Mike Wordsmith (@TorahMike) header
Mike Wordsmith (@TorahMike) profile picture

“And if it is evil in your eyes to serve the LORD, choose this day whom you will serve” (Joshua 24:15)

United States
Joined November 2010
Is this the “essence” of Mosaic Law? OT: “It’s okay to eat pork” - Satan NT: “It’s okay to eat pork” - Jesus
He didn’t say ‘Judaism’ went astray. He said that SOME interpreters of the faith, including many (but not all) Pharisees and Sadducees, were misinterpreting Mosaic law. He called people to go back to the essence of the Law.
78
Do these ideas look familiar? - If circumcision simply symbolizes cutting away pride and base passions, why bother with the physical act? - If the Sabbath simply symbolizes the soul resting in God’s creative power, why stop working on Saturday? - If kosher laws simply symbolize avoiding beastly vices, why avoid pork? What if I told you these allegorical arguments pre-date the New Testament? They were not newly invented through the lens of Christ or the apostolic writings. They were Hellenistic philosophical arguments that the Jewish philosopher Philo of Alexandria was already confronting in the Greco-Roman world before a single book of the New Testament was ever written. In 1st-century Alexandria—the intellectual capital of the Greek-speaking world—there was immense cultural pressure to spiritualize the Torah through extreme allegory. To fit into Greco-Roman society, some Hellenized Jews argued that once you grasped the philosophical meaning behind the commandments, physical observance became obsolete. Mainstream Judaism rejected that move. Philo himself argued that the literal commandment is the body and the allegorical meaning is the soul—you cannot discard the body and expect the soul to survive on earth. These ideas of spiritualizing away the Torah were already circulating in the 1st-century world during the time of Jesus—yet He never adopted them. While Jesus challenged the misuse of legalistic loopholes, His fundamental posture toward the Torah was to defend the written commandments against human systems that bypassed them: "You have a fine way of rejecting the commandment of God in order to establish your tradition! For Moses said..." (Mark 7:9–10). A generation later, in Colossians 2, we see Paul stepping into that exact same cultural battle as the message spread into the wider Greco-Roman world. For centuries, readers assumed Paul’s opponents in Colossians were judging believers for not keeping Jewish practices. Yet a growing body of historical scholarship flips that assumption on its head: the antagonists in Colossians 2 aren't promoting Torah—they are promoting Greco-Roman philosophy, visionary mysticism, and extreme asceticism that treats the physical body as inferior (do not handle, do not taste, do not touch). Unless one believes the biblical holidays (Moedim) and observances such as Sabbath are "human tradition", I believe that framework is absolute. And if so, Paul isn't telling believers to abandon biblical rhythms; he is telling them not to let philosophical outsiders judge them for practicing them—whether in what they eat and drink, or in keeping festivals, new moons, and Sabbaths. Drawing directly on Platonic categories of shadow versus body/substance, Paul anchors those communal practices in the reality of the Messiah rather than letting them be replaced by human ascetic philosophy. From Philo, to Jesus, to Paul, the pattern holds: physical covenant observance was defended against human frameworks that tried to explain it away. Yet culture is a powerful force. Over the centuries that followed—the very "extreme allegorism" that 1st-century Jews, Jesus, and Paul resisted eventually won the day and became the dominant lens of the Church.
2
12
523
The Jerusalem council is widely understood, including scholarly interpretation, as being a summary of the Torah requirements of resident gentiles while in the land of Israel. Leviticus 17-18 specifically. But there’s one important aspect, these Jerusalem Council gentiles *were not* in the land, yet the law being applied was that of sojourning gentiles while *in the land.” Anyone who is remotely familiar with the Torah knows how important this is. The Council was treating Gentile believers as the functional equivalent of foreigners dwelling among Israel, not because they have moved into Israel's territory, but because they have joined a community belonging to Israel's Messiah. Additionally… The Noahide laws (A post second-temple Jewish formulation outlining what laws apply universally to gentiles) renders laws for gentiles while *outside* of Israel. But that isn’t what the Jerusalem council used as their basis for righteous gentiles. They used a summary of the laws as required by Gentiles who were IN the land — effectively viewing the Messianic community (the Church) through faith as an embassy extension of “the land” itself. The Noahide laws commonly subtract Genesis 9:4 dietary command “Do not eat the meat with the blood” because they interpret Genesis 9:4 to have only pertaining to LIVE animals, which was not reiterated in the Law of Moses as pertaining to gentiles. The Jerusalem council does not agree with that interpretation. They interpret Genesis 9:4 to mean as it more plainly reads, to not eat what has been strangled, and blood. The summary of the laws for sojourning gentiles (Lev 17-18) by Jerusalem council appears to be pragmatic for simplification. In other words, you might see some commands in 17-18 missing from the Jerusalem council’s edict. Example, at first glance you might see the command to not eat an animal that has died of itself is missing. However the category of “strangled” meat covers the same legal principle as animals that died naturally or were torn by beasts — any meat whose blood was not properly drained. We don’t see the temple rules (Pertaining to sacrifices, and other temple related functions) presumably because these people were outside of the land and there was no temple. But we do see a broader instruction from in Lev 17-18 to “follow my rules and keep my statutes and walk in them.”, which might explain an ending note to the Jerusalem council’s edict, “For from ancient generations Moses has had in every city those who proclaim him, for he is read every Sabbath in the synagogues.” (Acts 15:21)
2
1
1
8
618
For those who believe Noah, Abraham, and other pre-Mosaic figures weren’t personally observing clean/unclean dietary restrictions (“Noahide laws” only), I have a question. Why do we never see God accepting an unclean animal as a sacrifice unto Himself, even centuries before Israel existed? The usual explanations for the dietary laws are that they were given specifically to Israel, either to distinguish Israel from the surrounding nations, or for health reasons in an ancient world without modern food safety practices. But consider this: Noah explicitly distinguished clean from unclean animals, and offered only clean animals and clean birds to God. Abraham likewise offered animals later identified as acceptable sacrifices under the Mosaic Torah. We see the same pattern with other pre-Mosaic figures. God certainly wasn’t going to get sick from an unclean offering. And the clean/unclean distinction couldn’t have originated merely to separate Israel from the nations, because the distinction already existed before Israel. When God later gives Israel the dietary laws, He explicitly connects the distinction to His own holiness: “Be holy, for I am holy.” So the question remains: Why do we never see God accepting an unclean animal as an offering unto Himself, even before Israel existed?
11
5
1
14
888
If gentiles are not to heed the Torah, as it was not given nationally to them, why does Isaiah 24, speaking of the still future global apocalypse and destruction of earth, condemn them on that very basis: “The earth is also defiled under its inhabitants, Because they have transgressed the Torah, Changed the ordinance, Broken the everlasting covenant.” (Isaiah 24:5) If you think Isaiah’s use of the word “Torah” does not include gentile adherence to mosaic Torah concepts such as dietary laws, Sabbath, or biblical holidays, (“That was for Jews/Israel only”) consider Isaiah’s depiction how these exact Laws will apply: Who will be saved from this still future event? “And the foreigners who join themselves to the LORD, to minister to him, to love the name of the LORD, and to be his servants, everyone who keeps the *Shabbat* and does not profane it, and holds fast my covenant—these I will bring to my holy mountain” (Isaiah 56:6-7 Who comes to an end? Still future: “Those who sanctify and purify themselves to go into the gardens, following one in the midst, eating *pig’s flesh* and the abomination and mice, shall come to an end together, declares the LORD.” (Isaiah 66:17) How are the Moedim held, in this perfected world after destruction? “From new moon to new moon, and from Sabbath to Sabbath, all flesh shall come to worship before me, declares the LORD.” (Isaiah 66:23)
31
11
1
61
2,322
If the new covenant existed in the OT, prior to the ministry of Jesus, His death and resurrection (It did), even if only in small part on an individual basis, then it cannot be interpreted to mean the Torah is no longer to be heeded.
1
8
196
Texas will be Red again 💔😢
Bloodbath: What Happened, Why & Where on Earth Do We Go from Here?
1
98
A common objection to the textual citing of “Torah” in Genesis 26:5 is that this wasn’t a fully developed term yet. That historically/grammatically, it didn’t mean the same thing at the time of Abraham as it did at the time of Moses. There’s a tendency to think Genesis 1-5 was written at the time of Adam, the verses about Abraham were written at the time of Abraham, and so forth. Because that’s how it reads. In reality, Moses wrote Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy, as mediated to him by God throughout his (Moses) lifetime. The question becomes not what did “Torah” mean at the time of Abraham, but what did it mean at the time of Moses? Which makes it hard to turn around and say Torah meant something different to Abraham than it meant to Moses, because this was the word used as written by Moses, at the time of Moses. The Torah is the eternal measure of righteousness, in both directions. God’s righteousness is unchanging. God calls it “My” Torah. It was given to Moses, but it stood before Moses, and it still stands today.
1st century Judaism believed Abraham to have kept the Law of Moses (Torah), pre-Sinai. This is documented and still true of Judaism to this day. “because Abraham obeyed my voice and kept my charge, my commandments, my statutes, and my Torah.” (Genesis 26:5) This historical context is important when reading Paul’s model of Abraham as an example for gentile believers in Yeshua Messiah.
4
2
10
391
God’s commandments are a testimony of His perfect righteousness. “But you are near, O LORD, and all your commandments are true. Long have I known from your testimonies that you have founded them forever.” (Psalm 119:151-152)
1
7
211
1st century Judaism believed Abraham to have kept the Law of Moses (Torah), pre-Sinai. This is documented and still true of Judaism to this day. “because Abraham obeyed my voice and kept my charge, my commandments, my statutes, and my Torah.” (Genesis 26:5) This historical context is important when reading Paul’s model of Abraham as an example for gentile believers in Yeshua Messiah.
3
1
23
870
I believe the Torah is still the measure of sin. BECAUSE THE BIBLE SAYS SO.
I believe that homosexuality is a sin. BECAUSE THE BIBLE SAYS SO.
2
2
34
642
Does Nehemiah’s prayer match your view of God’s Torah? Right, true, good, holy… “You came down on Mount Sinai and spoke with them from heaven and gave them right rules and true Torah, good statutes and commandments, and you made known to them your holy Sabbath and commanded them commandments and statutes and the Torah by Moses your servant.” (Nehemiah 9:13-14) For 99.99% of Christianity, it does not.
7
134
(Rooster crows)
1
2
152
What is your approach to handling historic records that take narratives attributed to God, and attribute it to an earlier pagan deity? Some examples referenced below. There’s been historical claims that circumcision pre-dated Abraham in Egypt, that Melchizedek was a priestly name for a pagan deity (Zedek), Noah’s the Ark resembled some sort of Egyptian pagan shrine, etc. There’s a million of them. For me, though I welcome historical records when it supports the biblical narrative, I don’t immediately assume any historical record is true when claimed that it pre-dates the Christian record. This isn’t necessarily a double standard. It’s because I hold the biblical record as the highest standard. But even if something did theoretically pre-date the biblical record, I also know that satan is the great deceiver who likes to imitate God (~Angel of Light). I don’t know how much he knew when, so even if there is something from pagan history that is claimed to have pre-existed a biblical narrative, i just chalk it up to the devil doing what he loves to do and attempting to immigrate God and twist a the biblical narrative. These could be disassembled more thoroughly one by one, but, just sharing my approach, lack of interest/care. And wondering how you handle claims like this.
Replying to @ThenIsaugh
I put this sort of stuff in the same bucket that YHWH’s attributes and some history was borrowed from nearby ancient Canaanite deities (El and Baal) that pre-dated it (Supposedly historically); that Melchezedeck was a priest of a known Canaanite deity; that Egyptians were circumcising before Abraham, and that is where they picked up the tradition (In Egypt), etc. I don’t think that God copies or himself after pagan deities that He hates (And actually forbids this very practice). My takeaway is that Satan is the great deceiver, we don’t know what all he knew when, but that it’s Satan who is more than glad to copy and add a slight twist to it that points away from God. Nor do I have confidence that historians can find something the bible attributes to God, and pre-date that thing to another diety. I would attribute this to a deception tactic of Satan. So, no, not uncomfortable. This sort of stuff has been around since the beginning.
1
87
Was this a dumb *question*?
3
9
235
Solomon thought it was to fear God and heed the Torah
I'm a big believer that we ought to know what the purpose of life is so we can live it well.
1
14
272
Eating pork was more than simply causing ritual uncleanness — such as birthing a child, or burying a relative. It was, and therefore always will be, a sin. “For the assembly (Ekklesia in Septuagint), there shall be one statute for you and for the stranger who sojourns with you, a statute forever throughout your generations. You and the sojourner shall be alike before the LORD. One Torah and one rule shall be for you and for the stranger who sojourns with you.” (Numbers 15:15-16)
Pork is unclean for the Jews. Not for the Gentiles.
3
1
21
531
Following up on this, Emperor Hadrian (Of the Bar Korba revolt) is not commonly attributed to being a minor fulfillment of Antichrist (Type), but, as a messianic, I believe he is. He punished by penalty of death any observances of Sabbath, biblical holidays, dietary law observance, basically any key elements of visible Torah observance. He greatly accelerated the diaspora which ended the biblical calendar (Later replaced with the Rabinic calendar). He crosses a lot of boxes for the Dan 7:25 prophecy. If so, this may be what we would likewise expect in the future from the major fulfillment of the Antichrist figure. “He shall speak words against the Most High, and shall wear out the saints of the Most High, and shall think to change the moedim and the Torah; (Daniel 7:25) In the end, the gentile church we read about in the NT either dropped these practices as taught and preached by the apostles, fled the region, or they were killed. The Roman Christianity that remained hereafter was therefore purged of that sect.
The mark of the beast is obviously people being deceived into rejecting God's law. Objectively, Scripture points to the seal of God being keeping the law. Also, satan wars against people that keep the commandments and they are the people that won't take the mark of the beast.
3
148
I’ve always found it strange that Westminster Confessional Presbyterians (PCA) can be so extraordinarily precise about doctrine, yet their confessional standards are remarkably thin when it comes to eschatology. They don’t even establish whether the millennium is pre-, post-, or amillennial. What about Daniel’s prophetic chronology? Revelation 20? The sequence of events preceding Christ’s return? The nature and timing of the coming kingdom? The fulfillment of prophetic promises? Affirming that Christ returns, the dead are raised, and judgment follows is certainly doctrine. But that’s barely scratching the surface of biblical eschatology. Prophecy is doctrine, too. Why is so much of it left doctrinally untouched and undefined in a tradition otherwise so committed to precision?
1
55