Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard) profile picture

"The intensity of the conviction that a hypothesis is true has no bearing on whether it is true or not." - Sir Peter Medawar, Advice to a Young Scientist (1979)

Joined October 2013
Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)Photo by Bill Burgess (@ProfSondergaard)
The problem is risk aversion, not funding priorities. "Grants to individual researchers" go through risk-averse, grant-dependent institutions. Those institutions hire and fire for safety, not independent brilliance. The institutional model is far more broken than the priorities.
It's a bad idea. If you dictate scientists just what to work on, you will get a low return on investment. The current science funding schemes ALREADY have this problem: pour money into some specific program, see scientists produce something that fits into the program to get the money --> topic is overcrowded with incremental and nonsense research that mostly leads nowhere. It's inefficient for the same reason planned economies are inefficient. Scientists need MORE freedom to do what they want, not less. teapawt.net/NewsfromScience/status…
62
They’re psychological suicide bombers: gladly creating hell, even for themselves, as long as (a) they have control and (b) however bad it is for them, it’s even worse for you. Then they blame their own sadism on you and call themselves victims. They win, even when they lose.
Replying to @JulieLevineArt
Yep and revenge is not the same as cause and effect. Everyone gets consequences… not only the innocent. Keeping someone prisoner for wanting a divorce is actually insane.
1
62
Those who seek to demonize healthy boundaries are themselves the demons.
Standing up for your rights should never lead to being labeled as irrational or crazy. Such accusations often serve as a means for others to evade their own responsibilities. There is nothing inherently wrong with advocating for yourself.
1
85
Some "disempowering ideas"— - Without credentials, you aren't qualified to have an opinion. - You're overthinking, it's all in your head. - Why are you so selfish and negative? Relax. Try having some gratitude. - It takes two to tango. - You're not entitled to boundaries.
Replying to @karenmitchell__
"8. Pushes ideas (either subtly or not so subtly) that disempower those who have been abused by narcissists, psychopaths." I'd like to know more about this.
1
3
197
Despairingly, those who don't recognize the signs are likely to support the predators' accusatory narrative. My red flag for a predatory narrative — whether repeated by the predator or by an unwitting flying monkey — is the embedded concept "you're either with us or against us".
Replying to @karenmitchell__
And I’d add, I suspect anyone who has experienced gaslighting, coercive control, narcissistic rage etc at any level is probably handling this better than those who don’t recognise the signs
2
8
164
Their hand could literally be in the cookie jar — and they'll angrily shout that they have been forgoing the cookies for you, lamenting (while eating the cookies) your self-centered ungrateful refusal to acknowledge their noble sacrifice...then graciously offering to forgive you.
The classic malignant narcissist approach to being exposed: - attack, attack, attack - lie, lie, lie - blame, blame, blame – throw grenades everywhere so no one knows what’s going on and can’t see the grift, the abuse & the exploitation.
1
4
102
It’s critical to recall that narcissists target only a tiny few at a time; the rest are “wined and dined” with regular compliments, remembrances, and sympathies, all intensely convincing. Throw in the all-too-common power asymmetry…and a standing army of flying monkeys is born.
1
6
156
Flying monkeys / enablers play a truly essential role empowering and protecting abusers. This fantastic comparison reveals how enablers use the “poison the well” logical fallacy to predispose third parties in the abuser’s favor using simple, seemingly innocent spin.
1
1
5
151
We detect extrasolar planets by noticing the effect they have on their sun. Likewise we could detect predators by the effect they have on their targets. But instead we call the person disordered. Imagine if astronomers said, oh, that sun is wobbling oddly, it must be disordered.
Replying to @Shrink_at_Large
Do you know it’s impossible to diagnose a ‘human predator’ from the DSM? Yet there are at least 8 different ways to diagnose ‘prey’, many of whom have been deeply abused, in fact tortured, by the human predator. NPD or ASPD are the closest diagnostic concepts for people who actively violate social norms and harm and disadvantage others by conscious choice but neither of them capture the attributes of the predatorial kind of person/dark personality in a way that a diagnosis can be made. Human predators or dark personalities within the psychiatric profession have set up the entire system to protect their own kind and pathologise normal people, many of whom they have sadistically controlled and harmed. Then you get predators who are diagnosed with BPD which gives it a bad rap, because many mental health professionals don’t fully understand the human predator nor are able or willing to diagnose it, particularly in women and there are millions of human predators that are women on the planet. So they all get a diagnosis of BPD. Additionally, the many millions of people on the planet who are born to human predators and suffer an upbringing of extraordinary pain and suffering have appropriate behaviours and yet where is this dynamic written about in the academic literature or anywhere? We have so far to go!
4
150
Isn't it strange that the common term for an angry outburst by someone who has been deliberately provoked — "reactive abuse" — shifts blame from the instigator to the victim? For 800 years the English language has called it "baiting". Could we call this "baiting abuse"?
Reactive abuse' - which I prefer to call 'reactive defense' - is when a victim who has been suffering prolonged abuse fights back. It is done in self-defence or as a reaction to provocation, but abusers use the situation to further their abusive agenda. shadowsofcontrol.com/article…
1
3
161
Do your most satisfying memories involve someone losing? When arguing, do you easily recall all your counterpart's transgressions going back years? Are most of your problems somebody else's fault? Are challenging questions personal attacks? Does being right justify your acts?
1
2
390
If mental-health utopia could be reached through accusations, narcissists would get there first.
1
12
458