Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT) profile picture
Joined July 2025
Photo by Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT)Photo by Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT)Photo by Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT)Photo by Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT)Photo by Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT)Photo by Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT)Photo by Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse (@ChristianFWT)
In addition to what is said below, Calvinists commandeer other words, like ‘reformed’ and ‘reformers,’ so as to make them apply only to Calvinists. The Arminians, Anabaptists, and Lutherans were also part of the Reformation.
The Fallacy of Unfalsifiability Calvinists protect their system from being tested against the plain reading of Scripture by inventing double meanings for the very words the Bible uses. Once those double meanings are in place, almost any verse that looks like it contradicts their system can be reclassified so it no longer counts against it. Take “grace.” Scripture speaks of God’s grace, favor, and kindness being shown to people. When a verse says God is gracious or offers grace in a way that does not fit limited effectual grace, it gets labeled “common grace.” Common grace is said to be real but non-saving, so it does not touch the doctrine of irresistible saving grace given only to the elect. The same word is doing two different jobs, and the distinction is not clearly marked in the text itself. Nothing in the passage has to change; the category does the work for them. The same move happens with “love.” When Scripture says God loves the world, or loves those who reject him, or desires their salvation, that love is redefined as a general, non-electing love that does not actually intend to save. The special, electing love is reserved for the elect alone. John 3:16 can stay in the Bible without requiring that God genuinely loves every person in the same saving sense. The word “love” has been split so the universal statements no longer falsify the particularist claim. God’s “will” gets the same treatment. The decretive will is what God secretly determines will happen. The preceptive will is what he commands and invites. When the Bible says God wills that all be saved, or that he takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked, that is assigned to the preceptive will, which is not the will that actually decides outcomes. The decretive will remains absolute and limited. Apparent contradictions disappear in their mind because the two wills are not the same will. The system cannot be shown false by the plain sense of the command or the invitation. “Calling” works the same way. There is a general, external call that goes out to everyone through the gospel, and an effectual, internal call that only the elect ever receive and that always succeeds. When Jesus or Paul says “come,” “believe,” or “whoever,” that is the general call. It can be resisted, so it does not threaten irresistible grace. The effectual call is the one that actually saves, and it is not given to those who refuse. The same language of calling now covers both a resistible invitation and an irresistible summons, and the distinction keeps the system intact. Drawing, world, all, desire, and other terms receive parallel treatments. Each time a verse appears to teach a genuine, universal provision or a real condition of faith, a special sense is introduced that limits the force of the verse to the elect alone. The result is that the system becomes consistent with nearly any reading of the text. Counterexamples are not allowed to count as counterexamples because they have already been redefined into a category that does not threaten the core claims of the Calvinist. That is how the system stays unfalsifiable. The ordinary words of Scripture are given technical double meanings that are not required by the passages themselves, and those meanings absorb the evidence that would otherwise challenge the doctrine. In their minds, the text can say what it says, and the system remains untouched.
1
13
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Announcing my latest book! Coming later this fall— “Understanding Calvinism: A Guide for Non-Calvinists.” For the last several years in virtually every church where I have preached or taught, I have been asked by pastors and lay people alike to write a non-academic book on Calvinism that does two things. First, explain Calvinism in understandable language. Second, offer a critique of Calvinism that is accessible to those who have little or no knowledge of Calvinism. The first part of the book will be descriptive and explanatory. There will be not a single syllable of critique. The second part of the book will offer a critique of the basics of Calvinism, including issues of divine determinism, compatiblism, free will, each of the five points (though I basically agree with perseverance and affirm eternal security of the believer), and more. The current manuscript is 150 pages. I will be handing it off soon to Tony Byrne @_TheoMed for editing. It will be available on Amazon Books and will be reasonably priced. Calvinists have rarely offered any substantive interaction with my previous three academic books on Calvinism (“The Extent of the Atonement,” “Calvinism: A Biblical and Theological Critique,” and “Liberating Romans from Reformed Captivity”). Perhaps things will be different with this book.
31
11
6
143
16,920
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Saw this other post and think you've explained yourself well It is a grace that we have inspired Scripture but the debate is not whether there is any grace given but on whether the HS must "attend" or "assist" the reader to overcome an incapacity In terms of incapacity, I think that we can separate "understanding" from "applying" After all, a natural ability would allow understanding while a moral inability would prevent application Thus some might acknowledge an incapacity of fallen people born in such a condition that they cannot believe (or do good) without the aid of the HS but can still allow for comprehension/understanding of the content in Scripture without that aid On the other side, setting aside TD, we see in Scripture that the HS does draw, illuminate & convict and these are all "assisting" the reader (inwardly) to understand both the content and the need to apply it For many of us this work of the HS would fall short of the demand some make for a full regeneration that must come first Finally, an active HS that does "assist" us can work in us in such a way that we can cooperate (or not) and that He will also respond to how we use this light (or don't)
If someone wishes to claim that the Holy Spirit may “attend” an unbeliever as he reads Scripture—assisting him to discern its truthfulness—that claim does not, by itself, challenge the view I am defending. God knows what any given person needs in his particular circumstances, and I have no interest in denying that the Spirit may use a host of providential means to bring a sinner into contact with the truth. The question is not whether God ever assists a reader. The question is whether fallen people are born in such a condition that they cannot understand or willingly believe the gospel until an additional, miraculous work first gives them this ability. That distinction is simply the difference between what is sufficient and what is necessary. Scripture itself treats the Word as able to do the work God assigns it. Paul writes that “the sacred writings… are able to make you wise for salvation through faith in Christ Jesus” (2 Tim. 3:15) and that “faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ” (Rom. 10:17). John states the purpose of his Gospel with the same confidence: “these are written so that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name” (John 20:31). James likewise says that the implanted word “is able to save your souls” (Jas. 1:21). None of these texts treat the message as an empty husk that must wait for a prior, secret regeneration (or whatever you wish to call it) before it can be understood or believed. The same principle applies to other means God may choose. A person in a land with no access to a Bible or a preacher may be reached by a dream, a vision, or some other unusual providence. Job 33 describes God speaking “in a dream, in a vision of the night,” in order to turn a person from destruction. Cornelius received an angelic visitation that prepared him to hear the gospel. Such means are sufficient for the purpose God intends in that situation. They are not thereby shown to be necessary for everyone, nor do they imply that human beings are born with a moral inability that uniquely prevents them from believing the Scriptures. They simply illustrate that God meets people in the circumstances in which He finds them. The point of contention, therefore, is more specific. It is the claim that we are born so corrupt that we cannot believe—or even adequately understand—what the Bible teaches about Christ, until an extra-biblical grace first grants us a capacity we otherwise lack. That claim sits uneasily beside ordinary human experience. People devote themselves, often at great cost, to philosophies, political ideologies, religious systems, self-help programs, and sacred texts of every kind. They can grasp arguments, weigh evidence, change their minds, and reorder their lives around books that make far more extravagant demands than the gospel does. The doctrine of total inability asks us to believe that this same rational and moral creature is uniquely incapacitated when the book in question is the Bible—despite the Bible’s own testimony that it is “living and active” (Heb. 4:12), that it “will not return void” (Isa. 55:11), and that it is “the power of God for salvation to everyone who believes” (Rom. 1:16). Jesus Himself presupposed that His hearers could search the Scriptures and yet refuse to come to Him (John 5:39–40). The scriptures do not describe people who were constitutionally unable to understand; they describe people who were responsible for what they did with what they heard. In short, God may use whatever means He chooses—Scripture, preaching, dreams, circumstances, or the quiet attending of His Spirit. Those means are sufficient for the purpose for which He employs them. What they do not require, and what Scripture does not teach, is that we inherit a moral defect so total that we can believe any other book in the world and yet cannot believe the one God sent to call all to be reconciled to Himself!
1
2
2
132
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Replying to @DineshDSouza
Actually, it isn't. Look at every use of the term 'predestined' in the Bible (below). Literally none of them point to salvation. They all point to adoption - conformity to Christ on the day of His appearing. That is the day that we receive our inheritance in Christ. Romans speaks about this: "Not only that, but we also who have the firstfruits of the Spirit, even we ourselves groan within ourselves, eagerly waiting for the adoption, the redemption of our body.  For we were saved in this hope, but hope that is seen is not hope; for why does one still hope for what he sees?" See, the adoption is future. That's why it is predestined - not for unbelievers, but for believers. Not that we should be saved, but rather, that those who are saved have a divine appointment to see Jesus Christ face to face, and be made like Him... and receive an inheritance in the family of God. Calvinism has the definition completely wrong to begin with. THAT is the core problem.
1
3
280
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
It makes no sense to me to add the “controlling” adjective here to His prescriptive will when God’s prescriptive will is violated ALL THE TIME. Also, control ≠ influence, influence is influence and is non-determinative.
9
1
2
27
2,325
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
DEAD MEANS DEAD!!! When Jesus called the church in Sardis “dead” and told them to “wake up” and “remember what they’d received, and repent” did He mean to suggest they weren’t able to do so given their corpse like “deadness?” Yes or no and why?
46
16
4
136
5,822
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
"...just as the Son of Man did not come to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many..." Matthew 20:28, Mark 10:45 & John 13:1-17
11
9
88
2,196
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
When Jesus says the dead will hear His voice…but someone in the crowd brought their systematic theology instead of their ears:
15
15
4
88
5,639
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Below, James White tacitly deploys the No True Scotsman fallacy to exclude Arminians (not to mention Anabaptists) from the Reformation, and also tacitly redefines “Sovereign” and “Creator” in a way that isn’t normal in Hebrew, Greek, or English.
14
5
21
1,822
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
My Summary of 1 John 5:1 and whether regeneration precedes faith: “Everyone who believes that Jesus is the Christ has been born of God.” In Greek, believes is a present active participle, which conveys ongoing action and is best understood as “the one characterized by believing.” Has been born is a perfect passive indicative, indicating a completed action with continuing results and is best understood as “stands born of God.” The grammar itself does not determine which comes first. Looking at the context, 1 John is about assurance of salvation. 1 John 5:1 fits right in – if your life is characterized by believing, then you stand born again. Arguing that 1 John 5:1 teaches that regeneration causes faith immediately faces two challenges: 1) it’s addressing perseverance in faith rather than conversion and 2) it’s an evidence-and-inference relationship rather than cause and effect. The first issue, that 5:1 is about perseverance in faith rather than conversion, seems insuperable. Calvinists may challenge whether the present participle necessarily conveys ongoing action, but that is its normal sense, and much of 1 John uses the present participle to describe ongoing sin, rather than a one-time act or ongoing righteousness rather than a one time good work (see 1:7; 2:4, 9–11, 15, 29; 3:4–10, 14–15, 24; 4:7–8, 20–21). Calvinists could argue that if the new birth causes perseverance in faith, then it also causes initial faith, but there are many alternatives here and even if that were true, it cannot be established from 1 John 5:1 or its context. If Calvinists grant that the faith is ongoing, the debate is over. Whatever the order of faith and regeneration, continued faith takes time and so does the process of assessing whether one’s life is characterized by ongoing faith or not. This fact is recognized in Reformed confessions like Westminster Confession 18.3 - this infallible assurance doth not so belong to the essence of faith, but that a true believer may wait long, and conflict with many difficulties before he be partaker of it (same as the 1689 London Baptist 18.3). So even if the relation between new birth and perseverance in faith is causal, 5:1 says or implies nothing about the order of salvation. Thus, even if Calvinists can overcome challenge 2, that 5:1 about evidence/inference rather than cause and effect, it does not advance their case. Calvinists have insisted there’s an implied causal relationship that makes the test of assurance work – the root bears the fruit. They support this from two similar present-participle-with-perfect-indicative constructions in 2:29 (“everyone who practices righteousness has been born of him”) and 4:7 (“whoever loves has been born of God”). The argument is we know we are born again because we see ongoing righteousness and love in our life, but this is no coincidence! New birth causes ongoing righteousness and love, as 1 John 3:9 says: “No one born of God makes a practice of sinning, for God’s seed abides in him; and he cannot keep on sinning, because he has been born of God.” So since the grammatical construction is shared between 2:29 and 4:7, the point is the same – regeneration causes righteousness, love, and faith. Not only is this irrelevant due to 5:1 being about ongoing faith, which takes time and therefore has no implications on the order of salvation, but it is incorrect. It is not grammar, but the context of 1 John 2:29 and 4:7 that indicates the relationship between new birth and righteousness and love is causal. Nor does the contextual clarification make the grammatical construction inherently causal. This may seem like a subtle distinction, but 2:29 and 4:7 are still evidence/inference relations that, per the context, we know to be due to a cause-and-effect relationship. This distinction is vital, because new birth does not always produce enough good works to support assurance. 1 John 3:19–22 describes testing our hearts, and we may pass or not. If we don’t pass, we may still be saved, but we won’t know it. As 3:20 states: “whenever our heart condemns us, God is greater than our heart, and he knows everything.” The fact that the new birth might not be producing enough righteousness or love for assurance means the focus of 2:29 and 4:7 is not on the causal force of the new birth, but the evaluation of righteousness or love when it is present. Now if a Calvinist rejects this distinction and insists a contextual reading of 2:29 and 4:7 express a causal relationship, so what? The grammatical construction is not inherently causal (see, for example, John 3:18). While 2:29 and 4:7 are supported by the context of texts like 3:9 directly stating the new birth causes holiness, there is no similar context in 5:1 saying the new birth causes ongoing faith (let alone initial faith). One last argument that Calvinists bring up is whether faith causes the new birth or the new birth causes faith. While Arminians don’t believe faith causes the new birth—God does—the whole question is off topic in 1 John 5:1, which is about ongoing faith and the assurance of salvation rather than the order of salvation. @DrDavidLAllen @HwsEleutheroi
17
11
1
66
6,662
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Hence why Heiser is largely right 😉😇
Why Heiser's method and the hermeneutical posture of Reformed confessions are incompatible. "... indices in Heiser’s books reveals virtually zero interaction with the history of Christian interpretation... this is a feature, not a bug of his methodology." theopolisinstitute.com/conve…
10
3
42
4,962
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
For those who may be interested in my exegetical refutation of James White’s take on 1 John 5:1 regarding regeneration preceding faith, check out this hour long program. Bonus feature at the end: an exegetical argument as to why 1 John 5:19 and 1 John 2:1-2 assert unlimited atonement. 👇👇 Here is the link to my written response as well: dropbox.com/scl/fi/tdopabge6… King’s to you, Fernand!
17
21
5
89
6,815
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
He’s right, you know. 😏 teapawt.net/_ochiedike/status/1989…
The most ridiculous story ever told.
17
1
3
39
5,197
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
As I’ve mentioned, Philō of Alexandria, Wisdom of Solomon, Sirach and Testament of Judah are some examples of Jewish literature that describe the metaphysics of conversion in ways similar to that of Arminianism. It is important to note that those sources viewed the necessity of God’s transcendent intervention as a feature of humanity, not a bug. They viewed it as a necessity BOTH before AND after the fall. They viewed it as coextensive with all other worldly manifestations of God. Augustine was not alive to influence those authors, so Provisionists will have to look for another excuse. And since Calvinists already generally accept that those sources had a robust view of free will, I don’t need to address any misguided claims they make about those sources. If you object to man needing God’s transcendent intervention, you won’t like what I have to say. If you don’t like that all men are enabled to believe unless they resist, you also won’t like my observations. But history remains. Anyway, here’s a link to @NickQuient’s article on the prologue of John. John was writing with a very Jewish perspective. Nick wrote for a slightly different purpose than I am here, but he captured the essence of what I’m talking about. biblicaltheology.com/Researc…
1
8
303
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Hey my Calvinist friends Stop calling free will a superpower We’re trying to keep that under wraps
16
3
2
41
2,501
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Hey @Lifeway, I do not appreciate Calvinism in my SS book. Neither Jn 3.5 nor Titus 3.5 say that one must be regenerated before they can **believe**. "Enter/see the kingdom" is not the same thing as "believe".
40
12
2
151
8,439
Christian Free Will Theist Clearinghouse retweeted
Then Satan is redundant. But thank you for being consistent with your theology.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
27
13
2
102
5,710