Evidence: pilot users 40% faster. Claim: company-wide productivity rises. The numbers aren’t the argument. The missing sentence between them is. That’s the Warrant. (Episode 05 · Argumentation)
Three prestigious sources under the Claim. One is GDP. Your Claim is about junior research hours. True ≠ relevant. Cut the decoration. (Episode 04 · Argumentation)
9
“AI will help juniors” isn’t a Claim. It’s a vibe. A Claim is precise enough that two people could agree what would count as being wrong. Vague agreement is not a Claim. (Episode 03 · Argumentation)
An argument isn’t “claim + proof.” It’s six questions a challenger can force: What? On what? Why that move? Why trust the rule? How strongly? Unless? Labels come after. (Episode 02 · Argumentation)
2


