The question then…after last week’s games, what changed? Why was Iowa higher last week? Ohio State was certainly not as impressive in beating NW as Iowa was 1 week earlier. And IA and Oregon beat opponents of similar caliber and record by nearly identical scores. What changed?
I realize this isn’t how CFB playoff rankings are determined, but after this week’s circus I was curious about the Oregon - Ohio State - Iowa comparisons. I asked ChatGPT for the following neutral field point spreads. Make of this what you will.
Ohio State - 6.5
vs. Iowa
Oregon - 2.5
vs. Iowa
Ohio State - 4.5
Vs Oregon
It also told me Iowa would be favored against every team ranked behind it in the poll and an underdog of less than a field goal against Oregon, Texas Tech and BYU.
61
Brett Ridge retweeted
Yet the 16th place team in the Big Ten beating the 6th placed team in the SEC means nothing.
This sport is DUMB.
Brett Ridge retweeted
ESPN’s SOS is completely broken.
UCLA: 69th SOS. Full B1G schedule with 4 of the top 8, and no FCS.
TX State: 61st SOS. Entirely G6/FCS schedule except for one game at Texas.
This is the model the Committee is using to tell you certain teams haven’t played anyone. #CFPRankings
This is the point and what I said last night before Oregon and Ohio State fans lost their shit on me.
This is my biggest issue. There’s an argument to both Ohio State and Oregon being ranked above Iowa. But the idea of them JUMPING Iowa when all the teams won (Iowa by 3 scores as well) makes last weeks ranking essentially worthless. It doesn’t make any logical sense
1
731
Brett Ridge retweeted
The SEC's 10-2 record against other P4 teams is consistently cited to justify the "SEC bias" in the CFP rankings. What's consistently ignored is:
1) The 10 wins are vs teams that are a combined 53-47.
2) The SEC went 2-8 in bowl games last year not against other SEC teams.
Brett Ridge retweeted
Replying to @David83691297 @HawkeyeHuddle2
USC lost to Wisconsin who Iowa beat 30-0.
Iowa played Ohio state when they were #5 and still had Sayin.
Try again
Michigan State over Oregon, Washington over Indiana, Nebraska over Ohio State….puts Iowa in Big Ten Championship Game if they win out. Need a signature win? Beat UCLA.
The Iowa fans' rooting guide this week to get into the CFP discussion (other than winning, of course). Some of these options are as tasty as a shot of Robitussin.
Direct help:
Nebraska over Ohio State
Michigan State over Oregon
Baylor over Texas Tech
Kansas over BYU
Georgia Tech over Wake Forest
LSU over Tennessee
Missouri over Kentucky
Indirect help:
Iowa State over UCF
Wisconsin over Purdue
Minnesota over Northwestern
Michigan over UCLA
Washington over Indiana
3
455
They played a game 6 weeks ago with different talent. Ohio State is currently missing a huge piece in their talent pool. Additionally, Iowa has vastly improved with their three new offensive linemen and new quarterback all playing significantly more consistent high level football
Ohio State is ranked 14th.
Iowa is ranked 15th.
They played a game at Iowa 1 month ago.
Ohio State won by 17.
Committee got this right.
2
9
375
Brett Ridge retweeted
Nice little dated, heavily inaccurate dig at Iowa here.
Iowa has 10 TD passes in their last 7 game, by the way.
Truly can’t make up some of the stuff this network is publishing/putting on air right now.
They did it this week to get the complaining out if the way because they intend for Oregon to be above Iowa regardless of the outcome in Champaign.
The main thing I cannot get over is how the CFP punished Florida State without Jordan Travis years ago. This is clearly not the same Ohio State team without Julian Sayin and they get a pass.
Oregon could have leapfrogged Iowa but it makes no sense right now. Let the Illinois game play out and then you can justify a jump.
And the bottom five is just… 😷
1
163
Brett Ridge retweeted
*A team is ranked
*That team plays Iowa
*Iowa wins, causing that team to become unranked
“iOwA dOeSn’T hAvE aNy RaNkEd WiNs”
Ohhhhh. Right. That totally explains it.
Replying to @HawkeyeHuddle2
But Brett...Iowa sucks because their offense was inefficient and led by Deacon Hill three years ago. And the "three years ago metric" MUST be considered. Duh.
1
3
540
Brett Ridge retweeted
If the justice for Oregon jumping Iowa is because of the result vs Ohio State, the committee MUST put Iowa ahead of Oregon if they beat Illinois this week. Otherwise this is corruption.
Yes, but it was the same last week. So what happened this week to see such a stark difference? OSU beat NW at home by less than IA did on the road the week before and the Buckeyes jumped six spots. If the logic they claim is used, OSU should have been over IA last week.
Hunter Y actually explained the Oregon-Ohio St-Iowa order pretty reasonably. It's not just head to head.
62





























