Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL) header
Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL) profile picture

#Sportsbetting & gaming lawyer. Co-Founder @UNHLaw sports wagering. Teach @MiamiLawSchool. Contributor @Forbes. Co-Founder @Condetrimental #sportslaw podcast.

Hallandale Beach, Florida
Joined November 2024
Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)Photo by Daniel Wallach (@WALLACHLEGAL)
No wonder it took 6+ months. A big win for states and tribes. The 2–1 split masks substantial common ground. Even the dissent excludes props and parlays from “swaps,” muting Kalshi’s silver lining. A wider circuit split (with two divided panels) could hasten SCOTUS review.
A closer look at today’s Fourth Circuit ruling against Kalshi reveals several significant legal conclusions concerning federal preemption, state gambling authority, the definition of “swap,” and the limits of CFTC oversight. Some notable passages from the opinions. 🧵
3
309
A closer look at today’s Fourth Circuit ruling against Kalshi reveals several significant legal conclusions concerning federal preemption, state gambling authority, the definition of “swap,” and the limits of CFTC oversight. Some notable passages from the opinions. 🧵
3
11
4
22
7,292
Benjamin concludes that Kalshi’s sports contracts are “swaps,” Maryland’s laws are field preempted, and Kalshi is likely to succeed on the merits. She would vacate and remand. But hers is the dissent. The Fourth Circuit affirmed the denial of Kalshi’s preliminary injunction.
1
175
Notable omission from Benjamin dissent: She addresses only field preemption, without analyzing express preemption or reaching conflict preemption. Her conclusion rests on two premises: Kalshi’s sports contracts qualify as “swaps,” and state gambling laws are field preempted.
133
Not sure Kalshi is loving this dissent. No props or parlays. No statutory limiting principle—just “common sense” untethered to the text. And its lone judicial ally fails to follow SCOTUS precedent in defining the preempted field. 3 for 3. Perhaps a dissent not worth having.
Replying to @WALLACHLEGAL
Benjamin cites a 1974 Senate report stating that federal law preempts the field of futures regulation. But what about Oneok v. Learjet? SCOTUS instructs courts to define the preempted field by examining what the state law targets. Maryland targets gambling, not futures trading.
1
1
5
845
Kalshi lost 2-1. But even its lone judicial ally draws the line at props and parlays. Judge Benjamin concludes that props and parlays are NOT swaps under the CEA. Even the pro-Kalshi dissent doesn’t protect the full sportsbook menu.
Replying to @WALLACHLEGAL
By contrast, Benjamin asserts that traditional sports parlays and proposition bets generally fall outside the CEA’s swap definition because they cannot reasonably be used to hedge risk, lack independent economic consequences, and are better understood as “pure speculation.”
1
12
845