Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl) profile picture

Assistant Professor Methods & Statistics at @OU_Nederland. PhD Educational Sciences and MSc in Psychology from @UniLeiden. Half-Polish, Half-Iraqi, fully Dutch

Netherlands
Joined October 2012
Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)Photo by Ron Pat-El (@RonJPatEl)
Ron Pat-El retweeted
Coming this week: "llmClassificR: Text Classification with Large Language Models, Network Psychometrics, and Calibrated Uncertainty in R"
20
1
86
4,535
Preprint! Psychometric networks are summarized with centrality indices that are sometimes useful and other times not. We show that a node's influence depends heavily on the configuration of edges in the network; its degree distribution. osf.io/preprints/psyarxiv/tk…
1
6
17
587
Inquiry-based learning is so ineffective that anyone with even a remote desire to teach will naturally find themselves inclined to use direct instruction, whether they realize it or not. The elements of inquiry-based instruction are still retained, though, and direct instruction is used as a backup when the former fails. As a result, there's a consistent waste of a significant chunk of class time throughout the year. Some people may think they are using direct instruction when the issue is raised, but there is a big difference between using it as a last resort, or even subconsciously, and using it in its proper way from the start. You are not using direct instruction properly unless it is your primary method of instruction.
The reaction to Sold a Story 2 be like
2
9
1
55
4,792
Ron Pat-El retweeted
My email archive holds exchanges with dozens of statisticians, including legends like David Cox, Arthur Dempster, and David Freedman. Future historians would be amazed at the narrow dogmatic thinking that traditional statistical education can foster--all due to the assumption that probability distributions, once fully estimated, can represent scientific knowledge.
Most students in the quantitative sciences are forced to start their education with statistics, which is a grave mistake, with deep harmful consequences on the way students view science and reality. The next generation should start with causation, to get a scientific view of reality and, only then, take stat-101, for students who want to decorate their papers with p-values and regression analysis. Not sure the imperial forces of statistics would welcome this commonsensical transformation. @soboleffspaces @f2harrell @DagobertIX
4
17
4
162
13,910
מישהו אמר פעם לרבי מליובאוויטש: "היהודים האלה שבמשך כל השנה לא שומרים מצוות ורק ביום כיפור באים לבית הכנסת - זה זיוף. הם בסך הכל מתחפשים יום אחד בשנה". ענה לו הרבי: "הפוך! כל השנה הם מתחפשים. הדמות האמיתית שלהם מתגלה דווקא ביום כיפור". שנה טובה
40
177
8
2,063
50,640
In 1950, Iraq considered Jewish citizens "dual national" and stripped them of their Iraqi citizenship, issuing them single trip passports to a country of their choice (most of them moved to Israel) and stamping on their passports "not allowed to return to Iraq." Iraq never changed its law against dual nationality until the collapse of Saddam's regime in 2003. And you still get Arabs and Iraqis who insist that these Jews left of their own will and were never harassed or forced out. Israel understood the ejection of 750,000 Jews from Arab countries the equivalent of 750,000 Arabs who had left Israel (willfully or forcefully). Israel believed this was a population swap, just like India and Pakistan, around the same time, and Turkey and Greece, 25 years prior. The UN, however, turned the Arab relocation into a lucrative industry, managed by multi-billion dollar agencies over the span of eight decades, thus aborting the swap on the Palestinian side and keeping the conflict burning indefinitely.
17
382
21
1,207
32,818
"If employees are given a free trip to Paris, they are happy. If you give them a free trip to Hawaii, they are happy. But if you offer them the choice between the two destinations, they are less happy, no matter what they choose." a.co/d/0e2JiUkU
63
342
49
3,388
195,017
🚨 New paper in @NatureComms: (annoyingly) using college students to study cross-cultural effects underestimates the size of cultural differences. More education predicts more Westernization. Income & status don't. w/ Cindel White. 1/
3
52
2
242
22,516
Ron Pat-El retweeted
Dan's argument is sharper than "use AI carefully." His real claim: students should only use AI for things they already know how to do *well*. Not brainstorm-with-AI-but-draft-yourself, which is basically what every district policy says. He argues that's the wrong line entirely. His point is that those policies borrow a workplace model — AI as associate, student as lead, product is the thing. But for students, the product isn't the point. The essay itself has no value; it exists so the student practices building an argument, integrating sources, thinking like a reader. Skip that mental work and the assignment is hollow, even if the output looks great. So his real test isn't "how much AI is too much" — it's "would doing this yourself teach you something." If yes, no AI. If you've already mastered it and repeating it teaches nothing, AI's fine — like a calculator once you know arithmetic. I like this argument a lot. And I noticed he never once says "offloading." That word already carries a verdict — like something was shirked. Dan just asks whether a step was a *learning* step or a merely *supportive* one. That's why it matters to me. Most discourse treats any AI use as offloading — a small moral failure — instead of asking Dan's actual question, which is whether that specific step is where the learning happens. His framing lets the answer be boring and mixed: fine here, real cost there. dtwuva.substack.com/p/studen…
11
78
7
370
22,649
Ron Pat-El retweeted
Behold, the Flynn effect! Curiously, we don't see the FE on any tests that people don't train on via cultural osmosis, so reaction times and simple working memory assessments are unfazed. This fits with the fact that the FE isn't a 'real' change in intelligence.
The Flynn effect is absent on Digit Span. Working memory capacity has not increased from 1923 to 2008, despite increased exposure to digit-based tasks in the past century. The Flynn effect is remarkably test-specific.
13
26
1
327
22,864
Ron Pat-El retweeted
New Blog post: Which Data Repository Should you Use? In light of OSF closing down, I compare Zenodo, Dataverse, ResearchBox, PsychArchive, and local repositories on six important dimensions. If you want to know which to pick: It depends! daniellakens.blogspot.com/20…
1
36
2
86
11,286
Ron Pat-El retweeted
This paper gives a fancy name to a problem you can already feel in your bones "The Tragedy of the Cognitive Commons." Checking AI output requires deep expertise. Deep expertise comes from doing grunt work for years. And grunt work is the first thing AI eats So we're building systems that need expert supervision while dismantling the only known process for making experts The paper calls the shared pool of human expertise the "cognitive commons." Every profession drinks from it. Nobody's refilling it. By eliminating junior roles, each company is acting totally rationally, and the collective result: a profession that can't catch AI's mistakes anymore because it never learned to do the work in the first place Who checks AI's homework in 15 years?
326
3,197
364
12,316
609,502
A tool used to rephrase plagiarised text changed "final solution" to "mass killing of an ethnic group" in a chemistry paper. Now retracted thanks to a PubPeer user who spotted this.
278
3,587
632
43,766
3,129,360
A 7-year study of 3,900 social science papers found that only ~50% could be replicated. There was significant variation across fields, however. While more than 60% of political science & econ papers were replicated, only ~25% of sociology & 0% of education papers were.
170
988
418
5,842
1,564,548
A kid will quit a math app in 6 minutes, but grind Factorio for 6 hours. The math app has more points, badges, and streaks. Factorio has none.
137
283
58
11,406
755,589
Ron Pat-El retweeted
Citing articles that you have not read, and which you cannot confirm support the claim you are using that article to make, is literally academic misconduct. Yes, this means you should not do that. If you cannot do that, then don't cite the paper. What are we even doing here??
Replying to @tdietterich @arxiv
So this means you expect every author to check every citation and make sure that every citation is real and accurate? What if it's beyond the ability of one of the authors to verify one of the citations because that citation is in a language he doesn't know or concerns technical material he doesn't understand but another author on the paper does?
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
Yes. Academics (like Miller himself) are responsible for the work they produce, including accurate citation practices and thorough vetting of sources. Miller’s previous and current institutions have policies about this: smith.edu/your-campus/of… college.uchicago.edu/student-servic…
13
231
1
2,025
26,970
This is the best opening paragraph of any textbook I’ve ever read. As a bonus it makes for a terrific start for a horror plot.
70
510
21
5,999
90,078
Ron Pat-El retweeted
I called this meta-analysis out for being hot garbage and it just got retracted a year later. W's in the chat.
8
16
2
538
30,013
I took a UCLA class on causal inference taught by @yudapearl more than 10 years ago. Recently together with my co-author Egor we applied causal DAGs to persuasion. I believe it is worth a read: causality.pdf share.google/XFwcoxZMdlHmiEl…
4
28
3
172
65,902
As I was saying.
A teaching credential has no impact on student achievement.
15
87
9
774
29,929