Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen) profile picture

Totally Traditional

Joined December 2021
Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)Photo by Nazianzen (@RealNazianzen)
Thread of threads John XXIII declining to rule the Church by law teapawt.net/RealNazianzen/status/1… Texts on John XXIII's revolution teapawt.net/RealNazianzen/status/1… The New Church doesn't govern by law teapawt.net/RealNazianzen/status/1… A Dissertation on papal law from 1954 teapawt.net/RealNazianzen/status/1…
Here's a Catholic dissertation from Germany, 1954, that a friend found.
2
6
5
14
9,984
There appears to be confusion in this explanation, to do with "titles" in canon law. A claimant to the papacy who was universally accepted as pope would be pope, but this has nothing to do with a "coloured title" in canon law, which concept is to do with supplied jurisdiction.
Replying to @DTCory
If he converts to the Catholic faith before the juridical sentence, he will automatically become Pope upon converting. Unsentenced heretics, like Leo, can do this. If an imperfect general council condemned Leo before his conversion, he would lose the colored title.
1
2
153
Fr. Coradello quotes no such theologians in his article, of course, because he isn't arguing for either claim. His argument is more modest (if sufficiently weird anyway) - viz. he merely seeks to justify Guerard's "materialiter" as "something" rather than the nothing it is.
1
1
54
For the record, I don't share the horror of Guerard's Thesis that has become somewhat common in recent years. I think it's silly, irrelevant, and a distraction from traditional theology and law, but relatively harmless. Fr. Coradello's article is a great example of all of that.
1
51
Nazianzen retweeted
Replying to @DTCory
Can you explain why you are mentioning a title here? I can't see any connection with anything else you are discussing. It seems totally out of context.
1
1
122
The Catholic Church and the Ending of Slavery In May, Leo XIV ‘apologised’ for the Church’s supposed role in slavery, and failure to end it. This talk considers the accuracy of such claims: wmreview.org/p/catholic-chur…
1
7
22
893
Nazianzen retweeted
Replying to @crean_fr
Newchurch is a big tent. So big, we're literally the only ones not in it. 🤣
1
9
808
Nazianzen retweeted
I'm also confident, on empirical grounds, that without Christ you cannot escape slavery. Slavery is quintessentially the modern state of man. Slavery to sin, leading inexorably to slavery to tyrants. The idea that one can legislate slavery away is typically liberal fantasy.
1
6
154
Nazianzen retweeted
Slavery doesn't come with any moral quandary at all! It's perfectly moral to own slaves! Your view has absolutely no support. The Church transformed society by elevating, by baptism, men to supernatural life. This made slavery, as such, irrelevant. It didn't *prohibit* it.
2
1
4
220
Slavery is, per se, lawful. If it weren't then the Church would have instructed Christians from Pentecost on to free their slaves, as keeping them would have been a sin. She didn't because it isn't, and the theologians are clear that to say that it *is* sinful is a heresy. teapawt.net/habibianalytics/status…
1
1
1
19
1,160
So no, I'm not in favour of slavery. I'm in favour of charity unfeigned, and history already furnished a rich, varied, and immeasurably successful example of how slaves can become responsible men in the establishment of Christendom. We should have repeated that process.
2
6
291