Induction retweeted
As an overseas Chinese who has worked on China’s energy transition and energy security for more than two decades, I’m tired of German commentators selectively using China and mis-represent China to fit a green narrative.
Yes, China is building vast amounts of wind and solar. But unlike the permanent subsidy model some Germans still defend, China ended national feed-in tariffs for new solar and wind projects from June 2025. After more than twenty years of government support, these technologies are expected to compete in the market.
At the same time, China is adding more coal capacity than the rest of the world combined, and building more nuclear reactors than the rest of the world combined.
My generation and older generation of Chinese still remembers food and energy insecurity. We do not take modern industrial prosperity for granted. China’s approach has always centered on securing energy and food supply in a changing climate — not on treating intermittent renewables as an ideological end in themselves.
That pragmatic multi-source approach is the actual story about China, not the misleading version currently circulating in Berlin by wind and solar lobbyists.
China verabschiedt sich nicht nur für den Klimaschutz von Öl. Der Staat hat verstanden, dass Erneuerbare Energien Länder deutlich unabhängiger und damit sicherer machen
Diese Groschen ist in Berlin leider noch nicht gefallen.
zeit.de/wissenschaft/umwelt/…
Induction retweeted
You are far too kind to your enemies. Renewables advocates are either greedy psychopaths or gullible morons - and both are lying through their teeth. No amount of informed technical debate will ever change their minds. The last twenty years proves that. It is either ideological, or a determination to keep filling their boots at our expense. You cannot hate them enough.
We need a less heated debate about energy. People like Sunny are at least debating in good faith and solutions focused.
On energy and climate, we need to relearn the art of moderation. Indeed I'd say this is something we need to re-learn full stop in national politics. The Greeks understood that nothing in excess serves us well.
Induction retweeted
Replying to @neso_energy
@neso_energy and @FintanSlye_neso continue to astonish with their sheer ineptitude
You know you have multiple whistleblowers yet you think nothing of spouting such nonsense knowing there's a good chance the whistleblowers will repeat it because their concern appears to be that NESO management is more focused on PR than running the grid securely
How stupid do you have to be to keep blatantly doing the thing the whistleblowers were complaining about in the first place?
In any case, @ofgem has just announced it's going to investigate system security over the late June period, so let's see if Ofgem agrees that cutting exports to the Netherlands without their prior knowledge or consent is consistent with safe operation of the grid
Let's see if that aligns with agreed operational procedures
NESO already admitted yesterday that Corporate Affairs WAS involved in operational decisions. It said this made no difference, but admitted the media team wasn't just informed about operational decisions, it had "input" into them
How is THAT acceptable? What exactly does the PR team contribute to operational decision making? Are these people trained engineers? I doubt it so what do they contribute to these decisions?
I agree with @ClaireCoutinho that the control room staff do a vital job, and they do it well with outdated tools and apparently an unsupportive management. That they have kept the lights on despite demand forecasting that's a joke in the industry is amazing
But if the system is insecure this luck won't last. In a rapidly evolving grid, increasing parts of which the control room can't even see or communicate with this luck is likely to run out
I have written time and again of the problems...
* demand forecasting models not updated in "10-20 years"
* balancing tools (SORT) written in the 1980s, a literal relic of privatisation. A 2009 project to replace it was scrapped in 2024
* increasing amounts of solar and batteries on the low voltage grid which NESO cannot see or control... It has to try and guess what it's doing
* tens of thousands of balancing actions being taken per day when the automated tools that communicate these to power station control rooms (EDL/EDT) is also old and prone to outages. When it's offline instructions are made by phone... Imagine trying to instruct thousands of batteries by phone in real time when you have maybe 20 people in the control room!
Several people in the NESO control room have clearly decided the risks are so high they have gone outside all internal process and blown the whistle to the Shadow Secretary of State
The response of NESO, @Ed_Miliband and @mgshanks validates their approach
Claire Coutinho has promised not to let this go, as has @TiceRichard who also wrote to NESO with concerns about grid safety last month
@ofgem has weighed in saying it expects to be kept updated on the progress of the NESO investigation and that it is essential that engineers are able to speak to the external investigators without their managers knowing who said what
Otherwise we may find more whistleblowers coming forward
NESO and Fintan Slye need to stop fighting the PR battle and start asking why their own engineers think the grid isn't safe
Because I'd take the word of a control room engineer who's doing the job every day over the word of the CEO or comms team on engineering matters without any hesitation. The question is, why won't they?
@Ed_Miliband @ClaireCoutinho @AndrewBowie_MP @griffitha @NJ_Timothy @TiceRichard @DavidGHFrost @mattwridley @cmackinlay @Iromg @AllisonPearson @MerrynSW @EdConwaySky @mattotele @jonathan_leake @afneil @ofgem @energygovuk
The control room engineers at the NESO balance Britain’s electricity supply and demand.
If they don’t get it right, the lights go out and people die.
This is, in part, why I have been approached by multiple whistleblowers from within NESO who are concerned that it is getting harder to keep the lights on in Britain.
Few things can be more serious. As we saw in last year’s Iberian blackout, without electricity, people die.
The allegations made to me are threefold.
First, on 23 June, NESO failed to meet standards on constraints and reserves put in place to prevent blackouts.
Second, the Corporate Affairs team interfered with operational decisions, prioritising NESO's reputation over security of supply.
And third, operational decisions are being kept in ‘live documents’ with no audit trail, therefore preventing them from being accessed for Freedom of Information requests.
It is undeniable that the system is becoming harder to balance.
And yet, as of Monday, NESO launched an investigation into allegations of bad record-keeping and interference from their PR team, but it will not include whether control room operators think the system is being run securely.
I understand that at an all-staff meeting yesterday, Fintan Slye, NESO’s Chief Executive, said “my” allegations were false.
The problem is that these are not my allegations – they are the allegations of his own staff.
If this remark was indeed said, it would be an extraordinary prejudgment of the whistleblowers’ concerns and would potentially deter other people from coming forward.
Ed Miliband and his ministers, in a grotesque show of complacency, dismissed me as “scaremongering”.
Ofgem, the regulator responsible for monitoring NESO, are seemingly fine taking a backseat role.
As for NESO, their reaction has been to tell staff, who are so worried they have resorted to whistleblowing, that their concerns are false – rather than to seriously consider whether they have a problem.
And who will be to blame if it all goes wrong? I fear in the court of public opinion it will be the control room operators, who do an enormous and increasingly difficult service for our country.
That’s why I am fighting their corner now.
They deserve to be listened to and to have their worries addressed.
I can assure them I will not stop until that happens.
Induction retweeted
Abandon Net Zero and slash the size of the state.
Labour's Clive Lewis, "We were more exposed than any other country in the 2008 financial crash"
"Brexit has clobbered us financially, we all accept that"
"Covid has smashed us harder, we've not recovered compared to many of our OECD competitors"
"We're in a bad place"
"It would be nice to have some sort of consensus, politically, on how we get ourselves from the hole that we are in, to where we need to be"
"Public services are broken, we need to fix them, we need to rebuild this country, rebuild it's purpose"
"How can we have some sort of consensus about how we do that"
"The public are losing faith in the two main political parties turning elsewhere, which may not be the right answer"
Induction retweeted
Kemi Badenoch is right.
The UK cannot reach net zero by 2050.
It would cost over 3 trillion pounds, according to Cambridge’s Emeritus Professor of Engineering.
It means sending our carbon emissions abroad. Makes not a jot of difference while impoverishing Britain.
@KemiBadenoch
Induction retweeted
If renewables are cheaper, why did we pay a record £2.4bn in CfD subsidies last year? Average IMRP last year was £67/MWh. We paid over £150/MWh for offshore wind.
Replying to @7Kiwi
No this is nonsense. We all know electricity is cheaper when it's not from Gas..that's why smart tariffs work. We pay less when grid is less reliant on Gas. The secret therefore is use Heat Pumps and EVs to more efficiently use clean energy when it exists. That strategy works.
Induction retweeted
Every single person who calls oil and gas companies “evil” should be forced to remove hydrocarbons from their day-to-day lives and see how long they can live a “net zero” lifestyle. Most cannot function without a WiFi connection for more than an hour, much less survive a cold winter night without natural gas. I am all for exploring alternative energy sources, but I’m not going to demonize the primary energy sources that sustain modern civilization and net benefit us all.
Induction retweeted
To the surprise of absolutely no one, the Chinese coal trade body forecasts the country will boost coal consumption again in 2025, up ~1% to a fresh record high.
Chinese coal consumption is the elephant in the room of climate change.
#Coal #China
bloomberg.com/news/articles/…
Induction retweeted
UK electricity “system price” (marginal cost of balancing actions taken by @neso_energy) surges to £2,900 per MWh in effort to keep the lights on.
Rye House gas-fired plant, owned my commodity trader Vitol, getting paid an eye-watering >£5,000 per MWh.
Intermittency is costly.
Induction retweeted
They expect us to believe that spending £264-290bn from now until 2030 will being down costs. Even that is an under-estimate. They're away with the fairies.
New advice from @neso_energy confirmed that clean power by 2030 is achievable, cheaper & will create a more secure power system.
Our clean power mission will help us move from volatile fossil fuel markets to clean homegrown power controlled in 🇬🇧
Watch @StarkClimate explain📽️
Induction retweeted
Our Demand Flexibility Service delivered electricity to power 10 million households ⚡🏡 Read our article to find out which regions saved the most electricity during peak times across 1.6 million homes and businesses. More 👇
Induction retweeted
The size of the UK energy bail-out is off-the charts. According to @alexwickham, on top of the £130 billion to freeze household energy bills, Liz Truss is mulling another £40 billion for small business.
The ~£170 billion equals to the annual NHS budget, and it's >5% of GDP
Induction retweeted
German energy prices are on the rise again. Gas price jumps 30.4% while 1y power price +29% after Russia cut off the gas.
Induction retweeted
BREAKING: British energy regulator Ofgem lifts 80% the country's retail gas / electricity price cap to £3,549 from October 1. "The increase reflects the continued rise in global wholesale gas prices," Ofgem says | #EnergyCrisis #EnergyTwitter


























