A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Today, the Taliban passed a law that bans women from showing their faces and having their voices heard in public. Their burqas must now entirely cover their faces and they are not permitted to speak in public or to look at any males that are not relatives. Perhaps it’s been an emotional year, or maybe it’s because I’m triggered, but I once again cried when I heard the news. I’m still trying to piece myself together. Not even animals are treated with such cruelty, such dehumanization, such indignity, and such little value for human life. This is the entire erasure of the existence of women, and it cuts me to the core to know what Afghanistan and Iran were before this cancerous plague was brought to us. Where are the protests? Where is the outrage? Where is the ICJ? The ICC? Amnesty? Why doesn’t anybody care about the effective enslavement of millions of women under the jihadist system of gender apartheid?
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Breaking: woman to blame for male violence that hasn't occurred. More news as we get it.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Wikipedia is a cesspool of misinformation. It has been almost completely hijacked by far left (identitarian) activists. And we are training AI to pull from it.
Many think Wikipedia is objective because "anyone" can edit it. In fact, edits are gatekept by cliques of activists who use the platform to disguise their political views as knowledge and sneak them into our minds. Here's an account of one such gatekeeper. tracingwoodgrains.com/p/reli…
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
A message to every single Jewish person and lovers of Western civilization as we know it.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Went to UCLA this afternoon to talk to people peacefully. Few interesting takeaways:
1) Most of them openly say they support Hamas, a designated terrorist organization;
2) They say 10/7 atrocities, rapes, murders, didn’t happen. The official line is “even the NYT debunked it!”;
3) 10/7 was justified. It was resistance;
4) 100% of the people we spoke to had the exact same narrative and MO, trying to recenter the conversation to 1948, without knowing any of the details when challenged;
5) They have their own security and control access to their encampment;
6) We remained very calm, but they got really aggressive and angry;
7) When you approach people who clearly are junior to others, “handlers” show up very quickly to takeover;
8) Since many of them are truly ignorant about historical and present facts, when they know they’re going to embarrass themselves, they all say “read our 5 demands to divest, now I’m going to stop talking to you.”
More organized and orchestrated than I expected. Very sad to see so many young people in a higher education setting being manipulated and brainwashed and totally devoid of critical thinking.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
How would @Columbia respond if the students took over campus in support of the KKK and called for the genocide of other ethnic minorities?
Would @Columbia continue to support the demonstrations on the basis of a commitment to free speech or would the University’s code of conduct suddenly have operative impact?
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
If white bigots did this to black students anywhere in the US, every liberal journalist in America would erupt in outrage. Yet most of my left-wing media colleagues, so quick to deplore any hint of racism, remain silent in the face of this ugly, naked, menacing #antisemitism.
Jewish students get harassed trying to leave @Columbia’s campus tonight. You can hear someone yell “Yehudim Yehudim”- “Jews Jews.” They curse and yell “go back to Poland.” Antisemitism has become the new normal here.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Something deeper is going on: Maher literally cannot respond to specific points in substance. Not because the claims are true (they are) but because the ideology robs one of the ability to engage in argument. The only thing she has recourse to is her feeling state. @NPR
Replying to @JonathanTurley
...Maher responded to none of these specific points in substance. Instead, she attacks Berliner as "profoundly disrespectful, hurtful, and demeaning" to his colleagues by calling out the company for its political bias.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Wow. Pomona, perhaps following Vanderbilt’s lead, has occupying students arrested.
I have long said it would only take a couple of schools enforcing their own rules to set an example that would reverberate through academia.
Note: this is NOT about shutting down speech. Students are left with plenty of options. What they can’t do is occupy buildings, harass others, damage property, etc.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
This morning the @nytimes wrote a profile of me. The story can be found here:
nytimes.com/2024/03/24/busin…
I initially chose not to cooperate with the profile as to hopefully discourage the reporter from writing it, as the Washington Post and New York magazine had recently already done their own profiles. Clearly, I failed. So I agreed to a fact check with the reporter when the article was nearly finished.
What motivates these profiles?
Since October 7th, I have riled up the left and left-wing media organizations as I have been a catalyst for former Harvard President Gay’s resignation; I have supported Israel in its fight to destroy Hamas, and I have advocated against the DEI movement. I encourage you to read my long-form post (with 35m views) on the problems with DEI (as opposed to small D diversity, small E equity and small I inclusion, all things I support) which can be found here:
teapawt.net/BillAckman/status/1742…
In short, I have taken on issues in opposition to and that are important to the woke left, and my posts on these topics have had considerable impact. This is quite threatening to the leftwing media as the New York Times used to be the paper of record, and now a guy with an X account can impact and help shape peoples views on important issues, but only if they find what he has to say convincing.
The media no longer have a monopoly on opinions or the narrative. As their power diminishes, they attack those that threaten their power.
To make matters worse, I am a traitor, as apparently I was perceived to be one of their own before my recent advocacy. To set the record straight, I have always been a centrist politically, supporting the issues and politicians on the left, right, and center that I agree with. As a New York City resident, I have toggled between being registered as a Democrat, Independent, and/or Republican depending on who was running for office to make sure my vote mattered.
Having been the subject of now three profiles and one full-on attack on my wife over the last few months (and many other less high-profile examples) by left-wing publications, I now understand the methods behind their approach.
The goal: to smear my reputation and that of members of my family in an attempt to discredit me and my views to blunt their impact, and to discourage me from continuing my advocacy. Let me be clear on my commitment to advocacy on these issues:
I will not be deterred.
The Approach
Use trigger words and phrases to characterize me as a thoughtless, overconfident, bullying billionaire. Include references to private air travel/jets, penthouses, mansions, dinner parties “with a few dozen friends,” personal trainers, stylists, etc. and being sloppy with or otherwise overstating the facts to create the desired impression. You get the point.
Then discredit the legitimacy of my business success by referring to the same three high profile losses that we have incurred over the last 20 years: Herbalife, Valeant, and JC Penney. Fail to mention that these investments were made 10-12 years ago and the losses were realized seven to 10 years ago.
By mentioning these three bad investments, and, to appear fair, a similar number of good investments, create the impression that I am a hit or miss investor who perhaps gets one out of every two investments correct. To wit, in the Times story, the subheading is “Big Wins Big Losses.”
[In fact, Pershing Square has generated returns substantially above the S&P 500 now for 20 years, and we have an extremely high investment batting average. Since we are a concentrated investor, however, mistakes we make are likely to be large and notable. We call out our own mistakes because we believe our investors are entitled to as much transparency about our mistakes as our successes.]
Then, attack me personally, creating a narrative that suggests (this is a first for me) that I have made inappropriate comments about appearance to both men and women at my company, and then couple this backdrop with stories about my defending men who allegedly sexually harass and/or rape women to give the reader the impression that I am a misogynist.
Then, mischaracterize my motivations, statements, posts, and their timing to convince readers that I am a racist. Use anonymous sources and then defend their anonymity for “fear of losing their jobs.”
After you come away with the impression that I am a racist, misogynist, billionaire, insensitive jerk, why would you listen to anything I have to say?
Mission accomplished.
Below, I walk through examples of the above approach in the piece and I do my best to correct the record. I encourage you to read the Times article in its entirety if you are suitably inspired.
The Reporter writes:
“For some, the intensity of Mr. Ackman’s focus on the issue seemed to come out of the blue, but in fact this kind of crusade was an extreme version of what he has long done in his professional life: full speed ahead, without any regard for the kind of potential collateral damage that some say he inflicted on Harvard’s community.”
The implication of the above is that my approach to investing is ‘guns blazing’ regardless of the facts and circumstances, which could not be further from the truth. We do months of deep due diligence on potential investments. We study the business, the industry, the management, and the competitors. We are looking for businesses that we can own for a decade or more. We make few investment decisions each year, and we use extraordinary care in making these decisions.
We are by no means full speed ahead, without regard to collateral damage. While we have made a few investment mistakes, I am not aware of any 'collateral damage' that I or we have 'long done.' If there are any such examples, the reporter should be required to provide examples to justify this statement.
The Reporter writes:
“He became a billionaire by following the corporate raider model pioneered in the 1980s by Mr. Icahn, Nelson Peltz, and others, in which investors take stakes in companies and demand change.”
This is false. In the 1980s, Icahn, Peltz, and others used junk financing and ‘highly confident’ financing letters from Drexel to threaten to take over a company, and in return received so-called ‘greenmail,’ i.e., large premiums for their shares to go away. This practice was made illegal as the greenmailing companies were left overleveraged, the repurchases were highly dilutive, and value was destroyed for shareholders.
For its first 12 years, Pershing Square was an activist investor. Unlike the greenmail approach of the 1980s, shareholder activism is a practice that benefits all shareholders as long as the activist is successful in enhancing shareholder value. Today, we don't make activist investments, but we are a highly engaged owner that works with management and boards to help our portfolio companies succeed.
The Reporter writes:
“But in 2014 Mr. Ackman raised money on the Amsterdam stock exchange, where the rules of the exchange allowed him to create a fund where investors could get their money out only if someone else bought their stake, similar to what he plans to do with his new retail fund.”
“The fund would operate as a closed-end fund, meaning investors could take money out only if someone else put new money in. (In a traditional mutual fund, you can remove money at any time.)”
The purpose of the above two paragraphs is to create the impression that our investors are somehow ‘stuck’ investing with our firm because we have some kind of special arrangement which is unique to the Amsterdam stock exchange rules. The premise of and facts in these paragraphs are entirely false.
The substantial majority of our assets under management are in a closed end fund. A closed end fund is a publicly traded company which has shareholders. Our closed end fund is listed on the London Stock Exchange and Euronext Amsterdam. Investors can’t take their money out of our company the same way that investors can’t take their money out of Berkshire Hathaway, Apple, or any other public company or closed end fund.
When investors want to get liquidity – when they are invested in a closed end fund or any other kind of publicly traded company – they sell the stock. Our company is no different. There are “no rules of the exchange [that] allowed him to create a fund where investors could get their money out only if someone else bought their stake.” This is an entirely false and misleading statement.
The Reporter writes:
“Take the case of David Sabatini, a former Massachusetts Institute of Technology professor and researcher who stepped down from his role at the university in 2022 after a review by other professors recommended revoking his tenure. M.I.T.’s president at the time, L. Rafael Reif, said in a letter to faculty that its own review concluded that Mr. Sabatini “behaved in ways incompatible with the responsibilities of faculty membership,” for having “engaged in a sexual relationship with a person over whom he held a career-influencing role” without disclosure. It had also received reports of “unprofessional behavior” by Mr. Sabatini toward “some lab members.”
Mr. Ackman, who said he conducted his own review, believes Mr. Sabatini was not fairly treated.”
David Sabatini is a world-class scientist that was accused of harassment by a senior colleague with whom he had a nearly two-year or so informal and consensual relationship. Their relationship had begun prior to a change in MIT’s rules on relationships, which then made their relationship impermissible, but they both elected to continue it nonetheless. The Boston Globe’s Spotlight investigative team did a nearly year-long investigation of the allegations and interviewed many dozens of people that knew David and the alleged victim and wrote a two-part, many thousands of words story about the situation. I strongly encourage you to read it.
apps.bostonglobe.com/metro/i…
David serves on two Pershing Square Foundation scientific advisory boards for cancer and brain research. When the accusations and stories first emerged, we did not immediately assume that David was guilty despite what we read in the media and in MIT’s own self-serving and biased statements. We did our own thorough investigation with access to thousands of pages of confidential information include text messages, MIT's investigative report, and other documents.
After the Boston Globe completed its own investigation and wrote its story, I and other members of our foundation decided it was time for David to go back to science. We believed that the world would be better off with him getting back to the lab rather than waiting for the courts to redeem the damage to his character from the media stories and the accusations that had been made against him.
When the reporter writes: “Mr. Ackman, who said he conducted his own review, believes Mr. Sabatini was not fairly treated” she creates the impression that I did a cursory review of the facts, and ignored the conclusions of MIT that purportedly did a thorough investigation.
Unfortunately, faculty in universities live in a climate of fear of being cancelled, convicted or worse from accusations from students and colleagues about everything from sexual harassment, to racism, misgenderism, and more. It has become a toxic climate in which to attempt to advance knowledge, and where the presumption of innocence until one is proven guilty is largely thrown out the window. That is why many of the best scientists and academics are leaving university settings for private industry or other independent organizations. It is a sad time for our once great universities.
The Reporter writes:
“Closer to home, Mr. Ackman also intervened in accusations of sexual misconduct. In 2010, his personal trainer was jailed at Rikers Island on a rape charge. He called Mr. Ackman, who helped him post roughly $200,000 for bail, helped him find criminal lawyers and paid his legal bills. The case never moved past a New York grand jury, though the alleged victim, who said through a lawyer that she didn’t know about Mr. Ackman’s involvement, recently filed a suit against the trainer in court using the Adult Survivors Act. (The filing said that two other women had reported the trainer to the New York Police Department, accusing him of sexual assaults. The defendant filed his own defamation lawsuit in response.)
Mr. Ackman said he’s been a longtime supporter of the Innocence Project and has paid legal bills for people he didn’t know. In this case, he said, he believes his personal trainer was unfairly accused in all three instances.”
More than a decade ago, my then-personal trainer was arrested and accused of date rape. I bailed him out and helped him find a good lawyer and paid his legal fees (he offered to pay me back with training sessions). It was an eye-opening front seat into how the criminal justice system works. At the time I made the decision to assist him in his legal defense, I did not know whether he was innocent or guilty. He had only recently become my trainer, but I liked him, he had good references from the person who recommended him to me, and I believed he deserved a proper defense.
The story is worthy of a movie. In short, it involves false accusations that were later withdrawn, line-up fraud where a police officer told an unrelated groping victim to pick him out of the line up (the police did not understand how a ‘punk’ could have made $200k bail so they assumed he was a drug dealer and wanted him rearrested and put in jail), an exculpatory DNA sample that proved that he was not the one who had had sex with one of the alleged victims, a politically motivated AG office which was found to have ignored and/or suppressed exculpatory evidence in other unrelated rape cases, and one actual alleged victim whom he had met at a bar and had sex with, consensually, according to him. The prosecutor dropped two of the three above cases for the reasons described above, but went ahead with the he-said, she-said case.
Very few lawyers would recommend that their client testify in front of a grand jury, particularly if you are a man accused of raping a woman. You are not allowed to have your lawyer present, and the grand jury nearly always indicts the accused after the prosecutor makes her case. The accused almost never (actually probably never) shows up, particularly in a rape case.
The trainer’s lawyer advice was no different. He told my trainer not to testify. But my trainer told me that he was tired of being under a cloud and having me fund his legal and investigation fees, which by then, nearly two years after he was accused, were about $500,000 (a lot of training sessions). So, after the alleged victim testified (he was of course not present during her testimony), he testified. When his testimony did not match that of the alleged victim, the grand jury called her back for more questions. Thereafter, we learned that the grand jury had found him not guilty.
He was found NOT GUILTY by the grand jury. He never should have been mentioned in a profile about me. He has moved on with his life. He is married, gainfully employed elsewhere (I stopped working with him 8 or 9 years ago), and shouldn’t be included in a front-page New York Times article written about a false accusation more than a decade ago.
The reporter in this case initially insisted multiple times that she had to include his name in the article despite my pleading with her not to do so. In light of the damage this could cause to him, his career, and personal life etc., I explained all of the above to the reporter in considerable detail and the devastating impact that naming him in the story could have on his life.
After pushing back multiple times, when I continued to persist, she said that she would have to talk to her editor about getting his name removed from the story, which she eventually was able to do. But this was not without consequence to me. The reporter writes:
“The case never moved past a New York grand jury, though the alleged victim, who said through a lawyer that she didn’t know about Mr. Ackman’s involvement, recently filed a suit against the trainer in court using the Adult Survivors Act.”
Note:
‘who said through a lawyer that she didn’t know about Mr. Ackman’s involvement,’
The only reason why the alleged victim didn’t know about my involvement was that it was confidential, and had never been disclosed until the reporter told her.
Why is a reporter telling an alleged victim of my personal trainer of more than a decade ago that I paid for his lawyer? I thought the job of the press was to report the news and not to make the news. WTF?
The Reporter writes:
“Shortly after the Hamas attacks on Israel, Mr. Ackman became a vocal critic of the response by Harvard president Claudine Gay to complaints of antisemitism on campus. He quickly began to attack her by saying she had been hired because of her race and gender; from there, he used the occasion to join a larger crusade against diversity, equity and inclusion efforts at universities and in workplaces.”
This is totally false and misleading. I did not attack President Gay ‘[s]hortly after the Hamas attacks on Israel’. Nor did I ‘quickly beg[i]n to attack her.’ I did the opposite. I privately reached out to members of the Harvard board and President Gay multiple times and offered ideas to help resolve what I thought could become an explosive situation on campus. Only after I was rebuffed for weeks for a meeting with the board and President Gay and had a very disappointing conversation with its chairman, Penny Pritzker, did I write my first public letter on November 3rd, almost a month later.
In the November 3rd letter, I made suggestions to President Gay, which I would have made privately to her if given the opportunity, on what I thought Harvard should do to address the explosion of antisemitism on campus. I did not attack her whatsoever in that letter. Rather, I explained how I believed her proper handling of the issue could enhance her legacy and be an important example for other universities around the world. In the last two paragraphs of the closing section of the letter entitled: ‘Your Historic Opportunity’ I wrote:
Successfully addressing antisemitism at Harvard and creating an environment with true freedom of expression will become a critically important part of your legacy as the Harvard community works together to address these challenges at a difficult time in world history.
I would be delighted to help in any way that I can to enable you to succeed in this mission and as Harvard’s president. Please let me know what more I can do to help.
I encourage you to read the letter. It can be found here:
teapawt.net/BillAckman/status/1720…
More importantly, I did not say that "she was hired because of her race and gender." I said in an X post that:
“I learned from someone with first person knowledge of the Harvard president search that the committee would not consider a candidate who did not meet the DEI office’s criteria.”
What I said was that the pool of candidates was limited only to those who met the DEI office’s criteria. These candidates included LGBTQ+, people of color, etc. Not just black women. And I never said she was “hired because of her race and gender.”
The Reporter writes:
He began to live more like a billionaire. The company bought a private jet. People close to him said he hired a stylist around this time, though Mr. Ackman said he simply had someone bring in fabrics and recommendations for business suits (“I have my own style,” he said). The not-stylist introduced him to his personal trainer.
Our company owns a private jet. It’s an extremely useful business tool and time management device. Our company paid for it with its own money and we have no outside shareholders. I reimburse the company for any personal use as do other employees. The press doesn’t constantly reference the fact that Warren Buffett and the vast majority of Fortune 500 CEOs fly privately, and all of these companies have outside shareholders. Why do they always mention this fact in articles about me?
Second, I have never had a stylist. More than a decade ago, I bought suits from a traveling salesman who happened to be female. She did not advise me on what to wear, she simply provided me with a samples of fabrics for suits that I chose from. I have limited time so having someone come to the office rather than going to a tailor worked for me.
The reporter suggests that I have a stylist and makes fun of that fact to create the impression that I am hopefully out of touch with the average man on the street. She assumes that the suit salesperson is a stylist because she is a woman. Isn’t that sexist?
The Reporter writes:
“At Pershing Square, his investment firm, Mr. Ackman also tends to get closely involved in the lives of its several dozen employees. He can be generous, personally paying for medical bills and helping employees pay off debt.”
My gripe with the above is the phrasing: “He can be generous…” The implication of ‘can be’ is that I am often not. This could not be further from the truth. One of the privileges of being successful is that it is easy to be generous. And I have taken advantage of that privilege in personal situations, in how we do compensation at our firm, philanthropically ($700m+ of grants and counting and I am a signatory of the Giving Pledge) and otherwise. The reporter chose to say ‘can’ instead of ‘is’, and from that we understand her bias and how it affects the reader.
The Reporter writes:
“Last March, he hosted a small dinner at his Manhattan penthouse apartment and asked the dozen or so guests to bring ideas for ending the war in Ukraine.”
I consider ‘a small dinner’ to be two or maybe four guests. The reporter uses ‘small dinner’ and refers to ‘the dozen or so guests’ to imply that my concept of small is a normal person's concept of large. In other words, she implies we typically host lavish banquets, part of the billionaire theme to the story.
The Reporter writes:
“This month, he and Dr. Oxman hosted a dinner at his apartment for a few dozen friends where Yuval Noah Harari, the Israeli intellectual and best-selling author of ‘Sapiens,’”
More of the same. We had 20 guests include Yuval and his entourage. We invited six couples. She writes a few dozen to reinforce the billionaire theme.
The Reporter writes:
“...Mr. Ackman has at times taken things too far. He often critiques men’s appearances, by pushing them to lose weight and use his nutritionist. (Mr. Ackman said he had done that only with his close friends who happen to work with him.) He encourages his employees to work out at the company gym and told one of his executive assistants that the women in the office should consult him on hair and makeup decisions.”
Our firm has a unique, family-oriented, small firm culture. We have 40 partners/employees, many of whom I consider close friends, including some that were good friends before they joined the company. Two of these male friends struggled with weight and associated health issues at the time I encouraged them to see a nutritionist, something that I had personally found helpful in addressing my own challenge with weight issues years ago.
As CEO, my first and most important priority is the health and safety of all of our employees. That is why we serve healthy food to our employees and I encourage employees to live a healthy lifestyle including walking and running to work and/or using our gym.
When the reporter writes that I “told one of his executive assistants that the women in the office should consult him on hair and makeup decisions,” the reporter is attempting to accomplish several objectives. First, she is suggesting that I have several executive assistants (not including other assistants) to create the impression that I have many people serving at my beck and call.
I have only one assistant. I have never commented about her hair and makeup decisions, nor suggested that she nor anyone else should “consult with me on hair or makeup decisions.” We have a broad range of diversity of appearance, hair, facial hair, and makeup at our firm and neither I nor anyone else have ever established a policy about grooming or dress at the firm. People dress appropriately and don’t need my advice on that.
Second, the reporter is trying to create the impression that I am micromanaging everyone around me, including inappropriately, the appearance of others. This is totally absurd and false.
The Reporter writes:
“(He also wants to control his press narrative, warning this reporter “not to be the bad version of The New York Times.”)”
Clearly, I failed to do so. This is exactly what I meant when I referred to the bad version of the The New York Times.
Please see my below letter to the President of Harvard University sent today:
November 4, 2023
Dear President Gay,
I am writing this letter to you regretfully. Never did I think I would have to write a letter to the president of my alma mater about the impact of her actions and inactions on the health and safety of its student body in order to help catalyze necessary change. For the past four weeks since the horrors of October 7th, I have been in dialogue with members of the corporation board, other alumni, as well as students and faculty sharing and comparing our concerns about the growing number of antisemitic incidents on campus, as we wait for you and the University to act. Four weeks after the barbaric terrorist acts of October 7th, I have lost confidence that you and the University will do what is required.
Last Wednesday, I spent seven hours on campus meeting with Jewish, Israeli, and non-Jewish students and faculty at the Law School, at HBS and in a 90-minute town hall in Aldrich 112 with 230 Jewish college students (coincidentally, one for each hostage held by Hamas), research staff, and faculty from the University at large, organized by Harvard Chabad. Over the course of the day, it became clear that the situation at Harvard is dire and getting worse, much worse than I had realized.
Jewish students are being bullied, physically intimidated, spat on, and in several widely-disseminated videos of one such incident, physically assaulted. Student Slack message boards are replete with antisemitic statements, memes, and images. On-campus protesters on the Widener Library steps and elsewhere shout “Intifada! Intifada! Intifada! From the River to the Sea, Palestine Shall Be Free!” as they knowingly call for violent insurrection and use eliminationist language seeking the destruction of the State of Israel and the Jewish people.
When you explained in your October 12th video address that Harvard “embraces a commitment to free expression,” you sent a clear message that the eliminationist and antisemitic statements of the protesters are permissible on campus. Putting aside the legal limitations on free speech that include restrictions on fighting words and true threats, “where speakers direct a threat to a person or group of persons with the intent of placing the victim in fear of bodily harm or death,” if Harvard indeed had a strong track record of protecting free speech, many would have taken your support for free speech more seriously. Unfortunately, Harvard has not embraced a serious commitment to free speech, particularly so in recent years.
In The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) Annual College Free Speech Rankings, Harvard has consistently finished in the bottom quartile in each of the past four years, with its ranking deteriorating each year. On September 23rd, just two weeks prior to October 7th, FIRE announced that Harvard achieved its lowest free speech ranking ever for the 2023 academic year, ranking last out of 254 universities, with a rating of 0.00, the only university with an “abysmal” speech climate. See: thefire.org/news/harvard-get… the results of the survey where FIRE cites multiple examples of incidents on the Harvard campus where students and faculty were denied their First Amendment rights. Therefore, when you cite Harvard’s “commitment to free expression,” in supporting the protesters, it rings false and hypocritical to the university at large and the Jewish community in particular.
Many Jewish students have also recently become afraid to express their concerns. Many have also felt the need to remove their mezuzahs, yarmulkes, Stars of David, and other overt evidence of their religion and heritage on campus and in Cambridge to avoid being exposed to discrimination, bullying or worse.
I am incredibly saddened to say that Harvard has also become a place where Jewish students are concerned about the threat of physical violence (which likely has a corresponding impact on their mental health) while among other insults, they are forced to sit next to classmates who openly and comfortably post, under their actual names, antisemitic statements and imagery on the student-wide Slack message system with no consequences for their actions.
And it is not just the Jewish students and faculty that are up in arms. While on campus, I heard a constant refrain from non-Jewish members of the Harvard community:
Why are Claudine and the administration doing nothing about this?
Harvard’s Office of Equity, Diversity, Inclusion and Belonging
I have heard from many members of the Harvard community that Harvard’s Office of Equity, Diversity, Inclusion and Belonging (“OEDIB”) is an important contributing factor to the problem. I was surprised to learn from students and faculty that the OEDIB does not support Jewish, Asian and non-LGBTQIA White students. I had never read the OEDIB DEI statement until today when I wrote this letter. The DEI statement makes clear that Harvard’s conception of diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging does not include Jews (at least those that are not in one of the other welcomed DEI groups). According to Harvard’s DEI statement:
"We actively seek and welcome people of color, women, persons with disabilities, people who identify as LGBTQIA, and those who are at the intersections of these identities, from across the spectrum of disciplines and methods to join us."
In other words, Jews and others who are not on the above list are not welcome to join. When antisemitism is widely prevalent on campus, and the DEI office – which “views diversity, equity, inclusion and belonging as the pathway to achieving inclusive excellence and fostering a campus culture where everyone can thrive” – does not welcome Jewish students, we have a serious problem. It is abundantly clear that the campus culture that is being fostered at Harvard today is not one where everyone is included, feels a sense of belonging, welcomes diversity, or is a place where “everyone can thrive.”
Equity on Campus
The issue of equity, or the lack thereof, was another issue about which I heard constant complaints, i.e., the so-called “double standard.” One member of the faculty rhetorically asked:
"What would Claudine do if 34 Harvard student organizations put out a statement on May 25th, 2020 that ‘George Floyd had it coming,’" noting that you have yet to condemn the student organization letter which holds Israel “solely responsible” for the heinous and barbaric acts of a terrorist organization.
Other faculty, alumni and students asked other rhetorical questions including:
"How would Harvard respond if a trans student attempted to walk by an anti-LGBTQIA demonstration on the HBS campus and was subject to the same abuse that the Jewish HBS student experienced at the Free Palestine demonstration on October 18th?"
"How would you respond to a Harvard white supremacist protest where students shouted 'Tulsa! Tulsa! Tulsa! From the Atlantic to the Pacific, America should be free of Black people.'"
Would Harvard even permit the above demonstrations to take place on campus?
Despite the outburst of antisemitic activities and protests on campus, the first initiative that Harvard took to protect students was the establishment on October 24th of a task force to “support students experiencing doxxing, harassment, and online security issues following backlash against students allegedly affiliated with a statement that held Israel ‘entirely responsible’ for violence in the Israel-Hamas conflict.” The creation of this task force sent a very strong message that the University was not just ignoring the antisemitic incidents and threats to Jewish student safety on campus, but rather it was taking sides in the conflict by only supporting students who held Israel responsible for Hamas’ vile acts.
In summary, your failure to condemn the barbaric acts of October 7th opened the door for a wave of anti-Israel attacks on campus that have led to a growing number of antisemitic protests and actions. Your subsequent two statements about October 7th to the University attempting to address the failings of your first letter were not taken seriously as many perceived those statements as being driven by pressure from the alumni community rather than reflecting a sincere and authentic understanding of the issues, and real empathy for Israel and the Jewish community.
The failure of your communications to the public and the University coupled with the fact that the first tangible action by the University was to protect those who blamed Israel has created a belief among the Jewish and Israeli community at Harvard that they are not deemed welcome nor worthy of protection by the University.
“Narrow Casting”
Finally, your announcement on Friday October 27th about launching a task force to address antisemitism and your statement that “Antisemitism has no place at Harvard” was welcomed by members of the Jewish community in attendance, but students who participated in my Thursday town hall were either unaware of that announcement or alternatively questioned your commitment to address antisemitism.
At my town hall, it was noted that your antisemitism speech was made only to Jewish students and parents at a Hillel Shabbat dinner, and a transcript of your remarks was only given to and published in the Forward, a niche Jewish publication with a tiny subscriber base. Two members of the Harvard faculty described this as “narrow casting” to an affinity group rather than you making a serious public commitment to address antisemitism. One research fellow stated, and many in the room agreed, that they would only believe that you were committed to stamp out antisemitism at Harvard if you stood up in front of the entire Harvard community and made that commitment, and you then implemented tangible and decisive actions consistent with that commitment.
While the members of the Jewish community I met with at Harvard were happy to hear from an alum who was willing to listen, many students questioned why you have not sat down with students so that you can hear their concerns first-hand.
Antisemitism at Harvard Prior to October 7th
In the transcript of your speech published in the Forward, you said about antisemitism at Harvard: “For years, this university has done too little to confront its continuing presence. No longer.”
Your remarks imply that antisemitism has been a serious issue at Harvard that has gone unaddressed for years. I have been an active alum for 35 years having attended the college and HBS, taught numerous classes on campus each year, have participated in many fireside chats with large student audiences, mentor current students and recent graduates on a regular basis, and have been a member of the Dean’s Advisory Board at the business school for many years. During this period, I have neither experienced nor have I become aware of any antisemitic incidents at Harvard until beginning four weeks ago.
When I asked my daughter today about her experience with antisemitism at Harvard (she graduated in 2020), she described antisemitism when she was at Harvard as “non-existent.” While I am sure it is possible if not likely that there have been some antisemitic incidents at Harvard over the last 35 years, the reality is that Harvard has been an extremely comfortable place to be Jewish and/or Israeli, up until the last four weeks.
In truth, the outburst at antisemitism at Harvard is a recent one and is largely due to your actions and inactions and that of the administration and the University at large in failing to appropriately address blatant antisemitism on campus.
How Can You Solve the Problem?
What I find particularly upsetting about recent events on campus is that the problem is not so difficult to address. I do not believe that antisemitism is widespread among the student body and faculty at Harvard. Rather, I believe that a small minority of students, faculty, and staff are antisemitic and the administration’s inaction in confronting the problem head on have emboldened this antisemitic subset of the community to escalate their antisemitic actions because there have been no consequences for doing so.
Actions speak much louder than words. Members of the Harvard community have heard some words, but experienced no actions of substance to address antisemitism on campus. I would therefore recommend the following steps which I believe will dramatically reduce if not eliminate antisemitic acts at Harvard immediately.
First, the students involved in harassing and allegedly physically assaulting the HBS student on October 18th should be immediately suspended. I understand that the University is waiting for the outcome of a police department review of the situation to take action, but this makes no sense. It is clear from the multiple videos available of the incident that the conduct of the protesters involved does not meet the standards for student conduct outlined in the Harvard College Student Handbook, in particular Harvard’s anti-bullying policies outlined in the Report & Recommendation from the Anti-Bullying Working Group adopted on September 1, 2023. communitymisconductpolicies.… These standards alone are enough to invoke Disciplinary Probation until such time as the police department investigation is completed. Harvard student disciplinary actions should not be outsourced to the police department.
Taking decisive action now will put all Harvard students, faculty and staff on notice that the University takes violations of Harvard’s code of conduct seriously, and will bring great comfort to the Jewish community at Harvard that appropriate actions to reduce threats to their safety are being implemented.
Second, the protesters who have been chanting Intifada and other eliminationist statements should be subject to disciplinary action. There are multiple videos available of the various protests that would enable the University to identify the individuals involved who can then be referred to the Administrative Board where appropriate disciplinary action can be determined and acted upon.
Third, the University should review the student Slack message boards to identify those students who have made antisemitic statements or shared antisemitic imagery. These students should also be referred to the Administration Board for appropriate disciplinary action.
Fourth, the University should publicly reach out to students in an effort to obtain other examples of antisemitic acts that should also be carefully investigated, and for which appropriate disciplinary steps should be taken.
Because Harvard students are notoriously focused on their job and career prospects post-graduation, disciplinary actions by the administration for failure to meet the University’s standards for appropriate conduct that become part of a student’s permanent record should serve as an effective deterrent to overt antisemitic acts on campus. No law firm, corporation or graduate program will hire or admit an antisemitic or racist student. I note that the recent letter to the deans of law schools around the country signed by many of the top law firms in the U.S. has, I am told, already begun to have an effect in reducing antisemitic acts at the Law School.
Fifth, the University should form a task force to review the appropriateness of the activities of the OEDIB and whether its practice of excluding certain minority communities on campus, including Asian and Jewish students, is appropriate, which in fact may be contributing to discrimination against these groups on campus.
Sixth, the results of the antisemitism task force should be made public as promptly as possible so that we can better understand the sources of antisemitism at Harvard. Harvard’s admissions practices should be reassessed to ascertain why the university is admitting racist students, and should consider revisions to the application process to enable the University to better screen the character of candidates for admission.
Seventh, as Harvard president, you should make clear that Harvard supports free speech on campus, but that certain kinds of hate speech as well as fighting words and incitement to violence are not consistent with Harvard’s values or considered appropriate conduct for members of the Harvard community. In connection with your commitment to free speech, Harvard should form a task force to understand the constraints on free speech at Harvard that have led to it ranking last on FIRE’s annual college survey, so the issues that have led to Harvard’s last-place ranking can be addressed.
Violations of Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964
On September 28, 2023, the Biden Administration issued a clarifying release stating that Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits certain forms of antisemitism, Islamophobia and related discrimination as part of its National Strategy to Counter Antisemitism released in May 2023 whitehouse.gov/wp-content/up… Title VI of the Civil Rights Act requires universities to provide all students, including students who are or are perceived to be Jewish, a school environment free from discrimination. The consequences for a university’s failure to meet the requirements of Title VI include the cancellation of federal funding.
Harvard has failed in recent weeks to meet its Title VI obligations which threatens a major source of the University’s funding. When coupled with numerous Jewish and non-Jewish alumni that have publicly and privately shared these same concerns, important sources of Harvard’s revenues are at risk. While the University should not need a financial incentive to eliminate discrimination on campus, Harvard’s recent failure to create a safe and non-discriminatory environment for Jewish students threatens the University’s funding for research, scholarships, and more.
Your Historic Opportunity
You have been president of Harvard, one of the most important institutions in the world, for four months at one of the most challenging times in its history. As Harvard’s leader, your words and actions are followed closely. As a result, the steps you take to address antisemitism at Harvard will be recognized around the world, and can contribute greatly as an example to other institutions seeking to eliminate antisemitism in all of its forms.
History has taught us that when the sparks and initial flames of antisemitism emerge, we must promptly put out the flames before a conflagration begins. It is therefore critically important you act with alacrity in addressing these issues. I encourage you to act boldly and promptly to eliminate this scourge at Harvard.
I also call upon you to complete the commitment you made at inauguration when you stated that “Knowledge is our purpose. We serve that purpose best when we commit to open inquiry and freedom of expression as foundational values of the academic community.” Harvard must create an environment where free speech is encouraged and accepted. At the same time, the Harvard community at large must understand the difference between speech protected by the First Amendment and speech that incites violence or seeks the elimination of any group. Such speech does not advance knowledge nor does it belong on campus regardless of whether or not it is protected by the First Amendment.
Successfully addressing antisemitism at Harvard and creating an environment with true freedom of expression will become a critically important part of your legacy as the Harvard community works together to address these challenges at a difficult time in world history.
I would be delighted to help in any way that I can to enable you to succeed in this mission and as Harvard’s president. Please let me know what more I can do to help.
Sincerely,
William A. Ackman
A.B. 1988, MBA 1992
cc: The Harvard Corporation Board;
Penny Pritzker, Chairman
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Swedish Member of Parliament Louise Meijer is a "social democrat" known for having supported the acceptance of large numbers of Muslim immigrants when they arrived in Sweden in 2015.
expressen.se/debatt/jag-har-…
She now says that she has completely changed her mind and understands how mass Muslim migration has changed her country. She writes:
"Sweden today is a completely different country than it was at the end of the 20th century. In modern times, Sweden per capita has received the most immigrants in the Western world and the rate of immigration has been higher than in other Western countries. Today, over a third of Sweden's population has a foreign background.
"In a new report, the Social Democrats themselves write: 'The biggest social change during the 21st century in Sweden is the changed demography due to immigration'...
"But it is clear to me that mass immigration to Sweden has led to several major problems. Most immigrants are not self-sufficient. Serious, organized crime is committed mostly by people with a foreign background. The culture of honor, separatism, and Islamism is limiting and dangerous."
expressen.se/debatt/jag-har-…
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
This is precisely the message for peace. Two key pillars:
1) Equally indigenous. Two states for two peoples: Jews and Arabs.
2) Long term work.
From the wisdom of the Jewish sages: “you are not tasked with finishing the job, but this does not release you from undertaking it.”
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
What Hamas did on October 7th is the logical conclusion of Islamism when they feel they have the power and the moment to act physically as opposed to applying pressure in other ways
Britain needs to have zero tolerance for Islamists expressing their hate and incitement
You have never seen psychopaths filled with such joy as Hamas terrorists had when killing men, women and children
They cut people’s heads off and burned them - yelling Allahu Akbar in a state of religious ecstasy
Nothing Islamists say is an affectation or empty threat
They genuinely despise non-Muslims and they will rape and kill and butcher you with pride and happiness
Take this shit seriously
It’s not a joke
They are at war with you and they will take advantage of any leeway you give them
There is no reasoning or compromising with them
Oppose them wherever and whenever they manifest themselves
They will destroy our civilisation - slow or fast, sneakily or openly, however they can achieve their aims
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
Hey @AlJazeera , we thought your journalists were supposed to give unbiased reports on situations, not actively participate in creating them on the front lines as Hamas terrorists.
A laptop that belonged to Muhammad Washah, an @AlJazeera journalist, was recovered by IDF in the northern Gaza Strip. It has pics proving he also serves as a senior Hamas military operative in the anti-tank missile array and in late 2022 he moved to work on R&D of aerial weapons for the organisation.
Intelligence analysis carried out on the computer includes photos linking subject to his Hamas activity.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
🚨 BREAKING: The IDF reveals that Hamza al-Dahdouh, the "journalist" killed in Gaza earlier this week, was a member of Palestinian Islamic Jihad's rocket engineering apparatus.
Here's a PIJ document with Hamza's name on it.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
🚨 Breaking: Israel 🇮🇱 just bombed civilians in Gaza 👇
Sorry for the typo, this is Bashar Assad's bombing of civilians in Idlib, Syria 🇸🇾 tonight.
Nobody cares.
teapawt.net/morphiaz/status/174123…
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
October 7 survivor just told me: “I used to believe in peace, but I don’t anymore. I used to trust Arabs, but I don’t anymore. A guy named Khaleel lived in our village for 30 years. We called him our brother. He slept in our homes. He ended up drawing a map of our homes in the village and gave it to Hamas to slaughter us. How can I trust after this?”
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
I repeatedly asked @jeremycorbyn if he thought Hamas was a terrorist group and whether they should stay in power in Gaza.
He repeatedly refused to answer either question. Staggering.
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
80 Years After Hitler Failed, Nazis Finally Seize London buff.ly/46aPACP
A. Norman 🇺🇸 retweeted
800 murdered civilians in Sudan and NOT A WORD of concern from the “humanitarian” Hamas Caucus?!
Got nothing to say because Jews can’t be blamed, @RashidaTlaib @IlhanMN @AOC?!
You’re a bunch of fake humanitarians but real Jew haters!
This quoted post is unavailable.

































