Nawab retweeted
Great tweet
Only one thing to add: ASML has probably a lot more technical debt than most are willing to admit and a relatively clean build from the Chinese might yield a path to strong innovation. This is the other reason I imagine they don't want to disassemble ASML's DUV stuff, while they could learn a thing or two they could also get influenced into the wrong direction.
I suspect that the goal is to skip imitating a 30 years old tech stack and going straight for a completely fresh start.
As someone once said there is no way you can look at the internals of ASML EUV and not think "yeah no the seven mirrors are probably not a design necessity"
Wrong.
the US wants to reduce Chinese compute. Thus, export controls on chips. A FEW GPUs slipping through doesn't mean this is failing.
Thus also China must be stopped from *making their own chips*. To slow down litho R&D, they must get ZERO EUV tools to reverse engineer.
This is a deep difference in kind. Nvidia GPUs are relatively trivial for the Chinese. Ascends are behind on performance overwhelmingly due to tech process limitations. They are, true, somewhat behind on design too, because Nvidia is very rich and executes very well and Jensen is a visionary. But roadmaps can be adjusted; updated 960PR will already be close to the current gen Nvidia hardware, and on the cluster level Huawei might well be stronger. Accordingly, GPUs are a purely quantitative issue. The fewer they get, the better export controls work; but nobody seriously expected 100% success in preventing smuggling. A few hundred racks out of tens of thousands produced making it past Malaysia/SG and into the Mainland is a stunning success of enforcement, it's actually very close to 100%!
in the neutral situation, China would have been buying like 30% of Nvidia's total output, probably more.
Lithographic tools are a whole different beast. If the Chinese get 1 (one) EUV tool, they may drastically accelerate their ongoing R&D. They'll skip dead ends, they'll have a reference to test against, they'll be able to concentrate capital in the lowest-risk direction. So the US is pretty earnestly trying to not let them get any. This, too, is a resounding success so far, and probably will remain a success because it's much easier to achieve: there are a few tools in existence, belonging to very few trusted partners, and they're all monitored in real time. The only realistic threat here is the MATCH act, as @lithos_graphein says – because the Chinese have a lot of DUV tools serviced by ASML, and they are actively using them. If Americans get that service terminated (under the "reduce Chinese compute" imperative), they'll have little choice but to reverse engineer them at least to continue maintenance (plus of course they'll have little reason to not just tear down a few and try to build clones, which they currently won't do because ASML will immediately notice it, report to the US, and be forced to exit). They are much closer to domestic DUV (small series, inferior machines) than to EUV (research prototypes of individual parts). As a result their DUV timeline will get a lot shorter, and there isn't really a limit as to how much compute they'll produce if they crack high volume domestic DUV. Of course, the fact that the Chinese don't yet pull the plug on their end suggests they don't expect this acceleration of DUV to be positive-EV. Under a zero-sum mindset, this means MATCH act is rational, but there's a lot of variance and misaligned incentives here.
----
forgot to send, well, might be of use to some
Nawab retweeted
A video for the Syrian president Ahmed Al-Sharaa driving a tank with skills when he was leading battles against the Assad regime
Nawab retweeted
"Strategic Air Command... a force for peace!:
...The United States Air Force, through S.A.C., is historically and by technical know-how best organized, equipped and trained to carry out our strategic mission - to deter war - and continue world peace!"
— General Dynamics Poster (1958)
Nawab retweeted
I actually hate this type of clinical diagnosis style attacks in public debate. Words people throw around like projection, insecurity, closeted whatnot are extremely frustrating and are not a productive way to have a conversation.
Nawab retweeted
Iran designates Argentina's navy and air force as 'terrorist organizations' reut.rs/4sTR6WZ
Nawab retweeted
Dangerous political instability does not come from peasants rioting but from the nobles engaging into the political entrepreneurship & recruiting peasants for their causes
Riots per se are perfectly impotent and do not lead to anything
Nawab retweeted
One of the essential texts to read about modernity is Baudrillard’s 1985 encyclopaedia article under that title. His point about Third World amalgamation and adaptation is especially relevant here.
There are five types of cultures.
1. Those who created modernity (English, American, Dutch)
2. Those who sought out Modernity (French, Chinese, Mexican)
3. Those who had modernity thrust upon them (Japanese, Jewish, Turkish)
4. Those for whom modernity slowly slithered in (Indian, Arabian, Indonesian)
5. Those for whom modernity still has not arrived
Nawab retweeted
Many Muslim countries had their own Ataturks, but failed because the conditions were not conducive. Amanullah Khan of Afghanistan after kicking the English out of his country embarked on a radical project of secularisation, but was overthrown in an uprising as a direct result...
Replying to @ElegantiaeArbit
Muslims hate to hear this. The things Ataturk did to religion were abominable, yes. Eventually, Turkey matured beyond the need for such draconian restrictions. But the Turk transitioned into social, cultural, economic, political modernity thanks to him. Not an India or a Nigeria
Nawab retweeted
This is what the le chill Sufi yappers of the West, with their cute niche institutions and lofi vibes bookclubs, have missed
“our monasticism is war”
You’re unable to view this Post because this account owner limits who can view their Posts. Learn more
Nawab retweeted
Differentiating Profit Percentages by Duration in Muḍārabah
islamicportal.co.uk/differen…
Nawab retweeted
The film adaptations of Dune have robbed us of the homosexual menace so central to Baron Harkonnen's character
All the sleaze and predation Frank Herbert intended (as a mirror to Paul) was dropped
It would scandalise Hollywood to ever depict a Gay character this negatively
Nawab retweeted
A lot of "civilizational Muslims" seem to reduce it to being distinct from ABC (often Western) country.
The point of Islam incl its politics is obedience of Allah. And everything else (social justice, political independence, civilizational stuff) is downstream
Replying to @escutarian
Sure, being civilizational losers sucks, but praying 5 times a day is a very concrete demand of God. You wouldn't let a vague and dubious sense of maslaha override what's clear and direct. Maybe 5 times prayer was given to us as a litmus test, a criterion for judging fitness.
















































