James Coghlan (@JamesMC61) profile picture

Business owner. Former ISME Chair 2015-17. Interested in current affairs, sport & lots more. Never drink & tweet. Views my own.

Dublin City, Ireland
Joined June 2013
Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)Photo by James Coghlan (@JamesMC61)
Excellent article by @ConorPMBrady on reforming our instititions, such as the Minister & Secretaries Act 1924, as recommended by the Devlin Commission (1966-69), and more recently by a Joint Oireachtas Committee (2022/23).
37
Remarkable explanation of the French pension system & its significent inter-generational impact.
The ugly truth about France and some of the other European countries currently in turmoil - and which none of the politicians want to admit because it'd be political suicide - is that you can't solve the problem by going after immigrants (as the right asserts) or the rich (as the left asserts), but you could solve it by going after the old. One extraordinary statistic for you: people over 60 in France, a quarter of the population, own 60% of France's wealth, non-financial and financial (ofce.fr/pdf/revue/2025/3-192…). And here is another crazy statistic: that same quarter of the population, those above 60, receive nearly two-thirds of all social spending by the French government (previssima.fr/actualite/prot…) - which is famously among the highest in the world (France's government spending is an insane 57.3% of GDP). Last statistic: they make up about 40% of voters because they're a third of registered voters (insee.fr/fr/statistiques/266…), and they turn out far more than anyone else (franceinfo.fr/elections/sond…). Put our 3 statistics together and there's almost a bit of an apartheid situation here: the old own most of the country's wealth, collect most of the social spending and have the political power to keep it that way. Which makes them a de-facto rentier class, living off assets and transfers paid for by younger generations. And, of course, at the risk of stating a truism, the future is built by the young. Yet France keeps effectively taking money away from them to give it to those whose working lives are already behind them - and need the money far less since they already own the country's wealth. What about inheritance, I hear you ask? That's the funniest/saddest aspect: given that life expectancy has kept rising, the French now inherit a home at 54 on average. The most common case is someone in their 80s leaving it to heirs in their 50s, in effect the very old transferring wealth to the about-to-be old (insee.fr/fr/statistiques/fic…). You can add this to our earlier apartheid statement: on top of all the rest, even when the old finally let go of their wealth, it stays within their own "camp". That's my personal situation, incidentally: I'm 42, my father is 71 and he is starting to look at ways to pass things on to me and my siblings, when our professional lives are already well settled, so it'll arrive when it changes things the least, which is pretty much the French system in a nutshell. Now, I get that there'd be some unfairness in going after them: they paid into the system their entire working lives, playing by the rules of a social contract that told them if they paid up they'd collect at the end. Changing the rules now means breaking that promise, which is admittedly unfair. But there's no magic wealth tree in any society: you can only take it where it is. That's the way most major societal transformations end up happening. They're often triggered by a catastrophic event (the so-called "four horsemen": mass-mobilisation war, revolution, state collapse, plague) BUT what really drives change is a transfer: wealth gets pried from the privileged class who've been sitting on it and handed to those who'll build what comes next. So, in theory and in an ideal world, you can do without the catastrophic event and directly proceed with the transfer... The fact that in France, and elsewhere in Europe, it's the youth protesting is probably no coincidence - even though they don't frame it as a generational fight. And even though, cruel irony, the left politicians many of them march behind promise to bring the retirement age back to 60 (lcp.fr/actualites/legislativ…), which would make the situation even worse. Let's say they understand intuitively that the system is stacked against them, even if they haven't yet figured out how. And politicians are obviously doing what politicians do, meaning pandering to the people who actually vote, while pointing the young towards easier - and politically convenient - scapegoats. To be clear I'm not saying it's the only problem in France, VERY far from it. I'm also not saying that all old people in France live a lavish lifestyle at the expense of younger generations: there are also plenty of very poor retirees who, if anything, would deserve more. What I am saying is that it's probably the biggest elephant in the room: everyone can see it, nobody dares mention it - no politician, from any side, wants to run on cutting grandma's pension - and it makes every other problem harder to fix.
1
51
Interesting post from FT writer @jburnmurdoch. Bottom line, the suggestion is had we held our nerve re housing rent controls, we would now have much greater supply, naturally lower rents, and market equilibrium would be closer.
What’s the evidence on rent control? I charted the findings from 112 studies: Great for rent-controlled tenants ✅ But: Pushes up rents for other people ❌ Pushes down new housing construction ❌ Pushes down building quality ❌
1
48
Compelling piece today by @CormacLucey, this is the stuff our professional and academic economists should be all over.
1
2
6
484
James Coghlan retweeted
ISME urges Budget 2027 to change focus from foreign multinationals towards Irish businesses independent.ie/business/iris…
2
2
68
James Coghlan retweeted
Isme tells government to divert FDI funding to Irish entrepreneurs instead businesspost.ie/companies/is…
2
2
94
Great substack piece by @SineadOS1 on a sort of socio-economic comparative of Ireland vs Pakistan, potentially helpful to a debate around an “independent” strategic review of Irish industrial policy (none in over 20 Years, since O’Driscoll 2004, Telesis 1992, Culliton 1982) & political governance (eg Minister & Secretaties Act 1924). Good Economy, Bad Economy? open.substack.com/pub/butthi…
202
Thought provoking & intelligent piece by @SineadOS1 who has pulled together some datapoints. Ireland has not done an “independent” strategic review of its Industrial Policy for over 20 years (Culliton 1982, Telesis 1992, O’Driscoll 2004), and it shows? Perhaps Ireland also needs a strategic review of its civil service & political governance systems, including a review of the Minister and Secretaries Act 1924.
The protests in Ireland are not about just fuel! They are about the distance between Ireland on this graph and every other modern and developed economy. Ireland is second wealthiest but gets waaaaay less than any other country for that wealth. By a golden mile. That visual gap in this graph? That’s what people are protesting. It’s a lack of infrastructure and the everyday enshittification of services, the economy, and the additional difficulty of trying to live, relative to peers in any other country. It also highlights why people don’t get uniformly listened to! - because there is no government architecture to engage meaningfully across this huge gap. That gap is a three hour drive to work in traffic, a 14 month wait for an MRI, buses that don’t arrive, trains that don’t exist, schools that have no places for your kids, houses that are unaffordable, pubs that close before midnight, €12 sandwiches, expensive fuel. People feel this gap, even if they can’t explain it precisely. And that builds into resentment, and ultimately protest. Fuel just happened to be the next thing that could be pointed to, today.
9
41
2
151
11,603
James Coghlan retweeted
@isme_ie's CEO Neil McDonnell joined @cooper_m on The Last Word to discuss ISME’s Indigenous Enterprise Policy launched last week. This paper urges the Government to improve the business environment for Ireland’s “Everyday Entrepreneurs” Click zurl.co/vc5zpto listen.
2
1
105
James Coghlan retweeted
@isme_ie CEO Neil McDonnell joined @ConallOM's Great Business Show podcast to discuss how Ireland’s reliance on a tiny number of multinational companies to deliver most corporation is not an economic policy, but a massive gamble. Click zurl.co/vzotX to listen to podcast
3
2
158
James Coghlan retweeted
Supporting the Everyday Entrepreneur is critical for Ireland’s Future. @isme_ie has called for a fundamental shift in Ireland’s economic strategy to better support indigenous businesses and reduce the State’s reliance on FDI corporations. Read Policy Paper zurl.co/Gnaa5
2
1
2
463
Insightful piece by Simon Kuper, well worth a read. “Europe’s elite tribe under unprecedented pressure from Russia, China, climate change, AI and Trump. The elite hope to ward off multiple catastrophes by waiting until adversaries act, then responding feebly. “
1
64
Interesting analysis of Mark Carney’s speech & it’s potential implications.
Who could have expected Mark Carney, a liberal establishment figure if there ever was one, to be the flag-bearer for the end of the US-led order? And from a podium at Davos, of all places? The more you think about it, though, the more it makes sense. Carney is, at heart, a central banker. As such he understands the power of words and beliefs better than anyone: when you strip things down to their core, a world order - like trust in a currency or a financial system - fundamentally relies on the maintenance of belief. Systems of power exist because participants act as if they exist. That's pretty much it: perception is reality. Once participants acknowledge the fiction as Carney just did (he literally started his speech announcing he'd "end the pleasant fiction" of the US-led order), the system itself unravels. This is incidentally a formal concept in game theory: the shift from private knowledge to common knowledge is what triggers cascades. Carney, with his background, ought to have known this was his most potent weapon facing Trump's America: "Trump has the economic and military might. But I have something his power rests upon: I can shatter the collective belief that sustains it." He's even explicit about this being his thinking: his entire speech revolves around Vaclav Havel’s famous shopkeeper analogy and the fact that the power of the Soviet Union rested on "everyone’s willingness to perform as if it were true," on "living within a lie." As Carney puts it, "when even one person stops performing, the illusion begins to crack" and the entire "system’s power" starts to crumble. Today, that "one person" was him. Make no mistake, Carney’s speech at Davos may prove to be one of THE most important speeches made by any global leader over the past 30 years. This is genuinely epochal stuff. More than anything, what it means is that, to the extent it even existed at all, the West irremediably lost the Second Cold War: a Cold War requires two competing systems. Carney just announced that one of them simply no longer exists. This is the topic of my latest article: an in-depth analysis of Carney's speech and its immensely consequential implications for what comes next. Enjoy the read here: open.substack.com/pub/arnaud…
114
James Coghlan retweeted
It's New Year, so time to look back and forward. These are 10 things I think we need to recognise in 2026. It’s a response to what I think are profoundly damaging mistaken assumptions I’ve heard and read from practitioners, journalists, and analysts in 2025. Warning: very long🧵
40
474
123
1,156
275,912
Collison Bros messaging needs mainstreaming so all will be influenced by vip influencers @collision & @patrickc. The people ask, where has all the money gone…much on gold plated competing quangos leading to inertia. Root & branch reform needed now before we repeat past mistakes!
Excellent piece by @collision on some of Ireland’s most acute challenges: irishtimes.com/life-style/pe….
1
5
250
Excellent piece, well researched, albeit not unknown. However, the Irish Times (& Independent) both have 50-60k circulations & sit behind a pay wall. How to circulate this piece to a much wider audience, particularly young people, can @collison & @ProgressIreland do that?
I wrote a piece for the @IrishTimes on why Ireland can’t build anything these days, and how to fix that.
3
1
12
1,623
Re John Ihle ⁦@ST__Ireland⁩ business. Revenue’s “Corp Tax ‘24 Payments & ‘23 Returns”, see Table 2, Page 37. Of total 214k Co Tax Returns, 57% returned avg tax liability €-13,523, 32% returned avg €4,944, so 89% of all Co’s returned tax liability<€5k. ⁦@isme_ie⁩
1
1
3
273
What is noteworthy is that 89% of the total Co population of 214k in Table 2, P37, being 191k Micro/Small Co’s who are responsible for total employment 47%, total earnings 42%, income tax take 42%, USC take 40%, PRSI take 41%, and VAT take 36%. All this data on said Table 2, P37.
2
62