Do you know why people *actually* give to organizations?
I asked this question on a seminar I was giving a little while ago, and I got a lot of different answers.
“They want to leave a legacy.”
“They want to support pick-your-mission.”
“They want to do good in the world.”
Sure, these are all technically true, but let’s go even deeper into the neuroscience of it all.
Why? Because at the end of the day, we are driven by brain chemicals.
When someone makes a charitable donation, their brain lights up. Literally.
Studies using fMRIs show that giving activates the mesolimbic pathway & subgenual area of the brain - the same parts of the brain associated with pleasure, trust, and social connection.
→ Bottom line: giving makes people feel good.
🧠 Oxytocin (the “bonding” hormone) gets released
🧠 Dopamine floods the system, creating a reward response that makes people want to give again.
🧠 Endorphins kick in, triggering a “helper’s high” that feels a lot like euphoria.
Now what actually sparks that chemical reaction?
Not stats. Stories.
When you share a powerful story, the donor’s brain lights up. They imagine themselves helping. They feel emotionally connected. That emotional connection drives action.
So if you want to raise more money?
Don’t just show your impact.
Help your donor feel it.
Because people don’t give to data & numbers. They give to people. And they like to give!
9
Most annual reports are leaving donations on the table.
Each year, you send out an annual report to your donors, trying to perfectly format charts, highlight metrics, and showcase growth.
The report can read as all head and no heart if you overdo it on the data.
The problem?
Donors don’t fall in love with numbers. They fall in love with stories.
Data alone won’t drive giving. Emotion does.
A little while ago, I helped a nonprofit reframe how they talked about themselves.
Previously, they led with data and information, occasionally adding in a token “client success story” to supplement.
While it was bringing in some donations, the nonprofit was far from reaching their donation potential.
They needed their messaging to actually inspire, not just inform.
So we started with story. We let storytelling – not data and information – be the bedrock of all the messaging we shared.
Then, we wove in the data as the supporting evidence.
The result?
It sparked conversations and giving spiked.
Now this doesn’t just apply to your annual report. It applies to all your messaging – your marketing, your appeals, your social content, and everything in between.
I want to know: what’s one story from this year that you’ll still remember five years from now?
16
There are some nonprofit leaders who think a strong mission statement or big vision is what makes a nonprofit memorable.
It’s not.
We’ve all seen them – those perfectly, polished, committee-approved mission statements overflowing with jargon but so often missing the mark and not really saying anything meaningful.
And when you go talk to your donors, your volunteers, the people you help… None of them quote your mission statement.
They tell you stories.
→ A family who finally got housing after living out of their car
→ A student who was the first in her family to graduate
→ A woman whose roof no longer leaks during a storm
That’s what people remember.
Stories are what turn your nonprofit’s work from a concept into a connection.
They transform your mission from being words on a piece of paper and numbers in a spreadsheet to being lived experiences that people can see, feel, and rally behind.
We call these “Impact Stories.”
When my clients started to weave Impact Stories into their fundraising asks, social content, and Board updates, the results were astounding.
Volunteer engagement increased.
Staff morale increased.
Giving increased.
When you start sharing stories of impact, everything changes.
What’s one story you could tell about your nonprofit’s impact? Let me know below.
2
At the Council of New Jersey Grantmakers Conference today, a new friend asked me a vulnerable question: “I don’t understand the terminology. Fundraising, development, advancement – isn’t it all the same?”
No, they aren’t the same.
Here’s the breakdown…
→ Fundraising = raising money.
This is pretty straight forward – it’s asking for money to fuel your work.
→ Development = relationship building.
This is about cultivating the people & partners needed to make fundraising possible.
→ Advancement = Big-picture impact
It’s how you move the entire organization forward through strategy, fundraising, partnerships, storytelling, visibility, and more.
Within an organization, all three are needed.
Without fundraising, you have no money to make an impact with.
Without development, fundraising just feels transactional.
Without advancement, there’s no clear direction & cohesiveness.
When you put all three together, you’re able to build a sustainable system that fuels long-term growth.
If you’re struggling with any aspect of these, give us a call. We’d love to help you maximize your impact for good!
7
Most nonprofits wait until the last minute to collect stories they need for their next fundraising campaign.
You’re a week or two away from launching your next big campaign, and your marketing director sends the team an email.
“Anyone have any stories to illustrate…?”
Suddenly, everyone is scrambling.
Someone remembers a client who said something powerful… but it was 6 months ago.
Mayyyyybe there’s a photo somewhere.
The staff member who oversaw that really cool project? They’ve left.
It doesn’t have to be this hard.
If storytelling is one of your most powerful fundraising tools, then you need a system to capture stories all year long – not just when you need them.
My recommendation?
1️⃣ Set up a shared “Story Bank” CRM.
This is a central place where everyone can drop in client stories, donor quotes, Board anecdotes, or milestones as they happen. Use something like @airtable or @NotionHQ where the information can be searchable by program, date, and them.
2️⃣ Create a routine rhythm of having your team add to the Story Bank on a monthly basis.
This doesn’t have to be full-blown stories – just moments & emotions that can be fleshed out later.
3️⃣ Commit to sharing stories.
A Story Bank that just collects stories and is never used isn’t of much value.
You need to actually tell the stories you collect. Commit to sharing a story at least once or twice per month.
The truth is, your nonprofit is already creating plenty of meaningful moments and success stories.
You just need a system to collect & share them.
What is your organization doing to collect Impact Stories? What tools do you use to aid in the process?
12
One of our clients just secured a $1M legacy gift. Here’s how she did it… 🔽
A nonprofit leader came to me knowing she had a huge opportunity.
She had a huge vision that needed big support, and she had a potential donor in mind that could help.
However, she knew that “simply asking” wasn’t enough. This leader knew that she needed a plan.
She needed to find a way to align the donor’s values with the nonprofit’s mission.
The key? Facilitating a conversation that felt like creating a partnership, not making a pitch.
After all, donors – and people in general – don’t enjoy being sold to. (I mean, how many telemarketers do you hang up on every week?) They don’t want to feel like they’re just a person on one side of a transaction.
What DO they want?
Partnership. Relationships. To be part of something meaningful. To leave a legacy.
And once we were able to find the overlap between the donor’s values and the nonprofit’s mission, the path to making the ask in a way that aligned with the donor became clear.
And when she made the ask?
The donor said yes…
…To the mission.
…To the legacy.
…To a $1,000,000 gift that changed what was possible.
7
Last week, a client called me. The frustration in their voice was palpable.
“We can’t make any progress. Every step forward with the staff gets walked back by the Board.”
Trust had eroded. The staff felt micromanaged. The Board felt out of the loop. And the Executive Director was caught in the middle of a passive-aggressive tug-of-war.
An email can’t fix trust. A pull-aside conversation isn’t going to fix it either.
I told my client she needed to flip the tables. No more emails or 30-minute Zoom meetings to try to smooth things over. You need to get everyone in the same room and hit the reset button.
How do you do that?
A strategic Board retreat. No, not a 5-day, all-expenses-paid trip to Bali.
I’m talking about 1 day in a focused, secluded setting that’s intentionally structured for team-building, re-alignment, and of course, a little bit of fun & goal-setting.
When I lead Board retreats, here’s a taste of what goes into them…
--Pre-Retreat: I hold confidential interviews to find pain points & unspoken tension.
--During the retreat, I guide them through resetting the relationship, clarifying roles, and building shared agreements.
--After the retreat, I send out documentation of the commitments made with an accountability plan.
A Board retreat is a strategic intervention to interrupt the dysfunction, so that something better and stronger can be built.
If you’re thinking it’s a Board retreat, don’t try to figure it out alone. Let’s talk about how to set it up for maximum ROI.
9
Feeling like your Board members are overreaching?
Many nonprofits operate in a gray area. Either Boards weigh in on little-to-nothing or they weigh in on every decision, slowing down progress. It often seems to be one extreme or the other.
The solution? You need to communicate with your Board what their roles are and what their rights are as decision-makers.
Here’s some real life examples…
What Boards *should* weigh in on:
→ Strategic plan approval
→ Executive Director hiring, review, and compensation
→ Budget approval and major financial shifts
→ Organizational values, mission, and long-term vision
→ Legal, ethical, or reputational risks
→ Major fundraising campaigns (and participation!)
What Boards should *not* weigh in on:
→ Staff hiring decisions (unless it’s the ED)
→ Day-to-day program implementation
→ Social media content
→ Office operations or internal workflows
→ Which platform or CRM the team should use
→ Micromanaging reports, edits, or word choices
A Board that understands its role is one of the greatest assets a nonprofit can have. However, without expectations and boundaries, they can be your worst nightmare.
Need help drawing the line? Send me a message and let’s talk. I've helped dozens of nonprofit executives and board members build alignment, role clarity, and partnership that propelled the organization forward - you can do it, too!
13
Are you 100% positive you have the right people on your nonprofit Board?
One of the biggest mistakes I see nonprofits make is allowing the wrong fit board members to stick around.
I get it, you don’t want to rock the boat. After all, they have good intentions, and they are often very passionate about your mission.
However, your Board isn’t just your governing body. They’re also your credibility, strategic partners, and door-openers.
A Board member who isn’t fully aligned will quietly cost you time, money, and energy.
So how do you know if someone’s a bad fit for your Board?
→ They consistently miss meetings. When they do show up, they contribute nothing.
→ They don’t advocate for your organization or assist with fundraising efforts.
→ They bring more politics than partnership, and the questions they ask tend to stall progress.
→ They’re not actively helping move the needle forward in your nonprofit, even though they’ve been on the Board forever.
You can’t effectively fundraise or lead your nonprofit when you’re walking on eggshells with your own Board.
So what do you do in situations like these?
✅ Start by defining what a “good” Board member looks like. On a practical level.
✅ Use these guidelines to create a Board agreement centered around accountability and engagement.
✅ Get honest about who is helping and who is holding you back.
✅ Thank and release the people who don’t fit your definitions for a “good” Board member or adhere to the Board agreement.
✅ Recruit new Board members based upon both mindset and their ability to support fundraising initiatives.
The work you do is critical and hard. Your Board should be your biggest champions and help make the work easier.
Don’t settle for anything less.
If you need help getting started, drop us a message - we'd love to help you and your board find transformational success and partnership!
14
Most nonprofit leaders think the key to success is to recruit better Board members.
The truth? Your Board’s success is based upon setting better expectations.
So what’s the difference here?
Most Boards operate on assumptions.
--“Everyone knows why they’re here.”
--“They’ll figure it out.”
--“We’re all on the same page.”
But assumptions are dangerous, and the consequences are real.
High functioning Boards start with clarity. They need to know what’s expected of them, as well as what to expect from you.
Why is this so important?
✅ It prevents confusion and passive disengagement
✅ It gives you something to point to when accountability gets hard
✅ It helps take Board members from good to great, because they know what the success metrics are.
So how do you accomplish this?
→ Instead of hoping and praying your Board members will magically be in alignment, create a Board Agreement.
What should you include in that?
✅ Time & attendance expectations
✅ Fundraising commitments
✅ Ambassadorship & advocacy
✅ Code of conduct
This should be an annual agreement that Board members sign every year, creating a natural checkpoint for commitment & alignment.
Now if your Board is used to being relatively informal, this may feel uncomfortable at first. However, it’s how you protect your team, your time, and your mission.
Have questions about your Board Agreement or want some feedback on your plans to hold your Board accountable? Send me a message! I'm here for you.
#Nonprofits #Leadership
10
Let's go #Baltimore! We hope to see all the brilliant #nonprofitleaders in charm city tonight for this #FreeWorkshop with expert fundraiser @KerryWatterson.
25
Fundraising is shifting fast. Inflation, markets, politics—all in flux.
Join us to get clear, confident, and ready to lead through uncharted waters.
May 8th 6pm at Baltimore Unity Hall
RSVP: eventbrite.com/e/navigating-…
#NonprofitLeadership #Baltimore #Fundraising
19
We are pleased to share our 2024 Impact Report!
To download the report, visit our website: fundraisingwell.com/our-impa…
And, if you'd like to discuss how Fundraising Well can help you achieve transformation results, reach out. We'd love to help you maximize your impact for good!
12,398
Impact starts at the top—with a board that reflects the communities it serves. Here’s how to recruit & retain effective, diverse board members!
What strategy helped your organization build a strong board?
#NonprofitBoards #BoardGovernance #NonprofitExcellence
18
Be a Strong Male Ally in the Workplace
Supporting gender equity isn’t just about words—it’s about action. Here are a few ways every man can support the women in his workplace.
#AllyshipInAction #GenderEquity #WomensHistoryMonth #MenAsAllies #WorkplaceInclusion
7
Nonprofit board members can drive #fundraisingsuccess:
🔹 Give personally
🔹 Make connections
🔹 Champion the mission
🔹 Support fundraising efforts
What’s one thing your board does well to support fundraising? Share in the comments! ⬇️
#BoardLeadership #NonprofitBoards
2
Building strong donor relationships isn’t just about asking for support—it’s about showing gratitude, impact, and connection.
Tag a nonprofit that does an amazing job at donor engagement and give them a shoutout for their great work! ⬇️
#DonorLove #FundraisingTips
1
Today, we honor trailblazing women who paved the way for equity, justice, & philanthropy—like Madam C.J. Walker—the first self-made female millionaire who used her wealth to fund scholarships for women, support the @NAACP's anti-lynching efforts, and empower #BlackEntrepreneurs.
12
March is a month of impact—celebrating #WomensHistoryMonth and #SocialWorkMonth, recognizing those who lead with purpose, advocate for justice, and drive meaningful change.
What inspires YOU to advocate for change? Share your thoughts in the comments! ⬇️
13
Today, on #WorldDayofSocialJustice, we thank the brave and bold #nonprofits on the frontlines of the fight for social justice, addressing systemic inequities and advocating for a better world for ALL of us.
6


















