
ALT The Times’s article reported that Justice Scalia wrongly attributed the direct quote “dangerous and unusual” to Blackstone. That is a fact, and one that has also been recognized by a federal appeals court. This reporting is an accurate portrayal of what Justice Scalia did. In the Heller opinion, Justice Scalia chose to put the conjunctive phrase “dangerous and unusual” in direct quotes, and per legal style, citations for direct quotes should reflect the exact wording. Instead, he used a “see” signal to introduce 12 sources, only half of which were conjunctive. The rest, including Blackstone, used the disjunctive “dangerous or unusual.” Following that, the result of the decision was to create a conjunctive doctrine that has since been inaccurately credited to Blackstone in hundreds of court briefs and opinions — including at the Supreme Court. The statement continues in the image.



























