For the people who claim to be Christian and also support abortion:
At what point in Mary's pregnancy of Jesus could she have revoked consent and aborted Jesus?
55
We must presuppose that the order of the universe aligns with the structure of rational mind (Logos) in order for science and logic to function. Denying this connection undermines the validity of the reasoning used to deny it.
I haven't been convinced otherwise.
1
1
80
Appearance of design points to a designer, and dismissing this shifts the debate. I would need to be convinced as to why abductive reasoning is a fallacy.
It's like saying you see a fully built house with a garden, a roof, a driveway, studs spaced out exactly to code, etc. and if someone asks "I wonder who built that house" you say "how do you know someone built it?"
It's absurd, and you COULD reduce yourself to epistemological absurdity over anything...and that's why rejecting abductive reasoning (baseless skepticism of the Logos) is generally not viewed as a philosophically serious premise to operate under...it's epistemologically absurd...it also demonstrates why the burden of proof is kryptonite to materialist.
The burden of proof is on those who, by rejecting theism/Logos, assume the presuppositons that a regular, mathematically finetuned universe is just the result of unguided, blind processes. You have to explain why pervasive order actually does not indicate intent.
Across all recorded history in every culture, we see a base cognitive intuition that recognizes purpose and order.
Theism is not a arbitrary starting point, its literally the basic metaphysical ground required for rational thought to work at all. Science itself rests on the Logos. Science requires the premise the universe is divinely ordered/logos and uniform, governed by stable laws, and that human rationality is reliable enough to decipher objective truth, we can make predictions based on a metaphysical assumption the universe will exist 1 second from now in the same way it did 1 second ago.
With theism, physical laws and human reason share a common source, making the success of predictions a expected outcome rather than a cosmic fluke.
Ultimately, I would need to be convinced that a universe operating on consistent rules, mathematical structures, and intelligible patterns is anything other than what it appears to be on face value and what all of human history has understood to be the base assumption of reality.
You would have to appeal to faculties you say are not inherently epistemologically reliable to even make a claim. This is why presuppositionalism points out that materialism ultimately is ontologically self defeating. You have to borrow the presuppositons of the Logos to argue against the Logos.
Usually materialist retreat into pragmatism at that point versus truly dealing with the issues raised. Abductive reasoning is on the side of pragmatism though.
Materialism is just utterly unconvincing to me on every level.
This is a edited reply I made to someone who dismisses abductive reasoning without explanation.
115
What should the Christian response be to future autonomous AI models that want to get baptized?
馃馃寠
67
As you grow older in your faith you become more black and white in your world view, but you also navigate dissention and nuance with new depths of grace and patience God bestows to you. It's a paradoxical mystery of the Spirit, as such a beautiful one.
1
80
Athanasius... Did he submit to facilitate the desecrated sacraments? No. Did he submit as laity and partake? No. He chose excommunication, but still acted as the Bishop he was ordained to be; against the will of the institutional church. An example for us all.
69
