Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK) header
Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK) profile picture

he/him/his; math, nature, politics

Houston, TX
Joined October 2019
Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)Photo by Rafi (رافع) (@Rafi3AK)
The real ∞-categories are the friends we made along the way.
2
2
40
(What I’m about to say is unfalsifiable, but) When a theorem seems an amazing coincidence, that’s usually just an indication that we haven’t yet found either the theoretical context that makes it *feel* inevitable or the wider family of obviously hard results to which it belongs.
The Riemann Hypothesis being true should make you think really hard about whether this universe is completely accidental
1
2
99
But, to be transparent, there are theorems of which I know no such satisfying proof. As a fairly elementary example, for any DVR A, the (convergent) sum over isomorphism classes M of finite A-modules of 1/|M| equals the sum over the same of 1/|Aut(M)|.
1
34
One can prove it straightforwardly combinatorially (keyword: iterated Durfee decomposition), but it feels like there should be more afoot…
15
“Someone claims a Lean verified 17.4M LoC proof of GRH by LLM.” Yeah, whatever. “It’s Alpöge.” Holy shit! “Someone claims a promising 1k pp natural language proof of GRH by human.” Yeah, whatever. “It’s Vakil citing BCnrd, reviewing work by Masullo.” Holy shit!
Btw Alessandro Masullo proposed a proof of GRH several months ago that has been under review by Brian Conrad "... and it is so far looking good." math216.wordpress.com/2026/1…
4
5
1
116
9,612
All in one day!
6
651
This has been the vibe among my mathematician friends since August
Checked the math major groupchat and the current mood is basically this:
1
9
990
(la sel3a jaune = GTM, of course)
72
The McDowells (pics 2 and 3 in the quoted tweet) are super underrated. One can* follow the ridgeline end-to-end (Sunrise TH to Tom’s Thumb TH or vice versa) as a tough but feasible day hike. It comes out to like 15mi + 6000ft AEG.
1
5
214
*Going off-trail in the Preserve is prohibited save with permission. The ridgeline is mostly not on any trail, but the routefinding is largely obvious, and none of the scrambling is particularly difficult.
1
59
Me when I show that X ≃ Y by gratuitously showing first instead that よ(X) ≃ よ(Y):
2
7
1
104
2,377
Replying to @Shartapus
I know we can't get rid of all of them, but the following people are on my primary list (so far): El-Sayed Darializa Hinajosa Mamdani Lander Van Hollen Khanna Jayapal Ilhan Pressley Shiff Flanagan Jackson Kiros Bernie (if he doesn't retire) Markey Summer Lee
1
16
1,502
Is there any publicly available summary of Gödel’s argument that AC is independent of ZF? Is it essentially just the forcing construction? Seems rather significant…
1
1
4
398
Ah, perhaps it’s like this:
Very cool AI-assisted work! I'm currently in an email thread (via Dana Scott) w/ Jan von Plato, who led this effort, & he sent us his Claude-assisted writeup. While Gödel's notes do *not* actually have a proof of the independence of AC from full set theory (ZF), from what I can tell so far: 1. Gödel's notebooks instead contained a proof of independence of the axiom of constructibility in type theory (by 1942). 2. Jan, working w/ Claude, reconstructed and completed Gödel's unfinished argument to prove the independence of the Axiom of Choice *in type theory* (Gödel was missing a key definition that makes comprehension hold in the model where AC fails). 3. In proving 1, Gödel had anticipated, 23-24 years prior, many of the central ideas from Boolean-valued forcing (BVF), which was Dana & Bob Solovay's '65-66 simplification of Cohen's original '63 forcing, for which Cohen got the only Fields Medal in logic. For example, it looks like Gödel had much of the machinery for assigning Boolean truth values to mathematical statements*, but hadn't completed the construction of an entire universe of sets governed by those truth values. * - E.g. Gödel had finite observations playing the role of Cohen forcing conditions, regular open sets as Boolean truth values, and Boolean interpretations of logical connectives & quantifiers. (However, Gödel lacked the full transfinite construction of a Boolean-valued universe of sets, together with a proof that it obeys all the rules of ZF set theory.) 4. On Jan's reading, in how Gödel develops the precursors to Boolean-valued forcing, you can see how his post-1944 Platonism could coexist with his earlier use of intuitionistic methods which, prior to this, was a bit of a puzzle that Sol Feferman & others acknowledged. Namely, Gödel's precursors to BVF support a philosophical view of observations from a finite observer defining neighborhoods of possible worlds & regular open sets giving Boolean truth values. In other words, Gödel believed mathematical reality needn't be limited solely to what a finite observer can construct or determine.
2
86
>an objectively good bill with no downsides at all, all because it actually builds solar farms Accelerating the buildout of solar farms on minimally disturbed land, particularly on top of slow-to-regenerate desert ecosystems, is a downside, genius.
This quoted post is unavailable.
2
174
It’s possible to be both pro-clean energy and anti-wrecking-the-environment. In fact, it’s the standard position of anyone with both a brain and a soul.
1
97
Heartwarming: Humans can write mathslop too!
2
1
176
13,057
Well, that’s next year’s costume sorted. Too bad the midterm wasn’t last week.
Vous êtes prêt pour "Democrat Texas Ranger " ?
3
302
It doesn’t matter—for how long do you think you’ll be able to guide AI better than AI? You’re going to get left behind either way, so just do whatever makes you happy.
Proudly saying “No AI was used in this” is not going to age well. Your agent count is the size of your intelligence. Scale or get left behind.
4
29
1,269
If that means grinding out however many more results in the last few years of human excellence, then do that; if instead it means retaining your dignity and independence and doing math the “old” way, then do that.
1
7
250
Ultimately whatever “your” agents achieve with some fancy prompting infrastructure and $100 of tokens today, any random’s chatbot will achieve with “solve X” and $1 of tokens in a few years. Aside from securing fleeting “credit” for the result, what is the value of the former?
7
162