Parachute retweeted
Why did an important proposal from an OG Polkadot project — Robonomics — not pass?
Polkadot's on-chain governance has evolved from "a three branches of power" into something closer to a faction-based parliamentary system for treasury management. To secure funding, one must align with the prevailing concepts and values — sometimes even those embodied in the web3 identities of voters holding 6 million DOT in voting power. The process is fully public, and not once was there even a hint of private messages or bribe requests sent to the founder by voters.
That said, there’s little room for real dialogue. At best, factions publicly state the outcome of their internal vote, but rarely engage in discussion. There’s no proactive effort from major voters to connect with proposal authors. My personal view is that on-chain governance is improving — becoming more transparent, participatory, and structured — but still feels like it operates within closed circles of shared interest.
In our case, despite the strong team and real traction over the last three months (I highly recommend revisiting the links in the proposal - polkadot.polkassembly.io/ref… - to see what we’ve already accomplished inside the Polkadot community — a testament to our commitment to building this ecosystem), if I were to summarize the criticism and reasons for rejection, I’d highlight three commonly voiced arguments:
1. "It’s not the right time for Polkadot."
My response: if that’s the case, imagine how hard it is for small OG teams that are building without any treasury support at all. If you look at other proposals, like rollup incentives, some are asking for even more — just for airdrops.
2. "This has nothing to do with JAM — and JAM is our future."
Fair enough. We’re studying the specs and watching the dev presentations like everyone else. Historically, we’ve always tried to be among the first to test new tech — just like we did with Substrate SDK in 2019. So it’s puzzling when JAM developers say “no” to us now, even though we’re ready to integrate any JAM-based features into the humanoid SDK the moment they become available. But should that really block useful work that could benefit the Polkadot ecosystem throughout 2025?
3. "Humanoids aren’t what Polkadot needs."
Strangely enough, I don’t take issue with people feeling this way — it’s exactly what on-chain voting is for: deciding whether people believe futuristic robotics have a place in Polkadot or not. And if voters aren’t ready to support that vision, that’s part of the process. But in truth, this argument came up less often. The first two points were the most common — and together they led to 18 million DOT voting against the proposal.
--
Monday’s a new day, and there’s still a lot of work to do. Our team is pushing forward with several other parallel tracks. And who knows — maybe next time I’ll rename the proposal "JAM JAM Humanoid SDK" and it’ll pass 😄
Parachute retweeted
Today, the Robonomics developers burned 7,000,000 $XRT 👾 This is an unusual page in the history of our team's adventures, and possibly the entire crypto world! Below, I will try to tell it from the very beginning...
Why build IoT on top of a blockchain?
- Decentralisation
- Security
Before starting to explain how the previous points empower IoT.
What is IoT? A basic example of IoT is smart home applications. Which you can control the functionality of different switches from network
$XRT
However, it doesn't stop at homes. It can be installed at factories and workplaces.
Decentralisation: if the systems installed is controlled by single entity. Once the entity is compromised, all systems are compromised.
$XRT #robonomics
theverge.com/2021/3/9/223221…
2
2
211
Security: Bitcoin authentication security has been proven for the last decade. It's almost impossible to hack or edit in the blockchain.
$XRT #ROBONOMICS
If you would like lo learn more, robonimcs academy offers free courses
robonomics.academy/
1
83
It's just a sneaker? What is so special about it?
#rtfkt sneakers future will be similar to what ur watching in this video.
1
88
is opensea dying or what?
floor prices are lower in Blur
Also I have meta'msk connection issues
1
58
Would be delightful if @dematerialised celebrated lukso mainnet launch with a drop to their pixel fans 👀 👀
#lukso
Received my satoshi shoes from @mutani_io powered by @dematerialised
1
2
258










