Paul Crabtree (@Infrastructor) profile picture

PE of Crabtree Group Civil Engineers and Town Planners. CNU Rainwater www.cnu.org. Rainwater-in-Context at Google Groups. TransectCodesCouncil www.transect.org

on the urban armature
Joined February 2011
Photo by Paul Crabtree (@Infrastructor)Photo by Paul Crabtree (@Infrastructor)Photo by Paul Crabtree (@Infrastructor)Photo by Paul Crabtree (@Infrastructor)Photo by Paul Crabtree (@Infrastructor)
Modern concrete starts falling apart in a few decades. Roman concrete has been sitting in seawater for 2,000 years and getting stronger. The Romans figured out that volcanic ash changed everything. They dug it from around the Bay of Naples, near the town of Pozzuoli, mixed it with lime and chunks of rock, and got a material that could set even underwater. The architect Vitruvius wrote about it in the first century BC. Pliny the Elder claimed that once it hit the sea, it became a single mass of stone the waves couldn't break. He wasn't exaggerating. Roman harbor walls and piers built in the sea are still standing today, while modern concrete in the same conditions cracks and crumbles. For a long time nobody knew why. In 2017, a geologist named Marie Jackson studied samples from ancient Roman piers and found the answer. Seawater soaking into the concrete was reacting with the volcanic ash and growing rare mineral crystals inside it. The ocean that destroys our concrete was actually reinforcing theirs. Then in 2023, MIT researchers found something else. Roman concrete is full of little white chunks of lime that scholars had long assumed were just sloppy mixing. They weren't. The Romans were likely mixing with hot quicklime, and those chunks acted as a built-in repair kit. When a crack formed and water seeped in, the lime dissolved and filled the crack back in. Self-healing concrete, two thousand years before anyone used that phrase. The Romans built on a scale that shows they trusted it completely. Herod the Great had volcanic ash shipped all the way from Italy to build an artificial harbor at Caesarea in Judea. Hadrian's Pantheon in Rome, finished around 125 AD, still has the largest unreinforced concrete dome on earth, about 142 feet across. No steel. Nothing holding it up but the concrete itself. After the Western Empire collapsed, the know-how faded. Medieval Europe mostly built in stone and timber. Modern Portland cement wasn't patented until 1824, and it still can't match what the Romans were pouring into the sea before the birth of Christ.
9
70
7
386
13,297
Paul Crabtree retweeted
Most people in ancient Rome lived in rented apartments. Today, a 1,900-YEAR-OLD Roman apartment block is still standing in Rome, at the foot of the Capitoline Hill. Records from the 4th century say the city had about 46,000 apartment blocks, called “insulae.” In comparison, there were fewer than 2,000 private houses. Some of these buildings were so tall that Augustus banned anything higher than 70 Roman feet (about 20 meters). Later, Emperor Trajan lowered the limit to 60 Roman feet. The floors worked the opposite way from today. Shops were on the ground floor, and rich tenants lived on the first floor. The higher you went, the cheaper the rent and the worse the living conditions: there was no running water, there were fewer windows, and there were a lot of stairs to climb.
75
500
32
4,195
285,646
Paul Crabtree retweeted
Build as if you only had a wheelbarrow, and you’ll preserve much more of the character of the land and streams, and also many of the trees. Your lots will be more valuable and far less boring in the early years than land scraped flat as per standard engineering practice.
1
5
1
59
1,612
The Hoover Dam was built in 4 years and 2 months (1931–1935). It contains 2.48 million cubic metres of concrete. Enough to build a 2-lane highway from New York to San Francisco and back. At peak, 5,200 workers were on site simultaneously. 113 died during construction. It generates 4 billion kWh per year, enough to power 1.3 million US homes. At completion, it was the world's largest hydroelectric power station and the world's largest concrete structure. Both records have since been broken. But the dam still runs on its original turbines, 90 years later.
24
39
3
539
80,084
Replying to @Tesla
In the 1950s, flying cars were the ultimate symbol of the future. It’s 2026.
They’re here. The future has arrived. ✈️
14
12
1
293
22,067
'The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result.' — Rita Mae Brown Case #1237 of using traffic engineering to solve the problems of traffic engineering. 📍 #Alexandria, Egypt 🇪🇬.
35
240
84
1,998
553,211
In Centuripe, the landscape determined the streets, and the streets gave the town its extraordinary shape. The town you see today largely dates from the 16th century, but Centuripe’s story reaches back to a Sicel settlement founded in the 8th century BC and a prosperous Roman city.
8
13
132
11,656
“Streets, the main public places of a city, are its most vital organs.” - Jacobs “If you want to know what a culture values, look at what it builds. Our cities and towns are some of the greatest works of human civilization. They all began with their streets.” - Dover+Massengale
1
33
2
90
3,040
Paul Crabtree retweeted
Epic
135
392
133
2,176
6,018,381
Paul Crabtree retweeted
NYC DOT announced that Park Avenue will return to its original park design. Nature is healing.
61
540
39
13,362
300,300
Paul Crabtree retweeted
Rest in Peace, Wendell Berry. You brought light and life and made the world a better place. My sincerest thanks to you. Do not live for death, pay it no fear or wonder. This is the firmest law of the truest faith. Death is the dew that wets the grass in the early morning dark. It is God’s entirely. Withdraw your fatal homage, and live.
1
3
339
Roman roads were built to last. Not for decades. For millennia. The construction sequence, documented by Vitruvius and confirmed by modern excavations, was: 1. STATUMEN: large flat stones laid directly on compacted subgrade 2. RUDUS: a layer of smaller stones or rubble, set in lime mortar, 20–30 cm thick 3. NUCLEUS: concrete made from lime, coarse sand, and gravel, 15 cm thick 4. SUMMUM DORSUM: the surface layer, flat polygonal stones fitted together without mortar, slightly crowned at the centre to drain water The total depth: up to 1.5 metres in some roads. The road was cambered, raised at the centre, so rainwater drained to drainage ditches on each side. The drainage ditches were themselves engineered: lined with stones, at calculated gradients. Roman roads didn't fail because of moisture. Most ancient roads do. By 200 AD, the Roman road network spanned approximately 400,000 km. Over 80,000 km were stone-paved. In Britain, several modern roads run directly above Roman foundations. The A2 from London to Dover follows the line of Watling Street. The M1 motorway in Hertfordshire runs parallel to the Roman road it replaced. The roads worked because the engineers understood the problem was not the surface. It was water management beneath the surface. That's still true of every road built today.
19
46
4
468
114,657
The coolest technology in a heatwave? Trees. Every tree planted today helps create a cooler, greener and healthier London tomorrow. We've already planted more than 640,000 trees since 2016, and we're continuing to grow and protect our urban forest to help London adapt to hotter summers.
185
21
621
56,615
Paul Crabtree retweeted
Call Off the Iran War. Just Walk Away!
83
416
24
2,790
49,707
Listen to that CRUNCH. Absolutely delicious. #WorldBollardAssociation
286
245
98
4,331
326,875
Most engineers learn fast in years 1–5. Then growth slows dramatically. Not because the job gets easier, but because the learning loop breaks. Here's why it happens and how to fix it: WHY THE PLATEAU HAPPENS You stop encountering new failure modes. In your first years, everything fails in ways you've never seen. You learn by being wrong. By year 5, you've solved most problems in your domain. You stop being wrong as often. Less failure = less learning. You stop reading outside your field. Civil engineers stop reading mechanical engineering papers. Software engineers stop reading manufacturing research. The best ideas in your field are often translations from adjacent ones. You optimise for delivery, not understanding. Experienced engineers know how to solve the problem without fully understanding why the solution works. Fast delivery is valuable. But it's the enemy of depth. HOW TO BREAK THE PLATEAU 1. Take on projects where you're the least experienced person in the room. Deliberately uncomfortable. Deliberately unfamiliar domain. The fastest learning always comes from being the person who doesn't know. 2. Teach what you know to someone junior. Teaching reveals the gaps in your understanding faster than any other method. If you can't explain it simply, you don't fully understand it. 3. Read the original papers, not the summaries. The textbook compresses 20 years of argument into one settled answer. The original paper shows you the uncertainty, the dead ends, and the assumptions. That's where the real understanding lives. 4. Do a project in an adjacent field once a year. Structural engineer? Learn one concept from geotechnical. Software engineer? Read one manufacturing process paper. Cross-pollination is where innovation happens. 5. Track your own predictions. Before a project starts, write down what you think will be the hardest part. After it ends, compare. Engineers who track their own predictive accuracy improve faster than those who don't. The plateau isn't inevitable. It's a sign that the learning environment needs redesigning.
19
57
3
347
60,419
Earth receives enough sunlight every day to meet all of humanity's energy needs 10,000 times over
19
32
6
412
65,228
Andenes are the stepped agricultural terraces the Incas and earlier Andean cultures carved into steep mountain slopes, and they are one of the defining features of the Sacred Valley. The word comes from the Spanish "andén," meaning platform or step, and it is often cited as one possible root of the name "Andes." Each terrace is a flat platform held up by a retaining wall of fitted stone, stacked in tiers up a hillside like a giant staircase. They were carefully engineered rather than just piled earth. A well built andén had large stones at the base for drainage, then layers of gravel and sand, and finally a deep layer of fertile topsoil often carried up from the valley floor. This structure let water filter through slowly instead of washing the soil away. The Incas built them for several reasons. They turned steep, useless slopes into level farmland in a region with almost no flat ground. The stone walls held soil in place against heavy mountain rains and stopped erosion. The drainage layers managed water and prevented landslides and waterlogging. And the walls created microclimates, absorbing heat by day and releasing it at night to protect crops from frost, while different elevations allowed a wide range of crops such as maize, potatoes, and quinoa. The best examples in the Sacred Valley are at Pisac and Ollantaytambo, where terraces sweep up the mountainsides in long curved and straight tiers. Moray is a special case, a set of deep concentric circular terraces that many researchers believe served as an agricultural testing ground, since each ring sits at a slightly different temperature. Many of these terraces are still farmed by local communities today, more than five centuries after they were built, which shows how well the drainage and soil engineering was designed.
1
1
2
642
Paul Crabtree retweeted
We’re building Silicon Valley outside Silicon Valley.
510
277
623
3,216
2,813,209
Paul Crabtree retweeted
Elon Musk just put a price tag on obedience. It costs $200,000. Musk: “You don’t need college to learn stuff. Everything is available basically for free. You can learn anything you want for free.” Every lecture. Every textbook. Every framework ever written. Free on any screen in any country right now. The entire knowledge monopoly collapsed in a decade. Nobody updated the price tag. Musk: “Colleges are basically for fun and to prove you can do your chores. But they’re not for learning.” Strip the ivy and the branding. What’s underneath is a four-year obedience trial. Can this person follow instructions on a schedule without asking why. Musk: “There is a value that colleges have, which is seeing whether somebody can work hard at something, including a bunch of annoying homework assignments, and still do their homework assignments.” That is the entire six-figure value proposition. Not what you know. Not what you can build. Whether you can be managed. The establishment doesn’t need you educated. It needs you domesticated. Musk: “If you’re trying to do something exceptional, you must have evidence of exceptional ability. I don’t consider going to college evidence of exceptional ability.” The system doesn’t produce exceptional. It produces manageable. It takes the most creative years of your life and teaches you to wait for instructions. That is not education. That is containment. Musk: “Gates is a pretty smart guy, he dropped out. Jobs is pretty smart, he dropped out. Larry Ellison, smart guy, he dropped out.” They didn’t leave because they couldn’t keep up. They left because the ceiling was underground. 8 billion people now carry the same library in their pocket. The one these institutions charged a lifetime of debt to access. The only product the university still sells is the belief that you need one.
995
5,634
530
22,575
1,399,265