There is lots of ignorance floating around.
Russia's economy is the fourth largest in the world in PPP terms, greater than Japan's and Germany's. This is how much stuff it produces measured at international prices (PPP dollars).
But in terms of market exchange rates, Russia's GDP is No. 9 in the world, slightly below Italy's. If the ruble continues to devaluate it might even go lower.
However, if you measure how much staff Russia produces which is a superior metric it is No. 4 after China (No. 1), USA (No.2), and India (No. 3).
"The Great Global Transformation: National Market Liberalism in a Multipolar World" – Branko Milanovic
(now in Spanish too)
youtube.com/watch?v=gXcUcByA…
5
1,965
"Don't know much about history /
Don't know much biology /
Don't know much about a science book /
Don't know much about the French...."
Sam Cook, "What a Wonderful World"
As other historians stated:
Professor Victor Gao (Chair Professor of International Relations, Soochow University; former interpreter for Deng Xiaoping)
• “Ms Kallas, go back to primary school and study history.” (Also said she should go back to kindergarten if necessary.)
• Eldar Mamedov (Responsible Statecraft / Quincy Institute)
• Titled the piece “Kaja Kallas’ shocking lack of historical literacy.”
• Chinese Foreign Ministry: Called the comments “completely wrong and extremely irresponsible” and evidence of a “lack of basic historical knowledge.”
She holds the formal title of the EU’s top diplomat and continues to shape policy on sanctions, defence, enlargement, and day-to-day foreign affairs, but the biggest member states have effectively sidelined her from the Ukraine peace track to the extent that Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni reportedly argued she lacked the necessary institutional standing.
Branko Milanovic retweeted
Book Review on BRAVE NEW EUROPE
Towards the Abyss – Ukraine from Maidan to War by Volodymyr Ishchenko @Volod_Ishchenko
Reviewed by Branko Milanović @BrankoMilan
braveneweurope.com/geopoliti…
#Ukraine #UkraineWar #Maidan #Geopolitics #Politics #USA #Fascism #Corruption #Russia
As for my own opinion of the relations of EU-Serbia I have very clearly (before the elections) expressed it here:
An axiomatic approach to Serbia’s foreign policy
Towards the October 25 elections and beyond
brankomilanovic.substack.com…
Deep relationships in many areas (economic, judiciary, education, freedom of the media) *without* membership.
As for my own opinion of the relations of EU-Serbia I have very clearly (before the elections) expressed it here:
An axiomatic approach to Serbia’s foreign policy
Towards the October 25 elections and beyond
brankomilanovic.substack.com…
Deep relationships in many areas (economic, judiciary, education, freedom of the media) *without* membership.
2
7
3,985
This tweet is obviously a critique of the European Union; not of Studentska Lista. As I wrote before, we should give SL 100 days of moratorium on the critique.
The idea that the EU will treat benevolently the new Student List govt in Sebia is pure fiction. On the contrary, the EU will treat it worse than it ever treated Vucic because it perceives it as ideologically divided and weak. Within six months the relations between the EU and Serbia will be worse than ever.
Одговор на слом представничке демократије по Лењину и Грамшију: Списи од пре сто година и данашња политика
oko.rts.rs/drustvo/5086845/o…
Branko Milanovic retweeted
Bu arada, 1513-1880 yılları arasında kadı sicillerindeki 266 bin Müslüman erkeği gözlem olarak kullanarak İstanbul’daki sosyal mobiliteyi ölçen çok ilginç bir yeni makale yayınlanmış.
Makale, temelde bir babanın toplumsal statüsünün oğlunun geleceğini ne ölçüde belirlediği sorusundan hareket ediyor. Bunu hem unvanlar üzerinden hem de (daha kısıtlı bir örnekleme dayanarak) servet üzerinden ölçüyorlar.
Makalenin birçok bulgusu var, fakat ben en önemli bulduğum 2 figürü aşağıya bırakıyorum. Aşağıdaki 2. fotoğrafta, baba ile oğul arasındaki toplumsal statü ilişkisinin dönemler boyunca nasıl değiştiğini görebilirsiniz. 1550-1650 arasında bu ilişki belirgin biçimde zayıflamış; yani kuşaklar arası sosyal mobilite artmış. Ama 1650-1800 arasında yeniden güçlenmiş. Bu da özellikle elitler arasındaki statü aktarımının daha kalıcı hale geldiğine ve toplumsal hiyerarşinin daha kapalı bir yapıya büründüğüne işaret ediyor. 1800 sonrasında ise eğilim yeniden tersine dönmüş: Baba ile oğul arasındaki statü bağı zayıflamış, dolayısıyla yönetici sınıflara erişim yeniden kolaylaşmış.
Yazarlar servet üzerinden yaptıkları analizde de benzer bir dönemsel örüntü buluyorlar. Bunu da aşağıdaki 3. fotoğrafta görebilirsiniz.
Kısacası, en azından İstanbul örneğinde, 1550-1650 dönemi sosyal mobilitenin belirgin biçimde arttığı; 1650-1800 dönemi bu hareketliliğin azaldığı; 1800 sonrasındaysa, muhtemelen 19. yüzyıl reformlarının da etkisiyle, sosyal mobilitenin yeniden yükseldiği bir dönem olarak öne çıkıyor.
The idea that the EU will treat benevolently the new Student List govt in Sebia is pure fiction. On the contrary, the EU will treat it worse than it ever treated Vucic because it perceives it as ideologically divided and weak. Within six months the relations between the EU and Serbia will be worse than ever.
Branko Milanovic retweeted
Não é um triângulo equilátero. O balé do cerimonial deixa muito claro quem é o parceiro sênior para o presidente da China, e quem é o socio minoritário.
Roosevelt was in the middle in Yalta. This was not an accident. US was, and still is, the top power.
Branko Milanovic retweeted
From the Middle East, to Europe and East Asia - the bloc-based security architecture to sustain hegemony collapses. Also, I comment on why I have to leave Norway after 6 years of intimidation.
glenndiesen.substack.com/p/t…
Every evening, and I mean *every* evening, when I come to my building in New York, there are dozens of boxes in the lobby. And the same people who order these hundreds of boxes--from socks to wine-- tell you later how strongly they feel about climate change and waste. And you are supposed to take them seriously.
Gramsci y Lenin sobre cómo trascender el “parlamentarismo” y sobre la democracia directa
letraslibres.com/politica/gr…
Gramsci and Lenin on transcending “parliamentarianism” and on direct democracy
Century-old writings and today's politics
branko2f7.substack.com/p/gra…
Branko Milanovic retweeted
Marx was the first student of fundamental historical features of capitalism, Keynes, the last cameralist. Marx was a philosopher who believed that economics shapes history, Keynes, the smartest adviser to power. In Capital, we have a Bible of capitalism, in General Theory, we have The Prince for economic management of capitalism.
A short essay on the differences between Marx and Keynes
As stimulated by Joan Robinson's "Essay on Marxian Economics"
branko2f7.substack.com/p/a-s…
Recall that Trump also greeted Xi at the airport when Xi last came to the US.
(Comparing to Mao makes no sense since Mao could hardly walk at the time.)
WOW! Xi Jinping fue a recibir a Trump al aeropuerto. Esto creo que es primera vez que pasa.
Cuando Nixon llegó en 1972, lo recogió Zhou Enlai.
El probable motivo del rompimiento de protocolo es que Trump hizo lo mismo en cuando Xi fue en septiembre a EEUU. No son amigos, como si pasa entre Xi y Putin, pero la relación no es mala.
Lo que EEUU no quiere es que los países de su patio trasero no tengan vínculos con China. Ellos sí pueden.
Why a struggle for multipolarity and intenational peace, and for domestic redistribution are in reality the same struggle--because the cause that led to international and domestic problems was the same.
Somebody asked me for the summary of my talk. And thus I summarized the key points from my "Great Global Transformation".
I would like to speak about the themes from my "Great Global Transformation". They are essentially a remarkably change in economic power between Asia and the West (and even more so if you compare Asia and Europe).
That has had two consequences: on the level of nation states it has led to imperialist competition not unlike before WW1 and conflict, and on the level of individual incomes it led to the decline in global income positions of lower and middle classes of advanced economies. The latter element, combined with the absence of such a decline among the top groups in advanced economies, is responsible for domestic political turbulence there.


















