Replying to @MonaRahalkar
Circumstantial evidence is not proof, but it seems to be a good way to sell books.
Just because there was a lightning storm doesn’t mean the forest fire didn’t start another way.
16
Replying to @amitavb1 @MonaRahalkar
Incorrect, by orders of magnitude on the mortality estimates. Suggest double checking your sources.
sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
2
22
Replying to @Ayjchan
Anyone can go into a local hardware store & gather supplies to make a weapon capable of mass harm. Intent is the real issue. Not access to resources. The same tools folks are using for cancer research can be used to make a bioweapon if there is ill intent & appropriate know how.
1
24
Correct, especially on platforms that make minimal if any effort to credential or even verify a poster is even human.
1
27
Replying to @jhas5 @angie_rasmussen
Asking for someone’s unfunded project proposal is no different from asking for unprotected IP. That any have leaked have very clear ethical and often legal implications for those who have leaked them as reviewer typically are bound by confidentiality agreements.
Replying to @capitolsheila
Yes, she has been on this beat for decades…but directly referring to the Promed source suggests pretty cleanly that was the source. Many virologists familiar with SARS1 thought the same thing after seeing Promed, so I don’t think anything controversial here.
1
36
Replying to @capitolsheila
It was released in a promed email that anyone signed up for that service received. Not a tip, just educated intuition.
1
2
95
Replying to @angie_rasmussen
Disagree.Not implausible in the slightest.Tropism and pathogenesis are not factors here. If a pox virus can be manipulated to express a filovirus protein,it doesn’t matter if it’s vaccinia or variola if performed by someone who knows what they are doing….which thankfully are few
1
60
Replying to @angie_rasmussen
Putting Ebola genes into pox vectors is absolutely possible and the basis for the MVA-BN-Filo vaccine (brand name Mvabea). Wasn’t a great vaccine, but addresses your point.
1
3
256
Replying to @dasher8090 @NIHDirector_Jay
Showing both sides of the argument. Something every one seems to want, for better or worse…
23
Replying to @emilyakopp
KA no doubt was out of line. There is unfortunately lot of bullying and name calling in science…some even happen regularly on your threads, including this one…
47
Replying to @DrWashburne
Agree context & intent is the key here.
ANY biological microbe can be weaponized.
Rajneeshees understood this well when they weaponized Salmonella &caused a massive food poisoning event aimed at political rivals.
Doesn’t have to be a select agent to be a “bioweapons agent”
1
31
Replying to @emilyakopp
Doubtful, the DTRA program was a diagnostic and surveillance one mainly bordering countries where known pathogens of concern circulate or countries with known bioweapons programs like Russia, both of which makes sense in terms of global biosecurity. Not the same.
37
Replying to @ashishkjha
Not really.
This was an old lab, long established history of working on bioweapons. The number of labs is less the issue over what the lab is doing and how safely.
2
1,365
Replying to @AmeshAA
Work w/plague should be done @ BSL3 w/respiratory protection, assuming standard protocols were in place& an appropriate post exposure protocol would initiate antibiotics immediately after the incident reported, failing all of this, one could assume it was not immediately reported
39
Replying to @mkoeris
This is an arguably more dangerous idea. Countermeasure development in high containment is not rudimentary cloning & protein biology. It is highly nuanced & involves validation in animal models, something that full LLM/robotics is not, currently, capable of doing safely
73
Replying to @jrkelly
Are you aware of the level of training necessary to work in BSL3/4 environments? It’s a human issue, highly trained, seasoned experts can make mistakes. Making them fully robotic opens an entirely new universe of risks especially in the context of experiments requiring animals.
36
