Pinned Tweet
All technologies begin at a price of infinite, i.e. unavailable at any cost because they haven't yet been invented.
A society's wealth is determined by how close they bring this initially ā¾ļø cost toward (but never actually) $0.
The more creative, innovative, cooperative, and free the population, the faster this happens. High standards of living don't come from money (infinitely printable 0s and 1s or dirty pieces of paper), but rather wealth (the ability to cheaply produce quality products and services).
Great doctors are a gift. Median doctors are a liability.
Let's call the median ones "mDs" with a lowercase "m".
MD ā Medical Doctor
mD ā median Doctor
Median doctors kill 300,000 Americans a year, four times cars and guns combined, and that only counts the mistakes they catch and admit to.
Your life might hinge on properly differentiating between an mD and an MD.
Full write-up here: gammaovertheta.substack.com/ā¦
1) An mD says "don't confuse your Google search with my medical degree". An MD tacitly acknowledges his degree is largely a few thousand flashcards, whereas the LLMs in your hand have read every paper ever published and parsed trillions of drug and condition combinations. Thousands versus trillions.
2) An mD is why second opinions exist. An MD gets it right the first time. Ask yourself how many of five hypothetical opinions on your condition would match. If the answer worries you, you have mDs.
3) An mD treats you as the bell curve: "if everyone did this, the system would collapse". An MD treats you as one point on the bell curve: "here is what is right for you". Is he treating a patient or a system? Malthus said we could not feed everyone. The mD says we cannot full-body scan everyone. Both ignore that prices and technology move.
4) An mD asks whether you own a firearm. An MD asks whether you own a blood pressure cuff. Only one of those questions is his damn business. Last I checked, med school does not teach threat assessment, self-defense, the logic of violence, crime statistics, or the safe storage and staging of firearms.
5) An mD holds your lab results until he has time to review them. An MD releases them the moment they exist. Your blood was drawn Monday, the lab finished Tuesday, and the mD tells you Friday, because the average patient will panic. If yours gatekeeps, try Ulta Lab Tests.
6) An mD treats "Against Medical Advice" as a diagnosis of stupidity. An MD treats it as a decision that belongs to you. Whether you accept a treatment depends on very subjective factors. A 20-something professional might drink Red Bull all day to set his career for life, and happily accept temporary heart strain. A 50-something might lean on a couple glasses of wine weekly in lieu of sleeping pills. Both can be rational tradeoffs. Lawyers never invented "Against Legal Advice", because lawyers understand that risk is personal.
7) An mD jokes about putting statins in the water. An MD believes in personal autonomy.
8) An mD prescribes a daily pill when every other day would work. An MD asks whether you can count. Rosuvastatin every other day lowers LDL nearly as much as daily, and the mD prescribes daily anyway because the average patient can't remember which days to skip. The DMV and public schools treat everyone as stupid. Your doctor should not.
9) An mD tells you all generics are the same. An MD knows the same molecule made in a jugaad factory is by definition not the same drug, and has read Bottle of Lies.
10) An mD adds a medication at every visit and never removes one. An MD asks what you can stop taking before he asks what you should start. "Judge a doctor by how hard he tries to get you off meds" (Credit unknown).
11) An mD believes he is the one professional exempt from "never ask a barber if you need a haircut". An MD understands that his profession is subject to the same perverse incentives and wasteful forces.
12) An mD resents the patient who walks in informed, because his years of memorization feel stolen. An MD is relieved, as are good lawyers and financial advisors. The resentment towards prepared clients is the Labor Theory of Value (pay me for my hours, not my results).
13) An mD says "I'm a doctor" to end an argument. An MD makes an argument. "I learned very early the difference between knowing the name of something and knowing something" (Feynman).
14) An mD went to med school because Plan A fell through and the salary was guaranteed. An MD went because he was curious. Think of your friends who went to med school and count what percentage fall into the former category.
15) An mD was trained to recall and cannot handle a hypothetical, a base rate, or a conditional probability. An MD reasons. Ten years of med school and residency rewarded obedience and punished independent thought. "Men are born ignorant, not stupid; they are made stupid by education" (Bertrand Russell).
16) An mD jokes that he "didn't go into medicine for the math". An MD would be ashamed of that. It's impossible to be good at a polymathic endeavor without numeracy.
17) An mD calls preventative scans "elective" and warns you about false positives. An MD asks which is more stressful: a Stage 1 false alarm, or a Stage 3 nobody found. More information isn't bad. Lousy interpretation is.
18) An mD cites "the consensus" after dissenters are silenced. An MD understands that censorship is short-termism disguised as prudence. The upside-down food pyramid was the consensus for thirty years and ran up a horrific body count in diabetes and heart disease.
19) An mD rejects data that arrives before its explanation. An MD remembers Semmelweis, who cut maternal deaths from 18% to under 2% with handwashing and was committed to an asylum for the insult.
20) An mD underreacted when nobody knew how lethal COVID was, then overreacted once everyone knew it wasn't. An MD runs risk-reward: being hypercautious in the first weeks cost almost nothing, while ignoring the second- and third-order consequences caused immense unnecessary human suffering.
21) An mD writes every rule for the bottom half of the bell curve and enforces it on you. An MD assumes you can follow the spirit of a rule. "Six feet apart" existed because the mD assumed you could not manage "don't hug, don't yell, don't share food".
22) An mD calls all of the above misinformation. A problem that is always the patient's fault never has to be fixed, which is exactly how he likes it. Ask your doctor what he believes that 90% of his colleagues would disagree with. If he can't name a single thing, he's a useful idiot.
1
170
Manish retweeted
I need you guys to understand that being āagainst AIā like as a stance is like saying youāre against the Industrial Revolution
Manish retweeted
If any elected leader opposes data centers or the reindustrialization of America, just say you support them in Chinese. Make every reply below their posts in Chinese.
They will eventually go insane.
Manish retweeted
Govt should be so small and inconsequential to our lives that it matters not who is elected.
Manish retweeted
All technologies begin at a price of infinite, i.e. unavailable at any cost because they haven't yet been invented.
A society's wealth is determined by how close they bring this initially ā¾ļø cost toward (but never actually) $0.
The more creative, innovative, cooperative, and free the population, the faster this happens. High standards of living don't come from money (infinitely printable 0s and 1s or dirty pieces of paper), but rather wealth (the ability to cheaply produce quality products and services).
Manish retweeted
āI moved here for a better life.ā
I see. It must be pretty bad in your country huh?
āOh no, itās better than yours and Iām a better person than you.ā
There are two types of Indian-Americans:
~2/3: Those who understand the newfound hostility on a macro level.
~1/3: Those who are causing that hostility by engaging in some subset of the following behaviors.
This list is for the latter group:
1) Keep dumping idols in water ā wildlife and the waterfront be damned.
2) Keep plucking periwinkles from public property for pujas because why should you spend money on stuff you can pilfer.
3) Keep plucking cherry blossoms at rare seasonal festivals because to hell with the enjoyment of future visitors. Some will say that youāre a guilty participant in the Tragedy of the Commons. But the truth is, not everyone will behave as sociopathically as you.
4) Keep hitting up free Costco samples as a meal replacement.
5) Keep talking down to people who are younger, or in a lower economic class than you.
6) Keep talking about how America would be nothing without Indians and showing your abject ignorance of civics or history.
7) Keep telling people that you consider another country superior, yet for some mysterious reason you left it, even though you once held its passport and could have stayed. Sure, your feet voted, but sometimes they have a mind of their own and cannot be controlled.
8) Keep making noise in public because screw anyone who is capable of actually having an internal dialogue and wants to complete an internal thought. You must drown out any prospect of peace. Treat every place like your living room.
9) Keep walking into private businesses to use a restroom and walking out without buying a $3.50 scone. The Tragedy of the Commons is just a theoretical economic concept and has never proven to have devastating consequences.
10) Keep leaving bathrooms dirtier than you found them. Screw the people who will come after you. Sustainability is for losers. Also, youāre creating jobs for those who get to clean up after you.
11) Keep littering. Don't worry about animals choking, or wind carrying your trash to faraway places and creating eyesores.
12) Keep jugaading. Ignore not only the laws and customs of your land, but also the spirit. The only thing that matters is that you meet your ends.
13) Keep haggling over stupid shit in inappropriate circumstances, because having too little friction in everyday transactions makes us complacent. Wear down every merchant to the point of them wishing you never set foot in their establishment again. Sticker prices are only for people who value their time.
14) Keep abusing the return system. By not maximally exploiting a longstanding high-trust system, you're leaving money on the table.
15) Keep abusing the wheelchair system with airlines so you can feel important and be maximally lazy. Plus, it feels very high-caste to be pushed around.
16) Keep the āLittle Indiaā in your city as one of the dirtiest places in town. Show people how committed you are to sidewalk encroachment by merchants, littering, poor hygienic standards, and bullshit haggling culture.
17) Keep cutting lines. Actually, screw lines altogether. Mosh pits are more fun. The elderly and toddlers should have the good sense to stay home to avoid being crushed.
18) Keep undermining due process and the First Amendment so your feelings donāt get hurt. Racism should be illegal and strictly defined by bureaucrats. Orwell was just fearmongering. Totalitarianism is a small price to pay to combat verbal bullying.
19) Keep undermining 2A and gun culture because historical illiteracy is efficient. Only the present matters, and humans are unlikely to ever try to do heinous things to you again.
20) Keep saying āAise hi hota haiā (āThatās how itās doneā) because screw creative thinking. Your anti-evolutionary slogan might keep your children from innovating, but at least theyāll be sufficiently brainwashed and obedient well into adulthood, and if you're lucky, until your dying breath.
21) Keep devolving every conversation into a pissing contest of WhatsApp U platitudes. Thinking is overrated. Better yet, just follow your parentsā script. As a bonus, your inheritance is more likely to be secured. Freedom of thought is worth sacrificing for a little extra financial security.
22) Keep making shit up. The adage āmean what you say, say what you meanā is for suckers. You can just say things. There's nothing wrong with being monkeys making incoherent noises at each other. Integrity and keeping your word are only for the excessively evolved.
23) Keep saying āweāre taking overā because every host country loves its self-described invaders.
24) Keep hiring nepotistically. Screw talent, screw merit, and even screw your own business. It's much more important to have a compliant workforce with good slaves from your own ethnic community who are culturally trained to be subservient, who say āsir/madamā every four words, who wonāt quit because their visa depends on pleasing you, than it is to have maximum profitability and provide high-quality products and services.
25) Keep tipping like a brokey (even though no one likes tipping culture) while simultaneously highlighting that you pay more in taxes than any other ethnicity. This is rational because taxes are required at the barrel of a firearm, while tipping is optional. It's not like service industry members collect 1000s of data points to make statistically valid generalizations about which groups are both the cheapest and the most demanding. They certainly donāt share these unflattering conclusions with others.
26) Keep optimizing your life around money and status. Know the price of everything, and the value of nothing (Oscar Wilde). Your time is worthless, as is everyone elseās, so you should be willing to waste as much as necessary to save an iota of money, even if it destroys the reputation of your entire ethnicity. Because if you donāt do it, someone else will. Classic Prisonerās Dilemma and Game Theory 101: always defect.
27) Keep chest-thumping, whatabouting, schadenfreuding, and turd-polishing. And when someone points out any of the above, keep calling it racism. A problem that is always someone elseās fault never has to be fixed, which is exactly how you want it.āļø
A local bureaucrat on a power trip is a 1000x bigger PITA than most billionaires.
Many of you choose your enemies very poorly.
3
440
Manish retweeted
Replying to @karlykingsley
1) Hunger isn't a money problem. It's a governance and supply (chain) problem.
2) If money could solve it, any govt could solve it with a tiny fraction of their budget.
3) Elon has wealth (tied up in companies), not money. Learn the difference.
4) Not Elon's job. He already has several.
Manish retweeted
Replying to @slave_2_liberty
Everything is a UBI jobs program now.
We create and amplify problems to keep untalented people busy.
Manish retweeted
WARNING: You will lose IQ points if you watch this.
These are the economically illiterate rubes who Mamdani has hoodwinked and are pushing socialism. "I'm a Dior bag socialist" and she says there's enough wealth in this country where nobody should have to live in poverty, but it's being hoarded by 10 guys.
The combined wealth of the 10 richest guys in America is $3 trillion...now keep in mind, kids, they don't have that in cash. That's the combined value of all their businesses. If you were to seize 100% of all their assets, you'd have to compel the sale of all of their stock and their entire businesses. You wouldn't eve be able to get the full $3T because the forced sale of their stock and businesses would crash the entire market and you would only get pennies on the dollar. Not only that, by seizing the means of production, you've now decimated businesses that employ 2 million people...these are taxpayers. Those businesses generate wealth and tax revenue, every year, in perpetuity...if you wipe them out, you collapse the entire economy and all the tax revenue required to fund all your social services.
But even in this imaginary Mamdani world, if you were to somehow seize $3T, that might sound like a lot, but that would only fund government for 5 months. That's it. Then it's gone forever, and all the annual wealth and revenue that their businesses create would be gone, causing a cascading collapse of tax revenue that would make the entire government go belly up. Even if you were to distribute that $3T as direct cash payments to every American, you know how much that would give you? $8,900. That's it. 4 months rent, at the expense of wiping out the entire American economy.
When I tell you these communists are stupid...I mean, they are dangerously stupid. They are truly like children; they fundamentally lack any understanding of how things work, so they can LARP as adults in this fantasyland of free everything.
And listen to what she says at the end...it perfectly sums up everything wrong with these socialists: "I'm not a political scientist, so if that's wrong, I don't care"
I can't stand these people. They are going to destroy our civilization.
Manish retweeted
Bo French is not a great argument for why Indian Americans vote Democratic, because most of them were doing it long before his post. And immigration policy is a major driver.
Conservatism has a long restrictionist strand, from the 1924 quotas to today's fights over H-1B and OPT. Indian Americans are the largest users of those visas and many face decades-long employment-based green card backlogs. If your top issue is keeping legal immigration where it is, you'll find the Democratic platform closer to your interests than the current GOP's.
That's a rational, self-interested vote, not dissimilar from the specific preferences of many other demographic subgroups in America. But if immigration is the animating force, it does mean these voters were never really up for grabs on taxes, school choice, crime, etc.
For Indian-American conservatives, the honest question becomes: does immigration policy trump everything else "conservative aligned" you believe in?
And if a Bo French tweet and online vitriol really was enough to move a group of Indian Americans from Thomas Sowell to the Democratic Party, were they ever really conservative?
Manish retweeted
One reason why multiculturalism failed is its shallow interpretation of culture.
Culture isnāt curry and clothes.
Culture is values, worldview, history, ideas, religion, rules, beliefs, norms, laws, traditions, language, the ingrained habits and instincts of a hundred generations.
Different cultures = different peoples
Manish retweeted
They want whatās good for their tribe in India and what they foolishly think is good for their tribe here. They do not want to be American. They want to feed off of America. So voting blue and letting it all burn to the ground is fine as long as they extract all they can first.
It is even more interesting to see quite a few Indian-origin Americans who cheer the BJP, a nationalist-populist party that wants a Hindu-first India and repudiates the Nehru-Gandhi legacy of Western-style leftism, distance from Hinduism, and a socialist coalition of "oppressed minorities."
But in America this group largely votes for exactly the leftist coalition they oppose in India. Same people, opposite principles, depending on the country.
I understand why. Still odd.
Manish retweeted
We need to bring back American pharmaceutical manufacturing (including the raw materials we buy from China). India is NOT SAFE and most of our generic drugs are made there. China is geopolitically unsafe (think weaponization of the supply chain).
Contaminated eye drops manufactured in INDIA were linked to a deadly drug-resistant bacterial outbreak across 18 U.S. states.
81 infections were reported.
4 DEAD. 14 SUFFERED VISION LOSS. 4 HAD THEIR EYEBALLS SURGICALLY REMOVED.
Why are we allowing imported medical products from India onto American shelves.
Manish retweeted
A lot of life is just birth lottery. But you have to realize that if people like Bernie and Zohran had control of the west most people on earth would still be working like this just to eat.
Blocked and hid my reply (along with 100s of other replies). This is how a big chunk of the world operates - unable to differentiate between words and fists.
Replying to @aravind
Memes and words are just speech. They are not:
"genocidal"
"violence"
"war"
"terrorism"
"insurgency"
These 5 words are literally from your post. It's silly to conflate the verbal and physical. I condone the former, but denounce the latter (even threats in any form).
This highlights just one stark incompatibility between our cultural values. To you and your followers, verbal mockery and violent threats are shamefully the same thing. Do better.
The world does not owe you respect, jobs, or trade. Only sovereignity.
The ridiculous arguments by Ambaniās army of Internet shills make no sense
On the one hand, they say Starlink couldnāt possibly compete with the amazing low prices offered by Ambaniās de facto monopoly in India and then, in the same breath, they essentially claim that Starlink would be too strong of a competitor! This is absurd hypocrisy and hyperbole.
The reality is that competition would greatly benefit the average citizen in India by giving them more choices, as it always does. Ambaniās profits will be lower, but he is not going out of business. And, obviously, if Starlink is too expensive in India, no one will buy it, so SpaceX will need to make pricing affordable.
Something feels off with this chorus of āIndiaās internet is great and super cheapā ⦠the data shows that Indian market is absolutely dominated by mobile. When they say itās cheap and well connected factually this only applies to mobile usage.
This makes sense because a tower connects thousands of subs instantly after construction and running fiber is a building by building or resident by resident job. This is also why āfixed wirelessā has started growing fast. Follow the incentives. Itās the cheapest and shortest route to revenue.
Due to this, India is amongst the highest mobile bandwidth usage populations on the planet. 30-40GB/month. (20-50% above US/UK usage) However, home Fiber lines in India pull closer to 300GB/month. 10x gap
For context, that gap in the US and UK is 20-30x. Itās pretty ubiquitous that if you have access to a lot of more bandwidth you will use it.
Bandwidth abundance does not favor mobile devices.
Iād argue that itās not very hard to believe that these paltry sub 5% fixed customer penetration numbers would be much higher if a cost effective alternative existed.
Is that alternative existed it wouldnāt be crazy to expect to see the fixed customer numbers jump from 6% to maybe 10%, 15% or 20%. 100M-200M customers.
And if the rest of the world is any precedent that would lead to a dramatic increase in overall bandwidth used.
However, that would mean that mobile bandwidth usage would likely drop or stagnate with in home mobile usage.



















