Pinned Tweet
Statement of the Committee on the Rights of the Child #UNCRC on the occasion of the Protection of Civilians Week. Accountability for grave violations against children is crucial for realizing their rights in armed conflict. #childrensrights @lexpsy
CoE (CDBIO, 2026): reading, recording or altering a person’s mind, once the Art 3 threshold is met, is “subject to no exception” and cannot be “balanced against any legitimate aim”. Art 2 and 14 also apply. Oversight that only balances cannot see it.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/6sjl4u531…
26
Kaikkien toimijoiden tulisi osallistua demokratiaan. Nyt siitä on tullut valtion hallinnon peli, jota pelataan myös rajojen ulkopuolelta ilman sääntöjä. Kansalaisen rooli pelissä on olla ainoa, jota säännöt koskevat.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/4wlekub29…
Section 5 maps the ECtHR case law (Natunen, Khelili, Pietrzak, Allen and more) against the gaps it leaves. @IntLawReporter @IntlLawBlog @Lauterpacht_Ctr @asilorg @LJIL_Leiden @oxfordPIL @ILA_official @ejiltalk @ECHRBlog @StrasbourgObse1 @Verfblogger @sevslv
When a state chooses what to keep about the people it targets, it builds the case before any court sees it. Our new paper shows how Finnish law keeps records to protect officers, destroys what could clear the citizen, and where European case law stops.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/h0ouehe0g…
49
The person’s own record has no legal protection. The State’s selected record travels to partners abroad. @fidh_en @IHRF_English @hrw @FrontLineHRD @CIJ_ICJ @privacyint @article19org @StatewatchEU @DanyaChaikel @fairtrials
When a state chooses what to keep about the people it targets, it builds the case before any court sees it. Our new paper shows how Finnish law keeps records to protect officers, destroys what could clear the citizen, and where European case law stops.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/h0ouehe0g…
2
46
When a person turns to an international body, the State answers from the same selected record. @PACE_President @PACE_LegalHR @coe @CommissionerHR @coedemocracy @chr_humanrights @michaelCJT @IntlCrimCourt @CourPenaleInt @UNGeneva @UNHumanRights @UN_HRC
When a state chooses what to keep about the people it targets, it builds the case before any court sees it. Our new paper shows how Finnish law keeps records to protect officers, destroys what could clear the citizen, and where European case law stops.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/h0ouehe0g…
3
45
UNESCO’s 2025 Recommendation (para 140(c)) calls for a ban on neurotechnology that manipulates people during sleep, political use included. Nothing lets the person obtain the evidence. @UN_SPExperts @profbensaul @Srjudgeslawyers @DrAliceJEdwards @Pau90874459 @MaryLawlorhrds
When a state chooses what to keep about the people it targets, it builds the case before any court sees it. Our new paper shows how Finnish law keeps records to protect officers, destroys what could clear the citizen, and where European case law stops.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/h0ouehe0g…
When a state chooses what to keep about the people it targets, it builds the case before any court sees it. Our new paper shows how Finnish law keeps records to protect officers, destroys what could clear the citizen, and where European case law stops.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/h0ouehe0g…
HE 137/2026: valtio voisi ottaa omaisuuden ilman rikostuomiota, kun esitutkinta on aloitettu. Hallituksen mukaan vastaaja voi puolustautua. CIVIX ry kysyy perustuslakivaliokunnalta: miten ihminen saa tietää esitutkinnasta, jota hänelle ei ole pakko kertoa?
dropbox.com/scl/fi/fktopkk99…
Eduskunta on säätänyt neljästi, että aineiston saa säilyttää asianosaisen oikeusturvan vuoksi — aina kun suojattava toimii valtion lukuun. Kun kohteena on kansalainen, säännös puuttuu. Laki lupaa sen käytön syyttömyyden tueksi. Kahdesti.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/avnidryah…
A doctrinal analysis of what the SOFA / DCA / Forward Land Forces framework actually changes — and does not change — about a host state's accountability for conduct reaching a person on its own soil.
Not an allegation. A reading of the instruments against ECHR Article 1, effective-control attribution (Al-Jedda, Jaloud), and the duty to investigate.
The finding: the framework adjusts jurisdiction, cascades classification, and formalises cooperation — but displaces none of the substantive obligations. It produces the appearance of legal exemption without the substance.
The exemption operates by default, not by law — and holds only until it is tested. The argument generalises to every member state hosting equivalent arrangements.
We welcome scrutiny and correction; that is why it is published before submission to international mechanisms.
@fidh_en @IntLawReporter @IntlLawBlog @sevslv
@Lauterpacht_Ctr @AJIL_andUnbound @asilorg @LJIL_Leiden @oxfordPIL @ILA_official @ejiltalk @ECHRBlog @StrasbourgObse1 @Verfblogger @StatewatchEU
When a state hosts foreign forces under the SOFA, the Defence Cooperation Agreement, and the Forward Land Forces framework, what do those instruments actually change — in law — about accountability for conduct that reaches a person on that state's own soil?
CIVIX ry publishes a legal analysis. This is not an allegation: it names no operation and no person. It is a doctrinal question.
The finding: the framework changes less than it appears to. It does not displace a state's Article 1 ECHR duty to secure Convention rights on its territory; it does not defeat attribution where the state holds effective control; it does not extinguish the duty to investigate.
It produces the appearance of legal exemption without the substance. The exemption operates by default, not by law — and holds only until it is tested.
Published ahead of a submission to international mechanisms, so the reasoning is open to scrutiny first.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/licg0yesw…
149
When a state hosts foreign forces under the SOFA, the Defence Cooperation Agreement, and the Forward Land Forces framework, what do those instruments actually change — in law — about accountability for conduct that reaches a person on that state's own soil?
CIVIX ry publishes a legal analysis. This is not an allegation: it names no operation and no person. It is a doctrinal question.
The finding: the framework changes less than it appears to. It does not displace a state's Article 1 ECHR duty to secure Convention rights on its territory; it does not defeat attribution where the state holds effective control; it does not extinguish the duty to investigate.
It produces the appearance of legal exemption without the substance. The exemption operates by default, not by law — and holds only until it is tested.
Published ahead of a submission to international mechanisms, so the reasoning is open to scrutiny first.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/licg0yesw…
Finland's Deputy Prosecutor-General, @syyttajalaitos has charged seven people over the Security Police's conduct — the charges concern the limits of police powers, the means used, and the handling of classified information. The methods themselves are now before the court.
Yet the same authority continues to commission executive assistance and to build the grounds for it. Where military, non-kinetic capability is directed at civilians on their home soil under that assistance, the persons live trapped between Articles 2 and 3 of the Convention: subjected to effects that cause pain and injury, which no body will independently verify.
We ask the prosecution authority directly: if the lawfulness of the Security Police's methods is already serious enough to charge, why is the use of those methods permitted to continue while the matter is tried? Who carries the risk to life and health that arises in the meantime?
The Article 3 prohibition is absolute. It does not yield to national security, in war or in peace. A method that produces pain or injury is not a covert investigative measure — it is a method of warfare, and it has no lawful place directed at a civilian.
— CIVIX ry
@profbensaul @SRjudgeslawyers @MaryLawlorhrds @Pau90874459 @DrAliceJEdwards - respectfully for your attention.
Finland's Deputy Prosecutor-General, @syyttajalaitos has charged seven people over the Security Police's conduct — the charges concern the limits of police powers, the means used, and the handling of classified information. The methods themselves are now before the court.
Yet the same authority continues to commission executive assistance and to build the grounds for it. Where military, non-kinetic capability is directed at civilians on their home soil under that assistance, the persons live trapped between Articles 2 and 3 of the Convention: subjected to effects that cause pain and injury, which no body will independently verify.
We ask the prosecution authority directly: if the lawfulness of the Security Police's methods is already serious enough to charge, why is the use of those methods permitted to continue while the matter is tried? Who carries the risk to life and health that arises in the meantime?
The Article 3 prohibition is absolute. It does not yield to national security, in war or in peace. A method that produces pain or injury is not a covert investigative measure — it is a method of warfare, and it has no lawful place directed at a civilian.
— CIVIX ry
@profbensaul @SRjudgeslawyers @MaryLawlorhrds @Pau90874459 @DrAliceJEdwards - respectfully for your attention.
Either the measure is applied contrary to its own preventive logic (a competence and lawfulness failure), or it is applied for a purpose other than the one the statute authorises.
There is some demand for a serious evaluation on the operational rational of intelligence services in Finland: If these methods are preventive in purpose, a measure that leaves its subject no option but to seek remedies publicly increases rather than reduces any security concern — so a genuinely preventive regime would offer a conditional off-ramp. The absence of one means the measure is either not preventive in the way claimed, or is being applied without regard to its own stated logic. That is a question about whether the statutory purpose (necessity, proportionality, prevention) is actually being served — which is exactly what oversight exists to test.
Our intelligence agencies may not be so intelligent after all.
Apulaisvaltakunnansyyttäjä, @syyttajalaitos on nostanut syytteet seitsemää vastaan Suojelupoliisin toiminnassa — kyse on toimivallan ylityksistä, toimivaltakeinoista ja salassa pidettävien tietojen käsittelystä. Menetelmät ovat siis syyteharkinnan kohteena.
Samaan aikaan sama viranomainen jatkaa virka-avun tilaamista ja perusteiden rakentamista sitä varten. Tämä tapahtuu §5a:n alla, kun oikeudellista perustetta ei ole. Kun virka-apuna ohjataan sotilaallista, ei-kineettistä suorituskykyä kotimaan alueella siviiliin, kohde elää pysyvässä loukussa EIS 2 ja 3 artiklan välissä: kipua ja vammoja tuottavaa vaikuttamista, jota mikään taho ei puolueettomasti todenna. Puolustusvoimat jatkavat sille annetun luottamuksen väärinkäyttämistä ei-kineettisten menetelmien kalibroijana.
Kysymme suoraan syyttäjälaitokselta: jos Suojelupoliisin menetelmien lainmukaisuus on jo syyteharkinnan arvoinen kysymys, miksi näiden menetelmien käyttö saa jatkua sinä aikana, kun asiaa tutkitaan? Kenen vastuulla on se riski hengelle ja terveydelle, joka syntyy sillä välin?
3 artiklan kielto on ehdoton. Se ei jousta kansallisen turvallisuuden nimissä, ei sodan aikana eikä rauhan. Menetelmä, joka tuottaa kipua tai vammoja, ei ole salainen pakkokeino — se on sodankäynnin menetelmä, eikä sillä ole laillista sijaa siviiliin kohdistettuna.
Salaista pakkokeinoa (PKL 10) valvoo tuomioistuin lupamenettelyssä. Mutta poliisilain 5a luvun nojalla ei epäillä ketään eikä rikosta edellytetä — mikä tuomioistuin tällöin testaa virka-avun ja ei-kineettisen suorituskyvyn kohdistamisen henkilöön? Vai kohdistetaanko sitä ilman pakkokeinolupaa lainkaan?
Jos originaatio on sotilastiedustelussa, molemmilla on oma valtuutusregiiminsä, kumpikaan ei ole PKL 10:n mukainen pakkokeinolupa. Jos ei-kineettistä suorituskykyä kohdistetaan henkilöön kummankaan nojalla, mikä tuomioistuin sen testaa — vai ei mikään?
— CIVIX ry
@tiedusteluvalv @oikeusasiamies @oikeuskansleri @tuomioistuinlaitos @SuomenPoliisi @SuomenEduskunta @KiuruPauli @matslofstrom @Suojelupoliisi @Puolustusvoimat
Finland's Deputy Prosecutor-General, @syyttajalaitos has charged seven people over the Security Police's conduct — the charges concern the limits of police powers, the means used, and the handling of classified information. The methods themselves are now before the court.
Yet the same authority continues to commission executive assistance and to build the grounds for it. Where military, non-kinetic capability is directed at civilians on their home soil under that assistance, the persons live trapped between Articles 2 and 3 of the Convention: subjected to effects that cause pain and injury, which no body will independently verify.
We ask the prosecution authority directly: if the lawfulness of the Security Police's methods is already serious enough to charge, why is the use of those methods permitted to continue while the matter is tried? Who carries the risk to life and health that arises in the meantime?
The Article 3 prohibition is absolute. It does not yield to national security, in war or in peace. A method that produces pain or injury is not a covert investigative measure — it is a method of warfare, and it has no lawful place directed at a civilian.
— CIVIX ry
@profbensaul @SRjudgeslawyers @MaryLawlorhrds @Pau90874459 @DrAliceJEdwards - respectfully for your attention.
In June 2023, Finland created a working collective redress mechanism. A designated association can now sue on behalf of a group — including for data protection breaches. It can only be used against companies.
Against a public authority — the State, the police, a welfare county, a ministry — there is no collective remedy of any kind.
A hundred people subject to the same administrative practice have a hundred separate procedures, and no route by which the practice itself is ever examined.
The asymmetry sits inside one authority's toolkit. The Data Protection Ombudsman was designated a qualified entity by the same reform.
Same breach: a collective instrument when the controller is a business, nothing when it is the State.
Meanwhile the Ministry of Justice is preparing to restrict individual administrative appeals, including a penalty for "abuse of process" whose criteria are not stated.
Narrowing the individual route where no collective route exists narrows the only route there is.
The legislature has already accepted the reasoning: where many suffer the same harm from the same practice, individual litigation is not an adequate response.
On what basis does that not apply when the counterparty is a public authority?
dropbox.com/scl/fi/u0nac57lk…
ANCESTORS' CHOICE
A civilization is one organism. We stand apart above the ground and are a single root-web beneath it. When corruption enters that web, every tree still looks like itself. The sickness is underground.
Almost everyone is held by the structures they live in. Some entered them and could, in principle, withdraw. Others never chose — the structure came and took them. Only the second kind can see clearly, because the structure never gave them anything to protect.
Parents think they protect their children with savings and a safe district. Alongside that runs a probability they never look at: the odds their descendant is the one the machine draws.
To protect the organism, a mirror must be faced, individually as an organism.
dropbox.com/scl/fi/t7x7184j7…
'Nulla poena sine lege', no punishment without law - yet the sentence runs for life and no court ever passed it.
People That Are Not Their Records — Their Records Are National Security
dropbox.com/scl/fi/od8uspcmx…




