Pinned Tweet
We own Parliament. So how did we lose control of it?
Follow the chain of command.
What power do you really have?
…
Chain of command:
Citizen: “We have to fix this problem.” (E.g., pollution in a river.)
Go to local government. They say: “No rules or laws are being broken. We cannot fix this problem.”
Go to your MP. Your MP agrees with you: “We need a new rule.” (E.g., a law banning the pollution of the river.)
The MP drafts a new law and presents it to Parliament.
This is where it gets interesting, because now we see who controls the government.
…
The MP can freely present it, briefly, to the other 649 MPs in the House of Commons.
It then goes through a back-and-forth process to refine it, and a majority vote by the MPs makes it law.
So, in short, the ultimate authority is the majority vote of the MPs who sit in the House of Commons. This is crucial to understanding NewCommons, but let’s leave that for now.
In practice, what happens to this new law? Who is in charge next?
No vote on the law itself takes place until its Second Reading. So who, or what, determines whether that happens? What is the next level of power?
An internal office, run by MPs, called the Office of the Leader of the House of Commons.
It writes the schedule, deciding which laws will be discussed. It has the power not to put something on the agenda.
It literally decides what the government considers doing.
So who runs this office?
An MP with the title “Leader of the House of Commons”.
Who appointed them?
The monarch.
But wait, surely not? We stripped the monarch of such power long ago.
Formally, yes. In practice, the monarch can only appoint the person they are told to appoint.
By whom?
The Prime Minister.
So the Prime Minister essentially controls the Office of the Leader of the House and therefore the agenda.
The power to enact this new law essentially lies with the Prime Minister.
….
Right, so who is the Prime Minister?
The Prime Minister is an MP given the title “Prime Minister”. By whom? The monarch again?
The same principle applies. The monarch does not personally choose whoever they want. They must appoint the person capable of commanding the confidence of the House of Commons, normally the leader of the party with a majority of MPs.
So, in practice, the majority of MPs determines who can be Prime Minister.
…
This is where theory and principle meet reality.
In principle, power in the House of Commons is divided equally between 650 MPs. Any of them can present a law, and all of their votes are equal when deciding whether to pass it.
However, the mechanism Parliament uses to organise itself, the Prime Minister and so on, concentrates that power into the hands of a small number of MPs.
This isn’t necessarily a problem. Parliament has to organise itself somehow, and the authority of these individuals ultimately depends upon the support of the other MPs.
It’s a genius system…but…what is really going on?
Courts and Tribunals Bill
Should some criminal trials go ahead without a jury to reduce pressure on the courts?
The Courts and Tribunals Bill would make major changes to criminal justice in England and Wales. It would remove the right of defendants in either-way cases to choose Crown Court jury trial, create new rules allowing some Crown Court trials to be heard by a judge without a jury, and allow complex or lengthy fraud, tax, bribery, money-laundering and terrorist-funding cases to be tried without a jury. It would also allow magistrates’ sentencing powers to rise as high as 24 months, require permission for many appeals from magistrates’ courts, tighten rules around sexual-history evidence and compensation claims in sexual offence cases, expand special measures for witnesses, remove the legal presumption that parental involvement usually benefits a child, and reorganise tribunal leadership.
Your representative will vote on this.
Tell them how on NewCommons.
newcommons.uk/lawsearch/e7df…
99
This Space is about solutions, not complaints.
My claim:
NewCommons - or a copy of its mechanism - lets the population take control of government, freely and legally, without needing its consent and with almost no effort from the individual.
Tommy won’t fix it. Rupert won’t fix it. Another political party won’t fix it. Changing who controls the system doesn’t change the system.
NewCommons does something different.
The public votes on legislation. We measure whether MPs represent their constituencies. Voters enforce the results at the general election.
An unofficial direct democracy operating through the existing electoral system.
Four questions:
1. Does it work?
2. Will enough people use it?
3. What happens if they do?
4. Is there a better solution?
If it doesn’t work, tell me where the mechanism breaks.
If you have a better solution, explain it.
That’s the debate.
3
110
Short-term Leases (Disclosure of Information) Bill [HL]
Should councils have the power to collect more information about short-term holiday lets in their area?
The bill would allow the Government to give local housing authorities powers to collect occupancy data and other information from owners of short-term rental properties and, where relevant, the companies that manage or advertise those properties. Councils could require annual occupancy data, details of bookings and online advertising platforms before or during advertising of the property.
Your representative will vote on this.
Tell them how on NewCommons.
newcommons.uk/lawsearch/6a4e…
110
NewCommons is a public control system for democracy.
Instead of giving a party your vote and waiting years to use it again, NewCommons lets you continuously decide what you want your representative to do.
Every parliamentary decision creates a Public Mandate in each constituency. Your MP’s record is measured against it, and at the next election, voters can use that record when deciding who represents them.
That’s the Public Whip: turning the electoral power of the public into continuous democratic accountability.
Your vote represents you.
Control Democracy.
Vote on the decisions Parliament makes.
Together, your constituency creates the Public Mandate.
Your representative’s record is measured against it.
The public becomes the whip.
12
NewCommons is a public control system for democracy.
Instead of giving a party your vote and waiting years to use it again, VoteUK lets you continuously decide what you want your representative to do.
Every parliamentary decision creates a Public Mandate in each constituency. Your MP’s record is measured against it, and at the next election, voters can use that record when deciding who represents them.
That’s the Public Whip: turning the electoral power of the public into continuous democratic accountability.
Your vote represents you.
78

