simon shadbolt retweeted
🧵
We need to talk about Angus MacIntyre, who left the @RoyalAirForce last week after a 40-year military career, and has been unveiled as Reform UK’s “Shadow Armed Forces Minister”.
Nigel Farage’s launch tweet claimed that MacIntyre “has more experience than the entire government defence team combined.”
MacIntyre’s service record is substantial, and nothing here is meant to belittle it. The questions are about something else. What is the appointment for? What does the title claim? How does his record sit beside the party he now speaks for? And what does his first pledge actually promise?
According to The Independent, MacIntyre joined the British Army in 1986, serving with the 17th/21st Lancers and then the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders, including attachments to the Royal Marines and Parachute Regiment.
His deployments included Arctic Norway, Northern Ireland and Brunei. He moved to the RAF Regiment in 1999 and did tours in Afghanistan, Kuwait, Sierra Leone, Liberia, Iraq and Somalia. He also spent a year in Mogadishu advising the head of Somalia’s National Army for the UN, and a year embedded in the Pentagon.
The most politically significant part of his career is recent. After Russia’s full-scale invasion in 2022 he coordinated British support for Ukraine. He then moved to NATO headquarters in Brussels, making regular trips to Kyiv to work with Ukraine’s defence and interior ministries. He received a commendation from the Vice Chief of the Defence Staff for that work. This is a Ministry of Defence commendation; state honours such as the OBE are awarded separately, through the honours system.
Reform says he “completed a course on the changing character of war” at Pembroke College, Oxford, and has lectured on NATO deterrence at All Souls. The Oxford centre’s own pages say something more substantial.
MacIntyre is listed as a 2025–26 Visiting Fellow at its Strategy, Statecraft and Technology (Changing Character of War) Centre, with a research project titled “NATO – Deterrence and peace in Europe through design or luck”. The All Souls “lecture” was actually a seminar he gave under that fellowship on 2 December 2025, while still a serving RAF officer.
The same bio records an MA in Applied Security Strategy from Exeter University’s Strategy and Security Institute, studied as a Chief of the Air Staff’s Academic Fellow. A book review he wrote for the RAF’s Air Power Review (Vol 21, No 3) says his thesis examined the UK’s declining influence in Africa and how it might be recovered, and describes him at the time as a desk officer in Military Strategic Effects in the Operations Directorate.
Set beside that bio, Reform’s launch briefing and the press copy based on it polished his record in small ways. A sponsored MA, studied as an RAF Academic Fellow, became work “in academia”. A seminar given as a visiting fellow became a lecture at All Souls. A year as military assistant to the Somali army chief and a senior UN official became, in the press copy, a year spent negotiating between the UN and the Somali National Army.
Oddly, calling the Oxford fellowship a “course” actually undersells it, which suggests looseness more than design. None of this matters much on its own. Together it shows a briefing gilding a record that was strong enough not to need it.
Start with the title. Reform calls MacIntyre its “Shadow Armed Forces Minister”, in his @X biography, in Farage’s tweet and in the party’s own announcement. But Reform is not the Official Opposition; the Conservatives are. Mark Francois made this point in the Commons in January. He noted that there is only one shadow cabinet, which belongs to the Opposition, and that even the Liberal Democrats do not have one.
This is parliamentary convention; no law stops a party choosing its own titles. The convention exists so that voters can tell who is formally holding the government to account.But there is a much more basic problem. MacIntyre is neither an MP nor a peer.
Responding to the appointment, Francois said that MacIntyre cannot hold defence ministers to account at the despatch box or in debate. Shadow ministers also work through the media and policy development, but by convention the defining part of the role is parliamentary: questioning a named minister, speaking in debates and voting on legislation. MacIntyre can do none of that.
What he holds is a party-appointed spokesman’s post dressed in the language of an Official Opposition front-bench. The Press Association put the title in quotation marks, which is the accurate way to treat it.
This matters because the title borrows constitutional authority. It signals a government-in-waiting with a defence team in place. Yet The Independent reports that Reform has still not given any of its eight MPs responsibility for defence. Its analysis found that Reform MPs took part in just 30% of the 210 defence-related debates and questions since the 2024 election.
Farage was described as the party’s defence spokesperson in June. Since the election he has taken part in only 10 defence debates and questions, nine of them about the Chagos Islands.
Farage’s headline claim, that MacIntyre “has more experience than the entire government defence team combined”, also needs a closer look.
The government’s defence team has five ministers: Defence Secretary Wes Streeting, Luke Pollard, Lord Coaker, Armed Forces Minister Louise Sandher-Jones and Veterans Minister Calvin Bailey. Two of them have served. Bailey spent about 24 years in the RAF, commanded air mobility forces during the 2021 Kabul evacuation, and left as a Wing Commander, the same rank as MacIntyre. Sandher-Jones was an Army Intelligence Corps officer from 2013 to 2020 and deployed to Afghanistan. Together they have about 31 years, the figure PA reported, against MacIntyre’s 40.
Measured narrowly in years of military service, Farage’s claim is true. But that is a very particular definition of experience, and the comparison is selective in three ways.
First, it counts only time in uniform and ignores ministerial and parliamentary experience. Streeting has been an MP since 2015 and a Cabinet minister, Pollard since 2017, and Coaker was an MP from 1997 to 2019 and has sat in the Lords since 2021.
Second, Reform’s supporting line, that neither Pollard nor the Defence Secretary has served a single day, is accurate but leaves out the minister MacIntyre would actually shadow. The Armed Forces Minister is herself an Afghanistan veteran.
Third, the framing implies a team of civilians when one of its ministers held the same rank MacIntyre left with.
In van Dijk’s terms this is positive self-presentation at work. The comparison is chosen because it flatters “us” and diminishes “them”, and the facts that would complicate it are left out.
So why now, and why him? The Independent framed the appointment as Farage moving to tackle concerns that he is pro-Putin. The timing supports that reading.
This week the paper published comments Farage made days after the 2022 invasion, saying he “understood” why Putin annexed Crimea and that he considered Putin a “rational player” at the time. The paper also cited concerns over Nathan Gill, Reform’s former leader in Wales, who was jailed for taking bribes from Moscow. That is background to Reform’s Russia problem; it says nothing about why MacIntyre in particular was chosen.
What follows is interpretation, based on the timing and the fit. If a party wants to rebut a perception that it is soft on Russia, the most efficient rebuttal available is a spokesman whose most recent work was helping Ukraine resist Russia. MacIntyre’s Kyiv record does that job in a single line. The appointment is useful to Reform partly because of who he is and partly because of what his presence says about Farage.
There are other explanations, and they should be weighed fairly. Labour and the Conservatives have been attacking Reform for having no defence spokesperson.
Politico reports that the party has gone more than two years without one and still has no detailed military policy. The Independent says Reform tried and failed to recruit a senior general. Retired Rear Admiral Chris Parry had been linked to the role. He was suspended as Reform’s Hampshire mayoral candidate in March after comparing a Jewish volunteer patrol group to “Islamists on horseback”, having earlier apologised for the wording of posts telling David Lammy to “go home” to the Caribbean. So the appointment may simply fill an embarrassing gap. These motives are not mutually exclusive, but only the gap is documented. The Putin motive is an inference from timing and fit.
Whatever the motive, MacIntyre’s record and his new party pull in different directions on at least six points.
1. The first is Ukraine and escalation. MacIntyre spent four years coordinating British and NATO support for Ukraine, and his own published views go further than that record. The summary of his December 2025 Oxford seminar says he argued that, in NATO’s current approach, “luck is playing far too big a part for fear of escalation”.
It says NATO must do much more and be seen to lead the multinational effort from the front, and it asks what happens if the US withdraws from NATO entirely.
Farage, by contrast, said in January that he would vote against deploying British peacekeeping troops to Ukraine, arguing the UK has neither the manpower nor the equipment. Politico reports that he has also called Kyiv “corrupt” and promised to review Britain’s military aid to Ukraine.
A spokesman who criticised the West for excessive caution now speaks for a leader who rejects even a peacekeeping deployment. His launch-day writing is in the same register: in the Daily Mail he warned that the threat from Russia over the next five years “remains very real”.
2. The second is women in the forces. The Independent reports that in March 2024, as chairman of the RAF Commando Association, MacIntyre argued for supporting female applicants through commando training and noted that the RAF lagged the other services. The sharpest contrast is recent.
In 2025 Richard Tice, now Reform’s deputy leader, shared the biography of a female station commander, Group Captain Louise Henton, with the caption “Kept safe & secure by an HR manager”.
Farage’s own view on record is older: in 2010 he called the idea of serving alongside women “extraordinarily bizarre”.
MacIntyre’s reported remarks are about women’s chance to qualify as commandos; they don’t settle his view on every question about combat roles. On that point, though, he sits closer to the Ministry of Defence than to his party’s two most senior figures.
3. The third is the party’s own history. MacIntyre’s launch statement says that over 14 years the Conservatives “oversaw a further decline in our military power” and, of the two “old guard parties”, that “neither can be trusted”.
Yet Reform’s front-bench includes Robert Jenrick and Suella Braverman, both of whom sat in Conservative cabinets during those 14 years. Lee Anderson, Danny Kruger, Andrew Rosindel are all former Tory MPs, and Sarah Pochin is a former Tory Councillor. Reform’s spokesperson for home affairs, Zia Yusuf, was a member of the Conservative Party until August 2024, and Reform Treasurer Nick Candy has donated over £270,000 to the Tories, only resigning from the Tory Party on 10 December 2024.
GB News described MacIntyre as the first Reform spokesman without any known Tory links! That’s a telling admission about a party claiming to replace the Tories, and it sits awkwardly beside his attack on them.
4. The fourth is uniform and respect. Reform’s case for MacIntyre rests on time in uniform. Its spokesman stressed that neither Luke Pollard nor the Defence Secretary has served a single day. In August, however, Zia Yusuf, who now sits on the same frontbench, called former Defence Secretary Ben Wallace a “moron” and a traitor. Wallace is a Scots Guards veteran of Northern Ireland.
Yusuf also posted a poll asking whether Wallace should be prosecuted for treason. Wallace’s reply was that Yusuf had never put on a uniform and had only worked at a bank. Farage called Yusuf’s language over the top, but the posts stayed up. Yusuf’s charge centred on Afghan relocations. Whether MacIntyre endorses his colleague’s language about a fellow veteran is a fair question. I have found nothing showing his view either way.
5. The fifth is money. Reform pledges defence spending of 3% of GDP by 2030 and 3.5% by 2035. The government has already committed to defence and security spending of 5% of GDP by 2035, under the NATO target in which 3.5% is core defence.
Reform’s 3.5% therefore matches the core-defence part of a commitment Britain has already made. It does not exceed it, and Reform has not said how it would treat the further allowance of up to 1.5% for wider defence- and security-related investment. Politico describes Reform’s targets as in line with Labour’s. That makes the claim to be the only party that can “fix and rebuild” the forces harder to sustain on the numbers.
6. The sixth is America. MacIntyre’s Oxford bio presents his US ties as a central asset: a year embedded in the Pentagon’s strategic plans branch in 2020–21, and a Pentagon network he says he used to keep NATO’s Ukraine effort aligned with Washington and London. Reform added that he worked on infectious diseases and the US Space Force, details his bio does not mention. Close American links are normal for an officer of his background. What stands out is where they point.
The abstract for his December 2025 seminar is blunter. It says the change of government in the US had put huge pressure on NATO’s European members to shoulder more of their own defence or risk a limited American response in a crisis. It then asks what happens if the US withdraws from NATO completely, whether Article 5 really has any utility, and what can be done to lure the US back into a more committed relationship with the alliance.
Farage, meanwhile, has tied his fortunes closely to Donald Trump, who has suggested him for roles such as Britain’s ambassador to Washington. On the eve of this week’s US midterms, in which the Republicans lost heavily, Farage told his GB News audience he did not share the consensus that Trump was about to be smashed.
Two days later, introducing MacIntyre, he admitted “I got this wrong”, and told journalists that Trump had broken his promise of no more foreign wars, and that this, together with rising fuel prices, had done the damage. Which version of the American relationship will Reform’s armed forces spokesman defend?
Then there is the first policy he has put his name to: ending prosecutions of service personnel and veterans within Reform’s first 100 days. Within 24 hours it had appeared in several different versions.
Reform’s launch graphic, under his name and signature, promised to end “all ongoing and future prosecutions of our service personnel and veterans”. Reform’s own post narrowed that to “the unjust prosecutions of our veterans”, adding that if he failed he would resign.
MacIntyre’s Daily Mail article promised pardons for those “convicted for simply carrying out orders”, an end to ongoing prosecutions and a bar on future ones, save with the Defence Secretary’s explicit consent. By the next morning, after a TalkTV interview, his own post promised to end “all unjust prosecutions”, with no mention of resigning.
Veterans’ own campaigners were unconvinced. Paul Young, a prominent veterans’ affairs campaigner, said: “We could not endorse those policies based on those wordings.” Campaigners had asked for a Supreme Court judge to decide whether cases proceed, he said, and had never sought pardons.
Philip Ingram, a former army intelligence officer, doubted that any legal mechanism exists to deliver what Reform is promising.
How a pledge can change shape so quickly, and what its shifting wording is designed to do, is the subject of the second part of this analysis (see next tweet).
MacIntyre may turn out to be a serious voice in a party that has rarely had one on defence. TThe Spectator, owned by Paul Marshall who also co-owns GB News, so hardly a hostile witness, judged him a serious addition.
The deeper question is whether Reform will listen when his professional judgement leads somewhere politically inconvenient, as it already has on Ukraine, NATO and women in the forces.
The real test will be whether his record shapes Reform’s policy or simply decorates it. He has no seat in Parliament and no published policy to defend yet, so the useful questions are direct ones.
Would he support British troops helping to guarantee a ceasefire in Ukraine, as his leader has said he would not?
Does he still back women qualifying as RAF commandos?
Does he agree with Zia Yusuf that a former defence secretary and Army veteran is a traitor?
Does he share his leader’s faith in Trump’s commitment to Europe?
Which version of his veterans pledge does he stand by: all prosecutions, unjust ones, or most, subject to a minister’s veto?
And when he blames 14 years of Conservative decline, does that include the former Conservative cabinet ministers on his own front-
bench?
How he answers will show whether Reform has hired a defence spokesman or a credential.
simon shadbolt retweeted
Extraordinary compilation if Farage lies
Replying to @nw_nicholas
Here’s a collection of 25 of empty statements.
I only checked in to see if he was still a blubbering fool.
simon shadbolt retweeted
It’s the cover up that is almost worse than the scandal.
🔴 EXCLUSIVE: After *five-year* legal battle, Democracy for Sale has forced the government to reveal who referred firms to lucrative Covid PPE ‘VIP lane’ for 'politically connected'
30+ senior Tories are named, plus ex Duchess of York, and many more 🧵
democracyforsale.substack.co…
simon shadbolt retweeted
Piers Morgan: What was it you were smirking about?
Moser: I was actually laughing... A recently founded settler colony, Israel, which was founded in living memory... ranting at an Iranian, saying that his country is fake, Iran, one of the most ancient countries in the world.
simon shadbolt retweeted
The best general of WW2 might be a man most people have never heard of: William Slim.
No famous pistols. No riding crop. No glamorous desert duels. Just a stocky, square-jawed Englishman his troops called "Uncle Bill." And he pulled off what might be the greatest turnaround of the entire war.
Slim wasn't supposed to be a general at all. He grew up in a family that had fallen on hard times. He worked as a clerk and a schoolteacher. He got into the army through a university officer training corps he wasn't even enrolled at. He was badly wounded at Gallipoli in WW1, then worked his way up the Indian Army with no money and no connections.
In 1942, he was handed a disaster.
The Japanese were steamrolling through Burma. Slim took command of the British forces there and led them on the longest retreat in British military history. Around 900 miles, through jungle and mountains, all the way back to India. They arrived starving, sick, beaten, and with almost nothing left.
Slim later wrote openly about his own mistakes in that campaign. Generals almost never do that.
In 1943, he was given command of the new 14th Army. On paper, it was a mess.
It was the most diverse army Britain fielded in the war. Indians, Gurkhas, Britons, East and West Africans, Burmese. Dozens of languages. It got the worst equipment and the lowest priority, because Europe came first. Its men called it "the Forgotten Army."
And it was being destroyed by disease. At one point, for every man wounded in battle, about 120 were falling sick, mostly from malaria.
Slim's fix was simple and ruthless. Anti-malaria pills became an order, not a suggestion. Officers were held personally responsible. If too many men in a unit got sick, the commander got sacked. Sickness rates collapsed.
Then he fixed the fear. The Japanese had won in 1942 by slipping around British units in the jungle and cutting them off, which caused panic and retreat. Slim's new rule: if you're surrounded, you don't run. You dig in, form a defensive "box," and the air force will supply you from the sky.
In February 1944, it worked. At the "Admin Box" in Arakan, a Japanese attack surrounded a British-Indian force. The force held. Planes dropped supplies. The Japanese ran out of food and broke. It was the first major Japanese defeat on land in Burma.
A month later, the Japanese launched their big gamble: an invasion of India itself, aimed at Imphal and Kohima.
Slim did something that terrified London. He pulled his forces back onto the Imphal plain and let the Japanese come to him. They had brought only a few weeks of supplies, betting they could capture British stockpiles.
They never did. At Kohima, the two sides fought across a tennis court at a few yards' distance. At Imphal, the British held for months while being supplied by air. The Japanese army starved in the hills. Out of roughly 85,000 men, tens of thousands died, many from hunger and disease. It was the worst defeat the Japanese army had ever suffered up to that point.
Then Slim went on the offensive.
In early 1945, he crossed the Irrawaddy River and made the Japanese believe his main attack was aimed at Mandalay. They rushed their forces there to defend it.
Meanwhile, he had quietly sent an entire corps south through jungle trails, under radio silence, using fake signals traffic to hide the move. It burst out and seized Meiktila, the Japanese supply and communications hub, far behind their lines.
The Japanese army in Burma was cut in two and collapsed. By May 1945, Rangoon was back in Allied hands. The army that had fled 900 miles in defeat had marched all the way back.
And even then, Slim almost got fired. That same month, his superior tried to push him out. When word got around, the backlash was so severe that the superior was the one who ended up being replaced.
Slim later became a field marshal, head of the British Army, and Governor-General of Australia.
He called his memoir "Defeat into Victory." No title has ever been more honest.
simon shadbolt retweeted
London’s oldest restaurant given to the National Trust
londontopia.net/history/rule…
simon shadbolt retweeted
Former Head of MI6 Sir John Sawers, "Russia was very keen that the Leave campaign should succeed and that Britain should leave the European Union"
"Because that would marginalise Britain as a global player and weaken Europe in general"
"That's the strategic opportunity the Russians spotted, and the leaders of the Leave campaign fell into it"
My view: Former MI6 chief Sir John Sawers says Russia saw Brexit as a way to weaken Britain and divide Europe, and that the Leave campaign’s leaders walked straight into the opportunity.
So let’s remember who sold it:
VOTE LEAVE
• Boris Johnson — political figurehead
• Michael Gove and Gisela Stuart — campaign committee co-convenors
• Matthew Elliott — chief executive
• Dominic Cummings — campaign director
• Daniel Hannan — leading Brexit advocate
• Priti Patel, Iain Duncan Smith, Chris Grayling, John Whittingdale and Theresa Villiers — senior Conservative campaigners
• David Davis, Liam Fox, Dominic Raab, Steve Baker and Douglas Carswell — prominent Leave campaigners
LEAVE. EU
• Nigel Farage — leading political figure
• Arron Banks — co-chairman and major funder
• Andy Wigmore — communications director
GRASSROOTS OUT / LABOUR LEAVE
• Peter Bone and Tom Pursglove — Grassroots Out co-founders
• Kate Hoey — Grassroots Out co-founder and Labour Leave campaigner
• Graham Stringer, Kelvin Hopkins and Roger Godsiff — Labour Leave campaigners
• Sammy Wilson — prominent DUP Leave campaigner
They promised Brexit would make Britain stronger.
Sawers says Russia saw the opposite opportunity: a Britain marginalised and a Europe weakened.
simon shadbolt retweeted
Replying to @ShippersUnbound @edballs
But any financial contributions will be small compared to the net gains in the economy?
simon shadbolt retweeted
This is EXACTLY* what Nigel Farage said about giving the Chagos Islands to Trump.
Anyone trying to deny this, is literally flying in the face of reality — 1984-style.
He said he'd trade them in return for Trump's silence on the Falklands.
*two edits for brevity
simon shadbolt retweeted
He’s never had a government role, was last in the Duma 15 years ago, only briefly worked for Putin, and never worked in the Russian intelligence services.
Like ‘former deputy foreign minister’ Fedorov, Markov is an irrelevant nobody.
There are Moscow taxi drivers that known more than him. Do better @BBCNewsnight.
"It's a direct lie... Either Prime Minister Burnham is lying, or the intelligence service of Great Britain."
Former Putin spokesperson Sergei Markov says that the PM's claim that Russia interfered in the 2016 Brexit referendum is "absolutely a clear lie."
#Newsnight
simon shadbolt retweeted
A last point on the ropey Tory 'Britannia shield' policy. What the UK needs to remain safe, as the SDR reiterated, is layered nuclear and conventional deterrence by both denial and punishment.
This means credible nuclear forces, early warning, expanded air defences, key conventional capabilities esp deep-strike, and resilience at home. The French term the mutual support between nuclear and conventional forces as épaulement.
Cowering behind one piece of the deterrent architecture - a 'shield' - won't deter the Russians nor defend the UK.
simon shadbolt retweeted
It has emerged that Netanyahu received no less than nine warnings of an imminent operation by Hamas that we can only reasonably conclude that he deliberately ignored. The warnings came from Egyptian intelligence, from the UAE, directly from Sheikh Mohammed bin Zahed, from MI6, and from his own intelligence chiefs, including the Military Intelligence Directorate and Shin Bet, along with Fatah mediator, Sufian Abu Zaida. One can only conclude that Netanyahu urgently needed a prexext to start what was an ethnic cleansing of Gaza long in gestation among his Kahanist allies, while simultaneously pouncing on an opportunity to evade an escalating case against him, where over three hundred witnesses are giving testimony of Netanyahu's twenty year rule of blackmail, corruption and malfeasance.
Replying to @spectator
Did he tell you he had painted the winning entry in the 1986 Exhibition?
Seriously though, if you've been meeting him every week for the last forty years since 1986 how on earth have you been able to keep track of fact & fiction. He was such a liar you must be utterly confused!
simon shadbolt retweeted
Can we put this BS myth to rest already. Bill Clinton is a liar whose legacy is putting more Black people in prison than any other president.
Here's Zbigniew Brzezinski putting that bigoted anti-Palestinian myth to rest. He was there.
simon shadbolt retweeted
No, Michael, I say very clearly in the video that Hamas are guilty of brutal war crimes and murders on Oct 7th. Unlike you, I condemn war crimes on both sides.
But I also echo calls from Israeli families and media for an investigation into how many people were killed by Israel’s controversial Hannibal Directive, which the defense minister admitted was deployed. Why not watch the video and tell me what you disagree with, rather than engaging in performative snark? Surely you’re better than that?
Three years on, and @zeteo_news have identified the real villains of October 7th - Israelis…. When will this wickedness end?
simon shadbolt retweeted
I can play this game too.
Define "Jews".
No one in the Bible is called a "Jew" until Mordecai -- מרדכי היהודי -- in the Scroll of Esther, historically the latest book of the Bible, set in Persia in roughly 4th century BCE, i.e. 2,500 yrs ago.
No one was "a Jew" anywhere 3,700 years ago.
The stories that we are emotionally attached to are really hard to let go of. If you want to base your worldview on actual truth, please learn more about the Bible and biblical history.
And, regardless of what the Bible says, none of it is any justification for Jews of our time to murder Palestinians and steal their land.
Replying to @RabbiMivasair
Define "ruled by". There have been Jews in Judea and Samaria continuously for 3700 years. Muslims have been settlers at best. Colonizers is a better term. Face facts.
simon shadbolt retweeted
Replying to @GylesB1
“he said it was to be his last”
For once, Jeffrey Archer told the truth.
































