Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
There’s a lot of critique of Sold a Story’s second season going around right now, and I’m here for it. Season 1 moved policy fast, and Hanford’s framing deserves scrutiny. But much of what I’m reading leans on mockery, guessing at motives, and guilt by association. DI’s advocates get tied to think tanks and private schools, the evidence gets waved off as a sales pitch, and critics end up flattening the other side in exactly the way they accuse Hanford of doing. That’s frustrating, because some of the questions underneath, like whether early-grade results transfer to older students and other subjects, deserve a real hearing.
Daniel Willingham’s recent post shows what a serious critique looks like. He starts by explaining why DI works. It’s knowledge-rich, carefully sequenced, built on constant student response and teacher feedback, and precise about where students’ attention goes. He grants that the evidence is good, though uneven, sometimes overstated, and strongest for foundational skills.
Then he makes his real point. Season 1 was a fight over methods toward a shared goal: everyone agreed kids need to learn to decode. Season 2 is partly a fight over goals, meaning what school should be and how children should experience it. The features that make DI effective, like tight control of talk, attention, and sequence, are exactly the ones many people object to. Willingham also separates evidence from values. “Autonomy produces independent thinkers” is a claim we can test, and the evidence for it isn’t strong. “Children deserve autonomy as part of childhood” is a value, and a legitimate one.
Finally, he holds both sides accountable. If you reject DI because of what children will experience, own it: say what you’d do instead and how much achievement you’re willing to trade. And if you’re a DI advocate, evidence alone doesn’t settle a debate about values.
That’s the conversation I want, one that takes the evidence seriously, names our values out loud, and admits the tradeoffs. dtwuva.substack.com/p/the-de…
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
“One of the most interesting things about expertise is that it changes how difficult the same material feels for an expert and a novice:
The more we know, the less mental effort we need to expend on things that once required all our attention.”
We know that spacing out your practice works, but we don't really know why it works. One of the most interesting things about expertise is that it changes how difficult the same material feels for an expert and a novice: the more we know, the less mental effort we need to expend on things that once required all our attention.
So, how hard something is, is not so much a property of the task itself but more about the presence or absence of knowledge around the task. tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.…
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
I felt Daniel OK-Carr’s latest column on Savvas MyView in my bones.
Honored to share it at the @CurriculumIP.
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Imagine being a district leader paying to retrain new teachers in reading while the programs that prepared them are still teaching debunked methods.
teapawt.net/Dale_Chu/status/211763…
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Parents are replacing conversations with their children with scrolling, and it’s affecting kids’ literacy prospects.
Reminder: A child's vocabulary when entering kindergarten is one of the strongest early predictors of later reading comprehension.
Children who begin school with larger, richer oral vocabularies are primed for success as readers.
Question: Are children’s and parental screen use associated with children’s receptive vocabulary and grammar development from ages 5 to 7 years?
Findings: In this cohort study of 747 Norwegian children, primary parent smartphone screen time was significantly associated with slower receptive vocabulary growth, and children’s digital device ownership was significantly associated with lower baseline receptive vocabulary and grammar scores.
Meaning: Study results suggest that parental smartphone use and children’s device ownership may be meaningful indicators of risk for poorer language outcomes, highlighting the importance of considering screen use at the family level when evaluating children’s language development.
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Evidence keeps pointing to the idea that taking away the kind of old-school teachers who required kids to speak in full sentences with conventional grammar (because it seemed racist or culturally-hegemonic to correct dialects or other ways of speaking), was probably extremely harmful to the kids who most needed strong oral language skills in order to become readers.
Bring back teachers who correct children’s spoken grammar.
Also, bring back teachers who speak as if they’ve had elocution lessons—IOW who both speak and teach children to speak in the same form of the English language they will encounter on the page.
It’s so strange how the efforts to dismantle oppressive structures have actually had the most devastating effects on the most vulnerable and under-resourced among us.
(From a Chat GPT translation of the article:)
Wat bepaalt hoe goed je begrijpend leest? Onderzoekers analyseerden bijna 50.000 correlaties tussen cognitieve vaardigheden en lezen. De resultaten sluiten opvallend goed aan bij de Simple View of Reading. Maar met belangrijke nuances.
wp.me/prJwm-elA
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
The last straw for me as a teacher was a PD titled, "No More Trivial Pursuit!" We were told kids shouldn't study the War of 1812 (which they didn't anyway). Instead they should "grapple with essential questions like, 'Is war ever justified?'" A formula for creating idiots.
I wanted autonomy mainly b/c I didn't want to be forced to use PBL, inquiry, rich tasks or any number of ineffective fads. I'm fairly certain I'm not alone in this
.
the74million.org/article/res…
@rastokke @mikesully97 @BrankinMomma13 @AltB56073878 @tetheredtoed1 @oliviajune82
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Your daily reminder that kids often learn vocabulary through repeated exposure.
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
My daughter came home from school today and immediately asked if it is rude to correct a new teacher if the information she is teaching the class is wrong.
I told her it’s important that the students have the CORRECT information and that all teachers should have enough content knowledge to teach their subject and the curriculum expectations.
This new teacher was unsure of the differences between symbiotic and asymbiotic relationships (a little knowledge of morphology would have helped prevent that confusion!)
Since the class has a test next week, my daughter felt it was important for the class have the correct information. So she clarified the definitions for the teacher who had the definitions reversed.
My point is, our education system has NOT prioritized content knowledge for so many years- instead focusing on skills alone- that we now have teachers going into the teaching profession without the knowledge they need to teach the content!! This is exactly when teachers start to rely on an “inquiry-based approach” because it’s easier to ask students to figure it out themselves than to teach what they don’t know.
Direct instruction is key to learning- but for direct instruction to be effective, we also need knowledgeable teachers!! @KnowledgeMatrs @natwexler @nsachdeva2019 @New_Old_Paul
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
This was my favorite segment of @MrZachG's conversation with Anita Archer.
Note her emphasis on the role of deliberate, independent practice in solidifying skills.
"One of the things that again both the science of instruction and the science of learning say is give feedback. Our motto is feedback feeds forward.
Feedback whether it is affirmative telling you and particularly specific praise. It is also going to be corrective in many cases feedback.
And finally we have lots of practice and this is one of the challenges of many times in instruction when I visit schools and look at their gains is that they did the initial instruction but they didn't pair it with enough independent practice that was deliberate practice that was spaced over time that was coupled with feedback.
So, it's like sort of this whole package of behaviors that are necessary for good explicit instruction. Yes, we think of someone teaching it directly, but then all of the other attributes go with it."
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Meta-analysis of retrieval practice, spacing, and interleaving in classrooms concludes fairly robust average effects of each (open access) link.springer.com/article/10…
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
The very worst arguments in education are those which say "you have a different opinion than I do about how children learn, therefore you must be a bad person. Children are precious and I need to save them from your harmful agenda."
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Lower academic standards, inflated grades and graduation rates, online credit recovery, lower cut scores, no accountability for poor behavior.
Sorry, who's quitting on who?
Starr: Perhaps chronic absenteeism is a canary in the coal mine portending a much deeper issue, especially at the middle and high school levels buff.ly/372z2U1
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Daniel OK-Carr has some powerful points about Savaas MyView, one of the popular basal curricula.
On its Science of Reading-era revamp:
"I bought the 2020 student textbook for my grade level to see the differences myself. What changed?
I kid you not, the order of the worksheets. The stories, the questions, the formulaic close read prompts, and the worksheets themselves — they all are exactly the same.
Either Savvas is supremely confident that their product has achieved the pinnacle of textbook glory, or they are simply supremely lazy."
I wish these stories weren't so common.
30 years ago, John Stossel asked why San Diego schools weren’t using Direct Instruction to address students’ struggles in reading and math.
The superintendent’s response? Classrooms should be “more than just worksheets and multiplication facts.”
When Stossel pointed out that kids weren’t mastering basic skills, she cited rising graduation rates.
His retort: “You’re graduating them, but they can’t read.”
Fast forward to today, the reflex remains the same: When students aren't academically proficient, deflect to gameable metrics.
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
“There's no way to backfill years of reading experience.“
Former SAT & ACT tutor here!
Vocabulary is one part of the test you can't study for.
I could re-teach algebraic formulas in a session or two, it just takes practice. Same with the Pythagorean theorem or how to FOIL two binomials. Once it clicks, it clicks, and I knew those questions would *always* be on the test. Bam, you're scoring higher in math already.
But vocab is much harder. There's no way to teach somebody all the words. So you do as best you can with context clues. But some questions don't have those. There's no way to backfill years of reading experience. I told more than one parent to have their kid read a NatGeo article at breakfast every day, just to expand the number of words they've encountered.
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Do Decodables Promote Love of Reading? What Books Launch Lifetime Readers?
shanahanonliteracy.com/blog/…
Literacy Lass 💗📚 retweeted
Here are my colleague Sadie McCleary's excellent notes on making PLC's better.... no surprise she's got some videos to share!
teachlikeachampion.org/blog/…


































