Alberto Turnes retweeted
What amazes me is the attitude of so many of the centibillionaires.
A 5% tax will not make any difference to the way they live. Their spending may be extravagant, but it is still much less than their (correctly measured) income.
They know that, as gifted as some of them indeed are, they have benefited from extreme luck (and the help of the state, and, to speak like an economist, monopoly rents).
They know that their effective tax rate is low, relative to what many others pay.
They know that extreme inequality is extremely unpopular, and can lead to political unrest, backlash, or worse.
They must admit that, morally, it is hard to argue for a society in which some become obscenely wealthy, while so many are poor and see their income stagnate.
They typically have not indicated that they are building their wealth to eventually make the world a better place.
But they are still willing to fight the tax, spending hundreds of millions in California to avoid paying the tax. Why?
They simply think what is theirs is theirs, end of story.
They believe in the slippery slope, and if they do not take a stand on this levy, the government will come back for more.
They hate the state and the notion that their money will be misused?
Or?
As persoas que formamos o Grupo ICEDE aprendimos a interpretar a economía galega e a economía mundial coa luz, o maxisterio e os lúcidos ensaios que Beiras nos foi brindando ao longo dos anos. Grazas polas ideas, a lucidez e o exemplo de honestidade intelectual e compromiso
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Third question on AI.
A question that also remains unasked is whether the AI boom can continue without leading to a massive increase in inequality.
A recent paper by Stijn Van Nieuwerburgh runs the numbers on how much revenue the AI industry needs to generate to recover its massive investment (summary and a link to the paper can be found here: brookings.edu/articles/finan…).
Van Nieuwerburgh’s arithmetic should make us more concerned. AI investments will average about 3.6% of GDP annually between 2025 and 2032. Van Nieuwerburgh calculates that, using a 10% rate of return, the industry would need to generate annual revenues of about $3.7 trillion by 2032 to recover these costs (growing from its current levels of about $200 billion or so). That is significantly more than 10% of current US national income, and will likely remain around 10% of national income by 2032, even if GDP growth rose from its current level.
A large fraction of this revenue will go to capital income. That means a massive increase in the share of capital in national income, which has already risen substantially over the last 25 years or so – now standing at an all-time high of about 47% (bls.gov/news.release/pdf/pro…).
Capital income is much more unequally distributed than labor income, so a massive increase in the capital share of national income will translate into a very sizable surge in inequality.
The rise in inequality may not stop with the capital share. My work with Pascual Restrepo documents that (automation-driven) increases in the capital share of national income are typically associated with rising labor income inequality as well (see, for example, economics.mit.edu/sites/defa…). The same may happen in the next several years, boosting inequality further.
What is missing from our current debate is any discussion of a fundamental dilemma these numbers pose: can the AI boom avoid both an economically costly crash and a huge increase in inequality?
If the industry reaches these revenues, inequality surges. If the industry does not become profitable, a crash, with substantial costs in terms of lost output and jobs, becomes likely.
My assessment would be that the industry is unlikely to reach levels of revenue Van Nieuwerburgh calculates. First, diffusion has been and will likely continue to be slow. Second, competition from open-weight models, which are getting better, will limit how much proprietary models can charge. Third, despite important advances, I still believe that AI models will not be able to automate entire occupations anytime soon, thus limiting their value to businesses as cost-saving devices.
Whether this leads to a crash or not is more complicated and will depend on whether various AI companies are bailed out and what kind of support they receive.
Nevertheless, even if revenues fall short of these gargantuan amounts and we avoid a dramatic surge in inequality, I expect that the diffusion of AI will push up inequality between capital and labor and within labor.
If inequality does surge, a further question becomes central: can our democracy survive such astronomical levels of inequality?
Alberto Turnes retweeted
🔚 The WATER-MINING 5th Consortium Meeting has come to an end!
💙 Our final in-person gathering was a bittersweet milestone filled with collaboration & innovation. We reflected on our journey, discussed #sustainability, & set the path forward.
👏 Huge thanks to all partners!
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Derradeiro día da 5º reunión do proxecto @watermining onde os investidadores @TurnesAlberto e @angeles_ps do @icedeUSC presentaron as súas contribucións ao proxecto no relativo á definición de novos modelos de negocio e paquetes de políticas para a Economía Circular.
Alberto Turnes retweeted
👉🏻 Por qué creo que el Sistema de Financiación Autonómica de régimen común no es tan equitativo como parece. Y por qué no me convence el uso de la palabra solidaridad.
Es un sistema basado en la aportación 'de las CCAA' y no 'de los habitantes de las CCAA'.
🧵 ¿Es justo?
1/n
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Hoy escribo en @publico_es sobre Venezuela y la a veces difícil relación entre una parte de la izquierda y la democracia
blogs.publico.es/dominiopubl…
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Las comunidades autónomas recaudan 9.000 millones menos de los que deberían al imitar las bajadas de impuestos de Madrid - Infobae infobae.com/espana/2024/07/3…
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Nice and interesting first day meeting of @Circulec european project on Circular Economy and Sustainability at the @UniversidadeUSC @EcoAdeUSC with the contributions of @icedeUSC and the 11 university partners from Kazahstan, Uzbekistan, Tayikistan and Turkmenistan.
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Este ataque soez no fondo e na forma é indigno e minte. É intolerábel un ataque así ao Poder Xudicial de quen goberna a Xunta. E minten: o Supremo confirmou a resolución á que se refiren. Noxo e preocupación.
Como líder de En Marea, Luís Villares intentó paralizar todos los proyectos industriales en Galicia...
Ahora sólo recula después de recibir un varapalo del Tribunal Supremo.
¡No se puede ser juez y parte! 👨⚖
galiciapress.es/articulo/eco…
Alberto Turnes retweeted
💬 El daño que están haciendo determinados influencers, youtubers y economistas mediáticos en toda una generación de estudiantes es terrible. Son muchos los que llegan a clase con la cabeza llena de prejuicios, falacias y una arrogancia talla XXL. No va a ser fácil salir de ahí.
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Estadísticas de I+D 2022:
👉(Solo) se incrementa la inversión en 2.000 M€.
👉Nos situamos en el 1'44% de I+D/ PIB (infame)
Pero:
👉Hay un cambio de tendencia. Catalunya y Madrid tiran con fuerza
👉La I+D crece un 23% en 2 años.
👉Atención al arco Mediterráneo
Innovar o morir.
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Ireland's corporate income tax revenue per capita: €4,500 and rising
It pays off to siphon off profits from all over the world!
(From the Global Tax Evasion Report 2024: taxobservatory.eu//www-site/…
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Condonación deuda autonómica:
(Con lo que se sabe hasta el momento; pendiente conocer más detalles)
▶️Es necesaria? Sí, algo hay que hacer si se quiere que todas las CCAA regresen a los mercados
▶️Discusión bilateral? No. Al CPFF
▶️El 20% todas? No. Distintas situaciones...
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Xavier Vence se plantea la economía circular más allá de los discursos convencionales mundiario.com/articulo/libro… @xaviervence en @mundiario
Alberto Turnes retweeted
Un prazer compartir este novo libro sobre "Economía Circular Transformadora y cambio sistémico", en colaboración cos demais colegas do grupo @icedeUSC publicado por @FCEEspana
Alberto Turnes retweeted
📊Moi recomendable este estudo de @Cotec_Innova sobre a "complexidade económica" de España e as súas autonomías.
Comparto algunhas conclusións que me chamaron a atención sobre os resultados que amosa a nivel estatal e galego.
🧵
complejidadeconomica.cotec.e…
Alberto Turnes retweeted
“El @Ivie_news certificó q el 42,9% de los Next Generation destinados a innovación y digitalización los han recibido entidades localizadas en Madrid. 323 euros pc, mientras que la media española es de 122”, concentración y desigualdad…”. elpais.com/opinion/2023-09-2…
Alberto Turnes retweeted
🖊️ Mirar hacia atrás, vivir hacia delante | Escribo sobre la evolución reciente de la renta per cápita española, la huella de las crisis sufridas en los últimos quince años y el papel de la productividad en perspectiva histórica. Mi opinión en @el_pais
elpais.com/opinion/2023-09-0…
































