TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal) header
TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal) profile picture
India
Joined July 2022
Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)Photo by TweetWinger (@MyselfLiberal)
TweetWinger retweeted
Notice anything? Yes. Number of Indian soldiers killed in WW2: 87,000 Number of Indians who died due to WW2: 3 million You forgot India which sent the largest number of troops, and the greatest amount of rations and money to fight WW2 on all fronts for the allied. This is how the world ignores India and its immense contribution to the world for thousands of years. In every possible way. If we question, they will tell us "India never existed then". But will put ROC ironically with current China flag there as having done great sacrifice. But even to fight the Japanese in ROC, Indian troops contributed. The Chinese troops of ROC who fought the Japanese were also trained in India by the Indian Army. All of this is now forgotten. Because India is never mentioned for its sacrifices and immense contribution during World War 2 against the fascists.
This quoted post is unavailable.
102
2,031
32
7,991
201,589
TweetWinger retweeted
A review of @SoniaGandhi’s book. First things first. Sonia ji must be credited with honesty. In this book she has largely revealed her true self, without gloss or make-up. I have often commented that for Sonia Gandhi the only thing that mattered was her family. Still, I sometimes wondered whether it was really true or whether there was some other, layered reality. Not any more. Sonia ji herself now confirms it. In writing. The only thing that mattered to her was herself and her immediate family. Everything else, national interest included, was secondary. This explains, without an iota of doubt, the many unfathomable decisions Congress took once Sonia Gandhi became its chief. The other striking facet is her absolute disdain for Indians in general and Hindus in particular. Remember, she is not writing in the 1970s, freshly arrived and still adjusting. In 2026, at almost 80, she has lived amongst us for nearly 60 years. Yet consider what she has chosen to write. Her horror every time she passed the Ganesha statue at the front door of Indira Gandhi’s house. Or her disdain for Indian food, a refrain through more than half the book. Contrast how she describes her childhood in Italy with her experiences in India. Everyone is entitled to nostalgia about a happy childhood, and by all accounts hers was. She longigly describes the idyllic small-town and village life of Italy. Fair enough. Now see how India is described, especially her first impressions (not the artificial closing lines). India is either intrigue by wily, cunning people, or dead bodies floating down dirty rivers, or ghoulish, medieval customs not up to her refined tastes. Her first memory of the Sangam is a pungent smell and an allergy to marigolds. What she remembers most of her father’s first visit to India is him giving money to beggars despite her objections. Her first impressions of Amethi are not those of a woman meeting her own people but of a European on a poverty-porn tour. “Shabash,” she says to the ‘natives’ of Amethi whenever they do her bidding, just as the British would address their domestic help in a benevolent mood. Contrast this with the delight and affection with which she describes her first impression of Afghanistan, because she met people in western clothes with European-looking features, unlike Indians. The passage is revealing. Sixty years after landing in India, her first instinct is still to view us through a European lens when forming her opinions, likes and dislikes. After reading the full book, though, the ‘only her family mattered’ line needs a qualification. Family means only herself and those biologically related to her: her parents, her siblings and her children. Consider the following. It is fairly well known that Feroze Gandhi was a womaniser. It is an entirely different matter when a family member confirms it, that too on the authority of Rajiv Gandhi. I doubt there is any other high-profile example of a family member putting such details in writing. Or the way Sonia ji throws even Rajiv Gandhi under the bus when it suits her. She says the book is not about politics. Yet she purpsefully chose to write about the Shah Bano case and essentially let Rajiv carry the can. For me, though, the most striking passage is her account of 12 Willingdon Crescent (1977-80). Indira Gandhi has been ousted as PM after presiding over the most despotic period in independent India’s history. Yet loyal, ordinary Congress workers throng her residence every day and raise slogans in her support. But what does Sonia Gandhi think of those days? Not gratitude for the workers. Not affection for their loyalty. Only disgust and horror at the daily invasion of her privacy in the ‘small house’ she was now forced to live in. More than any other pages in the book, these reveal how Sonia Gandhi really looks at Congress workers. Not as colleagues. Not as comrades in a common purpose. Either as loyal tools (loyal to her family, not to any cause) or as evil manipulators. The hierarchy was clear. No party worker was a fellow human being deserving of respect or equal treatment. When Congress workers nominate Rajiv Gandhi as PM after Indira Gandhi’s assassination, Sonia Gandhi records her reaction: “Who are they?”; “How dare they?” ‘They’ being people who had given their lives to the Congress party. I am sure that in honest moments, Congress leaders and workers who have worked with the family over the decades have felt the same disdain and superiority complex and would relate to those words. “Who are you?" Other passages are just as revealing. She describes her father as a "patriot" and a "their hero", “my hero”. Sonia ji passes critical judgement even on Rajiv and Indira Gandhi. Yet her father, a soldier in Mussolini’s fascist army, is spared any judgement for his political actions. So are the passages on her finally giving up Italian citizenship, almost 15 years after her marriage. Even then the words used are “their ways”, “proud Italian” and the like. Nor does she hide that the festival the family most looked forward to was Christmas. Diwali gets a mention once or twice. The family functions and memories almost always revolve around Christmas. Devi Sita is described as the “consort” of Prabhu Ram. Only a European mind could describe Maa Sita in the vocabulary of European monarchy, entirely missing how a billion Indians look upon Prabhu Ram and Maa Sita. The glaring factual inaccuracies have already been commented upon. Even the basics are wrong: there were no Uttar Pradesh elections in 2003 that BJP won; Rahul Gandhi is a five-time Lok Sabha MP, not four; Vajpayee formed the first NDA government in 1998, not 1999; and the 2020 COVID lockdown was announced when India had 562 confirmed cases, not tens of thousands of victims. The editors, many of them named and with pedigree, must face tough questions. Finally, what does the book add up to? 1) A stunning tale of rancour and complaint. Invasion of privacy; betrayals; being forced into public life; being forced to meet ordinary people; the atrocious food she was made to eat; the weird Hindu customs and practices. After 60 years in India and 28 in the Congress party, she is still filled with so much rancour. 2) Barring a pro forma last paragraph, there is not a word of gratitude to the Congress party, its workers or its leaders, who accepted her wholeheartedly and let her mould the party in her own vision. Only complaint. No gratitude to the Almighty either, nor a nod to destiny for placing her at the centre of history-shaping events in the oldest continuously living civilisation in the world. She sees India only through a tourist’s lens, not through the eyes of one who considers this land a blessing. 3) The book fully explains the path Congress has taken since Sonia Gandhi took charge. Only one thing mattered to her: protecting her family. When that clashed with national interest, family interest prevailed. The pleas for foreign interference to save ‘Indian democracy’; the coinage of ‘Hindu terror’; the free pass to jihadi terrorists. Everything was kosher if it served the family’s immediate interest. 4) To her credit, Sonia Gandhi accepts in 2026 that despite all her efforts, she failed to stop the march of India’s civilisational resurgence. The 2014 verdict on Congress, after a decade of Sonia Gandhi’s ‘rule’, was a mere 44 seats. By 2026, Congress of Sonia Gandhi is on the margins, gasping for survival while the Indian civilisation marches on. One last thought. I began by crediting Sonia Gandhi with honesty. But can someone who writes in 2026 that the cause of the Godhra train fire is disputed really be called honest? A better word is transparent. Sonia ji has been transparently clear. Thank God for that. She has ensured history will judge her correctly.
Replying to @Brahamvakya
Sonia Gandhi was never vested in India like a natural born Indian is. For her family was the only thing mattered. Hence, there was no line that could not be crossed when it came to protecting her family. Hence this viciousness in politics, that has been injected in polity, post her rise.
68
356
59
844
79,217
Do you ever collect stones because a Muslim procession is going to pass? Do you ever plan to poison biryani that is eaten by 40000 people? Do your doctors make Ricin that will be delivered by drones to 4 lakh ppl? Do you go out of your way to collect blades, cut them and then spread then carefully on path taken by Hajj pilgrims? They do.
85
2,529
33
5,365
77,993
TweetWinger retweeted
I went to France 24 home page expecting to read up on the riots last night and see the police and Macron's response. Instead, I kid you not, the lead story (yes lead) is:- "Indian opposition parties stage mega rally seeking election chief’s resignation." Why on earth would French people be interested in this? The next story is "How far will 'Cockroach' movement go? India's youth-led protests defy Modi government" and "India bans march on parliament by ‘Cockroach’ activists, risking a standoff". Can't see anything on the riots in France on its home page. Absolutely bizarre.
313
2,331
119
9,760
256,756
Irfan Habib wrote an article in HT before the excavation started. He argued that the ASI should not go deeper than 2 metres because the dispute pertains to medieval India and any depth more than that would yield material culture of the ancient India and a brick of the Kushan period could be used as a evidence of a Hindu structure. The Muslim side took the cue and pleaded with the HC to prescribe a 2-metre depth limit to the ASI. The court asked the ASI to reply. The agency argued that limiting the depth would be against the principles of archaeology. It would be an incomplete and meaningless exercise. A couple of months before, Habib had admitted of a structure beneath the earth but called it ‘a residential quarter for marginalised sections.’ All his roguery has been unmasked in my book India’s Rogue Historians. Here is the link. amzn.in/d/073fAHRv
Supreme Court’s Babri Masjid verdict was “totally illegitimate” from a historian's point of view, says historian Irfan Habib in a conversation with @dksingh73 and @MandhaniApoorva.
73
1,573
36
5,128
147,294
TweetWinger retweeted
When Bihar set out to spend Rs 500 crore on a new museum, an academic went to court to stop it. A state this poor, he argued, couldn't afford it. This week, that museum was ranked ninth in the world, above New York’s Met and the Louvre. Swarajya walked through it last year.🧵
27
869
34
3,562
65,128
TweetWinger retweeted
Bloomberg says truckers are avoiding India's new expressway. So an influencer went there to find out the ground reality. Instead of relying on headlines, he spoke directly with truck drivers using the Delhi-Mumbai Expressway (NE4). And what he found on the ground tells a more nuanced story. Yes, there are challenges. Yes, the expressway is still incomplete. But does that mean it's a failed infrastructure project? Here's what the truck drivers actually had to say.
India is building US-style expressways to move freight faster. But many truckers still prefer older roads, where food, repairs and rest stops are cheaper. Aryan Gupta explains what’s putting the country’s $130 billion bet at risk: bloom.bg/4Bn5lr4
13
453
10
1,849
63,559
TweetWinger retweeted
“I sent an account of my observations of India on the ground to editors who knew me well at The Washington Post, The New York Times, Foreign Policy, and Fortune, all publications I had written for many times. Every single publication refused to run it; two of the editors told me in confidence that their bosses were not allowed to publish the piece. Hindustan Times published it, and readers in India overwhelmingly agreed with my account.” ~ @wadhwa in @htTweets hindustantimes.com/opinion/t…
2
111
6
247
7,650
"Indian people are like fucking animals." While waiting to board a flight from Kathmandu to New Delhi, I moved to the side of a crowd in front of the jet bridge to catch up with my mother in line when I heard this man behind me say those words. His name is Joaquin Bonilla Garcia. He's a Spanish passport holder. When I called him out on his blatant racism, he remained silent. After the flight, upon realizing I had filed a complaint with the airline, he tried to tell me there was a "misunderstanding." But I heard him loud and clear. I'm sharing this for two reasons. 1) I believe in freedom of speech, and I believe just as strongly that words have meaning. I think hateful statements should bear consequences. I couldn't track him down, but I would appreciate your help in identifying his community and holding him to account. 2) Racism is alive and well, even (especially?) in unlikely settings. I wasn't expecting to hear this kind of language on a flight within South Asia, surrounded by South Asian people, from a tourist who was visiting the region voluntarily. As an Indian American, I feel the pressure to be extra conscious of my behavior when I'm a visitor in another country. Clearly, others feel the opposite, even more empowered to behave badly when they are away from home.
3,354
1,624
189
8,572
1,800,875
TweetWinger retweeted
Underage son of a Kerala JUDGE fatally rams Mercedes into man on scooter, gets bail in 3 hours. Judge father threatens victim’s family in police station, forces them to delete photos.
636
8,878
265
27,863
579,439
🚨This is why Islamists & Leftists occupy publishing business. Maqsad! To spread caste poison in IIMs, Careers360 has received "motivation" One Islamist is contacting people to create attrocity literature targetting India's premier colleges. And why not? Qazi works for editor Prabha Dhavala who insults Modi casually. Good going @careers360. Sab yaad rakha jayega!
6
314
6
675
9,244
I redid this chart, splitting the fake "South Asia" into Pakistan and India, to give Pakistan its "rightful place" in the chart.
The Economist's estimate of Britain's age- and sex-standardised conviction rates for sexual offences by the offender's nationality economist.com/britain/2026/1…
46
536
47
2,695
96,973
Islam is an Arab-origin religion, which is why Arabs retain a foundational place of pride and dignity within it. The Persians then resisted and Persianised Islam under native Persian Muslim rule after overthrowing Arab political control : they injected their high culture, elevated Persian language and literary forms into the core of Islamic high culture, and produced works such as Ferdowsi’s Shahnameh, an epic that deliberately celebrates pre-Islamic Persian kings and heroes while registering clear resentment toward the Arab conquest that overthrew the Sasanian order. In doing so, they largely stripped Islam of its early Arab tribal particularism and made it a vehicle for a partial Persian cultural continuity. The Turks, for their part, supplied the imperial arm of Islam from the High Middle Ages onward and eventually converted the caliphate itself into a Turkish institution under the Ottomans. Together these three groups (Arabs, Persians, and Turks) secured distinct and complementary roles as the theological, cultural, and imperial pillars of the Islamic world. Because the Islamisation of their lands was effectively complete, they faced little residual “pagan” stigma when they continued to take pride and transmit their pre-Islamic heritage. Iranian Muslims still read and teach the Shahnameh; Turkish Muslims still take pride in both Ottoman imperial achievement and their earlier Turkic traditions and origins; Arab Muslims continue to centre their own linguistic and genealogical heritage. Pre-Islamic culture could be domesticated without existential conflict. Elsewhere the pattern was different. In India, Islam was introduced and expanded largely by military conquest rather than by organic, majority conversion under native Muslim polities. There was never a sustained, indigenous Indian Muslim dynasty that ruled in the subcontinent. More decisively, Hinduism’s continued demographic resistance and civilisational continuity meant that large-scale Islamisation never occurred. As a result, Indian Islam was never fully domesticated. It retained a pronounced anti-Indian edge (with important exceptions) that has historically preferred to celebrate foreign Turkish invaders and an imported Persianate high culture while remaining distant from, or actively hostile to, the native Hindu high culture of the land. The contrast is concrete. How many Kashmiri Muslims read and treat Kalhana’s Rajatarangini (the classic chronicle of Kashmir’s pre-Islamic kings) as part of their own cultural inheritance, in the way Persianate Muslims treat the Shahnameh? How many Awadhi Muslims read Tulsidas’s Ramcharitmanas and regard it as a shared element of their regional heritage?. In other cases too, the answer remains largely negative: the preferred historical memory continues to centre figures such as Mahmud of Ghazni, Muhammad Ghori, Sikandar Shah, and/or the Mughals, while native pre-Islamic kings and traditions are treated as alien or irrelevant. This is an honest and still unresolved tension. As long as large sections of Indian Muslim opinion continue to glorify foreign conquerors and an imported Persianate culture at the expense of the native high culture of the subcontinent, simply because that native culture is shared with Hindus, Islam in India will remain incompletely domesticated. The resulting friction with the Hindu majority is structural, not merely contingent on particular politicians or incidents. Lasting civic peace becomes realistic only when the dominant pattern shifts toward the model represented by figures such as A.P.J. Abdul Kalam: Muslims who treat the land’s deeper civilisational inheritance as their own rather than as the property of an adversary community. Until that domestication occurs on a broad scale, the cultural and historical gulf will continue the conflict.
This quoted post is unavailable.
45
340
19
1,402
50,844
SADAK PE FAISLA" ECOSYSTEM: PUPPETS ON CHINESE PURSE STRINGS? An editorial in The Indian Express titled “Foreign hand bogey is wearing thin. Bury it” stands in contemptuous judgement of any suggestion that the “regime change” protests in India may not be entirely the organic machination of young minds railing against a system that has stopped listening to them. The editorial dismissively shames anyone even considering the possibility of “foreign intervention” as evidence of “a kind of political and intellectual bankruptcy”. The attempt is obvious: to project the protests against the CEC and the NDA as a wholesome expression of dissent borne out of genuine causes. One would not ordinarily spend so much time interrogating the conclusions reached by The Indian Express had it not been for the pretentiously high-minded slogan printed in full caps above the editorial. It reads: “BECAUSE THE TRUTH INVOLVES US ALL”. 1/6
59
360
17
1,124
38,140
TweetWinger retweeted
The next wave of global protests and democratic resistance movements is being workshopped this week off in Salzburg, Austria. Nonviolence’s biggest names would be present in Salzburg including Erica Chenoweth (Harvard) and Breza Race Maksimovic (Director of CANVAS). Please see 🧵for more details.
10
57
5
118
6,847
Paris. Tirana. New Delhi. Manhattan. Apparently, we are ridiculous for noticing the connections of the foreign-hand in the so-called 'protests in India'. Start with Indian Alliance Paris. Fox News and @AsraNomani identifies the France-based diaspora organisation linking French and Indian protest messaging and that it partnered with the People’s Forum in Manhattan. Then comes Progressive International’s own October 16 briefing. It puts India, France, Spain and Albania in the same political frame and explicitly describes its work to “support and connect” these forces. It even asks how popular revolt can become organised political power. Its India section names names: Abhijeet Dipke, Left student organisations AISA, SFI and AISF, and Progressive International figures Nikhil Dey and Shaik Salauddin. Forget the commentary for a moment. Let's look at the financial trail. Start with Neville Roy Singham, the Shanghai-based American businessman whose radical left funding network was examined in the 2023 New York Times investigation. That reporting identified NewsClick as a recipient of network financing. Now his wife, CODEPINK co-founder Jodie Evans says: “I want people to look at France, Spain and India.” And his company funded Tricontinental’s Vijay Prashad explicitly invoked India: “Paris-New Delhi-Buenos Aires...Let fury have the hour, anger can be power.” India is being actively folded into a wider international anarchic left-radical regime change campaign. So spare us the sneering dismissal of every question as a “conspiracy theory”. Explain the partnerships. Disclose the funding, Investigate the transactions. Identify who supplies strategy and amplification.
29
252
10
561
18,129
Kanyakumari, TN: A Hindu Class 10 student observing a religious fast for the Kulasekharanpattinam Dussehra festival was ordered by her Christian headmistress to cut the sacred Tulsi Mala and hide it from view, or return to school without it.
75
895
42
1,871
89,230
TweetWinger retweeted
‘Feisty’ in India, but ‘manipulated’ in France? How Western Media saw the students’ protests in India vs those in Europe.
65
967
32
2,361
27,779
TweetWinger retweeted
Jean Dreze appears to be an infallible prophet
A worker at an Adani plant contributes more to the country’s development than a parasitic gora larper can ever dream of Anyone defending Jean Dreze as some development guru is the epitome of a low IQ moron
12
157
6
567
8,811