Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX) header
Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX) profile picture

Academy Associate @ChathamHouse /@SchwarzmanOrg Scholar 2023 / Spent time in @UKParliament / Ex-President @OxfordUnion

London, England
Joined December 2019
Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)Photo by Chengkai Xie (@ChengkaiX)
Chengkai Xie retweeted
Useful framing by @ZhaiXiang5 into why the trilateral has appeal for Beijing.
For 31 years, the leaders of China, the United States, and Russia have shared photographs. On November 19, they will finally share a negotiating table of their own. And it will happen in China. Following announcements by the United States and Russia over the weekend, China's Foreign Ministry announced at 9 am Beijing time on November 16 that Chinese President Xi Jinping would hold a trilateral summit with Russian President Vladimir Putin and US President @realDonaldTrump in south China's city of Shenzhen (深圳) on November 19. I spent some time going through the historical records of meetings between the leaders of these three countries. And one thing stood out to me: This appears to be the first dedicated trilateral summit between the heads of state of China, the United States, and Russia in history. And the historical journey leading to this moment is fascinating. The earliest event attended simultaneously by the presidents of China, the United States, and Russia appears to date back to May, 1995. Russia held commemorations in Moscow marking the 50th anniversary of victory in WWII. Chinese President Jiang Zemin (江泽民), US President Bill Clinton, and Russian President Boris Yeltsin attended the military parade in Red Square. In October of the same year, the three leaders gathered again in New York to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the founding of the United Nations (top right). Since then, with the development of international multilateral diplomatic mechanisms, the leaders of China, the United States, and Russia have had increasingly frequent opportunities to appear together on the world stage. In 1998, Russia officially joined APEC. However, then-President Yeltsin did not personally attend Russia's first two APEC Economic Leaders' Meetings, instead sending his premiers to represent the country. On November 15-16, 2000 (exactly 26 years ago!), Chinese President Jiang Zemin, US President @BillClinton, and Russian President Vladimir Putin all attended the eighth APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting held in Brunei (bottom left). In October of the following year, the ninth meeting was held in Shanghai (上海), bringing together Jiang, George W. Bush, and Putin (bottom right). I was still in middle school at the time, and I remember watching Jiang deliver a speech in English on live television. In 2014, China hosted the APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting for the second time, with Xi, @BarackObama, and Vladimir Putin in attendance (top left). The upcoming APEC Economic Leaders' Meeting, scheduled for November 18-19 in Shenzhen, will mark the third time China has hosted the event. Since the establishment of the G20 leaders' summit mechanism in 2008, the leaders of China, the United States, and Russia have had even more opportunities to cross paths on the international stage. Yet one particularly intriguing fact stands out: Over the past three decades, the leaders of China, the United States, and Russia have appeared together in numerous group photographs, but they have never actually sat down at a negotiating table specifically set for a trilateral meeting. And the September 2000 summit of the five permanent members of the UN Security Council in New York was a five-party meeting, rather than a dedicated trilateral meeting between China, the United States, and Russia. On November 19, that changes. Why does this matter? Here is how I see it: Diplomacy: bring adversaries together. Ideas: challenge the logic of inevitable confrontation. Strategy: maintain relations without choosing sides. Institutions: turn a historic meeting into lasting dialogue. The summit's first significance is what it reveals about China's diplomatic convening power. Bringing friends together is easy. Bringing adversaries to the same table is an entirely different matter. The influence of a great power should be measured not only by whom it can deter, but also by whom it can bring together. Second, the summit offers an opportunity to challenge some of the most deeply entrenched and flawed assumptions in international relations. China has long advocated a balanced approach to justice and interests (正确义利观), a vision that fundamentally challenges traditional thinking in IR. In my view, conventional notions such as the primacy of national interests, the security dilemma, and the clash of civilizations are increasingly ill-suited to today's international landscape and serve only to generate unnecessary suspicion, hostility and conflict. This is not a new argument for me. During my time studying in the Department of Government at Cornell, I repeatedly questioned some of the fundamental assumptions underlying mainstream international relations theory. Yet I often encountered considerable resistance from a few professors and their overzealous TAs who seemed more committed to defending established intellectual paradigms than to examining their limitations. And I have always wondered: What happens when a theory designed to explain conflict becomes a prescription for producing it? One of the great tragedies of American foreign policy, in my view, is that some of its intellectual architects have become so invested in theories of competition and confrontation that they struggle to imagine a world organized around cooperation and mutual benefit. This summit will provide an important opportunity and a global platform for China to promote its vision of a new type of international relations. Whether China can encourage the world's major powers to move beyond some of their differences and seek common ground will be one of the most important aspects of this meeting to watch. New ideas about IR are not ultimately judged by how persuasive they sound in academic journals, but by whether they can help make the world a more peaceful place. Third, China does not need to undermine its relationship with one major power to demonstrate the strength of its relationship with another. Does a stronger China-Russia relationship necessarily mean a weaker China-US relationship? Does improving relations with Washington require Beijing to distance itself from Moscow? Why should China have to choose? Washington and Moscow may both hope that China will play a role in addressing certain issues, but whether Beijing will accept the agenda they seek to set remains to be seen. Fourth, perhaps the most consequential question is what happens after November 19. Will Shenzhen be remembered as a one-off diplomatic event, or as the beginning of a new mechanism preventing bloc confrontation in international politics? If the three countries can build on this meeting to establish more stable channels of communication, or even gradually institutionalize regular trilateral summits, its historical significance could extend far beyond that of a single APEC summit. Some have drawn comparisons between this meeting and the Cairo, Tehran, Yalta, and Potsdam conferences. I do not share that view. The differences in national interests, strategic disagreements, and levels of mutual trust among the three countries mean that establishing such a mechanism will be anything but easy. Moreover, no mechanism for dialogue among major powers should imply that a handful of powerful countries have the right to determine the fate of others. Its true value should lie in reducing the risk of confrontation, not in dividing the world into spheres of influence. The world is not short of great-power competition. What it lacks are mechanisms to prevent that competition from spiraling out of control. November 19 will give us another historic photograph. What happens afterward will determine its place in history.
3
8
28
4,601
Chengkai Xie retweeted
Great to see Berry Brothers DC thriving a year and a week since it launched stateside
4
5
123
8,745
Chengkai Xie retweeted
David Cameron: I loved coming back as Foreign Secretary. Mishal Husain: So if Kemi Badenoch is elected Prime Minister, you are available? David Cameron: I am absolutely available.
David Cameron Says Britain Should Leave the ECHR order-order.com/2026/11/13/d…
5
7
58
3,309
Chengkai Xie retweeted
The School of Pythagoras, Cambridge. Owned by Merton College, Oxford from 1266 to 1959, there’s an interesting alternative history in which this becomes the first Oxbridge College. As it was, it served as an insurance policy for Mertonians in case life in Oxford became too tough.
8
17
2
270
7,383
Chengkai Xie retweeted
Dua Lipa celebrates her husband Callum Turner's casting as the next James Bond in a new Instagram post. Via: @FlashCrave_
156
635
237
17,198
1,553,168
Chengkai Xie retweeted
London, you didn't reaaaally think we'd forget about you? 👀 In 2014, Josephine set her phone background to the Royal Albert Hall for a year. Now we're playing it. With an orchestra. 💛 Royal Albert Hall w/ the Technicolour Orchestra, 19.05.27.
6
13
9
248
11,594
Oh boy. Already can't wait to get out to the other side...
Today is the last time the sun will set in Oxford after 6pm. The next time the sun sets after 6pm will be in March 2027. And so the early evenings begin. 📷 Instagram | ObservingOxford
5
4
1
199
18,721
Chengkai Xie retweeted
MAD WORLD is out now, our first song in 4 years. We wrote it at the piano together in response to headlines of AI, war and climate change. What no one can take away from us is hope. Thank you for sticking with us. We've only just started…
13
87
16
886
12,250
Chengkai Xie retweeted
“If there are a million ways to win, [Britain] will find the one reason not to do it.”
Jensen Huang has a message for the UK
7
35
6,636
Chengkai Xie retweeted
The busiest job in Westminster is running after the PM with a dustpan and brush, sweeping up whatever he said five minutes earlier. Implying the 2016 referendum was illegitimate, until the entire govt comms machine scrambled to clarify what he said. Opening up a Scottish referendum, which his team had to shut down. Telling the WASPI women they deserved recompense, only to backtrack. Burnham is all over the place, making statements he clearly hasn’t thought through.
438
1,263
51
9,218
187,982
Chengkai Xie retweeted
🚣Burnham now seriously rowing back on Brexit/Russia in the Commons He says: "It is a matter of record, Mr Speaker, that Russian actors sought to interfere in the 2019 general election, and we think it is inconceivable that this was the first time." But on the Rest Is Politics he said: "I asked the question coming to Downing Street, was there interference in the 2016 referendum from Russia? And I've had the clear answer that yes, there was." But "we think it's inconceivable" is very different to "clear answer" of successful interference.
60
169
28
823
375,379
Chengkai Xie retweeted
Despair inducing the economic illiteracy.
French Presidential Candidate Jean-Luc Mélenchon: They tell us, "We must reassure the markets." Reassure the markets? What are their names? Where do they live? Let me go and reassure them! What market? What are you talking about? There is no market. There are hedge funds, financial companies and insurance companies.
2
7
3
64
8,363
Chengkai Xie retweeted
canary wharf is the marmite of london. i think the people who hate it just aren't used to things actually working, being clean, being safe i've lived in london 7+ years, the last 3 in a tower in canary wharf. concierge, gym in the building, air con. i love it 2 malls, loads of food and drink, coffee spots. dlr, elizabeth line, jubilee, uber boat, plus a cycle highway into the city. but apparently that's "not real london"
Canary Wharf is the perfect place to live in London if you want to lock in: - Third space gym (Europe's largest luxury health club) - Everything is extremely close together - Literally zero distractions - 10 min underground ride away from Central - Coworking areas with free drinks + private rooms to take calls - Cracked community of founders and influencers Haven't seen any downside so far
169
74
50
2,139
551,989
Chengkai Xie retweeted
Replying to @Inariokami__
少しの山東省訛りがあった😅
4
1
29
62,375
This is what the Chinese built for the same price and over the same period
Cars and buses go from Oxford Station down Botley Road for the first time in three years! The project took longer than the construction of The Titanic and saw costs balloon to £237m. Looks good though.
117
1,228
34
26,976
1,164,295
Chengkai Xie retweeted
Well the body language says a lot
In New York City, Vice Premier He Lifeng and I are continuing our discussions on the U.S.-China economic and trade relationship ahead of @POTUS’ historic summit with President Xi in Washington. These talks help lay the groundwork for President Trump to advance America’s economic interests and deliver results for the American people.
6
2
44
26,754
Chengkai Xie retweeted
🚨 NEW: Kemi Badenoch has announced the Tories would bring back tax-free shopping for overseas non-EU visitors "Britain should be the place where the whole world comes to shop"
247
118
94
1,619
415,612
Chengkai Xie retweeted
genuinely insane levels of awkwardness in this interview
16
10
5
609
88,408
You know this show is completely fictitious when the UK has the same PM for 4 seasons
A stolen nuke. A broken marriage. An unpredictable president. Keri Russell is back as Kate Wyler in The Diplomat Season 4. Premiering OCTOBER 15.
296
5,147
233
61,984
2,245,197
Unexpected coldplay concert incident in China
56
708
104
9,060
809,449