voiceofreason467 retweeted
Replying to @iamrobothead
But the prequels are brilliant. Let’s use Attack of the Clones as an example and compare it to a so called fan favorite like Andor:
Attack of the Clones for all intent and purposes invented digital cinema. It was an expansive film that encompassed multiple genres extending from the noir classics, to romance, to political drama, and a war story that clocks in at around 2 hours.
Today we are used to 8 hour ramblings that go nowhere, meandering in circles before finally dropping dead. AotC meanwhile is a dense work that assumes the role of an epic.
The issue being most current cinema (be it for movies or so called ‘prestige television) have two forms of language.
One way is through meaningless banter that feels natural but says nothing.
The other is through monologues and speeches where the audience is graced with inner working of the creator, all his ideas laid out in a poetic tone, allowing them to avoid scrutiny while being treated as an intellectual breakthrough.
Audio and visuals don’t play a role. They are tacked on for posterity, occasional spasms of color sprinkled in between to give the VFX guys something fun to do. These are usually unrelated sequences that could be inserted in at any interval.
That’s why guys like Gilroy constantly want to flatten the lighting and diminish the environments. They don’t want viewers distracted from the ideas that are being hand fed to them.
Star Wars is different, it has broad ideas related to philosophy, politics, romance, but they are all portrayed through visual and audio cues that allow room for interpretation. The dialogue follows a similar orientation, leaning on metaphors and associations to older cinema as a method to condense complex emotions into two minute segments.
We can take some popular line from Andor and compare it to an alternative scene in Attack of the Clones.
In Andor when Nemik gives his famous speech about tyranny, there is no subtext. I can pull out a dozen other such examples from the show, but the bottom line is nearly all the major narrative upswings like with Nemik, Mon Mothma, Marva, Luthen, etc. that end in some glorious monologue functions as a soapbox for the creator. There is no narrative context that affects the meaning, it is plain text that has no further meaning to discover on introspection.
It feels intelligent, but that feeling is due to certain word play that makes it sound smart, not because the context is dense or layered in any real way.
Now let’s take one random scene from Attack of the Clones: Anakin and Padme are traveling on a refugee ship to Naboo. Padme is asking about the Jedi and their capacity to love.
In modern cinema he would either give a passive response that implies something without revealing anything, or he’d go on a long expository diatribe about the problems of the Jedi and like Nemik intone his voice with inflections that would be clipped against swelling music, giving no grounds for disagreement, ascending the argument to the realm scripture, untouched by human error.
Instead we get this from Anakin: “Attachment is forbidden. Possession is forbidden. Compassion, which I would define as unconditional love, is essential to a Jedi's life. So you might say we are encouraged to love."
It takes a throw away conversation and compounds multiple techniques into two lines of dialogue.
We experience his earnest beliefs but they are portrayed as his own and not a universal belief that we too must by consequence accept. It requires a degree of thinking to understand because we are not expected to outright accept or reject his framing, nor is there a secondary response that provides us with additional clarity. We are left on our own to make of it what we will.
And sadly so many people are lacking in the arena of critical thinking that they throw up their hands, call it stupid, and move on.
Anakin might believe what he says, but he is also bending the code to fit within his own desires. On one hand he might be highlighting a flaw within the logic of those who say we must be unattached and yet committed to society at the same time, or he might be looking for a loop hole to exercise his own deprivations.
Either way we are given substance that develops over time with more narrative context, allowing us to appreciate it more the more we think.
“The thought of not being with you… I can’t breath” is another such excellent line rich with foreshadowing, but it’s not spoken with the same confidence as “the rebellion has flown away” so in popular culture we are left to think the latter is profound while the former is ‘bad writing’.
The mere fact that Attack of the Clones does all this while referencing Dr. Zhivago, The Sound of Music, and countless other classics at the same time is what transcends it from great to astonishing.
voiceofreason467 retweeted
Replying to @heart_
Oh no! The bigots won’t be able to commit targeted hate crimes in a video game led by two bisexual characters
voiceofreason467 retweeted
I can tell people don’t understand what people mean by “George Lucas had the Prequels planned.”
It doesn’t mean the script for them was around in its entirety. It means Lucas already came up with the basic premise by the time Episode IV came out and intended to make them.
voiceofreason467 retweeted
If this is their argument, why wouldn't they want to get rid of those statues off the streets and put them in museums so people can be taught how bad slavery is/was?? That's not a heritage anyone should be proud of, ever.
voiceofreason467 retweeted
brother yall doxxed a girl for just not liking someone in a romantic sense... then on top of that you throw your sexualized view of black people on top that... YALL ARE MAAAAAD WEIRD
voiceofreason467 retweeted
George Lucas, December 29, 1975, from a transcript of a private conversation with Alan Dean Foster:
“Then someday I want to do the backstory of Kenobi as a young man—a story of the Jedi and how the Emperor eventually takes over and turns the whole thing from a Republic into an Empire, and tricks all the Jedi and kills them.”
that's right libs, I've been duped by an elderly pervert and and am mere hours away from the having my cock and balls incinerated in a volcano
voiceofreason467 retweeted
The Paladins of Charlemagne were Christians, yes. The Paladins that exist in the broader cultural zeitgeist as a result of D&D (Paladin of Selune), Pathfinder (Paladin of Shelyn), and WoW (Sunwalkers and Zandalari Prelates) absolutely are straight up literally pagans tho.
Replying to @TheQuestBroski
I am saying that Paladins are Christian Knights. They follow a monotheistic religion. They should carry the ethics, and aesthetics of Christendom. Because that is the primary lens the class fantasy is filtered through.
Being a paladin of some dark evil god doesn't make sense. Everyone instinctually knows the vibe of a paladin.
It's not some follower of a dark god. It's a warrior who protects the church of Jesus Christ. The WORD Paladin was created by a Christian King, Charlemagne to describe his knights.
Every other class based on a real world religion does not receive this level of scrutiny. It's obvious why. The people doing it hate western civilization, and they hate Jesus Christ.
Everyone knows what a Paladin is meant to be in spirit. It's not some weird pagan oath bullshit.
voiceofreason467 retweeted
These guys really need managers who filter what they say.
You don't say stuff like this. You just don't do it. When you're running civilization-level technology infrastructure projects, you need public sentiment to not turn against you.
You need the little people to like you, no matter how pathetic and worthless you think they are, because they have pitchforks and ballots, and they will vote out all the politicians you bought to make your business model possible.
Hell, they might even pitchfork you. Lotta corporate execs getting killed in the street lately.
"You shouldn't have DRAM" reads like a threat. It turns on my lizard-brain and tells me that not only are you not Tribe, but you're willing to take Stuff from Tribe. And that means I'm going to have to stab you with something pointy to Defend Tribe.
Like, c'mon, this is really bottom-shelf basics of human nature, here. Don't tell people's lizard brains that you want to take their stuff.
Just further proof that techbros don't understand humans.






















































