (MAX_VERIFY_GAS_PER_IL). We can also cap the gas and size per IL transaction. Inclusion lists are also ephemeral and only useful for the duration of 1 slot, after which they can be forgotten about. And they never go onchain, so they don’t grow Ethereum’s state, which is one of our scarcest resources. For Hegota, I think FOCIL should sit in between and support a limited set of Frames with clear bounds on inclusion lists. A good approach for shipping FOCIL and Frames in general on devnets is to start with minimal FOCIL, make sure it’s ready, and then extend its transaction coverage gradually. This is a good way to guarantee we can ship FOCIL and Frames as soon as Frames are ready to go. PQ FOCIL “PQ FOCIL” can mean two different things, and we should differentiate them. The first is inclusion lists being able to cover PQ transactions. Here, the simple answer is that FOCIL, without any changes, would be able to include PQ transactions using leanSPHINCS signatures. But it would be able to include a lot fewer: a leanSPHINCS signature is around 5-7 kB and an IL is capped at 8 kB, so probably just 1 PQ transaction per IL, which means up to 16 PQ txns per block (because there are 16 includers, each of them building 1 IL per block). I think that’s fine and good enough for Hegota. Later, we will probably want FOCIL to cover PQ proofs as well, and for that we will need changes to FOCIL so each IL can include an 8288 proof (around 300 kB). The good news is that by then, we will need the machinery to handle these big recursive proofs being propagated on the network anyway. These are I*/J* considerations, but we should plan ahead and make sure the CL has the capacity to handle bigger ILs down the road. The second is inclusion lists being PQ/AI resistant. This one is easy: just replace IL BLS signatures with leanXMSS signatures, which would increase their size by 2.4 kB (each IL becoming 10.4 kB instead of 8 kB). But it also raises an interesting question: how important is it for ILs to be signed with PQ sigs? What is the worst attack that could happen if an adversary forged an IL signature? The worst an adversary can do with forged IL signatures is make every includer look like an equivocator. Nodes ignore ILs from an includer who signed two different lists, so forging a second IL for each of the 16 includers switches FOCIL off for that slot. So the worst thing that can happen is that FOCIL gets neutralised, which is of course far from ideal but a lot less concerning than consensus breaking or funds being stolen. Keep in mind that the adversary would also have to spend significant resources to break the keys of all 16 includers, who are only known a few minutes in advance. An adversary could also publish ILs on behalf of offline includers, but an IL can only force in transactions that are valid and fit in the block, which is what any includer can already do. And the extra load is bounded, because nodes forward at most two ILs per includer. So even though I think we should generally switch to PQ sigs across all layers of the protocol, this one is definitely not the most urgent or worrying. ILs could potentially keep BLS signatures in Hegota and move to PQ signatures with the rest of the CL. Closing thoughts I agree we should accelerate pqai, and prioritise every upgrade that is ready (PQ registration, leanSPHINCS). But DFI’ing everything else won’t make the parts that aren’t ready arrive any sooner. It only guarantees that Ethereum ships no user-facing features while we wait. PS: I want to be clear that I’m incredibly excited about the future of Ethereum. Thinking about PQ and ZK made me realise that we could completely rethink Ethereum as a cryptographic world computer, and accelerating towards this vision is very bullish. We just need to be careful not to sacrifice its other properties along the way (e.g., credible neutrality, privacy), and we have a very bright future ahead of us.
Replying to @barnabemonnot
I agree there are some nuances but I still think the pqai2027 timeline doesn't make a lot of sense for points that could be more grounded, we need to think about: - what to settle on from the cryptography side (specific signature schemes for leanSPHINCS and XMSS on the EL and the CL, leanVM specifics and what it means to FV a project of that size and complexity, choosing the hash function) - how easy we want to be able to switch to something else in case the hash we chose ends up breaking as well - we also need to differentiate PQ Casper and DC versions with or without aggregation because these involved widely different tradeoffs - 8288 is not just signature aggregation, it also currently includes leanSPHINCS and leanSTARK (now leaning towards leanPCS, which gives users the possibility to prove any statement and thus the flexibility to chose any signature scheme they like)
9
11
3
61
4,688
Ryan Berckmans ⟠ retweeted
𝗜𝗻𝘁𝗿𝗼𝗱𝘂𝗰𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗡𝗲𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗺𝗶𝗻𝗱 𝗟𝗶𝗴𝗵𝘁 𝗖𝗹𝗶𝗲𝗻𝘁 Trustless RPC for every wallet. Verify Ethereum yourself, without running a full node. 𝗛𝗼𝘄 𝗶𝘁 𝘄𝗼𝗿𝗸𝘀 → One trust anchor: a recent finalized beacon block root → Consensus: sync committee updates over libp2p, with signatures and Merkle branches verified → Execution: state on demand through SNAP, every range proven against the state root → Performance boosted through partial state caching for selected and frequently queried accounts. 𝗕𝘂𝗶𝗹𝘁 𝗼𝗻 𝗯𝗮𝘁𝘁𝗹𝗲-𝘁𝗲𝘀𝘁𝗲𝗱 𝗡𝗲𝘁𝗵𝗲𝗿𝗺𝗶𝗻𝗱 𝗰𝗼𝗺𝗽𝗼𝗻𝗲𝗻𝘁𝘀 → eth_call and eth_estimateGas run locally in the Nethermind EVM, nothing forwarded → Developed inside the Nethermind client codebase → Glamsterdam-ready 𝗙𝗼𝗿 𝘆𝗼𝘂, 𝗶𝘁’𝘀 𝗷𝘂𝘀𝘁 𝗹𝗼𝗰𝗮𝗹𝗵𝗼𝘀𝘁:𝟴𝟱𝟰𝟱 Point MetaMask, or any wallet, at it. In active development. Congrats @__flcl and the team. Follow the progress and share feedback: github.com/NethermindEth/net…
24
68
14
304
28,666
Since today sucks so hard, I thought I'd share some personal thoughts on the state of the market and how I think about reliably trading it. Bear markets are where fortunes are made preparing for the next bull. Unfortunately, wagmi isn't really true. But many people do make it in crypto, and you can too. As a cycle investor here's how I think about it 1. Don't panic sell majors If you're holding great spot bags, especially a major you believe in as much as I believe in ETH, imo now is an overall terrible time to panic sell. Sure it might go down more, maybe a huge amount more, to the point where panic selling looked genius. Are you going to bet your future on that? You already decided not to sell last week and the week before that. Has the long term thesis changed? For majors, probably not. If you want to be a person that actually makes it, you need to be selling on upswings, not panic selling. 2. Have realistic expectations for both price and timeline The seasonal top was only ~6 weeks ago. The passage of time is as important as the price level. It takes a while to form a bottom or a top. If you're a chronically online person, it might feel like to you (does to me) that it's been a month or more since BTC was at $80k, even though it's been 9 days. It helps to have empathy for the diverse and growing population of global crypto investors and traders. Many market participants are normies, or distracted professionals, or generally part of slower moving orgs. It takes them some time to process things, decide to trade, and execute. Reflexivity makes this not just a moving target but also a moving "gun". If you want to make it with reliable trades and investments, there's no substitute for waiting patiently. Bull and bear markets are a process, not a price level. For quality majors like ETH, patience will be hugely rewarded. 3. Avoid buying on leverage right now When used well, leverage is a wonderful tool to grow wealth. However, being underwater on borrowed money feels significantly worse than being underwater on your own money. A leveraged trade could ultimately end up a winner, yet the ongoing unrealized loss on borrowed money is so poisonous to the spirit that it can easily lead to capitulation. Particularly when the start of the next bull may be a ways away, that's a long time to stare at an unrealized loss every day. 4. Buy hard at the right time I'd give the bear some patient time to bake, then back up the truck and load up. Buying at low prices in the mid-to-late stages of a seasonal bear is a bet that the bull will eventually return. It's a terrific bet. 5. Make your sell plan for the next bull During the bear, decide how much of your spot bags you'll sell next bull season. Every season is an opportunity. Last season, BTC did +50% from pico bottom to pico top. ETH and alts did way more. There's money to be made, often relatively reliably, even in years with no ATH. Alternatively, you are of course free to ignore any mini bulls and wait for ATHs. Just don't tell yourself that you're doing that, only to then panic sell during a seasonal bear after the preceding seasonal bull disappointed you. 6. Follow your Sell Plan When the mini or real bull next returns, hopefully you are sitting on fat spot bags and possibly a moderate amount of leverage. Sell your leverage in the early stages of the bull when the position is up, say, 20% to 50%. I like to be conservative in realizing leveraged profits. You made money on borrowed money, don't overthink it or overgreed it. For spot bags, pick some personal top signals. Ideally do this when you make your sell plan. These are a simple, biased, imprecise, but hopefully probably accurate heuristic or rules of thumb to detect when the good times have returned and it's time to execute your sell plan. Your personal top signals don't have to be purely quantitative. Half of mine use numbers, and half are qualitative. imo a price target is not a good top signal. Once your top signals are hit, sell the slice of your spot bags that you previously committed to selling (when you decided this during last bear). If your personal circumstances have changed, then you might want to sell less or more than you previously had decided in your sell plan. But be careful not to confuse that with simply hoping that prices get higher. Your top signals were hit and it's time to secure the bag. That's part of why a price target makes for a bad top signal, it doesn't tell you when it's worth staying on the rollercoaster. 7. Compound your cycle gains After successfully securing the cycle bag, wait for the next bear to do it all again. I try to three days a cycle: the Buying Day, the Leverage Selling Day, and the Spot Selling Day. The selling days are often 1-2 months apart but the buying day is ~6 months apart from the selling days. Do all this well and grow your stack across mini/full cycles. ~~ In the crash in the past couple days, many people that are panic selling seem to think that crypto is burning down and this time is different. I disagree with them. imo it's an ordinary crypto bear market. Albeit with the addition of big problems in tradfi and geopolitics. imo these extra problems might result in lower lows, but they are unlikely to fundamentally change the current cycle structure. The bull will return. BTC will do well in the coming years, and ETHBTC will do great.
14
14
2
111
15,174
If ETHBTC was at 2025 lows we'd be at $1270 right now. The reason we're not is the same reason that ETH performed pretty well against BTC during the recent downtrend: Ethereum is in a significantly better place now than in recent years. Future is extremely bright
43
27
4
481
34,817
Not sure who needs to hear this but it's a normal bear market
11
1
49
2,694
Ryan Berckmans ⟠ retweeted
In the next ~two weeks, core devs may revisit the Hegota scope and consider whether a narrower focus on PQ would help us move faster. Reconsidering headliner EIPs like FOCIL or features that help us scale or reduce slot times is a significant step. These features have value, and changing an agreed scope has costs too, so the question is how to balance those priorities with the goal of full PQ readiness in 2028. And this brings us to where we are today: Glamsterdam ships soon, and Hegota is actively being worked on. Frame transactions have been chosen as the EL headliner for the fork. That's a great first step toward the PQ transition on the EL and something that needs to start asap because users, hardware wallets, dapps, and wallets need clarity to build PQ-ready tools, as well as time for this complicated transition. On the CL side, Hegota is expected to include a new registration contract for validators to preregister PQ keys, but larger PQ changes aren't scheduled yet. FOCIL (= inclusion lists) has been chosen as the CL headliner, but one question now is whether its size and interactions with frame transactions could complicate delivery and potentially delay that first step toward PQ. Some say FOCIL is ready and that if the interactions with frame txs are the problem, we could initially exclude frame txs from ILs. That could be worth evaluating, especially if it allows us to keep an agreed headliner without affecting the timeline. Ofc, this would also mean leaving some work for later and since privacy txs will need frame txs, focil wouldn't be able to support those. At the same time, every feature/EIP adds some complexity to a fork, and while existing progress is great, there's usually a long way to go from "ready on devnets" to "production ready." Ideally, the decision should therefore reflect concrete estimates of the remaining work and the interactions with frames. CL core devs will need to begin focusing on a PQ-ready version of Decoupled Consensus soon, which is a rather big effort by itself, and while not every dev should focus only on the PQ transition, there's a lot of hardening work ahead of us too and it might be good to free up dev resources by slimming down forks in general. Personally, I lean toward keeping Hegota focused on initiating the PQ transition, even if that means deferring FOCIL, but that depends on how much work and timeline risk it actually adds. If we can ship both with confidence, that's a good outcome too.
9
8
1
50
2,653
Quantum resistance coming a year earlier for @ethereum $ETH 👏👏👏👏
INSIGHT: Ethereum research group Ethlabs proposes pulling quantum resistance forward to 2027, a year ahead of the current target, by removing faster block times from the Hegotá upgrade and prioritizing post-quantum cryptography amid rising AI-driven security risks.
95
136
10
1,547
82,428
Jensen had ~60 direct reports. No new CEO can manage the company the way he did. It's not just a new CEO it's a huge executive reorg. He owns ~3.4% directly and can dump his entire ~$130B of NVDA in, apparently, as soon as one week, on Nov 19. Buckle up imo
4
1
53
3,020
Let's appreciate that on its craziest day ever, NVDA closed yesterday at $174 and currently trades onchain at $151 prior to market open in 5 minutes. Our worldview is taking over. Onchain will grow 10,000x. This was true before AI. Even more true now. ETH
12
8
82
2,499
NVDA just instantly shed $360B in market cap from after hours (Wall St is closed) onchain price discovery on reports of Nvidia preparing to fire Jensen. Everyone will come onchain, and AI will eat everything. ETH is a massive net winner in this new world.
7
5
104
4,338
pqai27 is a simple idea: - being PQ is eth's most tech milestone to achieve. - let's do it now, that way it turns into a strength instead of an *existential risk* in the oven. - do it by making hegota headliners PQ and frames, pausing FOCIL. (sad but important) - PQ ships in 2027
pqai27: Our view on post-quantum and post-AI timelines. We shared this on Ethereum Magicians as input into the Ethereum governance process. ethereum-magicians.org/t/pqa…
6
6
1
57
1,972
pqai27 is a proposal to make Ethereum postquantum ASAP instead of by 2029 or later. Both Ethereum and ETH will benefit massively from becoming PQ much sooner and reliably frontrunning Q-Day-- especially given latest exponential progress. imo this is critical. Let's get it done.
pqai27: Our view on post-quantum and post-AI timelines. We shared this on Ethereum Magicians as input into the Ethereum governance process. ethereum-magicians.org/t/pqa…
8
11
122
3,053
Ryan Berckmans ⟠ retweeted
Why ETH is the store of value for what's coming We are almost certainly heading into a period of high inflation and extreme economic and social volatility. As inflation and risk erode the purchasing power of nation-state money and many other assets, it will matter more than ever to hold assets that keep or grow their value. Gold and BTC are high-powered money and excellent stores of value. ETH goes further. Not debt-based. Like gold and BTC, ETH is not debt-based or credit-based money. Censorship resistant. Like BTC, or gold and silver held physically, ETH transactions on Ethereum L1 can't be censored. That's true for simple payments and for complex smart contract programs like DeFi, and those programs are guaranteed to execute. Cheap to hold. Like BTC, ETH is relatively cheap to hold and store securely. Cheap to use at any scale. Ethereum is cheap and easy to use whether a transaction moves $1 or billions. Any well-formed transaction is guaranteed to execute. Sound, and getting sounder. ETH is disinflationary and becomes ultrasound, meaning deflationary, during periods of high network activity. Broadly useful. ETH has many uses across the Ethereum economy, and that economy will grow by orders of magnitude as finance, and eventually every industry, moves onchain. Global adoption of the Web protocols in the '90s and '00s transformed the world economy. Ethereum is the foundation of Web3, the user-centric, decentralized web. Collateral money. ETH works as collateral, and collateral that grows in value over time is a powerful thing. Home of stablecoins. Ethereum hosts the bulk of stablecoin activity. Stablecoins serve as payment money and as unit-of-account money. Despot-proof. Like BTC, ETH can't be used by a despot to financially exploit or repress citizens. Over time that should have positive geopolitical effects. Programmable. ETH is programmable money. You can attach arbitrary logic to transactions and build an entire economy on smart-contract-based agreements and business processes (see shodai.network). Transparent or private, and auditable either way. Money and financial instruments on Ethereum can be public or private, and in both cases selectively disclosable and auditable. Privacy tools for retail and institutional users include VPNs, mix networks, shielded and privacy pools, Railgun, stealth addresses, Kohaku, and zero-knowledge proofs in many forms, including on L2s and on private permissioned EVM networks linked through bridgeless synchronous composability. Future-proof. By the end of 2027, or partway through 2028 at the latest, ETH will be quantum-safe and AI-safe money. ETH is the base money of an exponentially growing ecosystem that should keep growing for decades. Its monetary premium will keep rising, because retail, corporate, and government users will all need to hold some. Part of today's premium is speculative: Ethereum dominates smart contract blockchains, but it hasn't fully hit its stride or gone mainstream yet. Machine intelligence will supercharge every scientific and technological pursuit and grow global GDP bigger and faster than any of us can imagine. Ethereum L1 and modular Ethereum L2s will undergird most of the high-value agreements, transactions, payment flows, and complex business processes behind the coming hybrid human-machine decentralized economy.
Expanding on why I believe "ETH as store of value (SoV)" makes much more sense to focus on than "ETH as fee-burning token". Three primary reasons: 1. ETH as fee-burning token never was as strong as it seemed 2. Optimizing for ETH as fee-burning token would demand Ethereum and ETH function in ways that are very hard to make compatible with decentralization and capture resistance. 3. Meanwhile, optimizing for ETH as SoV is aligned with Ethereum focusing on its unique strengths (decentralization and CROPS) EIP-1559 (including its burn) is fine and good, we should keep them. But we should not feel sad if fee burn is < 10% of breakeven indefinitely; the value of ETH comes from elsewhere. The core idea: the big thing that people appreciate about Ethereum is decentralization and CROPS. The main pragmatic benefit that these things translate into is stability. SoV is the category where that is not an unneeded extra we merely put effort into for ideological reasons, but rather a pragmatic strength from the perspective of people putting in their assets. And in the era of AI disruption, stability will be highly valued.
176
346
76
1,913
180,933
See this must-read article from @potuz_eth Safety, strategy, and courage are always guiding lights in our hard forks. Now's no different. Making ETH and Ethereum post-quantum is our top priority. We must take this risk and turn it into a strength, ASAP. Progress is great. LFG
> The very first thing we need to decide is whether or not we want to commit to solving the PQ threat as a high priority. Great article. PQ is our top priority for both ETH SoV and 100% uptime. If that means redrawing the Hegota plan, LFG. potuz.net/posts/pq/
6
5
45
2,068