Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner) header
Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner) profile picture
🌕
Joined April 2023
Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)Photo by Bohan (@BohanTheRefiner)
This generation means that generation. Concede and consider other areas of prophecy to refute Preterism.
Sir please, the Exegesis I subscribe to is well documented in Orthodox Christianity. Calvin/Luther/Beale/Kline and down through the ages, you on the other hand know better I guess…
1
3
477
Preterists ☺️… Preterists and Futurists fighting again.
John, you have offered no exegesis only opinion. The word "genea" means contemporaries. This is not really debatable. Can you produce an example in Scripture where "genea" means something different? If not, this should be a major red flag for you.
1
3
214
Grace period was 490 years. We can discuss it here if you’d like. Someone in the thread blocked me I guess 🤷‍♂️
Jesus did not return in 70AD Judaism was destroyed “left desolate”. After a Grace Period to get Jews of that time to Come to Christ, the fulfillment of Judaism.
1
103
Yes I know. I hang with everyone: Preterists, Futurists. Doesn’t matter. I disagree with both. And I agree with both. Depends on the topic. I try not to block anyone. Not in to that.
I don’t think that’s what your compadres above adhere to. They are Full Preterists
2
78
He is risen.
1
156
USA Patriot blocked me about a month ago. Anyway… This debate about a 3rd temple can be resolved by reviewing the Greek usage of the word "temple." In 2 Thessalonians 2:4, Paul is referring to the spiritual temple. Not a temple complex in Jerusalem. If he was referring to a brick and mortar temple, he would have used the word ἱερόν (hieron). But he didn’t. Paul understood that the temple complex in Jerusalem was not "of God" — given that it was decreed by Jesus to be left desolate (void of Gods presence) Matt 23:38. ἱερόν (hieron) = temple precinct / physical structure → Paul’s term when he’s referring to the Jerusalem Temple Complex (as seen in Acts 21:26).
Replying to @2025usapatriot
How does not reading the manmade presupposition of “the Temple must be rebuilt and will be” into the text make Christ a liar? The pretrib rapture view uses proof-texting, an inconsistent hermeneutic, and lots of unbiblical presumptions to make their manmade eschatology work 🙏
1
1
258
Son of perdition is only mentioned twice. Once when referring to Judas Iscariot who was one of the 12. Paul is using the same Jewish idiom (son of perdition) to describe the way in which the man of sin is revealed. He emerges from within the church. He sits in the ‘temple of God’ — amongst the visible body of Christ. Paul is using "son of perdition" as a typological parallel. What he’s saying is that the lawless one *appears* to be ‘for’ Christ, *visibly*. But is actually against Christ. Or in other words: antichrist. Similar reality as Judas, who was one of the 12.
1
62
Most English translations do not distinguish the difference between Orgē and Thymos, rendering both Greek words as "wrath." It technically isn’t accurate to generalize the word "wrath." It causes theological confusion or misrepresentation. Which is one reason why the Complete Jewish Bible *does* render a distinction. Most of us do not read from the CJB, including myself except for researching translation differences. But the Blue Letter Bible has an app with an inter linear. It’s a good way to get familiar with the Greek, and cross reference with the translation that you’re already familiar with. And the BLB app is free. blueletterbible.org/
4
3
240
Translations that avoid the use of "wrath" in Luke 21:23. Orgē in this verse refers to God’s impending judgment (often linked to the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70), so alternatives like "judgement" or "punishment" characterize the *type* of anger in context, as divine moral judgment. Misconceptions can arise when the word "wrath" is rendered in the text — while the context is actually Devine Judgement (Orgē). Cross reference Orgē in Luke 21:23 with Orgē in 1 Thessalonians 2:16 "forbidding us to speak to the Gentiles that they may be saved, so as always to fill up the measure of their sins; but wrath (Orgē) has come upon them to the uttermost." I Thessalonians 2:16 NKJV In the 1st century, wrath (Orgē) has already come upon "them" to the uttermost. Given the broader context of the passage, who’s them?
90
Here is why the RAPTURE DEBATE was epic: Over 600 people attended. Mal Couch did a horrible job defending pretrib, angrily walking out of the building afterwards and refusing to take questions. DURING the debate, after listening to the prewrath viewpoint, the posttribs said they were more prewrath than posttrib! After the debate, Charles Cooper and Roger Best were surrounded by countless people wanting to learn more about the prewrath viewpoint. LISTEN to Charles Cooper explain the prewrath view: youtu.be/srusBwAKe5Q?si=SvC5…
6
9
43
6,202
Bible translations matter. The Greek adverb πρῶτον (prōton) is in the text. So it shouldn’t be omitted from any translation. Omitting the word "first" potentially obscures the *primary* intent of Paul’s explicit time statement. Some Bible translations have updated *editions* that include the word "first" — as in the case of the ESV. Bottom line: There’s no reason to remove it. For anyone interested: The Blue Letter Bible is a helpful resource to cross reference the Greek — and they have a free app. blueletterbible.org/
3
2
3
210
“Let no one deceive you by any means; for that Day will not come unless the falling away comes first, and the man of sin is revealed, the son of perdition,” II Thessalonians 2:3 NKJV
1
2
97
The Book of Daniel is written in two languages: Biblical Hebrew and Biblical Aramaic This color-coded chiastic structure ⬇️ is in the Aramaic section of Daniel. Language Breakdown by Chapters/Verses • Hebrew sections: • Daniel 1:1 – 2:4a (the introduction and setup in the Babylonian court). • Daniel 8:1 – 12:13 (the later apocalyptic visions). • Aramaic section: • Daniel 2:4b – 7:28 (the central portion, starting mid-verse in 2:4 with the Chaldeans speaking to the king in Aramaic — "Then the Chaldeans spoke to the king in Aramaic…" — and continuing through the narratives and the first vision). This creates a clear linguistic sandwich: Hebrew → Aramaic → Hebrew.
1
1
80
Significance of the Language Division Scholars and commentators highlight several interconnected reasons for this bilingual structure, which is deliberate and serves literary, theological, and historical purposes: 1. Audience and Thematic Focus • The Aramaic section (chs. 2–7) concerns Gentile (non-Jewish) kings and empires — stories set in Babylonian/Persian courts, involving Nebuchadnezzar, Belshazzar, and others. It includes court tales of faithfulness under persecution (fiery furnace, lions’ den) and visions of world empires. Aramaic, as the common international language spoken by these Gentile rulers and empires, makes the message accessible to a broader “world” audience. It conveys God’s sovereignty over Gentile nations during the “times of the Gentiles” (Luke 21:24). • The Hebrew sections (chs. 1 and 8–12) focus more directly on Israel/Jewish concerns: the exile’s beginning, Daniel’s faithfulness as a Jew, and apocalyptic visions about Israel’s future suffering, restoration, the end times, and resurrection. Hebrew (the sacred language of the Jews) suits these parts addressed primarily to God’s people. 2. Literary Structure and Chiasms • The Aramaic portion (chs. 2–7) forms a self-contained chiastic unit (as we discussed earlier: ch. 2 mirrors ch. 7 with four-kingdom visions; ch. 3 mirrors ch. 6 with deliverance stories; ch. 4 mirrors ch. 5 with proud kings humbled/judged). • The Hebrew portions (chs. 1 + 8–12) create a parallel or complementary chiastic framework around it. • This bilingual chiasm emphasizes symmetry, divine order, and the book’s unity despite the language shift. 3. Historical and Cultural Context • Aramaic was the dominant administrative and diplomatic language in Babylon and Persia (similar to how English functions globally today). Daniel, as a high court official educated in Babylonian ways, would naturally use it for records or messages involving Gentile rulers. • The shift also dates the book plausibly to the exile/Persian period (6th–5th century BC), as the Aramaic matches Imperial Aramaic dialects of that era. 4. Theological Message • It underscores that God’s kingdom and judgments extend over all nations (Aramaic for Gentiles) while His redemptive plan centers on Israel (Hebrew). Note: Debates on the identity of Israel, for another thread. • The structure highlights universal sovereignty: God reveals Himself to pagan kings in their language, humbles empires, protects the faithful, and promises ultimate victory.
1
59
Daniel 9:24-27 contains several interlocking chiastic (inverted-parallel) patterns, a hallmark of Hebrew prophetic poetry. These structures emphasize the Messiah and the timing of the 70 weeks at the center, while framing the prophecy thematically rather than strictly chronologically — while still outlining the 70 week timeline. A Decree at the beginning Decree at the end B Restore the City Destroy the City C Messiah the Prince Messiah is crucified
2
82
Daniel 9:24-27 is written in a chiastic structure, using "repetition with elaboration" — which is common and frequent in apocalyptic literature. The 70 weeks literally style is "apocalyptic prophecy, with elements of poetry and prose." It goes beyond basic parallelism and elevated prose. Scholars frequently highlight how these features shape interpretation, especially regarding sequence, emphasis, and the prophecy’s overall flow. 1. Alternating Focus / Bifocal Pattern (Poetic Alternation) A prominent "poetic pattern" observed by many analysts is the deliberate alternation between two main themes or foci: • Jerusalem / the city and sanctuary (restoration, building, trouble, destruction, desolation). • The Messiah / anointed one (coming of Messiah the Prince, being cut off, covenant confirmation). This back-and-forth shifting (e.g., Jerusalem in the first 7 weeks, Messiah tied to the 62 weeks, then destruction of the city, Messiah cut off, etc.) creates a rhythmic, non-linear progression. It prevents a strictly chronological reading and instead presents the prophecy as intertwined divine purposes — restoration and Messiah-centered redemption on one hand, opposition and desolation on the other. This alternation underscores that events involving the city and the anointed figure are parallel or overlapping rather than strictly sequential. 2. Chiastic (Inverted) Structure: The passage is widely analyzed as forming one or more chiasms (A-B-C … C-B-A patterns), a common Hebrew poetic/literary device that places emphasis at the center: • A typical outline pairs elements like: • Decree to restore/build Jerusalem → Messiah the Prince → 7 + 62 weeks. • Then inverted: After 62 weeks Messiah cut off → people of the coming prince destroy city/sanctuary → covenant confirmed for one week → desolation. • The center often highlights the Messiah’s arrival/cutting off or the 62 weeks, drawing attention to the anointed figure. • Some see a larger chiasm linking v. 27’s “one week” back to the Messiah in v. 25, reinforcing that the “he” who confirms the covenant refers to the Messiah (not a future antagonist in some interpretations). This structure emphasizes thematic symmetry over pure timeline, helping explain why the prophecy uses “repetition with elaboration” (v. 26 and v. 27 restate and expand similar ideas poetically). 3. Repetition with Elaboration / Revelatorial Pattern Hebrew prophetic poetry often repeats ideas for emphasis, building layers rather than advancing a step-by-step story. Here: • Verse 24 gives a summary of the 70 weeks’ purposes (six infinitives in parallel). • Verses 25–26 elaborate on starting point, divisions, and key events. • Verse 27 repeats/expands v. 26’s themes (covenant, destruction/desolation). This “revelatorial” style reveals progressively deeper insights into the same period, not new sequential stages. 4. Lineation and Perceptibility Recent studies test formal criteria (e.g., cola balance, syntactic units aligning with poetic lines, linguistic contrasts with surrounding prose) and conclude the passage has a high density of "lineated discourse" markers — making it read more like crafted poetic lines than flowing prose. This supports printing it in poetic format in Bibles, enhancing its rhythmic, memorable impact as apocalyptic revelation. In essence, these poetic elements — alternation, chiasm, repetition/elaboration, and lineation — make the sequence more thematic and symmetrical than strictly chronological. They invite readers to see the 70 weeks as a unified divine plan centered on Messiah, restoration, and ultimate resolution of sin.
1
48
There is nothing in the original Hebrew text of Daniel 9:24–27 (from the Masoretic Text) that linguistically or structurally suggests detaching any portion of the “seventy weeks” (שָׁבֻעִים שִׁבְעִים, shāvuʿīm shivʿīm—understood as 490 years via the prophetic day-year principle) from a continuous historical fulfillment (potentially aligning with a first-century context, e.g., Messiah’s arrival and crucifixion) and placing it in the distant future. Claims of a “gap” (e.g., between the 69th and 70th weeks, as in some dispensationalist/futurist interpretations) rely on external theological frameworks, not inherent textual indicators. A close examination of the Hebrew grammar, vocabulary, structure, and sequence: Key Hebrew Text Breakdown (Masoretic Text, Literal Rendering) • Verse 24: “Seventy weeks are cut out/decreed (נֶחְתַּךְ, neḥtak—Niphal of חָתַךְ, implying a precise, severed unit) upon your people and upon your holy city, to finish/restrain the transgression (לְכַלֵּא הַפֶּשַׁע), to seal up sins (וּלְהָתֵם חַטָּאת), to atone for iniquity (וּלְכַפֵּר עָוֺן), to bring in everlasting righteousness (וּלְהָבִיא צֶדֶק עֹלָמִים), to seal vision and prophet (וְלַחְתֹּם חָזוֹן וְנָבִיא), and to anoint a most holy (place/one) (וְלִמְשֹׁחַ קֹדֶשׁ קָדָשִׁים).” • This frames the 70 weeks as a unified, contiguous block with six infinitive purposes (לְ + verb forms), all to be accomplished within the decreed period. No Hebrew word or phrase hints at interruption—e.g., no temporal adverbs like “after many days” (אַחֲרֵי יָמִים רַבִּים, as in Daniel 8:26 or 10:14) or conditional clauses for a pause. • Verse 25: “Know and understand (וְתֵדַע וְתַשְׂכֵּל): from the going forth of the word (מִן-מֹצָא דָבָר) to restore and build Jerusalem unto an anointed prince (עַד-מָשִׁיחַ נָגִיד)—seven weeks (שָׁבֻעִים שִׁבְעָה); and sixty-two weeks (וְשָׁבֻעִים שִׁשִּׁים וּשְׁנַיִם), it shall be built again with plaza and moat, but in distressful times (וּבְצוֹק הָעִתִּים).” • Arithmetic sequence: 7 + 62 = 69 weeks, presented as continuous phases without separation. The vav-consecutive (וְ) chain implies logical/temporal flow. • Verse 26: “And after (וְאַחֲרֵי) the sixty-two weeks, an anointed (one) shall be cut off (יִכָּרֵת מָשִׁיחַ) and have nothing; and the city and the sanctuary shall be destroyed by the people of the coming prince (עַם נָגִיד הַבָּא), and its end (shall be) with a flood (וְקִצּוֹ בַשֶּׁטֶף), and until the end war—determined desolations (נֶחֱרֶצֶת שֹׁמֵמוֹת).” • “After” (וְאַחֲרֵי) directly follows the 69 weeks, with no gap marker. Events (Messiah cut off, destruction) are sequential, tied by vav-consecutives. No futuristic shift; the prince’s people could refer to historical Romans (e.g., Titus in AD 70). • Verse 27: “And he shall strengthen/confirm (וְהִגְבִּיר) a covenant with many (for) one week (שָׁבוּעַ אֶחָד); and in the midst of the week (וַחֲצִי הַשָּׁבוּעַ) he shall cause sacrifice and offering to cease (יַשְׁבִּית זֶבַח וּמִנְחָה); and upon the wing of abominations (shall be) a desolator (וְעַל כְּנַף שִׁקּוּצִים מְשֹׁמֵם), even until the consummation, and that determined, shall be poured out upon the desolated (וְעַד-כָּלָה וְנֶחֱרָצָה תִּתַּךְ עַל-שֹׁמֵם).” • The “one week” (שָׁבוּעַ אֶחָד) is the final/70th week, introduced with vav-consecutive (וְ), implying immediate continuation. “He” (subject pronoun implied) could refer back to the Messiah (confirming covenant) or prince (causing desolation), but the text flows without temporal dislocation. No Hebrew elements (e.g., adverbs like “in the distant future” or disjunctive clauses) indicate a millennia-long extraction.
2
2
115
For those interested in researching this further, one area of focus that might be of interest, is the "vav-consecutive (וְ)."
53
In my opinion, the 24 elders are raptured saints (likely prophets) from the Matthew 27 resurrection.
1
1
57