Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2) header
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2) profile picture

Listening with the intent to understand, not simply with the intent to reply. But this X algorithm is pushing me to spend more time on: @lawrenceg2@bsky.social

Joined January 2012
Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)Photo by Lawrence G 🇺🇦 (@LawrenceG2)
Take a bow @jonfavs @jonlovett @danpfeiffer @TVietor08 (...and a well earned rest!) THE POD DEFINITELY SAVED AMERICA. And credit too all the team at @CrookedMedia - an exemplary organisation that refused to capitulate to the bullying. From all the critical thinkers in the UK🇬🇧 🫡
15
teapawt.net/ReformDarius/status/21… @ReformDarius did you mean you wanted this June Mummery as Minister for Fisheries and Coastal Affairs? youtu.be/CntEMQ_ndjw?si=VuBp…
Can't wait to see you as MP for Lowestoft and Minister for Fisheries and Coastal Affairs 🙏🙏🙏🫶
117
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
Brexiter on BBC #PoliticsLive "I want us to have our own laws, govern ourselves, not be dictated to by an unelected European Parliament" My view: That claim sounds less like an informed account of how the EU worked and more like populist rhetoric repeated without checking the facts. The European Parliament was directly elected by voters—including UK voters while Britain was a member. Most EU laws were proposed by the Commission, then debated, amended and agreed by the elected Parliament and the Council of national government ministers. The Commission could not simply dictate laws on its own. British ministers sat in the Council and took part in those decisions; British MEPs represented voters in Parliament. The UK could be outvoted in some areas, but that is shared decision-making—not rule by an unelected parliament. And the Commission itself was accountable to elected institutions: Parliament had to approve the College of Commissioners. You can argue that pooling sovereignty was a bad deal, or point to a specific EU law you opposed. But “we were dictated to by an unelected European Parliament” is not a factual description of the process. It replaces the real debate with a slogan. And this explains the need for education and information so individuals such as this gentleman can make informed decisions based on accurate information, and not populist, divisive rhetoric.
38
120
14
292
9,056
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
This seems like a great time to reshare my favourite Sir Patrick Stewart performance, ‘What has the ECHR ever done for us?’ It’s just perfect in every possible way … including the ending 😂😂😂 RIP. 🎥 The Guardian
181
4,028
238
12,330
434,607
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
Victoria Derbyshire, "What did we learn about our living standards?" Ben Chu, "1% growth over 10 years" "We used to grow 2% every year" That's one way of illustrating the enormous economic price Britain has paid for Brexit #RejoinEU The OBR estimates that Brexit will leave the UK economy around 4% smaller in the long run than it would otherwise have been, with both imports and exports taking a substantial hit. We were promised greater prosperity, more opportunities and a stronger economy outside the EU. Instead, we've added significant trade barriers with our largest trading partner during a period of extraordinary economic stagnation. Brexit isn't responsible for every economic problem Britain faces, but it has made the challenge of improving living standards considerably harder. And ordinary households are living with the consequences of that decision.
11
199
11
427
34,621
Sergey Nalobin, a Russian ‘diplomat’ who launched the ‘Conservative Friends of Russia’ group has now been identified as a Russian intelligence officer involved in an attempted European disinformation campaign. Nalobin called Boris Johnson a good friend and was quick to congratulate Vote Leave Chief Matthew Elliott on his engagement. Elliott was a founder member of the Conservative Friends of Russia, and in 2012 went on a 10-day trip to Moscow with all expenses paid by the Russian government. The British authorities repeatedly refused to investigate Russian interference in the Brexit campaign and the UK’s broader politics. However, Nalobin was looking for a way to channel money into the Conservative Party in the early 2010s, and the Tories received many donations from Russian oligarchs resident in the UK. The article provides details of how Nalobin orchestrated Russian interference in Estonian politics, so it is very likely that he was playing the same role in the UK. Putin wanted Brexit. The Tories delivered it, and unfortunately every British government since then has covered up the extent and nature of Russian interference in British politics. Please repost if you demand that the government ends the conspiracy of silence and launches a full-scale investigation of Russian interference in British politics starting with the Conservative Friends of Russia and Farage's appearances on Russia Today. bylinetimes.com/2026/10/26/t…
28
791
35
1,055
14,411
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
Note to the EU haters. You can hate it. Many do. But it is still the UK's neighbours being in a club that the UK has to deal with from a point of weakness. Geography denial has failed, obviously. So far the only serious idea I've seen is "muddle through". Is that it?
UK offering Freedom of Movement would be the game changer for conversations with the EU, one of the trio of people, pounds and positivity I identified earlier this year as crucial to any significant move to removing barriers. thetimes.com/uk/politics/art…
50
84
6
355
21,566
How could anybody think we would be "better off"?? Brexit doesn't need help from anybody to make it catastrophic...it was always going to be so. What else was anybody expecting from making it harder to access & sell into the EU27 (& EFTA4) without (not in UK's gift to) making it any *equally* compensating easier to access & sell into any other country? Economic contraction and (harder to cross) longer border queues/delays are always - funnily enough - a feature of harder borders... thus always guaranteed. Rejoining the EU would obviously equally guarantee the opposite.
Replying to @MrTCHarris
I supported Remain. I don’t know for sure how much better or worse we’d be off if Brexit hadn’t happened. But I’m pretty sure reopening the debate and spending another decade focusing the entire energy of the political establishment on European membership would be catastrophic.
6
17
2
47
1,086
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
IHere's what Pres.Trump has done for Vladimir Putin since 2017: 🇺🇸➡️🇷🇺 First term 1Stood next to Putin in Helsinki and took his word over U.S. intelligence 2Lobbied to bring Russia back into the G7 3Withheld military aid from Ukraine to squeeze Zelensky (impeachment #1) 4Pulled out of Syria, handing Russia a freer hand 5Openly questioned NATO's mutual-defense pledge 6Lifted sanctions on Deripaska-linked companies, including Rusal 7Walked away from the INF nuclear treaty 8Walked away from the Open Skies treaty, leaving our European allies with less visibility 🇺🇸➡️🇷🇺 Second term
9. Called Russia's G7 expulsion a "mistake"
10. Declared Moscow "holds all the cards"
11. Opened talks with Russia with zero preconditions
12. Berated Zelensky in the Oval Office, then paused aid and intel to Ukraine
13. Halted offensive cyber operations against Russia
14. Had the U.S. vote WITH Russia against a UN resolution condemning the invasion
15. Said "Crimea will stay with Russia"
16. Rolled out the red carpet for Putin in Alaska
17. Pressed Ukraine, not Russia, to give up territory 18. Starshield 19. Diesel 20. Revoke Graham sanctions That's not "America First." You could never make that list of things a President has done for Zelensky, or for NATO. Ask yourself why.
179
1,559
99
3,815
74,783
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
“There is not a single sign of any overall economic damage done by Brexit” says @Nigel_Farage Meanwhile back on planet earth by almost every economic & financial measure Brexit has been disastrous for the UK Is anyone seriously buying his bull****? Get the FACTS here👇
242
954
44
3,039
422,085
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
Just to be clear about what happened here: - Trump cut a deal with Putin that will route ~$4B of American dollars to Russia. That money will be used to fund the war. - Trump announced an "energy ceasefire" that was probably Putin's idea, surprised the Ukrainians, is structured to benefit Russia, and was immediately broken by the Russian military. - When Zelensky spoke candidly about these terrible deals, the US cut off Starlink access in ways that made it harder for Ukraine to intercept Russian drones, and seemingly withheld intel about ballistic missile attacks. - Last week alone, Russia killed more than 150 civilians in Ukraine, including 33 in one strike on a bus stop. Trump is de facto asking @ZelenskyyUa to surrender. Zelensky can throw on a suit, he can endure lectures from whiny little bitches like @JDVance, but he can't lay down and die just because Trump wants the Nobel Peace Prize.
I fear that President Zelensky has gotten terrible advice on handling his relations with President Trump, and at the absolute worst possible time before what looks like a very difficult winter.
112
1,514
48
7,614
333,769
Recently, #Brexit supporters have been rubbishing the claim that Russian disinformation shapes British opinion. Well... here's an almost perfect example distilled in just 7 mins on @LBC radio this morning. You can just 'hear' the influence creeping in: globalplayer.com/catchup/lbc…
1
44
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
Here it is. This is the clip from yesterday's @CNN interview where I'm asked - for first time ever - about Brexit-Trump-Russia. "These vital questions of national security have been interpreted as about politics. And it's not about politics. It's about power. And about Putin."
324
4,764
602
12,005
Replying to @WasAcop
Brexit was delivered "properly" by the hardest of (ERG) Brexiters in BJ's government purged of Remainers after is 2019 GE. It was approved by the ERG star chamber & celebrated by them with BJ, Xmas 2020. May was responsible only for the WA (monies owed, citizens rights & the NI border & BJ changed the border to being between GB & NI to 'Get Brexit Done"). You got the resurrected hardest of borders against the EU27. Harder borders mean (funnily enough) they are harder to trade & move across. What else are you expecting to be "delivered" from it being now harder to trade & move across borders?? Brexit *levelled down* trade.
3
8
2
45
5,600
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
On the day after @peterjukes & I broke the story of Arron Banks’s covert meetings with the Russian ambassador, I was invited onto @BBCr4today to discuss it. Big news! Finally the chance to break through to a BBC audience. Only the interview was cancelled because they needed ‘someone from the other side’ & the Russian ambassador wasn’t available. Facts don’t have a side. It meant the BBC never covered the story. And here we are..
48
1,223
43
3,362
52,158
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
In June 2018, the Mail on Sunday’s front page read: “BREXIT: NEW SECRET PUTIN CONNECTION... now MI5 urged to act.” MailOnline reported the government was “likely to face calls to investigate.” The investigation never came. In 2020 the Intelligence and Security Committee found the government “had not seen or sought evidence of successful interference” in the referendum. It recommended an assessment. The government refused. Yesterday, the Daily Mail called No 10’s line on Russian interference a desperate backtrack, and quoted Farage’s “Russia hoax” without challenge. Different titles, different editors, I know. But the question the Mail on Sunday was asking in 2018 has still never been properly answered.
🚨 #FACTCHECK: Nigel Farage on Burnham, Russia and Brexit ‘Mirror, mirror, on the wall, whose claims stand up after all?’ I’m a retired academic, media literate, and equipped with critical thinking skills, so I have time to do this quickly and accurately. Earlier today, Nigel Farage called Prime Minister Andy Burnham “a liar” over his claim that Russia interfered in the 2016 EU referendum. Here is how Farage’s statements hold up against the record. In an interview with The Rest Is Politics podcast, released on 12 October but widely reported the day before, Burnham said that on taking office in July he asked whether Russia had interfered in the 2016 referendum, and was given “the clear answer that yes there was.” He did not say how Russia interfered and did not publish any evidence. This morning, Farage held a press conference in Dover, Kent, to launch Reform UK’s asylum plans. LBC’s Emma Corr asked whether Burnham’s claim tainted the result, and how Farage felt about having potentially benefited from possible Russian interference. He later repeated several of his claims in an interview with GB News. The exchange between Corr and Farage is available on YouTube from 1:00:07: youtube.com/watch?v=5n6L0ECw… 1. “The prime minister is a liar. Yes, a liar.” Verdict: Unsupported. Lying means knowingly saying something false. Burnham reported advice he says he received on entering No 10. That advice has not been made public, so his claim is unverified, and critics are entitled to say so. Nothing Farage cited shows that Burnham knew it to be untrue. At most, Farage offered evidence that the claim is unproven. 2. “Boris Johnson, when he became foreign secretary, one of the first questions he asked was, ‘Was there seen to be Russian interference in the referendum campaign?’ And the answer was no.” Verdict: Misleading. I could find no public record of this exchange. Johnson’s recorded public position was more qualified. In Moscow in December 2017, Russian foreign minister Sergei Lavrov said Johnson had confirmed Russia had not interfered in the referendum. Johnson interrupted him: “Not successfully.” He went on to say that Russian attempts to interfere in British elections and the referendum, whatever they may have been, had not succeeded. His position was that attempts may have been made and had failed, which is a different claim from “no”. The premise that anyone checked is also doubtful. Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee (ISC) published its Russia Report in July 2020. It found that the government “had not seen or sought evidence of successful interference” in UK democratic processes. It called for an intelligence assessment of the referendum, and the government refused. In 2019, BuzzFeed reported two anonymous sources saying British intelligence had found no evidence of Russian meddling in the referendum. That claim was unverified, and the ISC’s report the following year said the government had not sought such evidence. 3. Stephen Doughty “rowed it back and said even if there was some, it made no difference.” Verdict: Misrepresents the minister. Doughty, a Foreign Office minister, did narrow Burnham’s claim during Monday morning’s broadcast interviews. He told LBC that Russia had attempted to interfere in the vote but had not succeeded, and made the same point to Sky News. He also said Burnham had been making a broader point about Russian attempts to interfere in democratic events in the UK and across Europe. On the @BBC Today programme, which Farage named, Doughty spoke of Russian attempts to interfere in a range of democratic processes. He cited the jailing of former Reform UK Wales leader Nathan Gill for taking bribes to promote pro-Kremlin narratives. Farage’s summary distorts this. “Even if there was some” turns Doughty’s acknowledgement of attempts into a hypothetical. Farage followed it with the words “There was no Russian interference,” and in his later GB News interview (see 10) he attributed that denial to Doughty himself. I found no report of Doughty’s interviews containing those words, or anything to that effect. Doughty said Russia tried to interfere. 4. “There was no Russian interference… And the Russia hoax has run all the way through this.” Verdict: Not supported by the evidence. No official finding says there was no interference. The government’s position since 2020 has been narrower: “We have seen no evidence of successful interference in the EU Referendum.” The ISC noted open-source studies pointing to anti-EU content on the Russian state outlets RT and Sputnik, and to the use of bots and trolls, as evidence of attempts to influence the campaign. It criticised the government for not investigating. The defensible position is that attempts at influence were plausibly documented, their effect was never assessed, and no public evidence shows they changed the result. “No interference” and “hoax” both go well beyond that. The same standard applies to Burnham, whose “clear answer” rests on advice the public has not seen. 5. Arron Banks “was severely libelled over this. But in the end … [he] won in the high court.” Verdict: False. Banks sued the journalist Carole Cadwalladr over a 2019 TED Talk and a tweet. He lost in the High Court in June 2022, where the judge held that Cadwalladr’s public interest defence covered the talk. In February 2023, the Court of Appeal found partly in his favour, on one of his three grounds of appeal. It ruled that the defence lapsed for the talk’s continued publication after 29 April 2020, the date of an Electoral Commission statement clearing Banks. It upheld the dismissal of his claim over the tweet. Cadwalladr was ordered to pay £35,000 in damages and 60% of Banks’s High Court costs. The case also had no bearing on whether Russia interfered in the referendum. It concerned Cadwalladr’s statement about Banks and “his covert relationship with the Russian Government.” 6. “I don’t think our growth figures are anything to write home about. But … they’re a damn sight better than France and Germany and Italy.” Verdict: Accurate for this year, but selective over the longer term, and beside the point. On current figures Farage has a case. In the second quarter of 2026, UK GDP grew by 0.5%, against 0.3% in Germany and zero in France. The IMF’s July forecasts put the UK third in the G7 for 2026, at 1%, behind the US (2.3%) and Canada (1.1%). That is ahead of Germany (0.7%), France and Japan (both 0.6%) and Italy (0.5%). The OECD’s September forecasts placed the UK joint second in the G7, level with Germany at 1.1%. The longer view is less flattering. Between the end of 2019 and the second quarter of 2026, UK GDP grew by 6.2%, behind the eurozone as a whole (7.6%) and far behind the US (15.6%), though well ahead of Germany (1.9%, the lowest in the G7). By naming France, Germany and Italy, Farage compared the UK with three of Europe’s weaker performers, while the eurozone overall has grown faster since the pandemic. Headline growth has also been flattered by rapid population growth. In late 2024, the Resolution Foundation found UK GDP per head still below its end-2019 level, although per-head growth picked up to 0.6% in the first quarter of 2026. More importantly, none of these comparisons answers Burnham’s claim. Whether Brexit has done “more harm than good” depends on how the UK compares with a UK that stayed in the EU. The Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) assumes Brexit will leave UK trade around 15% lower in the long run, and potential productivity around 4% lower, than if the UK had remained. In 2024 it said these assumptions appeared “broadly on track.” Some economists, including Julian Jessop, a former chief economist and head of the Brexit unit at the free-market Institute of Economic Affairs, dispute these estimates. Even so, the official forecaster’s central view is that Brexit carries a long-run cost, and growth rankings, whether flattering or not, do not settle the question. 7. “If you even look at trade numbers, the increase in trade since Brexit…” Verdict: Partly accurate, but selective. Total UK exports have grown since the referendum. Briefings for Britain, a pro-Brexit research group using ONS data, puts total exports in 2025 at 5% above 2019 in real terms. That growth has come from services. The House of Commons Library reports that UK services exports to the EU were 28% above their 2019 level in real terms in 2025. However, goods exports to the EU were 14% below it, having fallen in real terms in each of 2023, 2024 and 2025. Not all of that fall is due to Brexit, but post-Brexit barriers fall mainly on goods, and goods trade with the EU is where the decline shows. The overall total obscures it. 8. Brexit has brought “some level of inconvenience… showing a passport, filling in a form,” amounting to “mild inconveniences.” Verdict: Understatement. Farage conceded there was more inconvenience “for people like Alcaline,” a Kent road haulage firm based near Hythe, but described it as “showing a passport, filling in a form.” The evidence suggests that undersells the effect, particularly for firms moving goods across the Channel. In March 2024 the OBR reported that UK goods trade was around 10% below 2019 levels and growing well behind other advanced economies, while services trade had grown more strongly than in the rest of the G7. The OBR attributed the gap partly to post-Brexit barriers falling mainly on goods. Brexit is not the only cause of the 14% real-terms fall in goods exports to the EU, but official forecasters attribute part of it to post-Brexit trade barriers, which go well beyond passports and forms. Farage’s answer also merges two separate issues: control of migration, and the trade frictions that come from leaving the single market and customs union. 9. Burnham is “looking forward to sitting down with Marine Le Pen or the AfD” Verdict: Speculation, contrary to the record. Farage offered no basis for this. In the interview that prompted the row, Burnham cited the German chancellor’s view that the AfD were linked to, and possibly funded by, Russia. He presented the party as a threat to European democracy. 10. The GB News version Verdict: False. In an interview with GB News later that day, Farage said Doughty, “being interviewed on the BBC this morning, disavowed it and said no, there was no Russian interference, it didn’t affect anything.” The “even if there was some” qualification had gone, leaving a flat denial attributed to the minister. Doughty’s reported position was that Russia attempted to interfere but did not succeed, which confirms attempted interference. Farage also presented Johnson and Doughty together as evidence that “both Labour and Conservative camps” reject Burnham’s claim. Neither man said there was no interference. Johnson’s recorded words in 2017 were “Not successfully.” Doughty said Russia had tried and failed. What both rejected was the narrower claim that interference succeeded, which is also the extent of the official government position since 2020. Conclusion Farage’s sharpest claims are his weakest. Nothing presented shows that Burnham lied. Johnson’s record says “not successfully” rather than “no”. The minister Farage cited acknowledged Russian attempts. In Dover, Farage turned that acknowledgement into a hypothetical, and on GB News into a flat denial. Banks did not win in the High Court. Farage is on firmer ground on recent growth rankings and on total exports, though neither settles whether Brexit has helped or harmed the UK, and goods trade with the EU tells a different story. Burnham, for his part, has made a significant claim without publishing the evidence behind it. The assessment the ISC recommended six years ago would serve the public better than either man’s certainty. Finally, it is worth measuring Farage by his own yardstick. Farage called the British prime minister a liar. The evidence he offered went only to whether Burnham was wrong, not to whether he knew it. If being wrong, or being unable to prove a claim, is enough to make someone a liar, the same test can be applied to Farage. By that standard, his answer in Dover contained five “lies”: that Johnson was told there was no interference; that Doughty conceded only that any interference “made no difference”; that there was no Russian interference; that the affair was a “hoax”; and that Arron Banks “won in the high court.” On GB News he added a sixth, that “both Labour and Conservative camps” deny any interference, and repeated three of the others. That makes six distinct claims, and nine in all, across two appearances in a single day. The row began over one claim by Burnham. The fairer test, and the one this fact check applies, is that lying requires knowing a statement to be false. By that measure, nobody can say Farage lied, any more than he can say it of Burnham. But on the evidence, Burnham’s claim remains unproven, while at least one of Farage’s, about his friend’s libel case, is plainly false on the public record.
10
124
3
187
4,686
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
One of the men in this picture is a politician currently serving 10 and a half years in prison for accepting Russian bribes. The other was his boss and doesn't think there's evidence of Russia interfering in UK politics.
138
3,225
75
9,340
112,236
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
Replying to @docrussjackson @X
🚨 #UPDATE 2: No 10 clarifies, and how the Mail framed it. Since my #FACTCHECK, No 10 and the PM have clarified Burnham's claim. Here is what changed, and what didn't. The PM's official spokesman said: "Given everything we know about Russia, it is inconceivable they did not seek to use the referendum to their benefit. But... we do not believe they have succeeded." No 10 declined to confirm that Burnham had been shown specific evidence. In the Commons, Burnham said of the referendum: "It was legitimate, I have always respected the result, I have never questioned its legitimacy." He added: "We think it is inconceivable that this was the first time" Russian actors sought to interfere. Burnham's claim has weakened. On the podcast he said he'd had "the clear answer that yes, there was." Today it rests on an inference that Russian attempts were "inconceivable" not to have happened, and No 10 won't say what evidence he saw. My fact check called his claim unverified, and it is now more clearly so. If he has evidence, he hasn't shown it. The government's position is now on record: Russia tried, and did not succeed. Stephen Doughty told LBC the same thing this morning: "they've attempted but not succeeded." That is the opposite of Farage's "there was no Russian interference" and "the Russia hoax." The verdicts on Farage's claims stand. How the Mail framed it: The Mail's headlines read: "No10 admits Russia DIDN'T sway EU referendum despite Andy Burnham's claim of interference" and "No10 desperately backtracks on PM's claim." But "despite" implies a contradiction that isn't there. Burnham claimed interference, not that Russia swayed the result. "Russia tried" and "Russia didn't change the outcome" can both be true, and that is exactly No 10's position. There was a genuine retreat, but on evidence, not on success. The Mail reports that No 10 declined to confirm Burnham saw specific evidence, but well down the article. Meanwhile, the same article quotes Farage saying "there was no Russian interference and the Russia hoax runs all the way through this", and never notes that No 10's line, which it also reports, contradicts him. Scrutiny for the PM. A free pass for Farage. Source: Daily Mail, 12 October 2026, updated 17:27 dailymail.com/news/article-1…
5
14
1
30
1,884
Lawrence G 🇺🇦 retweeted
🚨 #UPDATE: Boris Johnson responds Earlier today I fact-checked Nigel Farage's claims about Andy Burnham, Russia and Brexit. This afternoon Boris Johnson weighed in on @X, and his post bears directly on one of Farage's claims. Johnson said Burnham's claim was "just not true." He said that as soon as he became foreign secretary, he asked the security services the same question, and "they replied that there was no evidence of any successful interference in the 2016 referendum, by Russia or any other power." He then offered two explanations: either the security services have changed their view, "which would be very odd," or "Burnham is lying about what he has been told." A correction to my #FACTCHECK In point 2, I said I could find no public record of the exchange Farage described between Johnson and the security services. Johnson has now confirmed that it took place. But it undermines Farage's version. Farage said Johnson asked whether there was "Russian interference in the referendum campaign," and "the answer was no." According to Johnson himself, the answer was that there was "no evidence of any successful interference." Farage dropped the word "successful," turning an answer about outcomes into a denial that interference was attempted at all. Johnson's account matches his own words in Moscow in 2017 ("Not successfully"). It also matches the ISC's 2020 finding that the government "had not seen or sought evidence of successful interference." The verdict on point 2 stays the same: misleading. Johnson's own claim is a false choice. Johnson's evidence is about successful interference. Burnham's claim is about interference. Both can be true at once: the security services could find no evidence that Russia changed the result while confirming that Russia tried. Nor would a changed assessment be "very odd." The ISC recommended an assessment of the referendum in 2020, and the government refused. A decade of intelligence work has passed since Johnson asked his question in 2016. Like Farage, Johnson accuses Burnham of lying without any evidence that Burnham knew his claim to be false. Burnham's claim remains unverified, and Johnson's either/or does not change that. By Farage's own standard, my fact check counted his claim that Johnson was told there was no interference as one of his "lies." Johnson's post now contradicts it in Johnson's own words. The fairer test still applies to everyone: lying means knowing a statement to be false. On the evidence, none of the three men can be shown to have lied. Two of them have now accused the prime minister of it on the strength of an answer about a narrower question.
This is just not true. As soon as I became foreign secretary I asked the security services the same question and they replied that there was no evidence of any successful interference in the 2016 referendum, by Russia or any other power. Either the security services have changed their view - which would be very odd - or Burnham is lying about what he has been told. After all Starmer was in power for two years and had access to exactly the same information. theguardian.com/technology/2…
6
34
3
78
5,888
A beautifully articulated explanation of what Reform is doing by clear-eyed & intelligent @rafaelbehr People of the UK... don't fall for the cheap street hustle.
Rafael Behr’s analysis of Reforms latest policy announcement is spot on. #politicslive
26