
Act with kindness and empathy. Reason is a tool to be used with humility. See problems in relation to the totality. Writer & PhD lit. student @uarizona
Tucson, AZ
Joined March 2009
- Tweets237
- Following281
- Followers108
- Likes385
Pinned Tweet
How can we claim that it matters who wrote something without overstating authorial control? My article in Symplokē puts forward a new theory of literary authorship moving beyond Barthes and Foucault and more adequate to our time. muse.jhu.edu/pub/17/article/…
19
I'm organizing a seminar for ACLA 2027 (virtual):
"Euromodernism’s 'Chinese Eyes'"—Accepting papers on modernism, Orientalism, form, and fantasies of immediacy; Christopher Bush (Northwestern) will serve as respondent. Proposals due September 22: acla.org/seminar/0d0ebe6b-a8…
36
South Gaza: Tents, Food & Water chuffed.org/project/113222-t…
23
New short story out today with A Thin Slice of Anxiety:
athinsliceofanxiety.com/2025…
I translated a story about a lightning-wielding hermit by Li Hongwei for this gorgeous new anthology of translated contemporary Chinese literature. Pre-order here!
We're publishing "Ten Thousand Miles of Clouds and Moons: New Chinese Writing", ed. by Zuo Fei, Xiao Yue Shan, Simon Shieh in January 2025! ☁️ 🌙
Gathering sixteen phenomenal writers of the Chinese language in their English debut.
Pre-order here: buff.ly/4foGyXM
60
Wilson Harris, “The Frontier on Which ‘Heart of Darkness’ Stands”--breathtaking example of what the artist can say and the scholar cannot
1
43
David Huntington retweeted
Did this for architecture students when talking about form but feel like it's applicable to literature as well.
David Huntington retweeted
“the altarpiece”
come see me give a sermon in front of it this evening at 185 rue de louvain O #402!
David Huntington retweeted
My story “Notes from the Consulting Room” has been accepted by Read Paper Republic, an online publication initiative. Big thanks to the translators Yun Qin Wang and Dylan Levi King.
paper-republic.org/pubs/read…
Apparently there is a "Rejection Wiki" to help the struggling writer decipher the tone of all the automated form rejections they receive. So that pretty much sums it up.
rejectionwiki.com/index.php?…
36
David Huntington retweeted
My poem “To a Blossoming Saguaro” has been reprinted in @thenation.
To a Blossoming Saguaro thenation.com/article/cultur…
David Huntington retweeted
Students Protest in Peking, 1919.
May 4th, the starting day of May Fourth Movement, an intellectual revolution and sociopolitical reform movement that occurred in China in 1917–21, toward national independence, emancipation of the individual, and rebuilding society and culture.
David Huntington retweeted
Middlebury.
middleburycampus.com/article…
David Huntington retweeted
I think it will be remembered thus: in the face of atrocity students did something, anything, to try and disrupt those institutions they could affect. And all the people now mewling about broken windows braying for their arrest will slink away and hope they are not remembered.
David Huntington retweeted
Well I use these terms in two or three different registers, which can certainly be confusing, although I usually try to demarcate the sense I have in mind.
Most obviously, I'm just using them the way they are generally used today. So the "left" are, essentially, the Democrats, and the "right" are the Republicans. Or to be more specific, the Democrats and Republicans are, respectively, the left and right sides of the mainstream liberal "center", with the Democrats generally being "progressive liberals" and the Republicans being "conservative liberals". Beyond that, there is "the left", or "the far left", and "the right", or "the far right", which refer to the radical fringes of each party, people who are either on the edge or outside the mainstream, and may outright oppose "liberalism" itself as either "right wing" or "left wing".
Usually, when I'm referring to the left in that sense, I use scare quotes, or refer to it as "the so-called left", "the contemporary left", etc.
That is by way of contrast with what I'd consider to be the more fundamental historical sense of the distinction, which goes back to its origin in the French revolution, where "the left" referred to the radical wing and "the right" to the moderate wing of the revolution.
The left were radical in that they saw more radical measures as necessary to politically consolidate a free society, specifically democratic republicanism, whereas the right were moderate in that they saw such measures as threatening to undermine the gains that had been made, favoring a constitutional monarchy or aristocratic republic (in the sense of restricting the franchise to the propertied classes, not in the sense of giving power to the feudal aristocracy per se).
Proletarian socialism or communism, that is, socialism as taken up by the industrial working class, emerged as the "far left wing" of the radical party, "the Democracy", the "petty bourgeois" (small property-owning) republicans, and would eventually split to become a party unto itself. Hence, the left was generally divided between the democrats and the socialists in the second half of the 19th century.
The right, on the other hand, was more inclined to seek compromise with the forces of reaction and to embrace the notion of "conservatism" as famously articulated by Edmund Burke, although for some time the "free traders", generally liberal republicans, were allied with the left and opposed to both the liberal and reactionary monarchists. (For the sake of simplicity I'm generalizing over various national contexts and historical periods, so take all of this with a grain of salt.)
By the early 20th century, especially in Germany, the socialist parties simply were the left parties, with the petty bourgeois democrats and liberal republicans either sidelined, absorbed into the socialist parties, or aligning with the right, that is, the reactionary state.
So in that sense, by the left what I'm really talking about the socialist movement, which also stood for democratic republicanism, but sought such a constitution for different ends than the petty bourgeois democrats, namely, the emancipation of wage labor through socialization of capital, rather than the emancipation of the small proprietors through political limitation and regulation of large proprietors.
But even the socialist movement had divided into right and left wings by the turn of the 20th century, a fact which came out into the open with the "revisionist dispute".
The left wing were the orthodox Marxists (Rosa Luxemburg in Germany, Lenin and the Bolsheviks in Russia, Eugene Debs in the US), the right wing were the revisionists (Eduard Bernstein in Germany, the Mensheviks in Russia, Victor Berger in the US).
The essential difference was whether the socialist parties should maintain the "class struggle policy" of remaining in strict, openly revolutionary opposition so long as they were not themselves in the position to take power independently, meaning, not in coalition with parties representing other classes. By revolutionary opposition, I don't mean violent insurrection, but pursuing the goal of deposing the present ruling class from power and raising the working class to power in their place.
The revisionists, by contrast, were generally at least amenable to, or openly in favor of, entering into coalition governments and softening the rhetoric of class struggle, in the name of winning material gains for the working class in the form of concessions. The leading proponent of this perspective, Eduard Bernstein, famously summarized his position with the phase, "The final goal, no matter what it is, is nothing; the movement is everything", essentially arguing that capitalism was gradually evolving into socialism, both through the concentration and centralization of capital, and through the organization and social and political action of the working class.
Rosa Luxemburg responded by arguing that "the final goal of socialism constitutes the only decisive factor distinguishing the Social-Democratic movement from bourgeois democracy and from bourgeois radicalism, the only factor transforming the entire labour movement from a vain effort to repair the capitalist order into a class struggle against this order, for the suppression of this order", and that, "In the controversy with Bernstein and his followers, everybody in the Party ought to understand clearly it is not a question of this or that method of struggle, or the use of this or that set of tactics, but of the very existence of the Social-Democratic movement."
Explaining why this was an existential rather than a tactical question, she said, "Then what is it in our day to-day struggles that makes us a socialist party? It can only be the relation between [our] practical struggles and our final goals. It is the final goal alone which constitutes the spirit and the content of our socialist struggle, which turns it into a class struggle. And by final goal we must not mean, as Heine has said, this or that image of the future state, but the prerequisite for any future society, namely the conquest of political power. This conception of our task is closely related to our conception of capitalist society; it is the solid ground which underlies our view that capitalist society is caught in insoluble contradictions which will ultimately necessitate an explosion, a collapse, at which point we will play the role of the banker-lawyer who liquidates a bankrupt company."
To be clear, the point was not that "collapse" was simply inevitable all else being equal, or at least, not a collapse from which capitalism wouldn't otherwise recover. Rather, it was that the revolutionary orientation of the proletarian socialist movement's social and political action would drive such a collapse, in that the next major crisis would lead the immense majority of society in the advanced capitalist countries to rally around the political leadership of the socialist parties, as those that had retained allegiance to the bourgeois and petty bourgeois parties would vacate that support, being compelled to recognize their political bankruptcy.
There was also an "ultra-left" element within the parties, though it wasn't always strictly distinguished from the orthodox Marxist elements until the Russian Revolution, who veered more toward anarchism though without rejecting political action altogether.
The orthodox Marxists won out over the revisionists and retained leadership, but when WWI began, the parties were mostly betrayed by their own parliamentary representatives, who with few exceptions voted to support their own national governments in the war, breaking with a policy that had been well-established for a half-century, namely the "class struggle policy".
This applied to the question of war between capitalist countries led to the clear conclusion that the socialists needed to lead the workers of all countries to stand in united opposition to such wars, which were waged above all to consolidate the power of the ruling class on an international scale and to undermine that of the working class movement. Hence, they needed to do everything they could to turn such an "imperialist war" into what it really was, namely, a global civil war between the classes, an international revolution.
The Communist movement eventually formed out of the orthodox opposition to this counter-revolution within the socialist movement, which the party and trade union bureaucracies and more conservative sections of the working classes went along with, at least initially. Hence, the Communists became the left wing, and the Social Democrats the right wing.
I could go into further detail about subsequent developments within the Communist movement but this is already going on too long. The reason I explain all this is because its not as simple as "left-wing means x" and "right-wing means y". It's a complex and evolving relationship bound up with a fluctuating historical dynamic.
But there is a very general orientation toward the recognition and acceptance of the necessity of revolution, and of advancing that revolution beyond its more limited initial phases to its more radical culmination. With Marx, that culmination means the rule of the working class, as a transition to a classless society.
The contemporary left only has a very, very superficial relationship to this historical legacy at best, appropriating tropes, aesthetics, slogans, quotations excised from context, all of which are distorted not only by opportunistic appropriation, but multiple generations of compounded miseducation, such that this history is now understood (and not only by "leftists") in extremely confused, oversimplified, and falsified terms, to the extent that it is remembered at all. It is mostly forgotten.
I think the tasks that the historical left took up remain relevant, if only because the failure to achieve the goal completely reshaped the entire world, and not for the better. The consequences of that failure, whether or not it was predestined, are still very much with us.
But the failure itself is completely misunderstood, and most don't even recognize it as a failure at all. They see what issued out of 1914-1919 as representing the victory of socialism (e.g. the USSR, etc, and/or European Social Democracy). "Leftists" think that victory was good, desirable, and should be built upon, or at least that some elements of it were and should be.
Generally, people on "the right" take the opposite perspective, that it was a bad idea (whether out of malice, resentment, cynical manipulation of the gullible masses, or simple utopian naivete) that had predictably bad results, and that it was a failure, if not by the standards of socialists and leftists, then by the standards of normal, sane people that don't want to live under despotism.
But really, the so-called "left" is deeply right wing in the historical sense that they have made their peace with the status quo. But the status quo is not coherent, and hence, neither is the right. The right is opportunistic, more concerned with maintaining a stable social and political order than anything else.
They may reach for various ideological conceptions of what that order should and should not be, what elements of the status quo should be preserved, what elements are deleterious and should be excised, and what elements should be rescued from the past and revived in their place. But there are as many different versions of "moderation", "conservatism", even "reaction", as there are elements of the present that might warrant conservation, or of the past that might merit restoration.
The contemporary left, in that sense, is totally right-wing. They are concerned with conserving elements of the status quo; eliminating other elements that are viewed as destructive, oppressive, etc; and reviving elements that have fall by the wayside, like the Soviet Union or the New Deal, or worse, premodern tribalism.
It's not really left vs right in the historical sense anymore, but various factions of conservatives and reactionaries bickering over what should be preserved and what should be destroyed in order to best maintain the status quo, broadly conceived. To the extent that "revolution" is invoked, what is meant is usually something like the violent destruction of modern society for the sake of a romantic restoration of premodern society, before the evil white men from Europe ruined everything. That's not "revolution" in the sense of the historical left, but the exact opposite.
As the great reactionary, Joseph de Maistre, put it, counter-revolution did not mean a revolution in the opposite direction, but the opposite of a revolution. In other words, consolidation of order by those with the power to do so. The rest is just ideological bait or decoration.
If I had to summarize very concisely, the left should, and once did, stand for the fullest possible development of human freedom, as the highest end to which society ought to commit itself, whereas the right recoils from this emancipation into the security of order, authority, tradition, hierarchy, etc, although the forms those may take can vary widely.
For Marx, moreover, that full development of freedom was not an ideal that should be pursued because of its intrinsic moral or rational merits, but was what society was already pursuing, and had been pursuing with increasing consciousness and deliberateness over the course of human history, though consciousness of this end only really fully emerges with the modern period of the "bourgeois revolution".
But in capitalism, the pursuit of this end became self-contradictory, not simply with respect to political or even social conflicts, but in the very fundamental economic activities through which society reproduced itself. Hence, the task of the left, the party of revolution, of emancipation, was not simply to champion a "utopian" ideal or moral principle, but to work through the self-contradictory dynamic at the heart of the present social order, in order to fully unleash the productive capacities of society, and thus, the freedom of each individual.
This Post is from a suspended account. Learn more
David Huntington retweeted
tinyurl.com/beijing-blues
A trailing spouse, a café in Shunyi, a private detective, and a long wait . . . Spittoon (Not Exactly) Monthly presents "The Bitter Beijing Blues" by Rianka Mohan. After the story, stick around for an interview with the author by Jennifer Fossenbell.
David Huntington retweeted
david lynch ads for coffee in a can, set in the world of twin peaks, only ever aired in japan. wild
Two and a half years since I first heard Relatives in Descent... still can't stop thinking about that album @protomartyrband





















