Alan Dana (@AlanDana) profile picture

Jew. America conservative. Conserving the American Revolution, ordered liberty, and freedom.

United States
Joined December 2008
Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)Photo by Alan Dana (@AlanDana)
Alan Dana retweeted
Obviously Trump and his circle will blame everyone but themselves. Now it's up to republicans who maybe want to hold power sometime this century to tell them they're wrong and act accordingly.
16
66
594
12,929
Alan Dana retweeted
If the Trump admin is *this* toxic then the path is cleared for Mitch Daniels to pick up the pieces in 2028
34
16
2
256
19,886
Abdul El-Sayed literally just repeated the gist of the claim that got him in hot water this week: “It shouldn't be this hard to pay taxes and know that that money's gonna be spent on you and your kids, instead of dropping bombs on somebody else and their kids.” That is the essence of the highly controversial ad that caused Haley Stevens to break with him and sparked condemnation from Jewish leaders across America.
1,937
283
387
1,916
1,328,802
You’re telling on yourself. You’re admitting that for all of the pretense at intellectual and philosophical seriousness, NatConism and its postlib variants are just fronts for Vance and the patronage and power they expect from him. You’re projecting onto critics of your project the sort of shallow hackish water carrying you admit motivates the Vanceguard. I don’t think your ideas suck because I’m supporting Ted Cruz(!), I think your ideas suck suck because they suck. Not everyone is a duplicitous hack, but duplicitous hacks often have the hardest time seeing that.
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
24
49
5
423
34,085
Alan Dana retweeted
Make yourself an espresso, read this masterclass from @Doranimated, and purge yourself of so much of the retardation that passes as "right wing" these days.
Jonathan Keeperman (@L0m3z) gave a speech at the Nat Con conference, and I posted a crude reaction to it. He asked me politely if I would explain myself. Here is my response: Jonathan, thank you for your gracious response to my rather ungracious characterization of your speech. I appreciate your civility. Let me explain what provoked my reaction. I agree with your central premise. Today's political climate calls on us to justify the American-Israeli alliance in terms of American national interests. But after calling for a hardheaded accounting of costs and benefits, you never actually perform one. Instead, you offer a selective account of the grievances that some American nationalists harbor toward Israel and its supporters. At several points, you toggle almost imperceptibly between describing those grievances impartially to validating them, without acknowledging the toggle. You came to Jerusalem while the United States and Israel were engaged in a war against Iran. American and Israeli forces have fought alongside one another on an extraordinary scale. Both countries have committed military power and made great sacrifices in a struggle against a common enemy. Yet you barely acknowledge the war, let alone consider what it reveals about the value of the alliance. Surely that experience belongs at the center of any serious discussion of what America gains from Israel. There is also a question of elementary respect. You came to a country at war to explain why Americans are growing weary of its demands on their attention and resources. You found time to discuss the immigration preferences of liberal American Jews and the political sins of the ADL, but not the soldiers fighting, the lives being lost, or the sacrifices being made in a common struggle. Whatever your intentions, that is a failure to recognize the gravity of the occasion. And it is inseparable from the larger failure of your analysis. You tell us that Israel receives $3.8 billion annually in American assistance. But what does the United States receive in return? What is the value of Israeli intelligence, military power, technological innovation, and cooperation against common adversaries? What role does Israel play in America's competition with Iran, China, and Russia? What would it cost the United States to replace the capabilities and regional influence that the alliance provides? These questions are the beginning of the prudential calculation you call for but never undertake. More importantly, what would happen if Washington weakened the relationship to the point that Israel concluded it could no longer rely on the United States? No sane Israeli wants that outcome. But national survival may force Israel to contemplate it in the coming years. Israel would not simply disappear as a strategic actor. It would become a more independent one, making decisions about war, peace, deterrence, and relations with other powers with less regard for American preferences. American support does not give Washington control over Israeli decisions, but it does help keep Israeli military power integrated into an American-led regional order. That is an asset with considerable strategic value. If Israel became a de facto free agent, Washington might save money and escape some immediate obligations, but it would also surrender influence over one of the most formidable military powers in the Middle East. And Israel would not be operating in a vacuum. China and Russia would have opportunities to exploit the resulting realignment. Iran would have opportunities of its own. The regional order would change, and not necessarily to America's advantage. Perhaps you believe this would be a good bargain. But you never consider the possibility, much less calculate its costs. You call for realism while leaving the most consequential strategic questions unexamined. Your treatment of the American right is similarly selective. You emphasize the growing skepticism of younger conservatives, but you never mention that Donald Trump, the dominant figure in the nationalist movement you describe, has taken American military cooperation with Israel to unprecedented levels. Trump recognized Jerusalem as Israel's capital, recognized Israeli sovereignty over the Golan Heights, withdrew from the Iran nuclear agreement, and brokered the Abraham Accords. In his second term, he went much further, committing American military power to a joint war against Iran. How does his record fit your account of national conservatism? Why does the behavior of the nationalist president receive less attention than the attitudes of young nationalists? Is Trump an anomaly? Does he misunderstand the movement he leads? Or might his support for Israel reflect a nationalist assessment of American interests fundamentally different from the one you describe? These questions are indispensable to your argument. Yet you don't address them. I am also troubled by your treatment of antisemitism. You correctly observe that accusations of antisemitism no longer carry the political force they once did. But the declining effectiveness of an accusation tells us nothing about the reality or seriousness of the phenomenon it describes. There has been a conspicuous resurgence of antisemitic rhetoric in parts of the American right. Influential voices have promoted the idea that American foreign policy is controlled by Jews or manipulated on Israel's behalf. Such claims encourage Americans to interpret strategic decisions through theories of sinister manipulation rather than through an examination of American interests. Antisemitism, therefore, is not simply a problem for Jews. It is a problem for American national security, political judgment, and national cohesion. It also offers opportunities to foreign adversaries seeking to weaken the United States from within. Yet in a speech devoted to explaining declining support for Israel on the right, you give remarkably little attention to the role that antisemitic agitation has played in producing that decline. Instead, you place considerable responsibility on Israel's American defenders. You blame neoconservatives for opposing Trump, liberal Jews for supporting immigration, and even the ADL for antagonizing populists. Your reference to the ADL is particularly strange. What do the immigration preferences of liberal American Jews have to do with the strategic value of America's alliance with Israel? The ADL is an American Jewish organization, not an arm of the Israeli government. American Jews are predominantly liberal. They disagree with national conservatives on many domestic questions. So what? Even if every criticism you make of the ADL were justified, what do they have to do with the value of Israel as an American ally? Nothing, unless one assumes that Israel bears responsibility for the political behavior of American Jews. That is precisely the kind of collective attribution that ought to be examined critically, not casually incorporated into an explanation of why Americans are turning against Israel. The same problem appears in your treatment of America's wars in the Middle East. You say they are closely associated with Israeli interests. Associated by whom? Which wars? Which interests? And how accurately does that association explain actual American decisions? You leave those questions unanswered. Instead, you point to deeply tendentious interpretations of American foreign policy -- ones often advanced by antisemites such as Tucker Carlson -- as though they were established facts. Arguments frequently employed by Israel's worst antagonists enter your speech disguised as an objective description of American attitudes. This brings me to a broader problem with your method. You present yourself as a relatively detached observer of Israel and an informed observer of the American right. But throughout the speech, you alternate between describing the attitudes of nationalists and adopting their explanations for those attitudes. Reporting that some conservatives blame Israel for America's Middle Eastern wars is one thing. Treating that blame as an adequate explanation of their alienation is another. Political attitudes do not develop in a vacuum. Personalities, institutions, and campaigns of persuasion shape them. Yet your account assigns considerable agency to Israel's defenders, whose conduct supposedly alienated the nationalist right, while giving remarkably little attention to the people on the right actively encouraging hostility toward Israel and Jews based on the most vile lies. You thus present the consequences of an ideological struggle as though they were an impersonal historical development to which Israelis must accommodate themselves. Finally, there is something peculiar about the posture of the speech itself. You begin by explaining that Israel has never occupied a central place in your thinking and that you make no claim to expertise about it. Fair enough. But you then proceed to deliver sweeping judgments about the future of the alliance and the political adjustments Israelis must make. There is nothing wrong with an outsider offering uncomfortable observations. But the authority of those observations depends on their accuracy, not on the speaker's professed detachment. You conclude by imagining an Israel that Americans "do not have to think about." But the Middle East will not cease to matter to the United States simply because Americans grow tired of thinking about Israel. Iran will not abandon its ambitions. China and Russia will not relinquish their interests. And Israel's enemies will not stop threatening it because American voters would prefer to concentrate on domestic affairs. The question is whether America is better positioned to manage those challenges with Israel as a close ally or with Israel acting increasingly on its own. That is the prudential question you say would should address. It is also the question your speech conspicuously avoids. I don't know you. I have no basis for judging your intentions. I accept that you may regard your speech as a candid warning delivered in good faith. But whatever your intentions, its effect is to give a veneer of dispassionate analysis to a series of highly dubious claims about Israel, Jews, and American foreign policy. That is what I objected to. And it is why I reacted so strongly.
7
31
1
135
8,201
Alan Dana retweeted
Walking out of shul on Monday, I picked up a pamphlet by an organization called the Jewish Board, supported by the @UJAfedNY. The title was "When Safety Feels Shaken: Support and Practical Tools." What advice did the pamphlet give? Well, first, that tucking in your Star of David necklace "can be a safety decision made from strength." Because nothing says strong Jew more clearly than hiding who you are. Then, the pamphlet advises us to "choose your moments to speak up," because staying silent when attacked is also a virtue. And then finally, the pamphlet urges us to "move before acting publicly," just to make sure we think twice before standing up to our attackers. It's impossible to exaggerate how bonkers this is. Intellectually weak, morally revolting, historically disastrous, the result of decades of limp and deflating therapy-speak. So once again: Jews don't need to hide who they are or think twice before speaking. They need to be openly and proudly Jewish, and live robust and visibly Jewish lives. They need to remember that proud Jews are never guaranteed safety, but they are guaranteed freedom, the freedom to be who they truly are. And they -- we -- need and deserve organizations that advocate real self-defense. We don't need any more retarded psychobabble. We need guns.
44
71
8
358
22,604
Alan Dana retweeted
There's no way I could debunk all of the false information in this tweet, even if I spent a whole day on it. Bottom line, @TuckerCarlson repeats many of the false notions about 2,000-lb. bombs that the NYT, WaPo, CNN and others circulated in the months after Oct. 7 -- which makes it even more amusing when he says there's been a lack of scrutiny. Along with my colleague, retired USN Rear Admiral @MarkCMontgomery, I published an in-depth look at 2,000-lb. bombs in @commentary in April 2024. See rest of thread for link and key grafs. 1/1
According to an informed federal official, in the coming months the Trump administration plans to send a total of 40,000 Mark 84 and Blu-117 bombs to the government of Israel. Each bomb weighs 2,000 pounds. This appears to be the largest transfer of conventional explosive ordnance from the United States in modern history. How big is this shipment? It amounts to 40,000 tons of bombs. For perspective, the largest American air raid of World War Two was the Eighth Air Force’s attack on Berlin in March of 1945. Combined, the 2,023 Allied aircraft involved dropped about 3,000 tons of bombs. That’s 7.5 percent of what Trump is sending to Israel. That same month, March of 1945, the US Army Air Forces began the single most destructive bombing raid in human history, Operation Meetinghouse over Tokyo. More than 100,000 Japanese civilians were killed. By the end of that operation, the US had dropped 1,600 tons of bombs. That’s four percent of what Trump is sending to Israel. World War Two ended five months later, when the US dropped an atomic bomb on the city of Hiroshima. The shipment Trump is sending to Israel amounts to more than three times the destructive power of that nuclear explosion. There is no precedent for what the Trump administration is doing. Nor is there a justification. The government of Israel is not fighting World War Two, or even a war. It is engaged in periodic skirmishes with a guerrilla force in Lebanon, and it is working to exterminate an unarmed civilian population in Gaza. Neither front requires modern 2,000-pound bombs. An American-made Mark 84 has a destruction radius of half a mile. It releases a thermal wave the temperature of the surface of the sun. Within 100 feet of the explosion, rock melts and human flesh turns to vapor. The bomb collapses apartment buildings and leaves craters thirty-five feet deep. Until the war with Iran, the US military generally avoided using the Mark 84 in urban areas. It kills too many civilians. For the Netanyahu government, that’s been the upside. In the weeks after October 7, the IDF dropped nearly six hundred 2,000-pound bombs on densely populated areas in Gaza, including on more than 100 officially designated civilian evacuation zones. The slaughter was so grotesque and embarrassing that for a moment the Biden administration paused a shipment of Mark 84s. Those shipments quickly resumed under Trump. Now they’ve accelerated. It’s hard to overstate the scale of the crime the Israeli government is committing in Gaza. Over the last three years, more than a quarter-million Palestinians have been killed or wounded by Israeli forces there. The majority of them have been noncombatants: women, the elderly and tens of thousands of children. Many thousands more remain missing, presumably entombed under the rubble of 200,000 collapsed buildings. So far the Israelis have destroyed 92 percent of all homes in Gaza, and 34 of the 36 hospitals. By comparison, the 1945 Allied bombings of Dresden, now acknowledged as a war crime, destroyed about half of the city’s inhabited buildings. By any definition, what the Netanyahu government has done in Gaza is genocide. The 40,000 new bombs the Trump administration is sending will be used to do the same in Lebanon, and likely in other countries in the region. If you wanted to extend the Iran war into the indefinite future, this is exactly what you’d do. So far none of this has received public scrutiny. At some point, inevitably, it will be described in media accounts as an “arms sale.” It is not an arms sale. It is a gift, funded by American taxpayers through the Foreign Military Financing program, an arrangement designed to disguise welfare as capitalism: Congress appropriates money to the executive branch, which transfers the cash to Israel to “buy” American-made weapons, in this case from General Dynamics. Politicians claim this is a win for America. Most voters have no idea they paid for it. The bill in this case is about $3 billion. Add that to the $352 billion the US Treasury has transferred to Israel since 1951. How did this happen? The request for 40,000 new high-explosive civilian-killing bombs originated at the US Embassy in Jerusalem, which is run by Christian Zionist Ambassador Mike Huckabee and his aide David Milstein, who is the stepson of Fox News host Mark Levin. From there it moved to the State Department, where Marco Rubio enthusiastically approved it. At this point, only four more people need to sign off before the bombs ship to Israel: Senators Jim Risch and Jeanne Shaheen, the chairman and ranking member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee; and Congressmen Brian Mast and Gregory Meeks, the top two members of the equivalent House committee. All four are committed neocons. Collectively they’ve taken millions from the Israel lobby. In 2015, Brian Mast traveled to Israel to volunteer for the Israeli military. In 2023, Mast showed up in the House of Representatives wearing an IDF uniform. It’s hard to imagine any of them hesitating before sending more free bombs to Israel. Only public outrage can stop this.
1
3
8
336
This is very sinister. It’s not a real demand of Jews to change our religion. It’s an attempt to create a framework that justifies turning every Jew into a target.
Jews have been reciting the zionist Amidah prayer for 2400 years. It was made up by rabbis. They pray it 3 times a day. The notion that jews are inseparable from zionism is their choice to make and sustain. So far, the vast majority (~90%) continue to support the existence of 'israel' aka zionism. Not surprising when their prayers and religious lives contain zionist teachings. They can reform the Amidah. Change the outdated and supremacist sections. There's at least six: - Section 10, 11, and 14 which call for the usurpation of Palestine and displacement of native population. - Section 1, 12, and 17 which establish a mythical 'spiritual-bloodline' supremacy model and actively target post-Torah divine revelations. They can always opt to change and exist as a religious community without supremacy or stealing land. They can also just repent. They are actively choosing not to do either.
8
39
4
334
6,323
When Americans want a different kind of leadership, they will have it, and not a second before. It's entirely in our hands. "Here, the people rule."
14
35
5
182
8,182
Honoring the Jewish people’s historic claims to the Temple Mount and Jerusalem. A welcomed and important gesture that all Mamdani supporters should embrace. Thank you for helping remind the world why Jerusalem is the eternal capital of Israel. Very meaningful Tisha B’Av indeed.
Wishing a peaceful Tisha B’Av to Jewish New Yorkers across the five boroughs. From sundown tonight until tomorrow, mourners will pause and reflect on the history and resiliency of the Jewish people. May all observing have a safe and meaningful fast.
18
79
4
650
28,354
Periodic reminder that the claim that if you want to be represented by working class people or military veterans then you have to put up with the sort of flaws that Platner has on display represents a terrible libel of working class people and military veterans.
77
504
32
3,622
333,974
We all know he’s playing a game. But what is the thing that stops him from simply saying no? Answer: The non-moron world knows that Israel’s existence as a Jewish state is unassailably just.
Mamdani is smart. He surely knows that Israel has no state religion and that it's a Jewish state in that it's the state of the Jewish people, not the Jewish religion. But he's playing this little game to avoid saying Israel has a right to exist as it is.
8
11
136
7,447
Alan Dana retweeted
The administration has no answers to the very clear, legitimate questions raised by the US-Iran MOU and today's Treasury waiver. Calling people unpatriotic warmongers won't make it all go away. My latest: commentary.org/seth-mandel/i…
11
64
3
204
8,959
It won’t. It will just make more money available faster for the illicit activities. This is not a benefit to us. I imagine the next step here will be to argue for reconnecting all banks to SWIFT so we can have better knowledge of how they fund terrorism. Been there, done that.
Vance now says that waiving oil sanctions on Iran will allow us to learn more about regime's activities and is thus a benefit to the US. It's not even a concession at all! Is anyone buying that?
9
51
155
12,485
Alan Dana retweeted
Replying to @EylonALevy
He’s a vain moron who cares only about feeling strong and powerful. His personal weakness demeans the office.
1
3
315
I have asked for days, why can't we, the people, see the damn MOU?  Not through people briefed by an anonymous person.  Honestly, I've never seen anything like this.  If it is a great outcome for peace, then release it.
1,907
2,115
197
10,891
762,110
⭕ Mark my words, Iran will give nothing, and it doesn't matter what is written in this disgraceful agreement. In the ME, perception is everything, and everything I am seeing on Arab social media is that Trump sold out Israel and surrendered to Iran. Trump caved and let the Iranian runs circles him. That's his legacy. He owns it, and he thinks people will move on and forget. We want
137
338
24
2,093
101,880
Commentary on the Statement from Prime Minister Netanyahu's Office: ​**The Prime Minister's Office: ** ​President Trump spoke this evening with Prime Minister Netanyahu regarding the memorandum of understanding (MoU) currently taking shape with Iran to enter into negotiations. ​Although Israel is not a party to the MoU, the Prime Minister expressed his appreciation for President Trump's commitment that the final agreement at the conclusion of the negotiations will include the removal of enriched material, the dismantling of enrichment infrastructure, limits on missile production, and the cessation of Iran's support for its terror proxies in the region. ************************ ​Translation into Plain English: ​"Israel is not a party to the MoU" – Israel is under no circumstances bound by this agreement. ​Netanyahu appreciates "President Trump's commitment that the final agreement... will include the removal of enriched material, dismantling of infrastructure, limits on missile production, and cessation of support for proxies" – The emerging agreement currently includes absolutely none of these clauses. Instead, it consists solely of lifting the blockade on Hormuz, unfreezing Iranian assets to one extent or another, and empty promises to discuss these critical issues at some point in the future. In practice, the Iranians will never concede on these points; they will simply drag out negotiations indefinitely or until Trump folds yet again.
4
26
3
74
19,417
טראמפ הודיע כעת על ביטול התקיפות שתוכננו הלילה באיראן, לכאורה בשל התקדמות דרמטית במו"מ. על פניו, הנשיא מתעקש לעשות כל טעות אפשרית בדרך לאחד מהשניים - פיאסקו נוסף או הסכם רע.
76
32
3
394
12,109