Pinned Tweet
The Constitution of Ireland begins not with government, but with the Nation—with the People themselves. That is not symbolism. That is authority.
It is from the People that all power flows, and it is by our collective will that we established the Constitution as the supreme law of this State. Within it, we gave ourselves courts—not as instruments of control, but as guardians of liberty. Under Article 34, we vested those courts with a solemn duty: to protect and vindicate our personal rights.
Those personal rights are not abstract ideas. They are expressly recognised and protected across the Constitution—beginning in Article 40, and extending through Articles 41, 42, 42A, 43, and 44. Together, they safeguard what it means to live freely and with dignity in Ireland:
our personal liberty,
our families,
our children,
our right to educate according to conscience,
our private property,
and our freedom of religion.
These rights do not exist at the pleasure of the State. They do not depend on policy, preference, or administrative convenience. They are fundamental, and they are inalienable.
What we are witnessing at this moment is something profoundly serious. A member of the Government—holding office as a Minister of State, an office that exists only by statute—has purported, through a statutory instrument, to prevent the People of Ireland from exercising their constitutional rights in their own courts.
That cannot stand.
No statutory instrument can override the Constitution.
No minister, junior or otherwise, can suspend fundamental rights.
No act of secondary legislation can lawfully obstruct access to the courts where those rights are vindicated.
To suggest otherwise is not merely mistaken—it is constitutionally impossible.
The courts do not belong to the executive.
They do not belong to departments.
They belong to the People, because the Constitution says so.
And so, this is where the line is drawn.
The Constitution is not optional.
Fundamental rights are not negotiable.
Access to justice is not a privilege to be rationed.
Tomorrow, the law will be laid plainly before the Minister for Justice—not in defiance, but in fidelity to the Constitution; not in anger, but in duty to the People; not for personal grievance, but for the protection of all.
Because if fundamental rights can be restrained today, they can be extinguished tomorrow.
And if we do not stand now, we leave our children standing alone later.
This is not about power.
It is about principle.
It is about ensuring that the Constitution lives—not on paper, but in practice.
And it is about the furtherance of our fundamental rights, so that we may protect ourselves, our families, our children, the way we educate our children, our private property, and our religion—today, and for generations to come.
#NoFeeOnGuarantee – at Ireland
Holding Officials to Their Functions Protects Everyone's Rights
The High Court is where we vindicate, defend and protect our fundamental rights. But the District Courts in every county are open to us too, to enforce the statutory law when Irish officials step outside it. Every official exists to discharge a defined function. When one acts beyond that function, the conduct can be identified and prosecuted on its facts, or charged using the pre-approved offence code and wording. Each time an official is held to the rule of law, our fundamental rights are made stronger, not only for ourselves but for our families, our children and our communities.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
No office holder in Ireland, however high, has the authority to reach into the fundamental rights of a citizen or person living here. That includes the Attorney General, the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána, and corporate bodies such as the Courts Service. The Constitution gives the administration of justice to the courts alone, and no official stands between a member of the public and a judge.
Every person in Ireland has the right to swear an information before our District Court that an offence has been committed. No official can lawfully decide on the court's behalf whether your complaint will be heard. The decision to issue a summons or a warrant belongs to the judge alone.
That is why we must learn how to particularise an offence. Every statutory offence is made up of essential elements set out in the law. When you swear an information, you tell the court the time, the place, and exactly what the accused person did or failed to do, so that each element is met by the facts.
The attempts to stop me doing this have not come from the institutions of the State. They have come from individual people working within those institutions who chose not to follow the rules that bind them. That is the act of the individual, and it should be named as such.
Learn the elements of the offence. Set out the facts that meet them. Swear your information before the District Court. Our fundamental rights, including our personal liberty, are only as strong as our willingness to stand on them.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
How to Particularise an Alleged Offence in Plain Facts
Particulars should describe what a person did, not repeat the words of the statute. Start with the date and time, then the place, then the conduct act by act in ordinary language. Leave out legal labels such as "intentionally" or "without consent". Those are conclusions the court draws from the facts.
Every essential element must be met by a fact, and you should be able to name the section, subsection and limb each fact engages. You do not have to negative any defence or exception (Order 15, rule 9), and alternatives in the statute can be stated together (Order 15, rule 8).
Example under section 15 of the Non-Fatal Offences Against the Person Act 1997: "On the 1st of January 2020, A removed B from the front steps of a building on Main Street, brought B to a building on Church Street, kept B in that building for approximately two hours, and then let B go, and at no point did B agree to being removed, brought or kept."
A is "a person" and B is "another" under section 15(1). "Removed" and "brought" engage section 15(1)(a), "takes". "Kept" engages section 15(1)(a), "detains". "At no point did B agree" engages section 15(1), "without that other's consent". "Intentionally or recklessly" is inferred from the deliberate acts. Section 15(1)(b), "causes to be taken or detained", would apply if A directed someone else to do the acts, and section 15(1)(c), "otherwise restricts the personal liberty of", covers restrictions such as blocking a person's way.
Every element is met by a fact, with no legal conclusion. A court that refuses it has to say this conduct is not an offence.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
Finding an Irish Official's Address for a Private Prosecution
1. Set out the conduct. Write down what the Irish official did, when and where, as plain facts. Match each fact to an element of the offence in the statute. You don't have to negative any exception or defence (Order 15, rule 9).
2. Write to the body that holds their records. Ask its head, such as a Commissioner, Secretary General or Chief Executive, to attend the District Court voluntarily on a set date, or to send someone from the office, to identify the official and produce the record of their address. Set a deadline and keep proof of sending.
3. Let the deadline pass. A refusal or no reply shows the evidence won't be given voluntarily, which section 13 of the Petty Sessions (Ireland) Act 1851 requires.
4. Lay your information before a District Court Judge, on oath and in writing (Form 15.3). Set out the facts and what you know of the official's identity, state that the address is unknown, and exhibit your letter and any reply.
5. Ask for a witness summons in the same application. Under section 13(1) and Order 21, rule 1, ask the Judge to summon the head of the body to produce the identifying records, and to adjourn your summons application to that date.
6. Serve the witness summons at least three clear days before the return date (Order 21, rule 1(3)).
7. Attend on the return date. Once the records are produced, the Judge can issue the summons with the address included (Order 15, rule 3(1)). If the witness fails to attend without just excuse, prove service and ask for a warrant.
8. Serve the summons on the official for the hearing date it fixes.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
It's up to everyone in Ireland to hold Irish officials accountable to our laws and courts. Nobody is above the law. Have sworn facts? Your local District Court is open to you. That's how our rights are protected and vindicated.
#NobodyAboveTheLaw #OpenJustice #FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
Nobody Is Exempt Because of Where They Work
The Oireachtas wrote offences that apply to Garda members and Courts Service staff exactly as they apply to everyone else, and it gave every person a route to put the facts before a District Court Judge. I traced that law from 1851 to today, and the chain never breaks: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter
#OpenJustice
#NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
#RuleOfLaw
I will ask the High Court whether its restriction order stops me laying sworn information's before a District Court Judge, a right every citizen has had for 175 years. I’m publishing the motion, affidavit and submissions in full so everyone can see how access to justice works: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter
#OpenJustice
#NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
#RuleOfLaw
These are the words viewers heard in the video. Every label in them comes from three charge sheets, and none of those sheets states any act. One recites the wording of section 6 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 1994. One says only that I "assaulted" a named person. One cites "Section 19" with no subsection and says I "did resist/wilfully obstruct" a Garda member. Statutory wording like that tells the public nothing about what happened, but it lets anyone who repeats it paint whatever picture the words suggest. Whoever writes the charge sheet controls the narrative long before any court hears a word of evidence.
The rules of the District Court provide a different picture. Order 17, rule 1(1) requires the particulars of the offence alleged to be set out on the charge sheet. In my notice of motion before the Dublin Metropolitan District Court, which I have already shared with you, I asked the court to amend the three charge sheets to do exactly that. The particulars I proposed are taken from the prosecution's own witness statements. Drafted that way, the charges would allege that I did shout the words "arrest" and "commissioner"; that I did grab the right forearm of Mr John Hiney with a strong grip and said I was arresting him; and that I did grab onto a bench and try to resist being removed from the courtroom by Garda Michael McGrath, using the carpet as a grip to further impede him.
Look at the picture, then read those words from my notice of motion. The same allegations, two very different stories. The first is built from labels that only a judge may apply after a trial. The second is what is actually alleged, which you, a reporter and the court can weigh for yourselves.
As my notice of motion makes clear, those particulars are the prosecution's account, not mine, and I do not admit their accuracy. I reserve my right to answer the truth of each complaint once the charge sheets state the conduct alleged, as the law requires. When the Garda members who draft charge sheets and the officers who prosecute in the Director's name follow the rules of court, the facts tell the story. When they don't, the labels do.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #OpenJustice #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee
The courts of justice in this country belong to the people of Ireland. They do not belong to corrupt actors working within our State, nor to those who make it their business to shield them. The people established these courts through their Constitution to administer justice openly and fairly, and that purpose cannot be bent to suit anyone who would rather never answer for what they have done.
Fundamental rights are not handed down at the discretion of officials. They are guaranteed by the Constitution, and they are not extinguished because people working for the State are too cowardly to take responsibility for their own actions. A right that could vanish on those terms would be no right at all.
That conduct will not stay in the shadows. It will be sworn, fact by fact, before our courts, for judges and juries to adjudicate on. That is how justice works under the rule of law, and no one who works for the State is beyond its reach.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
On Monday I ask the High Court to let facts that have never been tried go before a District Court Judge. Every citizen has the right to swear to facts and seek process against anyone, whoever employs them: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#NobodyAboveTheLaw #FundamentalRightsMatter #OpenJustice #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #RuleOfLaw
A national newspaper told the public I was charged with assault, obstruction and threatening, abusive or insulting behaviour. None of those words says what I actually did. They are offence labels copied from charge sheets that state no act, yet they reached the public as though they described real events, before any trial: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
The truth lives in the facts, and the law still gives us a way to be heard. One judge in the High Court has closed off the civil process that would have let the actions of certain Garda members and Courts Service staff be examined on the facts and judicially determined. That door may be shut, but the search for the truth hasn't ended.
The Oireachtas did not leave the people of Ireland without a remedy. Under the criminal law, any member of the public can bring wrongdoing before the courts in their own name. The District Court is still open. Beyond it are the Circuit Criminal Court and, where the matter is serious enough, the Central Criminal Court. Our elected representatives put these paths into law for exactly the moment when other doors close.
Nobody is above the rules they swore to uphold. A Garda member or court official who acts outside the law must answer for it personally, in a court where evidence is tested and a decision is made on what actually happened. Ignoring the facts doesn't make them disappear.
So I will keep going, calmly and lawfully, one step at a time. Learn your rights, read the law for yourself, and don't accept that a closed door is the end of the road. Justice depends on ordinary people who are willing to put the facts on the record and let the law do its work.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice #TruthInTheFacts #PrivateProsecution
Mullingar District Court Finds the DPP's Own Approved Wording Inadequate, and a Witness Summons Now Requires the Director to Explain It
This morning, at around 11.30 a.m., the District Court in Mullingar told me that the information I laid before it was inadequate.
That information was not my own invention. It was the statutory offence wording approved by the Director of Public Prosecutions for section 6 of the Criminal Justice (Public Order) Act 1994, offence code A6144, set out word for word as the Director's Office approved it. It is the same wording, word for word, on which I was sent to Cloverhill Prison. It is the same wording on which the same court is allowing a prosecution against me to proceed. And it is the wording used across the country, day after day, to bring members of the public before the District Court to answer for their personal liberty.
So the question is a simple one. If that wording is inadequate when a member of the public lays it before the court, how can it be adequate when it is used against a member of the public? The words do not change depending on who holds the pen. Either they state an offence or they do not.
When a person is brought before the District Court, the substance of the complaint is put to them and they are asked whether they admit its truth. Only if they do not admit it does the court go on to hear evidence. That means the complaint itself has to carry the truth the accused is asked to admit. But the approved wording was settled long before the events it is now used to describe. What knowledge could the Director's Office have had, when it approved those words, of what any person did on any particular day?
A witness summons has now issued under Order 21 of the District Court Rules requiring Catherine Pierse, the Director of Public Prosecutions, to attend Mullingar District Court on the 26th of November 2026 at 10.30 a.m. The summons requires her to bring the record of the approval of this wording, who gave it, and the knowledge or information on which it was approved. If there is no such knowledge, the court and the public deserve to hear that plainly.
I act in my own name as a member of the public, using the same words and the same court forms that are used every day to bring people before the courts. I will keep the public informed of what happens on the 26th.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
The Irish Times has published a story based on the judgment of Mr Justice Brian Cregan. There is another side to the events that judgment describes, and I intend to set it out in a court of law, where evidence can be tested under oath.
On 11 October 2024, at the Central Office of the High Court, I was falsely imprisoned and assaulted. I name those I hold responsible as Courts Service staff members Kim Duffy, Colin Shorthall and Samuel, together with George Magdelina, a Garda member who is now suspended, and four other Garda members. On 11 November 2024, at the same office, I was again assaulted, and I say Kim Duffy and George Magdelina assaulted me causing harm.
These are serious allegations and I do not make them lightly. I have laid sworn informations before the Dublin Metropolitan District Court so that each person can answer for their conduct according to law. Everyone is entitled to a fair hearing, and I am entitled to mine. Personal liberty and bodily integrity are not suspended at the door of a court office, and nobody working inside one is above the law that protects them.
I will pursue this in the open, through the proper criminal process, and I will keep the public informed as it moves forward.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
How Can Your Council Help You?
Every council area in Ireland has needs that go unheard. A footpath nobody fixes, a street light that stays dark, a crossing that never comes. One complaint on its own is easily forgotten, but when many people raise the same need, it becomes something that can't be ignored.
The Constitution recognises your council as a forum for the democratic representation of your community, and the law gives your elected councillors real tools to act. What's missing is a clear picture of what people actually need.
I'm gathering needs from all 31 council areas across Ireland. It takes less than a minute. Just two questions: which council area you live in, and what you need your council to do. No name, no email and no sign-in required. Every week I'll count what comes in and publish what I find: 👇
patrickmcgreal.substack.com/…
#HowCanYourCouncilHelpYou #LocalGovernment #CommunityVoice #FundamentalRightsMatter #Ireland
Asking the High Court for Directions Before I Give Information to a District Court Judge
On 16 October 2026 I delivered a letter by hand to the Commissioner of An Garda Síochána. I gave notice that I would lay sworn informations before a Judge of the District Court in Dublin alleging false imprisonment and assault causing harm, and I asked that specified Garda records be preserved and produced to the court.
The reply did not come from the Commissioner. On 3 November 2026 the Chief State Solicitor's Office wrote to me instead. A solicitor employed in that office, a civil servant, described my intended application to a judge as "collateral and vexatious" and linked it to civil proceedings in the High Court. Civil proceedings are separate from the criminal jurisdiction of the District Court.
The Oireachtas gave every member of the public the right to give information to a District Court judge, and it gave the District Court the jurisdiction to decide what happens next. The Court of Appeal has recognised that the District Court can be trusted with the criminal jurisdiction the Oireachtas has entrusted to it. I can find no law that gives the Chief State Solicitor's Office any role in a criminal matter before the District Court.
That letter caused me to step back on 6 November. Rather than risk acting against any order of the court, I have now asked the High Court for directions so that I can proceed with certainty.
The folder linked below holds three documents: my email to the High Court, the letter I received from the Chief State Solicitor's Office, and my letter to the Commissioner of 16 October:
drive.google.com/drive/folde…
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
On 13 May 1937, Dáil Éireann debated the draft Constitution. The 1922 Constitution had said that the liberty of the person is inviolable and that no person shall be deprived of his liberty except in accordance with law. The 1937 text chose different words. Article 40.4.1° says: "No citizen shall be deprived of his personal liberty save in accordance with law." Article 40.4.2° keeps "any person" for the complaint of unlawful detention. The drafters had the word "person" in front of them and wrote "citizen" for the guarantee.
In the same debate, Éamon de Valera explained what "in accordance with law" was meant to secure: "What you have got to provide against is that, if his liberty is to be taken away from him… these things will be done in accordance with the due process of law and not according to the arbitrary will of an individual."
That is the question at the heart of my third complaint. Citizens of Ireland are serving sentences on admissions to approved offence wording, drafted and approved in advance by individuals, which states no word spoken and no act done. I say a deprivation of personal liberty resting on such wording is not in accordance with the due process of law.
The text of the Constitution governs, but the debate shows what the guarantee was meant to protect. I aim to have the complaint before the High Court, on affidavit, early next week.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice
The Third Complaint Is Being Prepared
Over the next few days I will be studying the Data Catalogue for Key Criminal Justice System Datasets, an assessment of the efficiency of bail laws in Ireland, and the relevant case law, to show how modern technology and records already held can identify when citizens of Ireland are deprived of their personal liberty otherwise than in accordance with law. I aim to have my third Article 40 complaint filed early next week, grounded on affidavit with legal submissions. Each complaint identifies what the next must achieve. Step by step, the aim is a full enquiry by the High Court, because this is a systemic, structural problem in the administration of justice.
#FundamentalRightsMatter #NoFeeOnStateGuarantee #OpenJustice













