Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
You are using SEC logic on the conf champ game scenario. They are keeping SMU and Duke from being ranked which then denies improving our SoS., while keeping very avg 3-loss SEC teams in the rankings. It’s a self fulfilling prophesy. Too bad the ACC leadership doesn’t squeal publicly about this and make membership in the conference mean something.
I think an 11-1 regular season and a loss in the ACC CG, especially to a team they beat earlier in the season in Wake, gets Miami in.
If UM wins out in the regular season, they likely are in the top 5 entering conference championship weekend. The committee has typically dropped conference title-game losers one or two spots, so UM should be safe.
A 10-3 Miami that loses two-regular season games and the conference title game is probably out, in my opinion.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
The systemic institutional bias against ACC, and in favor of SEC, will never change. ACC needed 24 teams in field to even get 2nd team in. Miami kicking SEC butt in postseason last year changed nothing. Hard to overcome systemic bias
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Let me explain the bias I'm referring to: The committee -without seeing anything head to head - automatically assumes that the 3rd, 4th, 5th SEC teams are better than the No. 2 ACC team. (This was reflected yet again in these rankings.) Might Kentucky and all these SEC teams be better than Wake? Perhaps. But how would they or anybody know? When you always assume a 2-loss SEC team is better than a 1-loss ACC team without any evidence that would hold up in court, that's bias.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Tonight I was told UCLA is better than Miami cause they won at 5-4 Minnesota while Miami, without its best player, lost by a TD @ No. 5 ND. Bruins deserve credit for no loss. But a 6 spot drop?
Not shocked, but you can’t tell me you watch ball & agree. Even the metrics call BS.
Something that was lost in the controversy on Saturday was how good the pass was from Mensah.
4th down, on the road, game on the line, pocket collapsed, scrambled to his left, and threw a picture-perfect pass where only Lofton could reach it.
🤝 Paid partnership
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
This is the play I was talking about in the Miami-Notre Dame game. I have zero rooting interest for or against either team. It was a good game. I did read the rule. Maybe @TerryMcAuliffe can explain further. He said Lofton didn't complete the process of the catch, but the receiver stepped inbounds with both feet, and out of bounds...at what point is the play over?
And people who personally insult me for asking a question should work on having a little class. It's not that difficult.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
I just don't think Miami should be downgraded all that much after losing AT Notre Dame by a TD without Malachi Toney.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
This is a catch under NCAA Rule 2-4-3.
Firm control in the air. Both feet down inbounds in the end zone. Control maintained long enough to take additional steps (football move). Catch is complete — he is a runner.
Under Rule 4-1-3, the ball is DEAD the moment a ball carrier goes out of bounds. The punch that knocks the ball free happens AFTER the ball is already DEAD. It cannot make the pass incomplete.
This should have been a touchdown. The call was wrong.
#GoCanes #ItsAllAboutTheU #CFB #CollegeFootball #Miami #Canes #NotreDame #ACC #BadCall #NCAARules #Touchdown
@CanesFootball
@MiamiHurricanes
@BR_CFB
@ESPNCFB
@PeteThamel
@Brett_McMurphy
@JoshPateCFB
@BarstoolCFB
@CFBonFOX
@TheAthletic
@On3
@Rivals
@RedditCFB
@flasportsbuzz
@J_McPherson1126
@GeoMilian
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
NCAA clearly got the call wrong in the @CanesFootball vs @NDFootball game. I personally have no dog in the fight but as a fan of the game its getting old watching the refs and replay officials get it wrong.
The NCAA has a rulebook for situations. Both situation #34 and #37 apply here.
The offensive player catches the ball, gets his required 1 foot in bounds, gets a second foot in bounds, takes a third step out of bounds. At the time the third step is taken, both the offensive and defensive player are both out of bounds. The defender swats the ball loose causing the offensive player to lose possession. Since the offensive player remained upright, had possession, made a football act, and was already out of bounds. The correct ruling is a catch for a touchdown.
The NCAA describes this sequence:
1. Receiver controls the pass and gets one foot down inbounds.
2. His other foot then touches out of bounds.
3. After a delay, a defender contacts him.
4. The receiver loses possession.
Official NCAA ruling: Completed pass.
@NCAAFootball @barstoolsports @ESPNCFB
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Tonight I learned you could clearly possess a ball in the endzone, put two feet down, step out of bounds, then after the play is dead, someone can hit the ball out of your hands and it can be ruled incomplete. Wild stuff.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
FSU fan here, but I believe Miami got robbed of a touchdown.
Under NCAA Rule 2-4-3(a), a receiver must secure possession, establish himself inbounds, and maintain control long enough to perform an act common to the game. He doesn’t actually have to perform that act.
The NCAA’s own instant replay guidance specifically identifies additional steps as evidence of transitioning from a receiver to a runner.
Miami’s receiver secured the football, established BOTH feet inbounds, remained upright, and took another step out of bounds before the ball was dislodged.
Rule 2-4-3(b) governs receivers going to the ground during the catch. That’s not what happened here. He remained upright.
If those actions established a completed catch before he stepped out, Rule 8-2-1(b) makes it a touchdown immediately. There can be no subsequent fumble because the play is already dead.
You can’t argue that his next step would establish possession in the field of play while automatically dismissing that same evidence in the end zone.
The standard for a completed catch doesn’t change simply because the receiver is standing in the end zone.
By that interpretation, Miami scored. And I’m saying that as an FSU fan.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
4TH Down TD: #Miami just got cheated.
The WR has possession in the end zone takes one step out of bounds and then gets the ball knocked out.
Explain this!!
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
I’m confused by the Lofton catch not being a touchdown tbh.
Full possession with both feet in the end zone.
Full possession with a foot out of bounds.
How is that not full possession?
He never went to the ground. Doesn’t have to survive the ground.
Explain.
Under NCAA Rule 4-1-3, a live play becomes dead the exact moment a ball carrier (or a player completing a catch) touches the sideline or anything out of bounds.
IT WAS A TOUCHDOWN!
@TomFornelli
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Every picture just leaves me more and more perplexed by this call. This looks like a TD on Sunday. Control and two feet down.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
I don’t want to be biased, but that’s full possession and two feet down before the ball is slapped out.
Lowell Karr 🟦🟧 retweeted
Two feet and control in the endzone. How is that not a TD? I honestly don’t know anymore

































