
Old geek with an interest in many things. Hard rule #1 Block me to stop me replying and you get blocked. 100%, no exceptions.
Wherever I am at the time
Joined May 2022
- Tweets32.7K
- Following217
- Followers1.1K
- Likes4.2K
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @PebMet1
If the shuttle were half of what is designed for Starship I might agree. The shuttle was supposed to be "quickly" reusable, not "rapidly". It never came close.
Attempts to speed it up led to the booster failure I woke up to one morning. Trying to speed up the central tank, fully disposable, also led to the loss of crew.
The Shuttle was rushed out, even in the 9 years, they veto'd an escape capability due to cost and then lost crew through "rushing it".
We saw similar just recently when they tried to force a return of crew with Starliner after having nearly lost the crew on ascent and ISS docking and doing Boeing some rapid patching of a highly irregular nature.
Starship aims for rapid reusability, safe crew transport, 200t to 400t to orbit depening on reuse and it will supply crew and cargo transit to both the Moon and Mars.
The shuttle was nothing more than a LEO transit which was supposed to build space stations and transfer crew to them at 70 at a time or more.
During the ISS build it proved too slow to launch to meet the ambitions of multiple large space stations and too dangerous to trust with large flights of civilians.
You then say "9 years to first crew" and assume it is a comparison.
In fact a rocket of this type would have taken NASA decades to produce. If ever.
If people want to make comparisons they need to create a list of goals for the shuttle design and then the achievements against those goals. Then compare that to Starship goals and where it is.
It is also worth remembering that the shuttle could not fly itself. So the first flight had to be crewed or it would not happen. The same high risk situation it continued in throughout its career.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @Eddystone506
So it had nothing to do with massive uncontrolled spending during Covid and war in Ukraine and Iran which sucked the rest of the world in and dramatically reduced Oil supply.
It is amazing to know that the UK So powerful that it caused 5% global inflation just by leaving the EU.
Good to know you are clued in as to what cases inflation.
Replying to @matthewstoller
Left: Elon is successful only because of government support.
Elon: Fine, I won't take any government money and cancel govt contracts.
Left: How dare you threaten me.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @Fernandonyny
The only reason Ukraine still exists to attack Russia is because Elon workers with the Canadian and German governments to get Starlink to Ukraine when it was communicate or lose.
Biden and his sycophants were dragging their feet and not helping. They would rather have seen Ukraine lose to Russia than Elon get one good word in praise.
They you sit there like a lying sack of shite and troll out your lies and call anyone who diflsagrees with you a Russian bot.
You are the lying trolling left bot and are Butthurt because Elon exposed your financial graft and left the US government no choice but to cut it off.
Don't bother blocking me, I reposted this.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @SciGuySpace
I asked Grok to summarise what I read in the article. Grok leans towards accuracy and fairness so it is not my "hit piece".
The final summary.
The piece is strongest when it documents the concrete contract pullbacks and the resulting NASA dependency. It is weakest when it treats current low Starship flight rates and higher NASA refueling estimates as near-permanent features, downplays production and architectural commonality with HLS, and applies a more generous “they are moving fast and will get there” filter to Blue Origin than to SpaceX. Your analysis tracks the article’s actual claims and the places it chooses not to look.
The rest.
Yes — the piece is structured as a long, carefully framed cautionary tale that treats SpaceX’s rational pivot away from Falcon/Dragon as a national crisis, while giving Blue Origin’s promises more weight than SpaceX’s existing hardware trajectory. It is not a pure hit piece, but the selection of facts, omissions, and tone line up closely with your reading.
Core framing and tone
Berger opens with the “El Dorado” metaphor (SpaceX hacking through the jungle of Boeing/Lockheed to win government contracts) and closes with the need for “another billionaire” (Bezos) to bail out NASA. The article’s title and subhead (“NASA desperately needs SpaceX, and SpaceX knows it, and Elon knows it”) set a dependency narrative. The Trump–Musk contract-threat episode is presented as proof the power dynamic has inverted, with commentary that Musk’s Dragon threat was “utterly irresponsible.” The political pivot you noted is explicit in the conclusion: NASA “turned its spaceflight fortunes over to one billionaire” and may now need another.
The piece repeatedly notes that SpaceX is still fulfilling existing contracts and remains more reliable/cheaper than alternatives, then pivots to the risks of the company choosing not to sign new traditional launch work. That is accurate as far as it goes (no new commercial Falcon sales after 2028, Crew Dragon wind-down by ~2030, declining some Space Force and CLPS-related launches), but the surrounding language treats the choice as abandonment rather than a company whose revenue is now dominated by Starlink + AI/compute and which is concentrating engineering on Starship.
Starship production, cadence, and HLS relevance (the gaps you flagged)
- Berger correctly states Starship has flown 14 times in ~3.5 years and that even a weekly cadence would make a ~20-launch refueling campaign take months. He notes SpaceX’s longer-term FAA filing for very high rates (10,000/year by the 2030s) and Musk’s 6–8 figure versus NASA’s higher near-term planning number (~22 / “about 20”). He also notes that higher performance and better refueling operations will reduce the number.
What is largely absent, as you said:
- Current production and test activity (multiple vehicles in test, rapid stacking, Megabay/Gigabay infrastructure at Starbase plus Florida capacity coming online).
- That HLS is a conversion kit on the same core architecture (rings, tanks, Raptor count, structural approach) rather than an unrelated new vehicle. Flight-rate progress, engine reliability, and structural/thermal work directly feed the lander.
- Pad and recovery differences versus Falcon. Falcon’s three launch mounts, drone-ship recovery cycle, and high rate of expended Falcon Heavy center cores are real constraints. Multiple Starship pads with higher reuse potential change the annual throughput math quickly once the vehicle is flying regularly. Your point that five pads with moderate reuse could exceed recent Falcon annual records (approaching or exceeding ~160) is a reasonable near-term scaling argument that the article does not engage.
On payload density for tankers versus Starlink: the article leans on current partial Starlink loads and the higher NASA planning number. It does not address that propellant is far denser than a stack of satellites in the same ~1,000 m³ class volume, that dedicated tanker ships with internal tanks are the logical architecture, or that single-use options (even a few of them) would further cut the flight count. Those are fair engineering observations the piece does not engage.
Blue Origin asymmetry
The article notes New Glenn’s pad explosion, then emphasizes the “uncharacteristic speed” of the rebuild, the $3 billion Florida investment, and the possibility that New Glenn becomes “the essential rocket powering NASA’s lunar ambitions.” It correctly notes Blue Origin’s short orbital track record (three launches) and that the lander does not yet exist. It still frames Blue as the plausible near-term alternative and Bezos as the billionaire who would “relish the role.” That is the optimism-versus-hardware contrast you highlighted: real flying hardware and production infrastructure at SpaceX versus a vehicle that recently failed on the pad, a lander that is still conceptual for Artemis III timelines, and a company whose execution record is shorter.
Additional alignments
- The Memphis / terrestrial AI reallocation is presented as evidence of deprioritization of Starship. It is also consistent with a company that has multiple large engineering problems (Starship flight rate + orbital compute) and is allocating talent accordingly.
- The financial comparison (high near-term Starship launch costs times 20 flights versus the original HLS contract value) is used to question incentives. It is less persuasive once higher reuse, higher payload density, and the fact that Starship is primarily an internal-payload vehicle are factored in.
- Several public replies to the X post (Handmer, Robotbeat, others) make versions of the same points: SpaceX can now say no; flight rate is the shared bottleneck for Starlink/AI and HLS; the industry has a long history of underestimating SpaceX cadence once the vehicle works.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @CristianaEmsley
The rebate is gone, if we go back it isn€20bn a year. But the new budget isndiloubke the old one and they never shrank it after we left.
So around €40bn a year.
If we have that much money to waste, why are we not spending it on the NHS.
They say we don't have nough money but they want to pour this money down and endless pit.
We have the true figures for net contributions now, they came out in the last EU budget negotiations when they had to fill the hole.
So we should be asking them why, if they have this money to throw away, why they are not spending more on the NHS and why are they shouting to tax more?
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @LizWebsterSBF
Excellent, just waiting for that EU parliament vote to vote in the biggest asshole who can do the most damage to the EU with all those others who are gradually starting to win majority in the parliament.
So we can be an even bigger pain in their ass then last time.
Do enjoy paying into their doubled budget which they will decide before we rejoin and we will have no chikce but to pay, €27bn a year. That's a damned sight more than 340m.
Just remember. We were the b'stards of the EU and a great many were glad to see the back of us.
Oh and they got rid of the rebates after we left. €40bn a year coming soon to an EU near you.
Do enjoy because we're going to love telling them all how wrong they are.
All over again.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @Suewilson91
No you want to drag us back into that mess for your own self interest.
So get this and understand.
There are more of us than you
We don't like the EU, most little Englanders don't like furriners either.
We will vote Reform in the EU parliament elections to deliberately screw up the parliament and if they won't do it we will vote for Restore who certainly will. Because the EU parliament is a "safe" vote, it doesn't matter.
We will vote for MP's who say they will "stick it" to the EU and we will vote for parties which can break the balance in Westminster and destabilise the country. Because if we break it we can win on marginal politics.
We Will come to Europe and tell them they are all wrong. Our MEP's will stand up in their parliament and tell them we don't like them and if they don't change we will work with the other, growing, disaffected groups and create havoc.
We will be the largest pain in their butt they have ever seen and that includes the last time so that they think the money isn't worth it.
Oh you didn't know this is all about that blockbuster new EU budget they can't afford?
What we are going to do is be exactly what we were before.
Just more.
Because now we know we don't have to put up with their crap and we can get out.
We are going to be so bad that they will write a new article, one which says they can force a member out of the Union. Then we are going to sign it into law as fast as we can.
Then we will have two ways out.
You may get your selfish deserts and Burnham may get his phyrric victory. But the EU will Rue the day.
NeilT retweeted
I’d be more than happy to welcome the UK back into the EU. 🇪🇺🇬🇧
Honestly, I don’t care about what happened in the past.
We can overcome our disagreements.
The British are part of Europe, and they always have been.
Brexit has been catastrophic. It's time to rejoin the EU.
standard.co.uk/news/politics…
NeilT retweeted
Capitalism has a win condition. Socialism does not.
Here's why, explained so simply a 10-year-old could get it.
It starts with a book written in 1944 by an Austrian economist named Friedrich Hayek: The Road to Serfdom.
Capitalism has a win condition. Socialism does not.
Here's why, explained so simply a 10-year-old could get it. It starts with a book written in 1944 by an Austrian economist named Friedrich Hayek: The Road to Serfdom.
Imagine a classroom of 30 kids. One day the teacher says: "From now on, I decide what everyone eats for lunch, which games you play at recess, and who sits next to whom. It's fairer that way."
First problem: the teacher doesn't know what you like. You hate carrots. Your friend is allergic to peanuts. Lucas wants to play football, Emma wants to draw. 30 kids, 30 different wishes. Nobody can know all of that, not even the smartest teacher on Earth. Hayek called this the knowledge problem. The information needed to run an economy is scattered across millions of heads, and it can't be gathered in one office.
Second problem: the kids start fighting. "Why does he get the window seat?" "Why football again?" Before, everyone just chose for themselves. Now every choice is a fight, because every choice is made for everyone.
Third problem: the class can't agree on a plan, so someone says "we need one person in charge who just decides." This is Hayek's key insight. Planning doesn't fail because planners are evil. A plan needs everyone to agree on the same goals, and free people never agree on everything. So the plan needs force to work.
Fourth problem, and it's the scariest one: who wants that job? The kind kid doesn't want it, because the kind kid doesn't want to force 29 people to eat carrots. The job attracts the one who likes giving orders and doesn't mind punishing those who disobey. Hayek wrote a whole chapter on this, called "Why the Worst Get on Top." It doesn't happen by accident. It happens by selection.
Here's the trap. When the person who controls your lunch also controls your job, your home, your shop and your newspaper, they control your whole life. You can't say no, because there's nowhere else to go. Controlling the economy doesn't mean controlling one part of life. It means controlling the means to every goal you have.
That's the road to serfdom. Nobody votes for a dictator. People vote for "someone should fix this," then for "give them more power to fix it," and one day they wake up with no one left to say no to.
The USSR, Maoist China, Cambodia, North Korea, Cuba, Venezuela. These are different countries with different cultures and languages, and the story has the same ending every time. When a script produces the same ending every time, it isn't bad luck. It's the script.
Now capitalism. Back to the classroom. Instead of one teacher deciding everything, every kid can trade. You give me your carrots, I give you my apple, and we both walk away happier. Nobody needs to know what everyone wants, because prices do that job. A price is a message telling millions of strangers what's scarce and what's wanted, with no one in charge.
That's the win condition. In capitalism, you get rich by making something other people freely choose to buy, so your success depends on serving others. In a planned system, you get ahead by pleasing whoever holds power. One rewards usefulness. The other rewards obedience.
And this isn't theory. Two centuries ago, almost every human being was extremely poor. In 1990, about 38% of humanity still lived in extreme poverty. Today it's under 10%. More than a billion people escaped it in a single generation. It happened when China, India, Vietnam and South Korea opened up to markets, trade and private enterprise. The largest reduction in poverty in human history came from letting people trade.
So why do so many people hate capitalism?
Because what they hate usually isn't capitalism.
They hate the bank that got bailed out with their taxes while they lost their house. They hate the giant company that writes the regulations so no startup can compete with it. They hate rent they can't afford because building new homes has been made nearly impossible. They hate the lobbyist who gets a subsidy while the small business owner drowns in paperwork.
Look closely at each one, and you'll find a state handing out privileges. A bailout is not the market. The market would have let the bank fail. A regulation written by incumbents is not competition. It's protection from competition. None of this is capitalism. It's cronyism, which is what happens when businesses stop competing for customers and start competing for politicians.
People see the symptom and blame the wrong cause. They say "capitalism failed" and ask for more state. That gives more power to the same people who created the problem, and it puts us right back on Hayek's road.
The answer to bad capitalism isn't less freedom. It's less privilege. That means fewer bailouts, fewer protected incumbents, fewer permits, and more people allowed to build, compete and trade.
Capitalism has a win condition: make things people want. Socialism has an end condition: someone has to be in charge. And history keeps showing us who ends up in that chair.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @CJHandmer
We may yet wind up with bot created bespoke OS' and applications using open protocols to talk to services and other systems.
That would be interesting. Right now I'm clean room rebuilding a Windows 3 app my wife won't give up and there really isn't an equivalent alternative around that is as easy for her to use. I say I am but really it's Grok Bot.
Will everyone eventually have their "home suite" of apps which are so bespoke that hacking them becomes impossible or self limiting.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @Vanessa_Sarges
Elon Musk was instrumental in ensuring that Ukraine had the communications to keep going in the first weeks of the war.
Without Starlink Ukraine would most likely have fallen in the first few weeks.
The EU and especially Germany prevaricated giving Russia time to take stock, refurbish, rearm and dig in. Creating a WW1 situation. It was 11 months before Germany got the fence post out of it's ass and decided to allow weapons to go to Ukraine. Note, most of the other Leopard 2 tanks in Europe were leased from Germany. They could not "give" the tanks to Ukraine because Germany had not said yes.
Do NOT blame Elon for what is going on today. He did more than most and allowed Ukraine the chance to throw Russia off. Just as did Johnson who had to fight his cabinet to pre position sufficient NLAW in Ukraine with training for them to make a decisive impact in the first weeks of the war.
Germany and the US, with the Abrams, prevaricated just long enough for Russia to dig in, build the most comprehensive tank defences since WW2 and totally negate the benefit of these tanks.
Try getting your facts straight. Ukraine is not currently ruled by Russia in no small part due to Elon Musk.
You are a bunch of bloody ingrates.
NeilT retweeted
I hope people will take the time to listen to this woman. I hope you will hear this with your own ears so you can understand what these people are doing. This past week they resurrected the USAID flag - what does that tell you? Firstly, they never give up. Not even in defeat. They fight back as if it is a God given right to give away millions & millions of your tax dollars to foreign nations to further their ideology globally. They act as if the election of someone who opposes DEI is a war crime & they marshall their resources & move to private groups where they continue to organize & plan how to subvert the will of the people who just defeated them. They do not whine about their own side - they stick together & they do not stop.
Let that be a lesson to all those who do nothing but bitch about this Administration. Whatever your grips, legitimate or not, don’t be so foolish that you let these people take back the power they lost. Don’t give up. Don’t surrender this hard-won ground. Because these people have not gone away. They are waiting, subverting, planning & most especially preparing. They were royally obliterated in the last election so what did they do? They started planning for the midterms. Instead of giving four years to Pres Donald Trump, their plan is to give him two.
Stay home in the midterms and you let that happen. Shrug your shoulders, and this is on you. Ignore the threat, and you only have yourself to blame.
@dararepublican the answer to your question about when this becomes treason is very simple: it is when they collude/conspire with an enemy of our country. An enemy is someone who is declared, like a foreign nation during a war. Or a domestic enemy like Antifa, as they have been declared a domestic terrorist organization.
Both treason & sedition are efforts to undermine our government and destroy our country. And your work here is evidence of a crime. This hurts all Americans and we have seen this before in 2020, when reporter, Millie Weaver, exposed a call just like this among federal employees who were still employed and planning how to subvert Pres Donald Trump after the 2020 election.
So far these people have gotten away with their crimes. But they are still crimes. People really need to pay attention to what you are exposing because this is an enemy like none we have ever faced: those who gain power again this way have no intention of ever ceding any of it to their adversaries ever again.
Thank you to all three of you for exposing these people. Please God someone in power will actually hold them accountable.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @DanielJHannan
I've liked your work for a long time but you are totally on the wrong side of this situation.
If you want to get the UK to create a serious capability for Space then get together with Perter Hague @peterrhague of shared family name, who is tirelessly advocating for a UK space capability.
Now some numbers.
10,000 satellites. That is how many Starlink are in orbit today for SpaceX.
12 million users. That is the number of users, mostly personal, who subscribe to Starlink. I am one.
10 million, the number of kits a year planned to be manufactured by the end of 2026. 5.4m was achieved early 2025. Starlink PCB manufacturing is the largest in the US.
60, the number of Starlink V3 satellites which will fit in a Starship launch
10, the multiplier in capacity that a single Starlink V3 satellite has compared to the V2
30, the number of planned flights "per day" for Starship when Louisiana is fully developed.
20, the number of flights "per year" that Ariane 6 is projected to be capable of
30, the number of (Starlink V2 class), satellites an Ariane 6 can launch
4, the number of Starlink V3 satellites required to exceed the entire bandwidth of the proposed IRIS2 290 satellite constellation. 3.3Tb/s IRIS2 compared to 4Tb/s for 4x Starlink V3
100,000, the final target for the sustainable Starlink V3 constellation
1 million, the target constellation for SpaceXSI AI-1 inference compute datacentre satelleites.
Today Ariane is launching about 6 times per year. Has a backlog stretching years at that cadence and has no path to 20 flights a year this decade.
The Scale of SpaceX is superpower nation scale.
The scale of Arianespace and ESA is 3rd world banana republic in terms of space. China is second to SpaceX and a LONG way behind.
So if you want to ask the question, learn what the reality is. SpaceX is building manufacturing in Bastrop Texas for 10GW of solar per year, AI-1 satellites to host that 10GW of solar and component and terminal production to vastly exceed the current 10m per year.
By 2030 there will be close to 50m users of Starlink all over the world. Users who, in the most part, have no viable alternative.
Now other data to see if you truly get it.
Starbase Louisiana, initial 10 launch mounts for Starship, final, over 12. $100bn committed investment. This is 11 years of the ESA budget.
Tefafab, where they will be producing all the chips for the AI-1 satellites. $119bn committed investment. But this is 50% Tesla so we will half it. That is another 6.5 years of the ESA budget combined.
SpaceX, a commercial space company, has committed 17.5 years of the Entire ESA budget to TWO projects which will deliver Starlink and AI compute at levels nobody can compete with.
It is all very well making political statements. But unless you have the knowledge behind it, you are just going to look stupid.
Like all the "EU is great forever" idiots.
You are a journalist. Information should be your monarch. This was an information free question.
NeilT retweeted
Replying to @MarioNawfal
So basically they want the UK "black hole" removed from the budget so they don't need to keep paying it.
That means all the states the UK was funding lose their money. Something they could not agree at the last budget and it was too short term to make any radical changes. They had all approached the budget assuming the UK would simply never leave.
But they will never tell you that and if you did not follow the last budget, you won't know.
NeilT retweeted
Despite being in a iterative test phase, Starship launched 10 times in two years, that's more than many finalized rockets have flown in their 3 years of existence
And as great as China's space program is, they're not beating the US/Artemis to the Moon as they have no care for a race and are just building out their own lunar manned program.
Yall have lost your minds
Replying to @Truthful_ast
how many times has your oh so precious 🥺starship launched in the last 2 years, that shit is going nowhere LMFAO bruh chinas gonna beat our ass and they deserve to, gladly cuz we suck atp, trumps gutted our space program and i hope any dem pres cuts ties with the muskian cancer
















