Replying to @TidmStreetlight
I’ve tackled this before
Red line is the one from Haunted Henry going to the “Station by the Lake” (Peel Godred & Black Loch).
Blue line is an old extension of Thomas’s Branch through Ulfstead. It crosses over it and joins the Main Line past Maron. We see it in S6 a few times.
1
19
484
- Mitton follows up on this idea in S6, having the “tunnel construction” lead to the “New Loop Line”, expanding Tidmouth Bay into a larger junction station and renaming it “Castle Station” to connect it to Castle Hill Climb.
- Mitton places Castle Hill Climb behind (east of) Tidmouth Bay in the final episode, and changes the Thomas’s Tunnel from being a newly built one to a previously existing one that he already marked on his map where the harbor line runs under the branch line.
Looking at the map, a “new” loop line could theoretically be created if trains ran down the harbor line to Tidmouth Bay instead of down the “old” loop line down to Tidmouth.
In previous threads, I have discussed why myself and others believe the “Loop Line” marked on David Mitton’s Map is the New Valley Line mentioned by Duck in the ‘Make Someone Happy” script, acting as the northern part of his branch.
In this episode, Edward is sent to show Stepney how to run the “New Loop Line” while Duck does his work.
He and Stepney are shown passing the Tower Windmill and stopping at Tidmouth Bay (aka Castle Station).
Before I move on, I want to share these previous tweets of mine where I discussed this theory and outlined where I believe Castle Hill is and where the railway climbs it.
It’s worth noting that the final appearance of Tidmouth Bay is far different than the original concept.
It was initially supposed to be a terminus of sorts for Toby’s Branch Line, with high cliffs and notably no castle to the east of it.
Tidmouth Bay Station is introduced in S5 as a beachside station with, you guessed it, a castle on a hill in the background.
In S6, the station expands and is renamed to “Castle Station”.
In the final episode, the narrative changes significantly.
Instead of the tunnel being built in the episode, it’s instead an already existing tunnel that is “under repair” when Gordon crashes into it.
In the script, a tunnel is bored through Castle Hill Climb so the engines no longer have to climb it, and it is later renamed “Thomas’s Tunnel” because… he was thoughtful about the kids playground? Sure why the hell not!
Castle Hill Climb is a location mentioned in the S5 script for “Thomas & the Rumors”. It’s described as a hill the engines have to climb that has caused many previous accidents, similar to Gordon’s Hill.
THREAD:
Why I believe “Thomas’s Tunnel” under “Castle Hill Climb” from the “Thomas & the Rumors” script could be located on the Tidmouth Harbor line, the “castle” is the the one seen in the background of Tidmouth Bay Station, and how it could connect to S6’s “New Loop Line”.
The “New Section of Railway in the Valley” is a line connecting Thomas’s Line to Callan, with the junction just after the Tower Windmill.
When heading west on the New Valley line, there is only a junction to the south, so the construction of this line makes sense.
8
148
The New Valley Line is double track the entire way, with Callan School, Callan Station and the Tower Windmill all located in between the Rivers Tid and Callan.
Duck’s Branch ends at Callan, while the line continues on under the Valley Bridge before joining the Main Line.
1
8
189
The line continues as triple track until two lines branch off to the east onto the New Valley Line, while a single track continues north and merges with Thomas’s Branch.
This 2nd junction is the one from Stepney Get’s Lost.
1
8
155
The line joins up with the Harbor Line here, and I’ll admit, things get a little wild here.
I believe this junction is actually this set from Thomas and the Rumors, with the set accidentally shown going east rather than west.
This is technically a Main Line loop, hence 3 track
1
6
153
I believe the Ironworks and various S5/6 scrapyard sets are located on a goods line that runs from this part of the line across the valley and into Callan Yards. We see the start of this line on the Callan end in both S4 and S6.
The west yard is where Stepney ends his journey at
1
6
177















































