R Scott Everngam, CFA (@EverngamR) header
R Scott Everngam, CFA (@EverngamR) profile picture

Director, RTO Policy & Federal Regulatory Affairs, E-Cubed Policy Assoc.; President, Blue Horseshoe Energy; former @FERC & @MarylandPSC. Go @Ravens & @Orioles!

Pasadena, MD
Joined June 2019
Photo by R Scott Everngam, CFA (@EverngamR)Photo by R Scott Everngam, CFA (@EverngamR)Photo by R Scott Everngam, CFA (@EverngamR)Photo by R Scott Everngam, CFA (@EverngamR)
After a delay of 9 years @FERC is addressing the DC Circuit Emera remand (Martha Coakley) for the base ROEs of the New England Transmission Owners (NETOs) at the March 19 Meeting. In the first (EL11-66) of four pancaked complaints the NETOs ROE was lowered by 57 basis points. 1/4
2
1
4
240
Hopefully @ferc will issue E-1, the @isonewengland ROE order, today after market hours following past practice for market sensitive orders. Wall Street is watching the Emera remand order with its potential decade of refunds, also an issue in the @miso ROE oral argument yesterday.
1
104
R Scott Everngam, CFA retweeted
After a delay of 9 years @FERC is addressing the DC Circuit Emera remand (Martha Coakley) for the base ROEs of the New England Transmission Owners (NETOs) at the March 19 Meeting. In the first (EL11-66) of four pancaked complaints the NETOs ROE was lowered by 57 basis points. 1/4
2
1
4
240
The DC Circuit agreed with NETOs that @FERC failed prong 1 (finding the 11.14% to not be j&r) and with Complainants that @FERC failed prong 2 (setting the new 10.57% rate as j&r). @FERC has never issued ROE orders on the ALJ Initial Decisions on the 3 pancaked complaints. 2/4
1
2
110
Even if @FERC again uses only the DCF and CAPM, rejecting Risk Premium and Expected Earnings, it will be interesting to see how the pancaked complaints and refunds are handled as well as whether there are further tweaks for determining outliers and the zone of reasonableness. 4/4
1
2
85
Coakley capped many of the generous incentive ROEs of the NETOs. The top of the zone of reasonableness of a 50/50 DCF and CAPM method should be higher and potentially restore most or all of those ROE incentives, which would mitigate a further reduction to the 10.57% base ROE. 5/5
70
UPDATE-Before further voting at the @pjminterconnect Annual Meeting MC, Chair Mark Takahashi withdrew his name from consideration. The membership declined to reconsider a vote on Terry Blackwell after an hour of parliamentary maneuvering. PJM must nominate two new Board members.
At today's @pjminterconnect Annual Meeting, members voted down 2 incumbent Board members for another 3-year term: Mark Takahashi 1.538 Terry Blackwell 2.173 A simple majority vote of 2.5/5.0 was needed. Newly proposed Board member Matt Nelson received 4.539 and was elected. 1/2
7
455
At today's @pjminterconnect Annual Meeting, members voted down 2 incumbent Board members for another 3-year term: Mark Takahashi 1.538 Terry Blackwell 2.173 A simple majority vote of 2.5/5.0 was needed. Newly proposed Board member Matt Nelson received 4.539 and was elected. 1/2
1
1
5
848
PJM has suspended the MC for a potential re-vote of the same Board slate tomorrow at 11:00 am. If that vote also fails, the Nominating Committee must select 2 new nominees for the June MC. CEO Manu Asthana is stepping down at year's end & the Board must select his successor. 2/2
3
252
In the latest edition of @FERC After Dark, FERC accepted 4-0 (See not participating) ER25-1357, the @pjminterconnect "settlement" of PA Gov Shapiro's EL25-46. The order establishes a price collar of approximately $175-$325/MW-day UCAP for the 26/27 & 27/28 RPM BRA delivery years.
5
293
On 11/18 @MISO_energy TOs requested limited rehearing on the Order on Remand where @FERC lowered the base ROE of the MISO TOs to 9.98% in response to the DC Circuit remand & vacatur of Opinion Nos 569/A/B on the issue of this rate being set retroactive to September 28, 2016. 1/3
Today @FERC addressed the DC Circuit remand of the MISO TO ROEs by setting a 9.98% ROE for the 1st 206 (15 months of refunds) and dismissed the 2nd 206. The 9.98% is effective September 28, 2016. @FERC averaged DCF & CAPM, stating Risk Premium may be justified in future cases.
1
5
480
@Edison_Electric & @wiresgroup jointly filed a rehearing on the same issue, arguing like the MISO TOs that FPA 206 does not permit refunds beyond a 15-month period, nor pancaked ROE complaints. These parties did not challenge the use of the DCF & CAPM average to set the ROE. 2/3
1
1
128
Complainants argued that @FERC should not have dismissed the 2nd complaint based upon the zone of potentially reasonable ROEs and provided additional refunds. They further alleged CAPM deficiencies involving the beta inputs used, preferring raw Yahoo!Finance NYSE-based betas. 3/3
1
99
Today @FERC addressed the DC Circuit remand of the MISO TO ROEs by setting a 9.98% ROE for the 1st 206 (15 months of refunds) and dismissed the 2nd 206. The 9.98% is effective September 28, 2016. @FERC averaged DCF & CAPM, stating Risk Premium may be justified in future cases.
Tomorrow @FERC plans to issue an order (E-4) responding to the DC Circuit remand/vacatur of the 206s against the @MISO_energy TOs ROEs (EL14-12 & EL15-45). I expect the order will affirm the original decision and rely solely upon DCF & CAPM, with a reversal on using Risk Premium.
3
1
2
1,949
Tomorrow @FERC plans to issue an order (E-4) responding to the DC Circuit remand/vacatur of the 206s against the @MISO_energy TOs ROEs (EL14-12 & EL15-45). I expect the order will affirm the original decision and rely solely upon DCF & CAPM, with a reversal on using Risk Premium.
1
2
1,724
Today @FERC issued an order in ER24-96 rejecting @PGE4Me's request for a 50 bp RTO adder for its participation in CAISO, due to the 2022 CA law mandating it. The formula rate, inclusive of the proposed 12.37% base ROE, was set for hearing & settlement procedures without comment.
The 12/13/2023 60-day statutory deadline has come and gone without a @FERC order. Did @PGE4Me actually get a 12.37% base ROE by operation of law due to a 2-2 deadlock? Without settlement and hearing? Further, did PG&E get the controversial 50 bp RTO participation adder in CAISO?
1
391