The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball) header
The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball) profile picture

The Meatball Mafia

@MafiaMeatball

#Youngstown style Italian #meatballsubs & pizza! Available at our first location in #OldHilliard @ the Center Street Market (inside crooked can brewery)

 Columbus, Ohio
themeatballmafia.com
Joined October 2013
  • Tweets223
  • Following50
  • Followers174
70Media
Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)Photo by The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
T-Bone & Tyvis (@BoneAndTyvis971) profile picture
T-Bone & Tyvis@BoneAndTyvis971Mar 4
Pizza Madness Sausage Region
66%Classic's
34%Meatball Mafia
146 votes • Final results
1
1,341
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
97.1 The Fan (@971thefan) profile picture
97.1 The Fan
@971thefanMar 3
Due to popular demand… we opened the whole thing up. All FOUR Pizza Madness regions are officially LIVE. Vote now at pizzamadness.pizza/ Then share your picks and tag the pizza spot you’re riding with. The debates start now.
Image from 97.1 The Fan (@971thefan)
Image from 97.1 The Fan (@971thefan)
Image from 97.1 The Fan (@971thefan)
Image from 97.1 The Fan (@971thefan)
5
5
1
51
12,042
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Common Man (@CommonManRadio) profile picture
Common Man@CommonManRadio8 Mar 2025
Replying to @MafiaMeatball @TimmyHallRadio
Keep making those peppers!
3
1
6
622
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Common Man & Timmy (@ManAndTimmy971) profile picture
Common Man & Timmy@ManAndTimmy9716 Mar 2025
Pizza Madness 2025 Round One, Eggplant Region: Rubino's vs Meatball Mafia
64%Rubino's
36%Meatball Mafia
441 votes • Final results
1
1
3,384
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
OGKek9✝️ (@OGKek9) profile picture
OGKek9✝️@OGKek918 Feb 2024
Replying to @MafiaMeatball
@MafiaMeatball What a great pie this was! Will be back!
Image from OGKek9✝️ (@OGKek9)
2
2
157
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Common Man (@CommonManRadio) profile picture
Common Man@CommonManRadio2 Sep 2022
FRIDAY FOOD: Meatball Mafia- 5354 Center St, Hilliard Timmy introduced me to this place. YTOWN style pizza. Thick, chewy & the perfect vessel for meat. Get a side of peppers to top the pie. If you crave a meatball sub, try the Nicky Santoro. GTH
Image from Common Man (@CommonManRadio)
11
8
263
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Buckeye Show (@TheBuckeyeShow) profile picture
Buckeye Show@TheBuckeyeShow29 Jul 2022
And @TimHall971's Top pizza spots in central Ohio:🍕 5. Flyer's 4. Meatball Mafia 3. Adriatico's 2. Mikey's Late Night Slice 1. DiCarlo's Thoughts?
62
3
6
32
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Christine Fusner (@FusnerChristine) profile picture
Christine Fusner@FusnerChristine12 Jun 2022
Replying to @nbc4i
Best pizza by far is Meatball Mafia in Hilliard. @MafiaMeatball
1
2
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Christine Fusner (@FusnerChristine) profile picture
Christine Fusner@FusnerChristine12 Jun 2022
Replying to @NyerinOH09 @nbc4i
5000% agree. BUT Best pizza I've tasted in Columbus is at Meatball Mafia in Hilliard. Ytown style pizza! #best @MafiaMeatball
1
1
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio) profile picture
Timmy Hall🎙@TimmyHallRadio5 Jun 2022
Burger from Hot Mess. And a lil @MafiaMeatball 🍕too!
Image from Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio)
6
1
14
The following vendors will be here from 11am-3pm tomorrow Dumplings of Fury, @coffeeconnectus, Serendipity, @crookedcanohio, @AlsDelicious The following vendors will be closed all day tomorrow @MafiaMeatball, Two Step Tacos, The Cheesecake Girl, Bakes By Lo, @Pitabilities
Image from Center Street Market (@centerstreetmkt)
1
3
Because we love @BobsBurgersFOX happy Halloween! Open until 8pm tonight Text ahead order line (614)564-7251
Image from The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)
1
3
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio) profile picture
Timmy Hall🎙@TimmyHallRadio25 Sep 2021
Za and beer kinda night at the Can. The butcher and a lemon infused Ohi-Yo lager. 🍕🍕🍕🍻🍻🍻 @MafiaMeatball @crookedcanohio
Image from Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio)
Image from Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio)
Image from Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio)
11
2
33
Thank you for sharing! The mafia appreciates it!🤌
Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio) profile pictureTimmy Hall🎙@TimmyHallRadio31 Jul 2021
Replying to @TimmyHallRadio
And the @MafiaMeatball 🍕🍕is on point tonight
Image from Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio)
4
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio) profile picture
Timmy Hall🎙@TimmyHallRadio31 Jul 2021
And the @MafiaMeatball 🍕🍕is on point tonight
Image from Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio)
1
1
16
So technically today is the official #nationalmeatballday, where as the other 364 days a year are unofficially national meatball day 🤷🏻‍♂️ We’ll see you today from 11-7pm! 💣🇮🇹🇺🇸
Image from The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)
Have you watched? instagram.com/stories/614mag…
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
614 (@614Magazine) profile picture
614@614Magazine26 Feb 2021
Do you like pizza, fried chicken, and 90s cartoons? Perfect. @MafiaMeatball and Fried Chicka Bang have created the sandwich of your dreams. 614now.com/2021/food-drink/f…

Fried Chicka Bang and Meatball Mafia team up for new chicken sandwich

Quick Columbus, think of two foods you love. Pizza and chicken, you say? Samesies. Fried Chicka Bang and Meatball Mafia have collaborated to bring two of our favorites together for a delicious result…

614now.com
4
8
The Meatball Mafia retweeted
Timmy Hall🎙 (@TimmyHallRadio) profile picture
Timmy Hall🎙@TimmyHallRadio6 Feb 2021
Replying to @CommonManRadio
I would say try @MafiaMeatball's pizza inside the Center Street market in Hilliard. It is a meat ball spot but their pizzas kick ass and they incorporate the meatballs and Italian sausage on them.
3
1
6
🚨New Specialty Pizza Alert!🚨 Named after our home town newspaper, “The Vindicator” has crushed meatballs and sauce under the cheese, crumbled dirusso sausage, and house made hot peppers in oil!
Image from The Meatball Mafia (@MafiaMeatball)
1
3
Load more