
Ottawa dad and husband. Active in IDV, passports, visas, border management, biometrics and travel technology with @entrust. I fly places.
Ottawa, Canada
Joined September 2011
- Tweets2K
- Following871
- Followers628
- Likes3.4K
Steven Grant retweeted
That’s a lot of fulmination to miss the point. 200K of people who are already here, and have been for years, is different, and has a different impact, than 200K of new, ie additional arrivals. You and I might disagree about the impact of those new arrivals, but there’s nothing to argue about whether existing residents are the same as new arrivals.
There. That wasn’t so hard, was it? And I didn’t even have to accuse you of lying or gaslighting or being deluded or not knowing how math works.
The gaslighting is just exhausting. Why is moderation such a difficult ask in the immigration debate?
Why must we be sandwiched by the deluded on one side and the racist on the other?
Seriously @acoyne, are you asking people to believe math no longer works?
A 380K PR cap without one-time measures is a very different net population growth rate, because existing TRs would have been included within that envelope.
The PR cap is now effectively 200K larger for net immigration. It’s a big increase regardless of where you put it on the ledger.
Why lie with technicalities?
FWIW, I think there is a reasonable case for a one-time, multi-year TR-to-PR program to correct the system long-term while being empathetic to TRs here.
But proponents should make the case for it, and the Feds should be transparent. The trade-off should be a lower net population growth rate through the duration of the program.
80% of people would find this compromise reasonable. In fact, it’s the one Canadians were expecting.
You cannot do one-time programs multiple times without breaking trust. Nor are we setting good precedent for future TR holders, who do not need to believe that we will enforce our rules.
Alternatively, if proponents and the Feds think we should have a higher population growth rate, make the case for why we’re prepared this time.
(We are not prepared)
Those who envision a much more populous country should advocate changes to our growth systems so it doesn’t lower quality of life by increasing housing scarcity or by reducing capacity in our transportation and social systems.
A country of 100M (or even 60M) is incompatible with our land use, infrastructure, and housing systems today without constraining most people to lower living standards.
That’s the reality. The pressures of the last boom did not result in sufficient reform either.
I cannot believe how irresponsible so many are being by trying to wish these problems away, even though we CAN ACTUALLY FIX THEM to enable faster growth. But it’s not easy!
It’s amazing how much $ is out there to lobby for higher immigration but there’s barely a drop to drink for groups advocating housing abundance, or for groups trying to make it easier for young Canadians to start families and have more kids.
It just shows how little they actually care about making the country better for the people who live here.
My warning to those who believe in immigration as a moral good (and not a means to an end) is that your inability to show moderation or accept reasonable concerns on this issue is likely to result in future failures that risk ending the already weakened immigration consensus in this country.
They are already obvious. Absent meaningful changes, affordability and housing pressures will resurge by 2030.
Canada has avoided the nationalist/anti-immigration politics of elsewhere until now. I fear it’s basically inevitable with this callous approach, and it will be, frankly, the fault of people who should have known better.
Minding my business while streaming the #Bluejays on @Sportsnet which has twice been interrupted by a message you are not able to watch tonight's *NHL* game due to blackout restrictions. I was able to reset, but c'mon man! #1 frustration with watching #NHL are the blackout rules!
2
161
Love my #BlueJays, but after watching the entire series with the Yankees (including two inside the Rogers Centre), and today's game against the Astros, Bichette is not helping. Only 4 hits in his last 7 games. – at Ottawa, Ontario
1
227
After seeing another two at bats tonight during game 2 vs Astros...
Bichette is not right. #BlueJays need to think about sitting him.
1
167
#BlueJays are in rain delay so @TSN_Sports is pushing out a stream of the Yankees-Mets game. Man-o-man is the commentary baaaaad! @DShulman_ESPN I love you man!
1
1
672
Thrilled to be in Helsinki at the @BiometricsInst ID@Borders Conference representing @Entrust. Lots of interesting border-geek discussion around ICAO DTC, EU EES, digital wallets, biometrics, and more. – at Helsinki, Finland
5
140
Funny. Staying at a Hilton property in Saint John, New Brunswick/YSJ, but the wifi splash page thinks I am in St. John's/YYT, Newfoundland and Labrador! Look at the list of Things To Do. @HiltonHonors @HamptonByHilton @HiltonHotels @VisitSaintJohn @CityofStJohns – at Toronto, Ontario
1
85
Lost Golden Doodle in #Sandyhill #Ottawa. Sometimes answers to Viens! or Biscuit! Name is Lila. – at Ottawa, Ontario
1
94
The score is because of Apple TV. So bad. On-air staff speaking between innings on their hot mics, amateur comments, etc. #BlueJays please get me out of here! – at Ottawa, Ontario
2
230
Another messy day for @AirCanada at YYZ. Lots of delays including every flight to @FlyYOW. Happy to be home after productive visits to AMS and LHR.
1
5
303
Only two weeks to go before @BiometricsInst ID@Borders! @Entrust will be out in numbers with Gordon Wilson speaking, as well as Shannon Kerrigan, @jonpayneWRS and yours truly @StevenGGrant attending to meet with friends and clients. See you in Brussels!
biometricsinstitute.org/even…
3
209
Great fun speaking on a digital ID panel today with Annet Steenbergen at #PTExpoConf moderated by @dutchrobabroad.
Very windy in Amsterdam today. @DvdHam @HansontheBike @trbouma
Gord Wilson of @Entrust_Corp speaking on #seamlesstravel at @border_mgmt IBMATA's Border Management & Technologies Summit Americas 2923 in San Diego.







