Recruitment | Everton Analysis

Joined April 2017
Crystal Palace, Everton and Sunderland are sleepwalking towards a relegation battle if they don’t get their act together. The warning signs are there. The managers either find solutions and turn things around, or the clubs need to make a change.
23
17
5
214
20,142
Wrote this back in April. The arguments are even more relevant today when it comes to Moyes and Everton. Give it a read or have a listen.
2
5
1
25
2,183
Whether it’s Arsenal or Hull, Everton keep showing the same problems. Moyes hasn’t addressed them, Friedkins have stepped back from the club, there’s little sign of accountability from anyone. The result is the same cycle of stagnation, with nobody driving Everton forward.
5
15
89
3,069
Why is Röhl chasing the ball over to the left instead of getting back into his position? George has to cover, but Röhl is completely abandoning his area. The lack of positional discipline and basic understanding is schoolboy stuff.
2
1
1
21
2,032
Pickford panics and takes out Armstrong, Mykolenko flaps at it, then Johnson allows Konsa to get the run on him. Three errors in one move. A terrible goal to concede so early.
3
1
25
1,821
Everton’s recruitment is perplexing. We’ve lost Gana’s defensive work rate and Iroegbunam’s physical presence, only to sign Hackney, a technical midfielder who doesn’t fit the manager’s approach, and a physically declining Nørgaard. If Garner and Armstrong are already leaving gaps in the press, we’ve signed two midfielders who do little to address the very problems we have.
💬 'We hoped it wouldn't have taken as long as this, but if that is the fact, then we have to wait and make sure we can get him as right as we possibly can.' 🗣️ #Everton manager, David Moyes, on the fitness of Christian Nørgaard 🎧 Hear more ➡️ bbc.in/4i1Idqu 🎙️ Inc @GiuliaBould | #EFC | #BBCFootball
13
6
1
35
14,050
“My main concern is that Everton keep making life difficult for themselves. The pressing has been poor, the gaps in midfield are too big, and those are exactly the sort of issues Arsenal can exploit.” - @ScoutTom_ Free article over on our Patreon ahead of this afternoons fixture.. 🔵
4
4
1
30
3,798
Tom Long retweeted
Moyes is a good manager no question, with flaws. Outstanding is a bit farfetched for me. This “plucky little Everton” mentality seems to have its say in the media realms. Hate it.
Everton for sale. Famous club, huge fanbase, great stadium, some fine players & an outstanding manager. Attractive proposition. Christian Purslow and I discuss the sale in depth and whether The Friedkin Group gets the £1bn+ it wants @FootyBoardroom #EFC youtu.be/yUDBk4BeZYY
26
7
2
332
40,138
Reminder: never put Man United and Emery in the same conversation. Villa X has gone absolutely nuts 😂
Manchester United should make Unai Emery their number one target. Look at the job he’s done at Villa, building a side capable of competing in the Champions League and improving players within a clear structure. The blueprint is there. Go and get him.
22
6
5,769
Manchester United should make Unai Emery their number one target. Look at the job he’s done at Villa, building a side capable of competing in the Champions League and improving players within a clear structure. The blueprint is there. Go and get him.
208
1
12
31
49,680
I find it strange that the narrative is shifting towards Moyes potentially leaving Everton in a better place than he found them. What has actually improved? - Same centre back core - No improvement at full back - Huge money spent on the Grealish loan - No development of Dibling - Average tactics - No clear identity -Underlying metrics not improved - Poor recruitment overall - Wanted Balogun for £40m despite not suiting the system - Wanted 29 year old Richarlison to replace Ndiaye Since Moyes arrived in January 2025, Dewsbury-Hall is the only player I’d confidently say has established himself as a genuine improvement. The Friedkins may have abandoned ship now, but that doesn't excuse the lack of progress on the pitch. £200m+ spent. Again, where is the improvement?
50
43
12
284
44,683
Been watching a good amount of Lequincio Zeefuik. At 6ft 6, his physical profile is elite, but consistency is the big question. His finish against Groningen here shows the quality, while his movement to score in both Netherlands U21 starts was excellent. One to keep following.
2
1
26
5,929
Watching Spurs here and the role De Zerbi wants Maddison to play, I can really see Josh King fitting into that role next season. Xavi Simons will come back from a bad injury, but it's one to keep an eye on.
2
715
Too many people confuse a centre forward’s xG with their overall performance. xG measures the quality of the chances they take. It doesn’t measure their link-up play, hold-up play, movement, ability to bring others into the game or contribution to the team’s attacking structure. A striker can generate good xG and still perform poorly overall. Equally, low xG doesn’t automatically mean they’ve played badly. Don't just judge on a single metric, assess the performance.
3
3
1
15
1,537
An interesting exercise for Everton fans. How many players from our starting 11 against Chelsea would get into Brighton’s team? Be honest with yourself. It’s a good test of how many of our players are genuinely at the level Everton should be aiming for.
31
1
8
37
169,881
Moyes prioritises defensive discipline and work rate off the ball. George and Hackney will struggle to get into the starting 11 while others offer that balance. Until Moyes trusts their work without the ball, their attacking threat alone won’t be enough.
1
628
I don’t want to single out players after that performance, but the abuse I got in the summer for questioning the Nørgaard signing was something else. Honestly, Yakubu would have more mobility playing on one achilles. He’s not displacing Armstrong or Garner, and if either gets injured, Everton have a serious problem.
12
3
28
5,146
To play the way Everton did in the first half and then produce that after the break is shocking. We got caught cold with Chelsea first goal and never recovered. Every change Moyes made seemed to make things worse. Not the performance you want to see with Arsenal next week.
1
3
44
1,676
Everton have gone up a level since the Armstrong tackle. Grealish has turned up today too. Could see George or Johnson coming on down the right in the second half to add another threat, but overall, a really good half from Everton.
13
823