Darth Silverhand retweeted
Its so funny seeing newer Halo fans / 343i fans saying "See this is what we were saying all along!" as if they haven't spent the last decade arguing in bad faith that Forerunners were never humans (even in Bungie's lore, which is factually incorrect).
As for the article, it's not bad. I found The Farmer and The Shepherd section to be a little heavy handed but still quite interesting. I speaks to the older implications Bungie left about the Forerunners and their mistakes, their sins that ultimately led to their destruction at the hands of the flood.
They strayed too far from their nature, their humanity, and in doing so their sacrifice gave the universe, and themselves, a chance at redemption. The Avus-jjaro thing was a nice touch.
The rest of the article was mostly fine, albeit you're essentially reading a flowery and verbose twitter argument on the subject, complete with the neutral party, the purist, and the fanatic. I do wish that Guilty Spark didn't have his memory wiped, as that would have only gave more reason behind his words in CE and Halo 3.
Lastly the goodbye at the end was nice. I take it that it was left by the Librarian, but I couldn't help reading it in Cortana's voice. Felt fitting somehow.
All in all, I can accept this but for one thing: I greatly dislike the intellectual dishonesty of the fanatics who claim this has always been 343i's lore. This article is a concession, and a soft retcon of their own lore in the effort of smoothing it over. This is exactly what 343i has been known to do for over a decade, retcon something major, then introduce a lot of small retcons to make their big retcon make sense. To deny it as anything other than this is to deny objective reality.
It's a win for Halo fans, but at what cost? How long did it take to get here, and with how much damage have these things done to the community as a whole? One article does not make up for over a decade of bad games and convoluted lore.
Fragments of data recovered from Alpha Halo's control room reveal a deep well of suppressed history concerning humanity's ancestral origins from the elder days of the Farmer and the Shepherd.
π aka.ms/VeritasAeterna



