This video reminds me of Assemblies of God Church when they did their politics. It was brutal because you couldn't even trust the church with tithe and offerings anymore, because the church was fighting over money and position. It's a shame that the church has been reduced to this state.
Noble Kenneth retweeted
You hear Muslims say the Quran and Islam are very easy to understand. Just one God in oneness and no complication at all. And you will hear other Muslims say, "The Quran explains all things." Then you will hear other Muslims say you don't need a high IQ to know Allah. And then you will still see the same Muslims say you will need a very high IQ to understand Islam. And then you will still see the same Muslims say the only reason Arabic is the only acceptable language is because any little mistake in the grammar can change the meaning of your prayers and reading.
God, which are we going to believe?
You will need a whole bunch of their scholars to interpret their text, and even their scholars still fight among themselves.
Islam is the most complicated localized religion gone public ever.
Noble Kenneth retweeted
When you're used to pretty women, the beauty loses its appeal, having seen them for who they are, and knowing that pretty women no dey ever finish. The make up is just a smokescreen, most women are boring and tiring to be around. What they have going for them is often beauty and sexual appeal which men use to put them on pedestal for obvious reasons. So they live in that delusion of overrated self importance because men will always want to hit. Women's self esteem is tied to their sexual appeal, that is why it is what they market and brag about. Ironically, women deal with deep-seated insecurity about their body so they need your validation/pedestal to hang on and feel better about themselves.
Women's bad behaviours which often cosplays as insanity are usually tolerated because of sex. In the end, post nut clarity will always unveil the truth about your worth because the truth comes when a man comes. You have to love a woman to always want her around, and that comes with vetting and flinging many people away. That is why prostitution will not go anywhere because in a manner of speaking, paying for the sex is healthier for most men since they can get full value for their money by using you as they please and don't have to deal with you after sex - until next time.
When women say "men will see a beautiful woman like this, who took her time to look good blah blah" or accuse you of "fumbling a bad bitch" because of sexual appeal, they are projecting and want to live in that delusion where men place them on pedestal. The men that know her and refused to be with her, you think they are stupid? Feel free to recommend her to your brother. Sometimes, this bad behaviour is a failure of consequences. Men have let them get away with their madness that they have come to believe insanity is normal behaviour they can get away with. But no matter how pretty a woman is, there is a guy who is tired of her shit.
That is why it is dangerous to lose your babe to players who have detached from the female delusion. They don't even fvck them like normal people but as recreational tools. While you are still making love to her, the bad boys are doing what you can't even imagine with your babe because in his head, she is just another mobile tot whose insanity he can block off till he nuts. Those ones don't have post nut clarity, they have pre nut clarity. They know exactly what they are using her to do and they ensure she knows too. When he is done, he sends her away or tell her to bring her friend. They control these women and the women respect them. But for sex, most men won't deal with women.
Nothing is more threatening, yet simultaneously attractive to a woman than a man who is aware of his own value to women.
- Rollo Tomassi
Women know women are not good people.
Women know women do not make good friends.
Women believe other women have witchcraft in them.
Women don't like other women.
Women know women are not intentionally kind people like men.
Women know women would never put women on pedestal.
The most toxic human relations exists between women
It ia men who pedestalize them and that is why the worst thing you can do to a woman is to treat her the way other women would treat her. Her validation always have to come from men even it sells itself through sexual appeal because relationship with men will always pay her more - inspite of the manifest mental illness.
A Yoruba babalawo praying to his deity in English is the same thing as an Arab man praying to Allah in Yoruba. It will not be recognized by either deity because they are serving a specialized and localized deity. Islam is a localized religion that has managed to spread unlike the African deities and to pray to that deity, you must go through Arabic and Arabs. Without the Arabs, Islam dies. Without the Arabs, Islam will not exist.
3
114
You Muslims will always amaze me, tbh. I am not strawmanning, and I don't know if this is a new English you just learned. You are dodging and running away.
I'm quoting you. You just said: "Why does YAHWEH suddenly stop understanding His scripture when it comes to Torah reading?"
Bro, He doesn't. That is exactly my point.
Yahweh understands every language. That is why He allowed the Shema, which is scripture, to be recited in any language. That is why He allowed the Amidah to be prayed in any language. That is why the Targum translation was read aloud in the synagogue right after the Hebrew, so the people would understand.
The Torah is read in Hebrew not because God cannot understand other languages. It is read in Hebrew because it is a public reading of a book, to the people, to preserve the exact original text. It is like reading Shakespeare in English. You preserve the original, but you still explain it in the people's language.
Solat is not a public reading of a book to people. Solat is you talking to God. Privately. 5 times a day.
So tell me, if God understands all languages, why does He reject your Solat if you say it in other languages?
You cannot answer that with Torah reading, because Torah reading is not a man talking to God. It is a man reading to other men.
And yes, I know Kriat HaTorah is not only once a week. It is Monday, Thursday, and Shabbat. Still, it is still not daily, still NOT done by every Jew, still not a prayer to God. It is done by one reader, for the congregation.
You keep trying to compare a communal reading to a personal prayer. They are not the same.
And you even quoted that "It is not the eyes that are blind but the hearts that are in the chests." What arrogance coming from someone like you.
I still agree. Because your heart is blind to this simple question:
If God understands Yoruba when you do Dua, why does He suddenly stop understanding other languages when you do Solat?
Is it God that stops understanding, or is it Islam that stops Him?
Answer that one.
Replying to @Nobleken01
You're strawmaning this too hard. You perfectly understood the analogy and your argument about daily or weekly is not valid. Why does YAHWEH suddenly stop understanding his scripture when it comes to torah reading. Also Kriat Hatorah is not only once a week.
2
6
261
You hear Muslims say the Quran and Islam are very easy to understand. Just one God in oneness and no complication at all. And you will hear other Muslims say, "The Quran explains all things." Then you will hear other Muslims say you don't need a high IQ to know Allah. And then you will still see the same Muslims say you will need a very high IQ to understand Islam. And then you will still see the same Muslims say the only reason Arabic is the only acceptable language is because any little mistake in the grammar can change the meaning of your prayers and reading.
God, which are we going to believe?
You will need a whole bunch of their scholars to interpret their text, and even their scholars still fight among themselves.
Islam is the most complicated localized religion gone public ever.
Good morning, y'all.
A quick question to Muslims. If a babalawo is doing incantation to his deity, his Allah, we all know he is praying to his deity. If another person from another country or region started learning deep Yoruba so he can also pray to the Yoruba deity, which is their Allah, we will all say he is praying to the Yoruba deity. Then why is it that African Muslims and non-Arab Muslims don't know that when they are learning and reciting Arab incantations to their Allah, they are praying to the Arab deity?
Why is that difficult for them to understand? A god that only needs a particular language to be pleased and bless you is a localized deity and not a universal one.
I'm genuinely tired tbh. How come you can't see you are admitting it again with each response and defense you are bringing? I've responded to this very question several times in different ways to different people. Let me respond to you as well.
You just said that In Judaism the normal prayer can be done in any language.
Exactly. The normal prayer. The daily prayer. The Amidah, which a Jew prays 3 times a day that is their Solat equivalent and can be done in any language. The Shema can be done in any language.
So Judaism's daily ritual prayer is not locked to Hebrew.
But Islam's daily ritual prayer, Solat, is the opposite. It is locked to Arabic.
You cannot compare Solat to ritualistic reading of the Torah. They are not the same thing.
The Torah reading is not a daily prayer for every Jew. It is a public reading, once a week, done by ONE person in the synagogue, while everyone else listens. And even then, historically they would translate it immediately into Aramaic, the Targum, so the ordinary people could understand it. They did not tell the people to just listen to the sounds they don't understand.
Solat is not like that. Solat is compulsory for every Muslim, 5 times a day, every day, for life. It is not done by one priest for you. You have to do it yourself, in a language you don't speak.
That is the big difference...
Judaism do daily ritual prayer with any language. Weekly public reading = Hebrew + translation so people understand.
While Islam do daily ritual prayer = with Arabic only as it seems to be Allah favorite language. No translation allowed in Solat. And you can't do it in Yoruba, it is invalid.
And you said Dua is like Jewish prayer. No. Dua is extra. Solat is the main obligation. You are comparing Islam's optional prayer to Judaism's compulsory prayer, and pretending they are equal. They are not.
If Dua is enough, why is Solat compulsory? Why will Allah judge you first on Solat and not on Dua?
You keep trying to make Solat sound like a small ritual. It is not small. It is the pillar of Islam.
So I ask you again bro
If a Jew can do his compulsory daily ritual prayer in English and God accepts it, why can't a Muslim do his compulsory daily ritual prayer in Yoruba and God accept it?
Is the Jewish God more understanding than the Muslim God?
Replying to @Nobleken01
That is where most Christians keep projecting because they take the word prayer as conversing with God or praising him. However that is different to the ritual of prayer. In Judaism the normal prayer can be done in any language in islam that's called duaa.
3
3
255
Noble Kenneth retweeted
Replying to @brmmyyx
Hmm, you do realize that your argument already collapsed with the kind of question you just asked me.
Yes, a Jew can pray in English. In fact, they can choose to pray in any language 馃挴
In fact, that is Jewish law itself. Their Mishnah says the Shema, the most important Jewish prayer can be said in any language. The Talmud in Berakhot 13a says the same for the Amidah, the standing prayer. Maimonides confirms it.
A Jew can pray in English, in African languages, in French, in Russian. God hears every language and It is valid.
Do you know why?? It is simply because Judaism teaches that God understands all languages. Prayer is about the heart, not the tongue/pleasing sound.
Now compare that to the so called universal Islam.
Can a Muslim do Solat in English? No.
In Igbo? No.
In Hausa? No.
In French? No.
It must be in Arabic which is your Allah favorite language, or it is invalid.
Do you see the difference now?
The Jew, who is not even claiming his religion is for the whole world, is allowed to pray in any language.
The Muslim, who Is claiming his religion is for the whole world, is not even allowed to pray in any language. Even his own mother tongue. Such irony!!
Isn't this backwards? Be honest with yourself.
If even Judaism which is a tribal, non missionary religion understands that God hears all languages, why does Islam the supposedly universal religion not understand it?
You just asked the one question that proves my point better than I could ever 馃檹
That you have to become someone else to be worthy of love.
The whole world is selling you a new version of you everyday. New body, new accent, new religion, new culture, new name, new past. As if the original you was a mistake that needs correcting.
I'm never falling for it.
If God made you Igbo, with a Igbo tongue, a Igbo name, a Igbo story, why would He need you to erase all of that before He can hear you? Why would heaven only accept a translated version of you?
The most radical thing you can do now is stay yourself, talk to God in the language your mother taught you, and refuse to believe you were born wrong.
6
277
Noble Kenneth retweeted
Whatever you do, pray for the ability to see your own sins, hypocrisy, and shortcomings. Never get so carried away pointing fingers that you forget you too are not perfect.
Hey Chris,
Thank you for proving my point just like the rest before you.
You just said that If Classic Arabic is not translated correctly, it can lead to a totally different interpretation.
Well, Exactly.
So what happens to the millions of Yoruba, Hausa, Igbo, Indonesian, and Pakistani Muslims who do not know Classic Arabic?
They are reading a wrong interpretation. Or they are not reading at all, they are just repeating sounds like a robot.
You just admitted that the Quran's meaning depends on a very specific, very difficult form of Arabic that even native Arabic speakers today don't speak in daily life.
So how can this book be a universal guide for all mankind, if understanding it correctly requires mastering an ancient dialect that 90% of Muslims don't speak?
In Christianity, the message is pretty simple, go and translate it into every tongue, so every man can hear God in his own language. That is why we have the Bible in African native language as well as in English, in 3,000+ languages.
In Islam, the message is that, you must come to Arabic, or risk getting it totally wrong.
And about the timeless conditional you just mentioned. that is simply grammar. Every language has grammar. African languages has grammar. English has grammar. Hebrew has grammar. A perfect, universal God who created all languages could have made His message clear in all of them, not hidden in one ancient grammar trick that only scholars understand.
If God wanted everyone to understand Him, why would He hide the meaning inside a grammar that makes a verse read as though it has already ended just like you just said unless you are an expert?
You are not defending Islam. You are admitting that Islam is locked behind a language barrier.
A Yorubaand Igbo man praying in his language does not need a scholar to tell him what he just said. He knows. He understands. He means it.
Can an average Muslim say the same about his Solat?
Replying to @Nobleken01
There's a major difference between Classic Arabic and English, which (if not translated correctly) can lead to a totally different interpretation of the verse.
Unless you're aware of this, every verse that contains a "timeless conditional", reads as though it has already ended.
One of your prayers as a human trying your best should be: pray never to meet and encounter someone like @stevewilldoit. He is the kind of person who will withhold your progress and fight others who decide to step in to help you. Such despicable and hateful people exist all around the world. They brag about their past good deeds while perpetuating evil, and they are boastful and ready to fight and pull down anyone who chooses to help someone he chose to neglect.
1
54
You are now contradicting yourself in every sentence.
Sure, it is not natural Yoruba but It is deep Yoruba. Esoteric Yoruba. Old Yoruba if you like to call it that way.
But it is still Yoruba.
Deep Yoruba is not Arabic. Deep Yoruba is not Chinese. It is the Yoruba man's own language, taken deeper.
And that is the difference you keep missing. The Babalawo goes deeper into his own culture. The Muslim is forced to go outside his own culture into Arab own culture.
A Yoruba Babalawo learning deep Yoruba is like a Yoruba man learning to be more Yoruba.
A Yoruba Muslim learning Arabic is like a Yoruba man learning to be less Yoruba and more Arab.
Do you see the difference now?
And you are asking why he even have to talk and not just talk in his mind?
Because ritual uses the mouth. But the mouth is still speaking his language. He is not borrowing another people's mouth.
You said something interesting that God doesn't give explanations, that's why He is God.
If God doesn't give explanations, then why are you here explaining for hours?
If we are not allowed to ask why, then you have just killed all Islamic apologetics. You cannot say that Islam is logical, Islam is rational, Islam is for thinking people" and then when we ask a hard question, you end up saying that God doesn't explain.
And if God doesn't explain, how do you know He wants Arabic? You are claiming to know His reason without explanation. That is blind following.
A God who is just would not punish a Yoruba man for not understanding a language he never gave him, and then even tell him not to ask why.
You also claimed that your Solat isn't talking to God, it is ritual prayers, just like the Jews prayer
If Solat is not talking to God, then what are you doing when you say something like "Iyyaka na'budu wa iyyaka nasta'in", You alone we worship, You alone we ask for help.
Who are you talking to? Are you talking to the wall? To yourself? Or to Muhammed your prophet?
And Surah Al-Fatiha stated, "Ihdinas-siratal-mustaqim, Guide us to the straight path."
If you are not talking to God, who are you asking to guide you?
You cannot say Solat is not talking to God. The Quran itself calls Solat dhikr, remembrance of God, and munajat, intimate conversation with God.
And you say "just like the Jews prayer which you keep repeating.
again, Jews pray in Hebrew, their own ancestral language, to their own tribal God. They are not claiming to be universal. You are.
You have admitted to these so far
That Solat must be in Arabic.
Thag Solat is not talking to God.
That God doesn't need to explain why.
If that is true, then you have just described a ritual where a Yoruba man stands 5 times a day, repeats foreign words he doesn't understand, to a God he is not even talking to, for a reason God will not explain.
Bro, is that worship? Or is that programming?
A Yoruba Christian says Baba, jowo bukun mi and he is talking to God, he understands it, and he knows why.
You are doing the opposite of all three, and calling it superior.
Please explain that.
Noble Kenneth retweeted
Replying to @olowo__ake
We pray in Jesus name because we consider Jesus our God and his name is above everything both in heaven and on earth. Nothing come close. Is that same with Arabic 馃
I finally get you to answer, my dear friend. Now you have finally said the truth out loud but bro, that truth is the problem. A very big problem you just trap yourself in.
This is what you just said
"Solat is not Dua. You are not speaking to Allah in Dua as you claim"
Wait a minute 馃槻 read what you just wrote. Read it slowly my friend.
You are saying Solat, the most important prayer in Islam, 5 times a day, the second pillar, the first thing you will be judged on is not speaking to Allah?
Then what is it? A dance? A gym exercise? A performance? Damn!!!
If Solat is not talking to God, then why do you say "Allahu Akbar", "Ihdinas-siratal-mustaqim, Guide us to the straight path? Who are you asking to guide you if you are not speaking to Allah?
You cannot have it both ways. Either Solat is talking to God, and then language matters. Or Solat is not talking to God, and then you have just admitted that Muslims spend their whole lives doing a ritual that is not even communication with God.
Which one is it bro?
And you also quote this "Solat is a ritual worship, it has ways and methods, that's why it is a religion, you get rewarded like a boss rewards you for work"
A boss is a human. A boss is limited. A boss tell you to do it this way or you don't get paid because he cannot understand another way.
God is not a boss. God is not limited. If a boss in Lagos tells his Yoruba worker to speak Arabic or he won't pay them, we would call that boss wicked and evil. Why are you making God act like that wicked boss?
And even a boss rewards you for work you understand. If your boss gives you a job in Chinese and you just copy the sounds without understanding, will he reward you? No, he will fire you. But you are saying God rewards you for repeating sounds you don't understand. That is not worship. That is obedience without understanding.
You even mentioned that babalawo learns ohun ife
Thank you very much for bringing Babalawo! You just destroyed your own argument again.
Yes, Babalawo learns Ifa. But what language does he learn it in? Yoruba in case you don't know. His own mother's tongue. The language of his ancestors. He does not have to go and learn Arabic to talk to his own gods.
A Yoruba Babalawo prays in Yoruba. A Yoruba Christian prays in Yoruba. Only a Yoruba Muslim is told that their Yoruba language is not good enough, that they should go and learn Arabic to access our Allah.
So I will ask you again, simple,
If God wants Solat done in a particular way because that's the way He wants, why does He want it in Arabic, the language of one tribe, and not in every man's language?
You said "God asks us to do it this way because that's the way He wants." That is not an answer. That is just saying "because I said so."
A child asks his father why? and the father says it's because I said so." That is not explanation. That is authority and finality.
If God is just and universal, He must have a reason that makes sense to a Yoruba man, not just to an Arab man.
So tell me the reason. I will really like to know.
I didn't ignore your points. You ignored my question right from the beginning. I will answer yours again, and you answer mine this time.
First, you said Language is never a reason for universality, languages can be learnt
Yes, languages can be learnt. But that is exactly the problem.
Why should a Yoruba farmer who cannot read or write have to learn Arabic before he can properly talk to God? A rich man can go to Arabic school. A poor man cannot. So you have just made access to God depend on education and money.
For trade, you learn a new language because you choose to trade. You can also choose not to trade. For God, you cannot choose not to pray. Solat is compulsory. So you are forcing a man to learn a foreign language to fulfill a compulsory duty.
And learning to pronounce is not learning to understand. Millions of Muslims can recite Arabic perfectly and cannot tell you what Surah Al-Fatiha means in their own language. I personal did this experiment among Yoruba Muslims and they said they don't need to know the meaning. They just learnt the sound, not the meaning. That is not learning for God. That is learning for performance.
If God is all-knowing, why does He need you to learn Arabic to talk to Him? He already understands Yoruba.
And you keep mentioning Jews history and that they wanted others to worship Yahweh
Yes, historically. I never denied it. But we are talking about today's claim of universality so please stop beating around the bush.
Modern Judaism does not claim that they are for all mankind, come and join us butIslam does claim that today. So Islam must be judged by today's claim.
Even if ancient Jews were expansionist, that does not prove Islam is universal. You keep pointing at Jews to avoid defending Islam and I am really tired.
You also said There were sects of Christianity that held a specific language was best and that Vulgate was attacked.
You just proved my point again without knowing it. Y'all keep doing that.
Yes, there were Christians who tried to lock the Bible in Latin. And what happened? The Church corrected it. The Reformers translated the Bible into English, German, Yoruba, and every language on earth because they realized locking God's word in one language was wrong.
That is exactly what Islam has not done. Christianity learned and changed. Islam still say that you cannot pray Solat in Yoruba or any other languages because It is invalid.
So you are using a Christian mistake that Christians fixed as a defense for an Islamic rule that is still enforced today.
You also say that we learn new languages for trade, why can't you do same for GOD?
Because God is not a customer. God is not a boss in Dubai who will only pay you if you speak Arabic.
If I learn Arabic for trade, I do it to talk to an Arab man who does not understand Yoruba, Igbo and hausa. That makes sens because the Arab man is limited.
But God is not limited. God understands all languages. He is the creator So why is He acting like He only understands Arabic in Solat? Is God limited like a trader?
You are lowering God to the level of a man who needs a translator. Is that how you view your Allah?
So let me ask you the question you keep running away from, for the third time.
If God understands Yoruba in Dua, why does He reject Yoruba in Solat?
Answer that one question directly, without laughing emojis, without talking about Jews, without talking about Catholics. Just that one.
If you cannot answer it, then you have proved my point. If you respond without answer that question, I will let you go.
They always ended up proving my point. I know it hurts African Muslims to hear this, but even when they try to argue and beat around the bush, the fact still remains: African Muslims can never be equal to Arab Muslims. Arab Muslims will always be superior and be their masters. They can quote every book, quote Allah, quote Muhammad, but they still succumb to the Arab way if they ever want to access their Allah.
1
60
Dude, learn to arrange your comment so I can respond. And you are trying to dodge the original topic and question.
Let me rephrase it so you cannot hide. In Christianity, there is no compulsory prayer where you must use a language you don't understand. In Islam, there is Solat. That is the difference.
You said the Jews are the least tolerant, they did conquests and massacres. I don't understand, this was never the subject of discussion but still I will not deny that. The Old Testament records wars, conquests, and killings. I am not defending Judaism's history.
But you are changing the topic. I don't know why Muslims always do this. We are not debating who killed more people in history. We are debating language and universality.
And even if Jews were violent in the past, that does not make Islam universal today. Two wrongs don't make Islam universal.
Also, modern Judaism does not try to convert the whole world. That is a fact. A rabbi will actually discourage you if you want to convert. An Imam will never discourage you. That is a very big difference.
Jews pray in Hebrew. Yiddish is just a language some Ashkenazi Jews speak at home in Europe. It is not the language of Jewish prayer. And again, Judaism is for Jews. They are praying in their own ancestral language.
You mentioned Ethiopian Christians: Yes, the Ethiopian Orthodox church uses Ge'ez, an ancient Ethiopian language. That is their own ancient language, not a foreign language forced on them by another people. An Ethiopian praying in Ge'ez is praying in his own heritage.
And you also mentioned Catholics: Yes, Catholics used to do Mass in Latin. But Vatican II in the 1960s changed it. Today, a Catholic in Nigeria does Mass in Yoruba, Igbo, English, fully valid. And even when they used Latin, the Catholic Church never taught that Latin was the only language God understands. And exorcism? Exorcism is not the daily compulsory prayer for every Catholic. It is a special rite done by a priest. A normal Catholic never needs Latin to pray daily.
Compare that to Islam, Solat in Arabic is not optional, not historical, not for priests only. It is compulsory for every Muslim, every day, forever, and cannot be changed.
And you also keep mentioning tongues.
No Christian church will ever tell you that if you don't speak in tongues, your prayer will be invalid.
In Islam, if you don't pray in Arabic, your Solat is invalid. That is the difference between preference and compulsion.
You are right that language is not the only criteria, True. But it is a necessary one. You cannot claim to be for all mankind and then make your core worship accessible only in one man's language.
You also mentioned that Islam killed Arab culture.
Again, both are true. Islam killed some Arab culture and froze other Arab culture and exported it.
Islam killed idol worship in Arabia. But it kept Arabic, Arab names, Arab dress, facing Mecca, Hajj to Mecca and made all of that compulsory for Yoruba, for Hausa, for Indian, for Indonesian and every other tribe and race.
So I ask you again, and please answer directly this time, without trying to hide in laughing emoji
Why must a Yoruba man become culturally Arab in name, in language of worship, in direction, in pilgrimage to worship a universal God?
If you can answer that, you have won the argument.
Replying to @Nobleken01
The Catholics do exorcism in what language ?
The Catholics and many other Christians believe that Greek and Aramaic are best to worship God
Yes some new Christian鈥檚 believe the best prayer is in tongues
All these are verifiable facts
Your explanation have a very big hole in it although I still give you a thumbs up.
You are saying two things.
One that Arabic preserves the message.
And the second that Arabic creates unit.
Let be logical for a bit.
If the goal is preservation, then why do most Muslims who recite it not understand it?
Preserving sounds is not preserving meaning. If I give you a Yoruba proverb in Chinese and you memorize the sounds for 20 years without knowing what it means, have I preserved the message for you? No. I have preserved the noise.
A Nigerian Muslim who recites Al-Fatiha perfectly but cannot tell you what it means in Yoruba has not received the message. He has received the melody.
The Bible is also preserved in Greek and Hebrew manuscripts for scholars to check. But ordinary Christians are not forced to recite Greek they don鈥檛 understand. They read it in their own language and understand the message. That is real preservation, preservation of meaning in the heart, not just sounds on the tongue.
If Allah wanted to preserve meaning, He would want you to understand it. Forcing a language you don鈥檛 speak does the opposite.
You also claim that Arabic create some sort of unity.
Sure, it creates unity of familiar sound. But is that real unity?
Think about this real quick, A Muslim from Nigeria, India, and Brazil standing together and reciting the same Arabic, sure, they sound united. But if none of them understand what they are saying, what are they united on? The sound, not the meaning.
True unity is not everyone saying the same words they don鈥檛 understand. True unity is that we all understand the same truth.
Christians also have unity worldwide without a forced language. A Yoruba Christian, a Korean Christian, and a Brazilian Christian don鈥檛 pray in the same language, but they are united because they understand the same message which is love God, love your neighbour. They don鈥檛 need to sound the same to be one.
And let鈥檚 be honest about that psychological safety, is it safety, or is it conformity? If a Yoruba man feels he cannot talk to God unless he sounds like an Arab, that is not belonging. That is being told you must abandon your identity to belong.
You said dua can be in any language. That is true. But dua is optional. Salah is compulsory. So the message is clear, Your language is good enough for your personal whisper, but not good enough for God鈥檚 official worship.
If God is truly universal, why would His official worship need a single human language? A truly universal God would be understood in every language, not just one.
And to add this final piece, unity should not require uniformity of language.
Replying to @Nobleken01
Yes, preserving a single, unchanging Arabic text anchors the core message, while evolving translations allow new generations to access its meaning across cultures.
In Islam this distinction separates the divine, unaltered scripture from human efforts to interpret it.
The
1
4
210














