
Twitter account for my YouTube channel Pale Blue Thoughts - A channel promoting Scientific Temper and Humanism. #AntiPseudosscience #AntiAlternateMedicines
India
Joined December 2021
- Tweets640
- Following101
- Followers821
- Likes1.4K
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
Multiple students at an Ayurveda Medical College fell ill and they were shifted to a real hospital for diagnosis and treatment.
But these are the same practitioners who call themselves "doctors" and are even allowed to perform laparoscopic surgery in India after masters degree in Ayurveda. Who's playing whom? Govt. playing the students or Ayurveda "doctors" playing the public?
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
Something important.
Dear friends, my recently concluded talk is now available to watch on YouTube.
Before I started my session, I put out a disclaimer that alternative medicine practitioners seated in the audience might find my talk extremely triggering. This is one session I thought would be taken down by alternative medicine (Ayush) regulators in India...
...because I do not mince my words at all, about the massive public-fund wastage called Ayush.
For students who are planning to join Ayurveda or Homeopathy or such Ayush-related colleges for professional training... or those parents who are planning to send their children to Ayush - especially Ayurveda-related professional colleges to make a career out of it, this video will mess up your mind - and rightly so.
This is one video, which I would like everyone to watch, share and promote.... especially among those trying to get into alternative medicine colleges in India as a career option because they will be given the title of 'Dr".
Let us stop wasting our childrens future in India by sending them to a career of deceit and fraud - in alternative medicine - just for the legal (but never practical or logical) 'Dr' title.
Sacred Poisons | The Liver Doc | RenaiESSENSE'26
youtu.be/jQDmse4Jod0 via @esSENSEGlobal
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
Trusted @EurekaForbes and @Aquaguard for a water purifier. Instead got false installation commitments, a tech w/o ID, & a local mgr who refused responsibility. Esc to Snr. mgmt & consumer authorities. CM-121225-63467533 @AquaguardCare @jagograhakjago @consumeraffairs @nch1915
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
Replying to @theliverdoc
Yes 🙌🏾
Mincing words just makes things murky. Better to be raw and on face.
“I talk directly, without beating around the bush. Do not go to an Ayurveda practitioner, do not take advice from a Homeopath, do not listen to a Naturopath, avoid other alternative forms of medicine such as Siddha and Unani. Do not consume unregulated products, herbal and dietary supplements. Do not trust the ones who are trying to sell you such products. Their products are untested. They are all healthcare liabilities, not assets to public health.”
👍🏾👍🏾
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
📣🙏
A private Ayurveda company filed a criminal defamation case against me and my co-authors for publishing the case of a child who developed severe Ayurvedic herbal injury from their products and nearly died.
Today, the honorable High Court of Kerala passed the judgement to stay all proceedings against all of us, the "accused (doctors and scientists)."
We doctors and authors of the study collectively paid close to INR 800,000 ($9200) in legal fees to defend our peer reviewed publication and scientific evidence.
It is a small win for medical science, but there is a huge battle up ahead as multiple lawyer sources tell me that the Ayurveda industry in Kerala is preparing for a coordinated attack on me (and my coauthors) for publishing reports on harms of alternative medicine and educating the public on the same.
I need the public's support on fighting the alternative medicine mafia in the near future because now, the playing field has changed. It is no longer my personal fight (it never was), but now it is the people against pseudoscience.
Through my lawyers and our rationalist group, Mission for Ethics and Science in Healthcare (MESH), I intend to plead for crowdfunding support to carry on not just the defensive, but also take the offensive on Ayurveda, Homeopathy, Siddha, Unani and Naturopathy quacks that have been misleading, misinforming, and mistreating the public and patients.
They may be an unstoppable force, but we intend to be the immovable object, to protect and shield you, from the harms of pseudoscience, with your continuous help and support.
cc: @arifhussaintm @Lucythebiped @DrTonyPhilip
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
Sadhguru started having a headache since 1st week of March.
He neglected it.
He even attended and performed at Maha Shiva Rathri night on March 8.
His headaches got worse.
He neglected it.
A week later headaches became excruciating. On 15th March he checked himself into a hospital.
The neurologist identified a large few weeks old bleed in the brain and areas of new bleed.
Emergency admission and management advised.
Sadhguru neglected it because he had India Conclave Meeting to attend.
Two days later, after he started losing consciousness and losing control of one limb, he checked in again with the Neurologist.
Right after admission his consciousness worsened and new CT scan showed brain swelling and compression of brain against the skull.
Sadhguru then said "Now is the time to operate."
Emergency medical science and skilled surgical intervention saved him.
I hope he recovers well, and wish him the best.
Remember we are all human.
It was very foolish of Sadhguru and especially his advisors to neglect the doctor's advise and convert this easily controllable situation into a life threatening one.
I learned it the hard way when I had a near fatal accident.
Don't make your work your life.
Consciousness means "bloody hell listen to your doctor." Nothing else.
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
I am not sure if anyone is following this, but the Supreme Court of India pummeling the charlatan Baba Ramdev, his pseudoscientific balderdash Ayurveda company and their obnoxious anti-science advertisements is better than the best Indian Premier League Cricket seasons you've ever watched.
This special season is brought to you by The Indian Medical Association👌
#SupremeCourt hears Indian Medical Association’s plea regarding misinformation against Allopathy.
The Association has also called out Swami Ramdev, Patanjali Co-founder, for making controversial statements against Allopathy
#SupremeCourt #Misinformation
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
The Pharmacovigilance Department in India will very enthusiastically warn about Meftal Spas and the rarest of its side effects, but will never warn public on traditional Ayurvedic herbals such as these that nearly killed a young woman from herbal liver injury.
No labels, no ingredients list, no safety studies, no good manufacturing seal, and no dosing schedule.
Also included a white powder named "Arthritis Bhasma" for rheumatoid arthritis.
By the way, that stick on the side was also part of treatment. Juiced with milk daily.
Patient is alive.
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
#OTD in 1996, Carl Sagan died: 27 years without Carl
«When my husband died, because he was so famous and known for not being a believer, many people would come up to me ― it still sometimes happens ― and ask me if Carl changed at the end and converted to a belief in an afterlife.
They also frequently ask me if I think I will see him again. Carl faced his death with unflagging courage and never sought refuge in illusions. The tragedy was that we knew we would never see each other again. I don't ever expect to be reunited with Carl.
But, the great thing is that when we were together, for nearly twenty years, we lived with a vivid appreciation of how brief and precious life is. We never trivialized the meaning of death by pretending it was anything other than a final parting.
Every single moment that we were alive and we were together was miraculous-not miraculous in the sense of inexplicable or supernatural. We knew we were beneficiaries of chance.
That pure chance could be so generous and so kind. That we could find each other, as Carl wrote so beautifully in Cosmos, you know, in the vastness of space and the immensity of time. That we could be together for twenty years. That is something which sustains me and it’s much more meaningful.
The way he treated me and the way I treated him, the way we took care of each other and our family, while he lived. That is so much more important than the idea I will see him someday. I don't think I'll ever see Carl again. But I saw him. We saw each other. We found each other in the cosmos, and that was wonderful».
― Ann Druyan
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
Is Baba Ramdev bigger than the Supreme Court of India? Clear violation and Contempt of Court, but in new India, it's perfectly fine to do so and then file cases against the Supreme Court judges. Wow!
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
Wake up babe, I am quitting my job as a Hepatologist because the Ayurveda community has just published scientific evidence on how turmeric acts as a liver detox.
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
The American College of Gastroenterology annual meeting #ACG2023 is ongoing.
Here are some interesting (and sometimes weird) reports of liver injury caused by various drug, herb and dietary supplements presented at the meeting.
(h/t @john_damianosMD)
Please share so that others will also benefit from this knowledge.
Apart from the usual suspects, there were some new and strange causes for severe liver injury.
👉Ashwagandha features again. Ashwagandha supplements are banned in Denmark and the rest of EU is also looking at removing Ashwagandha based herbal formulations from shelves. We published the largest series of Ashwagandha liver injury recently. You can check it out here: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3775…
👉Unknown to many, Aloe vera is a silent cause for severe liver injury and sometimes liver failure. It is rare, but since Aloe vera has no clinically relevant use, it is better to avoid oral intake, even though liver damage is rarely seen. Read more about it here: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK54…
👉Then there were liver damage due to herbal teas (Anamu tea - which is Jamaican Guinea Hen Weed reported here) and 👉plant-based food supplements (Tara Flour - a new plant-based protein made from seeds of South American tree Tara spinosa)
Reports also featured severe liver injury 👉due to multi-herbal supplements such as
[1] Progidy HRP-AID (OTC supplement for Herpes infection - not approved, not studied) containing Astralagus, Echinacea, Garlic powder, Caffeine, Olive leaf, Oregano, Elderberry, Red Ginseng --> showing dangers with mixing herbs leading to liver damage versus potential safety with singular use of these herbs in diet/cooking.
[2] Fat burner supplement called Okinawa Flat Belly Tonic and another called Albutarex V2. Fat burners are absolute waste of money (and sometimes life, as seen in this report presented, the patient died of acute liver failure). This particular product contained known liver toxic agents such as grapeseed, turmeric, bitter melon extract, and green tea extracts.
👉 Strange cases of liver failure was noted with Elderberry Syrup (first time I am hearing about it) and 👉a well known liver toxic agent used as "colon cleanse," Senna (be aware of Senna based laxative formulations prepared by Ayurvedic or Homeopathic companies). Read more about Senna here: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK54…
👉 Other agents causing liver injury included Iberogast, a proprietary herbal supplement developed in 1961 in Germany, "advertised" for irritable bowel syndrome (without evidence) and contains Bitter candytuft, Angelica, Chamomile, Caraway, St Mary's thistle, Lemon balm, Peppermint, Greater celandine and Liquorice - some well known to produce liver injury, such as Greater Celandine.
In fact, another report does show 👉Greater Celandine liver injury. Even though rare, Celandine liver injury can be fatal and lead to multiple organ failure. Knowing well that Celandine herb has no clinically relevant benefits, its better to stay away from such supplements, rather than become that rare case report. Read more on Celandine liver toxicity here: ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK54…
There was also a strange case of liver injury related to consumption of supplements containing 👉SEA MOSS. Apparantly, sea moss contains Carrageenan (look for this, its seen in many supplements) that can stimulate natural killer cells in our body that attack the liver through a complex inflammatory cascade (scary).
And last but not the least, 👉turmeric related liver injury keeps getting featured on the hit list time and again. Turmeric (especially the highly bioavailable forms) supplements are one of the most common causes for severe liver injury leading to liver failure and death (as shown in this report) in the West. Many countries are now giving black box warning to turmeric supplements worldwide. Turmeric is good in curries, dangerous in capsules. Remember this please. Read more on it here: pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3625…, here tga.gov.au/news/safety-alert… and here bpspubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.…
The meeting also discusses liver injury due to modern medicines, most of which are already known and all of which have proven benefits (>>>>risk), unlike the herbal and dietary supplements, which have no benefits, but more so, risks.
You can read these reports in detail on the #ACG2023 E-poster page and using the search bar function: acg2023posters.eventscribe.n…
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
How to read a potentially toxic multiherbal supplement even when modern medicine doctors fail at reading them for you?
Modern medicine practitioners are prescribing this proprietary Ayurvedic multiherbal cough syrup far too much - and its shameful.
Firstly, this is a proprietary product - meaning, the company has made it according to their arbitary thoughts on combinations of herbs that may or may not work without scientific rationale or actual product testing. This is not classical/traditional Ayurveda, but a product made on whims and fancies of the manufacturer.
Two, the product indication is misleading - "all purpose formula for all types of cough." - fools. There can never be one single way to reduce or treat ALL types of cough - a cough can be a benign symptom of a passing seasonal flu or can be a signficant lung or heart disease or primary or metastatic cancer.
The duration of the symptom divides cough into acute (less than 3 weeks), subacute (3–8 weeks), and chronic (greater than 8 weeks) and treatments are aimed at CAUSE for the cough and not cough per say.
See here: binasss.sa.cr/medintmarzo/AR…
Three, this product is multiherbal in nature - meaning, in the absence of safety data for use, there is high risk of developing organ damage due to presence of certain known herbal toxins in this product. The manufacturer has made no such disclosures on the product that would ideally help people be well-informed before taking a decision whether to use the product or not.
Toxic herbs in the product:
1. Cassia occidentalis (or Coffee Senna) - The product uses seeds of Kasmard (or Cassia occidentalis). Signs of Cassia occidentalis seeds poisoning in general include imbalance, muscle weakness, incoordination, stubbing, and body weight loss, eventually leading to death. Certain types of anthraquinones and their derivatives emodin, glycosides, toxallauminus and other alkaloids were among the compounds blamed for the toxicity of Cassia occidentalis. They mainly affect skeletal muscles, liver, kidney, and heart. See here: nopr.niscpr.res.in/bitstream…
2. Curcuma longa (or turmeric, haldi) - Turmeric, along with pepper (also seen in the product) or piperine to increase its absorption is now one of most common upcoming causes for severe liver injury and liver failure sometimes leading to death or liver transplantation. The Italian Govt has banned turmeric-based dietary supplements and given them "black box" warning. The Australian Govt has warned the public on using turmeric supplements and cautioned, due to liver damaging effects and the UK Govt has warmed people of high risk of hepatitis with consumption of turmeric based supplements.
See here amjmed.com/article/S0002-934…, here cot.food.gov.uk/sites/defaul… here nutraingredients.com/Article… and here tga.gov.au/news/safety-alert…
3. Glycyrrhiza glabra or licorice: Licorice ingestion/toxicity causes tachy-brady arrhythmias (heart rate problems), fatal arrhythmias (heart rhythmn problems, possibly due to hypokalemia), and cardiomyopathy (heart muscle damage). Imagine if this product is given to a patient whose cough is due to underlying heart disease, then it could turn catastrophic. See here sciencedirect.com/topics/neu… and here pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2883…
There are no safety data available from human studies on the other herbal components in this product.
Summary: If modern medicine doctors are prescribing untested, unregulated, multiherbal [Ayurvedic/Sidda or proprietary] products - then the best option is to change your doctor after dumping the product in the nearest available garbage bin.
Be well-informed about supplements you are prescribed or take. It may help avoid a catastrophe.
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
#Himalaya is now fathering tom, dick and harry...!
In the twisted realm of public health and legal system, the defamation suit by #Himalaya has taken an absurd turn now. It all began when the "arrogant and Rude" but courageous @theliverdoc dared to expose the deceitful practices of an alternative medicine fraud company, who was engaged in selling dangerous herbal supplements like #Liv52, in the guise of protecting liver, which in fact was killing people. Little did he know that his act of bravery would open the floodgates for every Tom, Dick, and Harry of the Alternative Medicine Juggernaut to file defamation suits against him...!
While @theliverdoc tirelessly fought to protect the well-being of the public, these charlatans saw fit to divert attention away from their own dubious practices. They are now concocting tales of defamation, hoping to ride the coattails of the original lawsuit and gain their own momentary fame and money. It is a sickening display of selfishness and a blatant disregard for the lives of innocent people.
As the defamation suits are piling up like a mountain of absurdity, @theliverdoc is finding himself drowning in paperwork and court appearances. Time that could have been spent researching new treatments or saving lives is now squandered on defending himself against these baseless claims. The irony is not lost on anyone who witness this farce unfold.
In the midst of this legal circus, the real victims are forgotten. The public's health, their safety, and their trust are all pushed aside in favor of the egos and greed of these fraudulent alternative medicine aka poison peddling companies.
It is a sad state of affairs when the legal system becomes a playground for fraudsters, and the pursuit of justice is overshadowed by the pursuit of personal gains. As the defamation suits continue to pour in, one can only hope that the truth would prevail, and @theliverdoc's noble efforts to expose these fraudsters would not be in vain.
Arif Hussain Theruvath
07/10/2023
#StandWithTheLiverDr #BringBackTheLiverDr #EndAlternativeMedicine #SavePublicHealth #HimalayanBlunder
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
📽️ Experience the essence of #Litmus23, the world's largest atheist gathering! Watch this video to see what it was like to be there.
Pale Blue Thoughts retweeted
"You can't convince someone of something if their salary depends on them not understanding it"
I keep thinking of this quote when I see 𝗮𝗹𝘁𝗲𝗿𝗻𝗮𝘁𝗶𝘃𝗲 𝗺𝗲𝗱𝗶𝗰𝗶𝗻𝗲 practitioners refusing to acknowledge either the lack of or the poor quality of research in their fields. I kind of understand the situation they’re in. They’ve invested so much of their lives in studying and practicing their field that all the years spent and all the hours of hard work they’ve put in would be for nothing. If I were in their shoes, I would feel a kind of denial where I would try to resist any criticism against my tribe and make attempts at attacking their tribe.
This is called the 𝘀𝘂𝗻𝗸-𝗰𝗼𝘀𝘁 𝗳𝗮𝗹𝗹𝗮𝗰𝘆. It’s like a gambler on a losing streak. He would try and bet even higher in an attempt to win all the lost money back. It’s like a gambler who’s in denial that he’s lost money.
It’s not like those who criticize you lack empathy and they can’t see that they’re attacking your profession. They’re doing this for 𝗽𝘂𝗯𝗹𝗶𝗰 𝗵𝗲𝗮𝗹𝘁𝗵. There’s no big pharma mafia that’s paying them to say any of this. They’re bringing well designed research with peer reviewed results and evidence to back up what they say.
I know it’s not feasible for most people to go back 5+ years of their lives and start an MBBS path from scratch. But if you feel this spells doom for your career, no it doesn’t. There are so many medical fields that you can branch into that don't require you to consult with or prescribe drugs/treat patients directly. They’re things like:
Nutrition
Medical research
Paraclinical options
Paramedical options
Public Health
Hospital Administration
Medical Transcription
Physiotherapy
Pharmacology etc.
You can talk to medical professionals for more options to try and 𝘀𝘄𝗶𝘁𝗰𝗵 𝘆𝗼𝘂𝗿 𝗰𝗮𝗿𝗲𝗲𝗿. I know people from an alternative medicine background who are doing really well in their career in nutrition, research, modern medicine, etc. Remember, we’re in a fight for public health. Not a fight against alternative medicine. I know I’ve said this before in videos but I’m typing it out here also for more reach. Please share this with anyone who might need to see this.
































