Replying to @joebutters
Are we just pretending that Trafford hasn't suffered in a similar way? Spurs at home this season was horrid.
3
346
Agree re inconsistency match by match, but the on-field decision was that Robertson was active in an offside position. VAR agreed or at least didn't deem the on field call to be a clear and obvious error. I think they gave it purely because he's close to Donnarumma and active.
3
1
60
Im not saying it's not ambiguous but he was technically active in the game in front of the keeper in an offside position.
1
30
Correct, the offence wasn't ducking - that was just the action he did which meant he was active in the game in an offside position. If he'd stood still, the ball wouldâve hit him and he'd still have been offside, or, if stood onside and ducking, the goal would have stood.
17
If Robertson hadnât ducked, the ball wouldâve hit him. That shows how central he was to the play. The refereeing is inconsistent but I can see why both the on field and VAR decision was an offside call (Law 11).
2
63
The law doesnât require contact or a delayed dive, just that an offside player makes an obvious action impacting the keeperâs ability to play the ball. Standing 2ft in front, in the direct path of the shot, is enough. The keeper has to factor that player in.
1
45
Robertson is in the line of the shot and close enough to affect the keeper's decision-making, even by presence alone, that can be judged as impacting play. Being 2 feet in front and in the ballâs path is enough under the laws, even if he didnât touch it or obstruct the dive.
1
35
Clive, being 2 feet in front of someone just means you're positioned ahead of them in the direction they're facing, and you are 2 feet away. Thatâs not a contradiction.
1
81
Replying to @RonByrne2 @henrywinter
Pleasure speaking with you, hope you have a wonderful evening. Try being a little less chronically online and you may spend less time being so frustrated in life.
14
Yes, he was stood 2 feet IN FRONT of the keeper and in the trajectory of the ball. Do you struggle with comprehension?
1
26
Replying to @RonByrne2 @henrywinter
Don't hold back mate, say what you really feel. (I'm not from Congleton, not sure why that town is catching strays).
38
Replying to @RonByrne2 @henrywinter
He ducked under the ball, whilst stood offside within 2 feet of the goalkeeper. You might not like the rule, but its offside.
22
Replying to @RonByrne2 @henrywinter
That's actually a very good idea mate, you should write in to the PGMOL with the suggestion.
36

