In September 2001 a golden retriever who'd just turned two climbed onto a wet steel beam in the ruins of the World Trade Center. She slipped, hauled herself back up with her front paws, and went on sniffing as if nothing had happened.
Her name was Bretagne, said like Brittany. Her handler was Denise Corliss, an electrical engineer from Cypress, Texas, who'd brought her home at eight weeks old in 1999. Corliss trained her twenty to thirty hours a week, unpaid, on top of her job. In 2000 they passed the tests to join Texas Task Force 1, one of the federal search and rescue teams. Ground Zero was their first deployment.
They worked twelve-hour shifts on the pile for about ten days. The dogs were there to find people alive in the voids under the steel. "I really believed we could find somebody, anybody, if we could just get to the right void space," Corliss said later. But there was nobody left alive to find. What the dogs found were remains, and every find meant something to a family waiting at home.
Bretagne found another kind of work on her own. One day she pulled away from Corliss and wouldn't come back when she was called. She went straight to a firefighter sitting alone on the ground, lay down beside him, and put her head in his lap. A vet who cared for the search dogs there said the men would sit stone-faced for hours, and then a dog would come by and they'd smile.
Bretagne went on to search after Hurricanes Ivan, Katrina and Rita. She retired at nine. When her joints got stiff at thirteen, Corliss put a pool in the backyard so she could swim every day, and she started climbing stairs again. She spent her old age at an elementary school near home, lying beside first-graders who were too shy to read aloud to people but would read to her.
In 2014, at fifteen, she went back to New York for the first time and walked around the memorial pools where the towers had stood.
By 2016 she was the last of the search dogs known to have worked at Ground Zero. That June her kidneys were failing and she stopped eating. Corliss lay down beside her and slept next to her all night. On 6 June they took her to the vet in Cypress. Firefighters and search teams lined the walk and saluted as she went in. When she was carried out under a flag, they saluted again.
34
White was charged with first-degree murder.
Under a law voters had passed three weeks before, killing an elected official to stop him doing his job could carry the death penalty.
His lawyers didn't deny he'd done it. They argued that White had been deeply depressed, so depressed that he couldn't have planned the killings in the way the law required for murder. California then allowed a defense called diminished capacity, and a psychiatrist testified that one sign of White's depression was that the once health-minded athlete had started living on junk food, Twinkies and Coca-Cola.
Reporters seized on it. The Twinkies were offered as a symptom, not a cause, but "Twinkie defense" stuck to the case for good.
The jury found him guilty of voluntary manslaughter. On 21 May 1979 he was sentenced to seven years and eight months.
That evening thousands marched from the Castro to City Hall. The crowd smashed the building's glass doors and set a dozen police cars on fire. Later that night police raided a Castro bar, the Elephant Walk, and beat people inside and in the street.
Scores of people were hurt on both sides. The next day would have been Milk's 49th birthday, and the Castro held a street party instead.
In 1981 the legislature rewrote the law, and in June 1982 California voters approved Proposition 8, which abolished the diminished capacity defense. A defendant's mental state could still be raised, but not to wipe out the kind of planning the law calls malice.
White served about five years. Paroled in January 1984, he lived quietly in Los Angeles County for a year.
In October 1985, back in San Francisco, he killed himself in his garage. Years later Falzon said White had told him in 1984 that it had been planned all along, and that he'd meant to kill two others as well.
Dan White was convicted of manslaughter, not murder, and served five years.
The man who killed two men walked free, and California rewrote the law.
16
That morning a former aide drove White to City Hall.
He carried his old police revolver, a five-shot .38, loaded with hollow-point bullets, and ten more rounds in his coat pocket. The building had metal detectors at the public doors.
White knocked on a basement window and told an engineer he'd forgotten his keys. The man let him climb in.
He went to the mayor's office and asked to see Moscone. When Moscone said no again, the two men went into a private room off the office so no one would hear them argue. Moscone lit a cigarette and was pouring them each a drink when White shot him in the shoulder and chest.
Then White stood over him and fired twice more into his head. He reloaded.
He walked quickly to the other end of the building, to the supervisors' offices. Dianne Feinstein, president of the board, called out to him as he passed. "I have something to do first," he said.
He asked Milk to come into his old office for a moment. Milk went in, and White closed the door.
He fired five times. The first shot hit Milk's wrist as he raised his hand.
White took his aide's car keys from her desk and drove away. He called his wife from a diner and met her at a church. Then he walked into the Northern police station, where he'd once worked, and turned himself in to a detective he knew, Frank Falzon.
At 11:20 a shaking Feinstein faced reporters who'd come for an announcement about a new supervisor. Moscone and Milk had been shot and killed, she said, and the suspect was Dan White. That night tens of thousands of people walked silently with candles from the Castro to City Hall.
In the interrogation room White confessed. He said he hadn't planned anything, that the pressure had built up until he snapped.
1
27
On a Monday morning in November 1978 a former city supervisor climbed through a basement window into San Francisco City Hall and shot the mayor and the first openly gay man elected to public office in California.
Everyone knew who did it, and he confessed that afternoon. A jury still decided it wasn't murder. The verdict set off a riot, gave the world the phrase "Twinkie defense," and led California voters to change the law on what a killer's state of mind can excuse.
In November 1977 San Francisco elected its Board of Supervisors by district for the first time. The new board looked like no board before it.
It had the city's first Chinese American supervisor, its first Black woman, and its first openly gay man, Harvey Milk, a camera-shop owner from the Castro. It also had its first former firefighter, Dan White, a 31-year-old Vietnam veteran and ex-policeman from a working-class district in the southeast of the city.
The two men clashed almost from the start. Milk voted to put a home for troubled young people in White's district, which White had promised voters he'd stop.
White cast the only vote against the city's gay rights ordinance in April 1978. George Moscone, the liberal mayor, signed it.
A supervisor earned $9,600 a year. The city charter wouldn't let White keep his fire department job, and a potato stand he ran at Pier 39 wasn't making up the difference. On 10 November 1978 he handed Moscone his resignation, saying he couldn't support his family.
Five days later he changed his mind and asked for the letter back. Moscone gave it to him and said he'd reappoint him if the law allowed.
But the city attorney ruled that White had already resigned. Milk and others lobbied the mayor to fill the seat with someone else, which would tip the board's 6-5 balance their way.
Then, on 18 November, came the news from Jonestown in Guyana. More than 900 followers of the Peoples Temple, most of them recent San Francisco residents, were dead. The city went into mourning and the argument over White's seat was set aside for a week.
Moscone decided against White. He chose Don Horanzy, a federal housing official, and called a press conference for 11:30 on the morning of 27 November.
1
53
By early afternoon everyone left outside was streaming back into the fort, which had never been meant to hold so many.
Men stood shoulder to shoulder in the open. One British gun could have done terrible work among them.
A Hessian captain came in under a white flag and gave Magaw half an hour to decide. While Magaw was talking it over, a messenger from Washington, Captain John Gooch, got through. He carried a note asking Magaw to hold out until dark, so the men could be taken off by boat that night.
It was too late. At about three o'clock Magaw agreed to surrender, and an hour later the American flag came down.
Gooch got away. He jumped off the wall, rolled down the rocks, dodged the soldiers below, and found a boat back to Fort Lee.
The Americans had lost 59 killed and 96 wounded. The British and Hessians lost about 84 killed and 374 wounded, most of them on the north slope. The British took 2,837 prisoners, 34 cannon, and a great deal of ammunition, tents and tools the army couldn't spare.
That was worse than it sounds. The prisoners were marched into New York and held in churches, sugar warehouses, and later in rotting ships anchored off Brooklyn.
They were starved and crowded, and smallpox and dysentery went through them. Only about 800 of them, by most counts, were alive when they were exchanged about eighteen months later.
Three days after the surrender, British troops climbed the Palisades north of Fort Lee. Greene's men left so fast they abandoned their cooking kettles over the fires. Washington's army, shrinking every day as enlistments ran out, retreated across New Jersey and over the Delaware.
Thomas Paine had been at Fort Lee as an aide to Greene. In December, on the far side of the Delaware, he published the first of his Crisis essays, and Washington had it read to his troops.
"These are the times that try men's souls," it began. "The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of their country."
On Christmas night Washington crossed back over the Delaware and caught a Hessian garrison at Trenton. Its commander was Johann Rall, the colonel who'd led the climb up the north slope at Fort Washington. He was mortally wounded, and the war went on.
Greene learned from his mistake and became, in the end, the best general Washington had. Margaret Corbin lived on near West Point until 1800. In 1926 her remains were moved to the cemetery at the Military Academy.
The fort was lost in an afternoon, and the army almost with it.
26
Howe attacked at dawn on 16 November with about 8,000 men, from three sides at once, with a fourth force landing as a feint.
From the north came 4,000 Hessians, German soldiers hired by the British crown, under General Wilhelm von Knyphausen. From the east, British light infantry and Guards crossed the Harlem River in flatboats as soon as the tide was high enough.
From the south came Lord Percy with British and Hessian regiments. And a battalion of Highlanders of the 42nd Regiment rowed across the Harlem River behind the American lines.
The Americans had built three lines of trenches south of the fort, but the third was never finished. When the Highlanders came ashore behind them, the men in front fell back.
Washington had crossed from Fort Lee that morning with Greene and two other generals to see for himself. Their officers urged them to get off the island, and they did, minutes ahead of the British.
On the northern slope, about 250 riflemen from Maryland and Virginia under Colonel Moses Rawlings held the Hessians off for hours. They fired from behind rocks and fallen trees as the Germans climbed through the timber the Americans had felled across the hillside. They broke two charges.
Near them a small cannon on the ridge was served by a Pennsylvania gunner named John Corbin. His wife, Margaret, had followed him to the army, as many soldiers' wives did, to cook and wash. When John was killed, she took his place at the gun and kept it firing until grapeshot tore her arm, chest and jaw.
She survived, crippled for life. In 1779 Congress gave her a soldier's half-pay pension, the first woman it ever pensioned for military service.
In the end the riflemen's guns fouled from constant firing. Some of them were rolling boulders down the slope. The Hessians reached the top with the bayonet.
1
17
On 16 November 1776 nearly three thousand American soldiers surrendered at Fort Washington, on the high rocky north end of Manhattan, after a single day's fighting.
General Washington watched it from across the Hudson. It was one of the worst American defeats of the whole war, most of the prisoners died in British captivity, and within a month the Continental Army was close to falling apart. Thomas Paine, retreating with it, began writing "These are the times that try men's souls."
In the summer of 1776 the Americans built two forts facing each other across the Hudson River. Fort Lee stood on top of the Palisades in New Jersey.
Fort Washington stood on the highest ground in Manhattan, a ridge of bare rock near the island's northern tip, about where the George Washington Bridge comes ashore today. Between them, soldiers sank old hulls loaded with boulders, to stop British warships from sailing up the river.
The fort itself was a five-sided earthwork of three or four acres. There was so little soil on the rock that the men had to carry dirt up from below, and they never managed to dig a proper ditch around it.
It had no well inside the walls. Its officers believed it couldn't be taken.
That autumn the war went badly. The British had beaten Washington on Long Island in August and taken New York City in September. In October their commander, General William Howe, landed in Westchester to cut the Americans off, and Washington pulled his army north to White Plains.
He left a garrison behind at Fort Washington under Colonel Robert Magaw, a Pennsylvania lawyer. The fort was now behind British lines.
When British frigates sailed past the river obstacles anyway, the main reason for holding the fort was gone. Washington wrote to General Nathanael Greene, who commanded at Fort Lee, that if they couldn't stop the ships, he didn't see what good the post was. But he left the decision to Greene, who was on the spot.
Greene thought the fort could be held, and that holding it would keep the British out of New Jersey. Magaw agreed.
He boasted that he could hold out till the end of December. Instead of pulling the men out, Greene sent more in, until nearly 3,000 were packed into the fort and its outer lines.
On 2 November Magaw's adjutant, William Demont, slipped out of the lines and went over to the British. He brought plans of the defenses with him.
Two weeks later, on 15 November, a British officer came up under a flag of truce and told Magaw to surrender or the garrison might be put to the sword. Magaw answered that he'd defend the fort to the last extremity.
1
184
On a Sunday evening in March 1966, a young man in south London took his dog out so he could walk to a phone box and call his brother, whose wife was expecting a baby.
The man was Dave Corbett, a 26-year-old Thames lighterman. The dog was Pickles, a black-and-white collie, four years old. They lived on Beulah Hill in Upper Norwood. Pickles kept running round the side of a neighbour's car, nosing at something by the front wheel.
It was a package wrapped tightly in newspaper and tied with string. Corbett's first thought was that it might be a bomb. He picked it up, put it down, picked it up again. Then he tore a strip off the bottom and saw the names of countries on a base. Brazil. West Germany. Uruguay.
A week earlier the World Cup had been stolen. The gold-plated Jules Rimet trophy was on show at a stamp exhibition in Westminster, four months before England was due to host the tournament. On the afternoon of 20 March somebody took it from its case. A ransom note followed, demanding £15,000. Scotland Yard arrested a man named Edward Betchley, but he said he was only a go-between, and the trophy was still missing. The whole country was embarrassed.
Corbett ran inside to tell his wife, then took the package to Gipsy Hill police station. He banged it down on the desk and said he thought he'd found the World Cup. The sergeant looked at it and said, "It doesn't look very World Cuppy to me."
It was, though. Detectives checked it, gave Corbett a whisky to calm him down, and drove him to Cannon Row police station in Westminster, where he realized that he was now their main suspect. He answered their questions until they believed him.
By morning Pickles was famous. He went on television, opened shops, and got a part in a comedy film, The Spy with a Cold Nose. Corbett collected thousands of pounds in rewards and used the money to buy a house in Lingfield, Surrey.
That July, England beat West Germany 4-2 at Wembley and won the cup Pickles had found. The players' celebration banquet included two extra guests. Corbett remembered that Pickles licked his dinner plate clean and then disgraced himself next to the hotel lift.
Pickles had one weakness, Corbett said, and it was cats. In 1967, near the new house, he chased one and his lead caught on a branch. He was buried in the garden in Lingfield. His collar is on display at the National Football Museum in Manchester.
Nobody else was ever charged with the theft. Betchley got two years for demanding the ransom. Brazil won the trophy outright in 1970. In 1983 it was stolen again, in Rio de Janeiro, and this time no dog came along. It has never been found.
147
Zaghlul agreed to the apology, the punishment, the ban and the fine.
He refused the Sudan and the water. Allenby ordered the Egyptian troops out of the Sudan anyway, and on 24 November British forces seized the customs house at Alexandria.
That evening Zaghlul resigned. On 30 November the new government accepted everything.
In Khartoum, Sudanese soldiers who sided with Egypt rose in revolt late in November. British troops crushed them. Their leader, Abdul Fadil Almaz, died when the British blew up the military hospital where his men held out.
The killers had to be found, and the police had very little. The Cairo police turned to an informer, a man named Hilbawi who'd once been part of the militant underground himself. With his help the police set a trap for two brothers they suspected, Abdel Hamid and Abdel Fattah Enayat.
The physical evidence went to Sydney Smith, a New Zealand-born doctor who was medico-legal expert to the Egyptian government. Smith reconstructed the shooting from the car and examined the bullets from Stack's body. They'd been cut so they'd expand on impact.
He compared the scratches and markings on them with test bullets fired from guns the police found. He matched the bullets to the pistols, and he linked the same weapons to earlier political shootings in the city. Tools used to cut the bullets turned up in one suspect's house.
Abdel Fattah Enayat confessed, and his statements brought in the rest.
Nine men stood trial. On 1 June 1925 eight were sentenced to death. The taxi driver got three years.
Abdel Fattah's sentence was reduced to life, because his confession had brought in the others. The other seven were hanged on 23 August 1925.
Smith wrote up the ballistics in the British Medical Journal in January 1926. He went on to a long career in Edinburgh as one of the founders of modern forensic medicine.
Two rising Wafd politicians, Ahmad Maher and Mahmud al-Nuqrashi, were tried in 1926 on suspicion of links to the killings. Both were acquitted. Both later became prime minister of Egypt.
Maher was shot dead in parliament in 1945. Al-Nuqrashi was assassinated in 1948.
The murder gave the men who ran the Sudan what they'd wanted since the war, a Sudan without Egypt in it. The Egyptian troops never went back. A new Sudan Defence Force took their place, and Gezira grew into one of the largest irrigation schemes in the world.
Egypt went on claiming the Sudan for thirty years. When the Sudan became independent on 1 January 1956, it did so as a country of its own.
Seven men hanged; a sentence commuted; two men acquitted.
A lunchtime shooting in Cairo helped decide that Sudan wouldn't be Egypt.
30
In November 1924 gunmen shot the British commander of Egypt's army in a Cairo street at lunchtime.
He died the next night. Within five days Britain had used his death to bring down Egypt's first elected government and push Egypt out of the Sudan, a split that helped set the borders of two nations. And a young pathologist proved which pistols fired the shots from the marks on the bullets, in one of the early cases that made firearms evidence part of how murders are solved.
At about half past one on 19 November 1924, Major-General Sir Lee Stack left the War Office in Cairo in his car. He was going to lunch at the British Residency, where Lord Allenby, the High Commissioner, was giving a small party for a visiting former prime minister, H. H. Asquith.
Stack was 56. He'd been born in Darjeeling, in India, and had spent a quarter of a century in Egypt and the Sudan.
Since 1917 he'd held two jobs at once. He was Sirdar, commander of the Egyptian Army, and Governor-General of the Sudan, which Britain and Egypt ruled together on paper and Britain ruled in practice.
Near the Ministry of Education the car slowed in traffic. A group of young men in the suits and tarbooshes of Cairo clerks stepped off the pavement and opened fire with revolvers. Someone threw a bomb.
It didn't go off. At least thirty shots hit the car. Stack was wounded in the hand, the leg and the abdomen.
His chauffeur, Frederick March, was hit in the arm and leg and kept driving. The gunmen escaped in a taxi.
March got the car to the Residency, and the lunch guests found the Sirdar bleeding in the back seat. Doctors were called. Egypt's prime minister, Saad Zaghlul, came to the Residency that afternoon.
Stack died the following night.
Zaghlul was the hero of Egypt's national movement. Britain had exiled him twice.
In January 1924 his Wafd party won Egypt's first real election by a landslide. He became prime minister of a country Britain had declared independent in 1922 while keeping control of its defense and the Sudan.
The British blamed him for the murder, not as a killer but as the man whose speeches had stirred up the young. Political killings had been going on in Cairo for years, against British officials and Egyptian ministers alike. Before Stack was even dead, Allenby had cabled London a list of demands.
On 22 November, the day of the funeral, Allenby didn't wait for London's final approval. He drove to the Council of Ministers with a full regiment of cavalry clattering behind him and handed Zaghlul an ultimatum.
Egypt was to apologize, punish the killers, ban political demonstrations and pay a fine of half a million pounds. It was also to pull every Egyptian officer and Egyptian unit out of the Sudan, and to accept unlimited expansion of British cotton irrigation at Gezira, on the Nile upstream of Egypt.
1
39
It was a terrible night.
Guns fired distress signals in the dark, and nobody could help anyone. Eight French ships worked their way out through the shoals and escaped south to Rochefort.
Seven more ran into the mouth of the River Vilaine. Their crews threw guns and stores overboard to lighten them enough to get over the bar. They stayed trapped there for more than a year.
The Juste was wrecked trying to reach the Loire.
At dawn the Soleil Royal tried to slip away to the shore batteries at Le Croisic. The British Essex chased her, and both went onto the Four shoal, near the Héros. The British Resolution had gone aground there in the night too.
When the gale eased on the 22nd, Conflans burned his own flagship. British boats burned the Héros.
The French had lost seven ships of the line, and about 2,500 men were dead, most of them drowned. The British lost two ships to the rocks and about 300 men killed and wounded.
Hawke wasn't satisfied. In his report he said that with two more hours of daylight he'd have taken or destroyed the whole French fleet. Then he defended himself.
"When I consider the season of the year, the hard gales on the day of action, a flying enemy, the shortness of the day, and the coast we were on," he wrote. Then came his verdict: "I can boldly affirm that all that could possibly be done has been done."
The invasion was dead. The French fleet never came out in force again in that war.
The British called 1759 their year of victories, and the actor David Garrick wrote a song for it that year, "Heart of Oak," which the Royal Navy still marches to. Officers took up a toast: "May our officers have the eye of a Hawke and the heart of a Wolfe."
The effects ran far beyond Brittany. With the French navy beaten at home, France couldn't send help to its army in Canada. In the spring of 1760 the French won a battle outside Quebec at Sainte-Foy and then had to watch British ships, not French ones, sail up the St. Lawrence.
New France fell that September. The American historian Alfred Thayer Mahan later called Quiberon Bay "the Trafalgar of this war."
Hawke was made a peer in 1776 and died in 1781. Conflans was blamed for the disaster and never commanded at sea again.
He chased a fleet into the rocks, and Britain kept its seas.
27
At dawn on 20 November Conflans was off Belle-Île, near the mouth of Quiberon Bay.
He sighted Duff's little squadron and went after it. Then more sails came up out of the west.
At 8:30 the British ship Magnanime, under Captain Richard Howe, signaled that she saw the enemy. It was Hawke, with two dozen ships of the line.
Conflans had a choice. He could fight in open water in a gale with his fleet strung out. Or he could slip into Quiberon Bay and dare the British to follow.
The bay was a maze of reefs and shoals, and his pilots knew it. Few British officers did. A gale was blowing from the west-northwest and the November day was short.
He headed for the bay.
Hawke signaled a general chase. Every captain was to crowd on sail and attack the nearest enemy, without waiting to form a proper line.
The story goes that Hawke's sailing master warned him about the rocks, and Hawke told him, "You have done your duty in pointing out the danger. Now lay me alongside the French admiral." The words come from later tellings, but they fit what he did.
Around 2:30 Conflans led his fleet past Les Cardinaux, the rocks off the tip of the Quiberon peninsula that gave the battle its French name. The leading British ships caught his rear just as it was entering the bay, and the firing began.
The fighting was close and wild, in big seas, with ships rolling hard. The French rear took the worst of it.
The Formidable was shot to pieces. Her commander was killed, and she surrendered to the Resolution just before four o'clock.
Then came the worst of the day. The Thésée, a 74-gun ship, was turning in the heavy sea with her lowest gunports open to fight. Water poured in through them.
She rolled over and sank in moments. Out of a crew of several hundred, only about 22 men were saved. Her captain, Kersaint, went down with her.
The Superbe went the same way soon after, and almost none of her crew survived.
The Héros struck her colors to Howe's Magnanime, and in the night she drifted onto a shoal.
The wind shifted to the northwest and threw the French line into confusion. Ships fouled each other. Conflans, in his flagship, the Soleil Royal, tried to lead his fleet back out to sea, just as Hawke came in aboard the Royal George.
Hawke steered to rake the French flagship. Another French ship, the Intrépide, put herself in the way and took the broadside. The Soleil Royal fell away to leeward and had to anchor off Le Croisic, cut off from the rest.
By five o'clock it was dark. Hawke signaled his fleet to anchor where they were, in the middle of the rocks, in a gale.
1
33















