Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken) header
Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken) profile picture

Writing at Story and Promise: A Study of the Language of Cultural Myth

Springfield, VA
Joined June 2016
Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)Photo by Greg Erken (@Greg_Erken)
Christianity should speak more in the “Language of Cultural Myth”: narrative, ritual, and symbol -- the most powerful ways of expressing a culture’s deepest beliefs.
6
620
Part of the issue is that the chattering class is way too beholden to social science. A lot of people spent much of the last decade saying “there’s no evidence phones are the problem!” when we all have the lived experience of our phones zapping our attention and dumb-ifying us.
50
106
20
1,156
61,586
We need a Catholic Mackenzie Bezos who uses her wealth to fund the beautification of Catholic churches
9
2
3
209
5,566
The Catholic Church was absolutely correct on marriage, divorce, contraception, and abortion. Popes of the past warned what would happen if the family was not the center of society and you're living in that smoking heap of a civilization right now.
103
1,042
33
8,987
159,762
“Meaning for us is mostly embodied in narrative.” The crisis has reached the level of identity and meaning. Mankind is properly located in a story, not a system. The story *is* the truth. The story is not a mere *package* for the truth.
Malcolm Guite explains, in just 90 seconds, how the deconstruction of our guiding stories leads to the collapse of civilization. @malcolmguite
1
34
Greg Erken retweeted
In 1965, 1.24 million babies were baptized Catholic in the U.S. In 2022? 438,000. That's a 65% drop in infant baptisms in less than 60 years. First Communions were 850K in 1990. In 2025: 537K Confirmations are up, though! 491K in 1990 to 498K in 2025.
16
25
7
147
31,779
Greg Erken retweeted
Mother Teresa of Calcutta died on Sept. 5, 1997, at the age of 87. St. John Paul II greeted and blessed St. Teresa in St. Peter's Basilica a few months before, on June 29, 1997. One of the last times these saints were seen together. Today is the tenth anniversary of Mother Teresa’s canonization. Pope Francis declared her a saint on Sept. 4, 2016 — just over a dozen years after she was beatified by her friend and fellow saint, Pope John Paul II. St. Teresa of Calcutta, who was born Agnes Gonxha Bojaxhiu, gained fame around the world for caring for the poorest of the poor and sharing Christ’s love with them. She founded the Missionaries of Charity, the religious order that carries on her work today around the world.
14
161
8
956
23,463
“Efficiency isn’t the only thing we should value when it comes to work. There is a pseudo scientific and materialistic bias to the discipline of economics. Older understandings made room for love, loyalty, and other humane values.” -C.R Wiley
1
1
6
1,864
The crisis has reached the level of identity and meaning.
1. You cannot understand this cultural and political moment unless you reckon with how lonely, disconnected, and "demoralized" a very large minority of young men in America have become. Roughly 4-in-10 young men aged 18-29 feel like failures, report chronic loneliness, are absent from religious, civic, or volunteer life, and lose themselves in digital worlds of porn, gaming, and gambling. This is what the digital revolution has wrought: a generation of young men adrift, disengaged, and drifting--too often bereft of connections to real people and real institutions in the real world. Major new report on "America's Demoralized Men" from @FamStudies Joe Davis, Michael Toscano & @KBurchfiel3:
23
Greg Erken retweeted
A lot of folks on high-alert against "communism" see *collectivism* as the enemy and *individualism* as the antidote. I see it quite differently. To the degree Marxism/Socialism is the problem today, I see it often as a materialistic, autonomy-worshipping, transactional worldview — and community, faith, and family are the antidotes.
17
13
3
125
35,735
It’s going to be hard for Christians and conservatives to reclaim the arts, if Christians and conservatives don’t become artists.
Which college majors are the least religious? The answer is folks in the arts: fine arts, studio art, and film and media studies. What majors are the most religious? Finance and nursing. I locate dozens of majors on religious affiliation and attendance in this scatterplot
2
78
Disappearing Public Spaces “We have designed our world, our society, for efficiency and economic benefit, and not necessarily for the thriving and well-being of humans.” — Julianne Holt-Lunstad, Brigham Young University. msn.com/en-us/health/general… msn.com/en-us/health/general…
1
23
“Why should a universe capable of beauty, order, and life exist at all? That question begins with wonder.”
Fairy Tales Teach Adults What Facts Alone Cannot Chesterton famously observed: “Fairy tales do not tell children that dragons exist. Children already know that dragons exist. Fairy tales tell children that dragons can be killed.” Most people think fairy tales exist to entertain children. G.K. Chesterton believed they exist to educate adults. In The Ethics of Elfland, one of the greatest chapters in Orthodoxy, Chesterton makes a surprising claim. Fairy tales prepare us to understand reality better than many modern philosophies because they begin with wonder instead of explanation. Children don’t wake up expecting the sun to rise. They delight that it does. Adults often do the opposite. We become so accustomed to the world that we stop noticing how extraordinary it is. The sunrise becomes routine. A tree becomes ordinary. The changing seasons become background noise. We explain everything and appreciate very little. Chesterton thought this was a profound mistake. Science can describe why leaves change color or how gravity works. Those explanations are valuable. But they do not answer a deeper question: why should a universe capable of beauty, order, and life exist at all? That question begins with wonder. Chesterton argues that we confuse consistency with necessity. The sun has risen every morning of our lives, but that does not make it less remarkable. Habit slowly convinces us that the world’s greatest miracles are simply normal. Fairy tales resist that temptation. In them, the world is full of rules, meaning, danger, and possibility. A promise matters, courage matters, and choices have consequences. The hero succeeds because he lives within an order greater than himself. Reality works much the same way. Music requires harmony just like language requires grammar. Friendships require trust. Freedom flourishes within limits. Perhaps that is why fairy tales endure long after childhood. They remind us that the world deserves gratitude before it demands explanation. Chesterton believed philosophy begins with the same question that fills a child with awe. Why is there something instead of nothing? The people who never stop asking that question never truly outgrow wonder. newsletter.thecultureexplore…
1
33
Greg Erken retweeted
And the value she creates is not only for your family! When we consider that 2/3 of wealth creation springs from human capital (labor & ingenuity are more valuable than physical capital), each well-adjusted adult a stay-at-home mom sends into the world is an enormous gift she's given her nation.
I calculated what it would cost to replace everything my wife does as a stay-at-home mom. The answer: $131,130 a year. Here's how I calculated that amount. My wife genuinely loves being home with our four children. She homeschools them, manages our home, cooks for our family, gardens, and invests her life in raising our kids. But every so often, she asks whether she should get a job to help financially. Not because she wants a career outside the home, but because our culture can make stay-at-home mothers feel like they are not contributing unless they bring home a paycheck. I always remind her: “You already have a career. You work for our family.” She may not receive a paycheck, but much of what she does saves us money we would otherwise have to earn, pay taxes on, and then spend hiring other people. So I ran the numbers using typical rates in the Des Moines, Iowa area: HOUSEKEEPER 12 hours/week × $20.74/hour $12,942 per year NANNY FOR FOUR CHILDREN 50 hours/week × $23/hour $59,800 per year HOMESCHOOL EDUCATOR 5 hours/day × 180 school days × $25.03/hour $22,527 per year PERSONAL SHOPPER 4 hours/week × $20.58/hour $4,281 per year PERSONAL CHEF 2 hours/day × $38.33/hour $27,981 per year PERSONAL GARDENER 3 hours/week × 30 weeks × $40/hour $3,600 per year TOTAL ESTIMATED ANNUAL REPLACEMENT VALUE: $131,130 This is not meant to be a literal salary calculation. Some responsibilities overlap, but that is part of the point: replacing what one stay-at-home mother does would require hiring several different people. And this still does not account for sick children, overnight care, appointments, curriculum planning, discipline, emotional support, family scheduling, or the constant mental load of knowing what everyone needs. My wife may not receive a paycheck, but she creates enormous value for our family every day. A paycheck is not the only proof that someone is contributing. Thank a stay-at-home mom today.
1
2
202
An excellent description of how theology and aesthetics can be directly related.
ON AESTHETICS I want to share something that came up organically—and it surprised me—during my conversation with Patrick Collison in Napa at the Cluny Institute's ZOE conference this week. As we were discussing the stagnation that people like Peter Thiel believe started sometime between 1969-1971, it struck me that something similar happened to aesthetics (this was the primary topic of our conversation) around 1965: the Second Vatican Council. It was the singular most important event of the 21st century in terms of the effects it had on aesthetics worldwide, and nothing else is even close. I challenge you to name a cause that rivals it. The Council ran from 1962 to 1965 and ended with radical reforms to many aspects of the Church's life. The most visible one was the liturgy: almost overnight, you had priests more casually dressed (the laity quickly followed, abandoning their 'sunday best'), guitars instead of gregorian chant, speakers installed in 500-year old old buildings, and architects around the world clamoring to design new churches that were a radical departure from the design of anything that came before, often in "UFO-shaped" designs with the tabernacle no longer central. (These design choices were direct consequence of a theological movement, and an important take-away here is that theology affects aesthetics.) It seems to me that when a worldwide institution present in every country in the world with a billion+ members undergoes such a drastic aesthetic revolution that quickly, there are ripple effects that spread throughout the whole culture—and they affect more than just aesthetics. They even affect technological innovation. There has always been a deep connection between technology, aesthetics, and the sacred. cf 2001 Space Odyssey. Kubrick understood; he tried to tell us. With the sacred so radically re-configured in such a short period of time, it is logical to believe the other things—aesthetics, and the vector of technological innovation—were affected deeply. You can not change one without the other. Perhaps this is a separate three-body problem: aesthetics, the sacred, tech. To give you one simple example among dozens: when the architecture of the churches flattened out and became less transcendent, literally less vertical, the human imagination suffered. Many of history's greatest innovators, including in science and tech, were religious—a large number of them Catholics. Now there are very few: and the ones that do exist are designing prayer apps or engaged in more parochial projects, not civilizational ones. (There are many exceptions, including the leaders of the Hamilton Society, who ran an amazing debate at ZOE; but they are the exception that proves the rule.) Changing the shape of our buildings and the way that billions of people worship changes the vector of innovation. The cultural implications of Vatican II may not be fully appreciated by more secular people—who may know nothing about it, or consider it inside Catholic baseball. My point is that it is anything but. And that anyone interested in the question of aesthetics and the changes of the past 100 years should study the changes of the council.
16
Hyper-politics (politics with high emotional intensity and very low practical impact) is just the flip side of hypo-sociality (lots of alienated individuals interacting virtually without any real community).
15
2
69
2,706
Great, Elon wants to lead the Right from mere imitation of the mainstream to AI slop imitation. More thoughts on the right’s imitation problem: open.substack.com/pub/greger…
Elon Musk says Grok will make a full-length “historically accurate” version of ‘The Odyssey’ before the end of this year.
44
Replying to @_CLancellotti
The principle of non contradiction is always helpful. Or it never fails to amuse how so many exert their will to refute free will. Similar with those argue zealously on the depravity of human reason.
1
65
Listen:
When does a human life begin? And when does it become a person? They sound like the same question. But @Princeton professor and legal philosopher Robert P. George says confusing the two is one of the most consequential errors in modern public debate. “An embryo is not something distinct from a human being. It is a human being at the earliest stage of its development.” — Robert P. George Praxis Circle sat down with one of America’s leading moral philosophers — author of Embryo: A Defense of Human Life — to explore what embryology actually tells us, where science ends, and where philosophy must begin. Watch the full interview. 👉 praxiscircle.com/leader/robe… @McCormickProf #RobertGeorge #PraxisCircle #BuildingWorldviews #HumanLife #Personhood #Embryology #BigQuestions #Philosophy #ScienceAndFaith
1
18
Watch the exact moment @khloekardashian finally connects the dots on what we’ve been warning people about for years: Big Fertility and the abortion industry are completely intertwined. It’s simple. When you turn pregnancy into a commercial contract, you hand over control of a human life. Khloe is realizing the terrifying reality that she cannot even stop a surrogate from choosing to abort her own child's twin if the contract allows it. This is what happens when you treat a baby like a business transaction. Children get reduced to property, and parents find out too late that they have signed away the right to protect their own kids. You cannot treat a baby like a retail order where abortion is just a clause in a contract. It is wrong, it is exploitation, and people are finally starting to open their eyes.
29
110
7
946
126,391