Andrew Nicholls (@Woirble) profile picture
Joined August 2017
Photo by Andrew Nicholls (@Woirble)
$SOC PHMSA has brought a motion to dismiss the case in the 9th Circuit attacking PHMSA determination pipeline is interstate on basis case is now moot. On June 26, 2026, PHMSA issued four documents: (1) a special permit that supplants the prior emergency special permit; (cont.)
5
4
37
6,850
(2) analysis and findings supporting the special permit; (3) a superseding jurisdictional determination (with more detailed and reasoned basis); and (4) a finding of no significant environmental impact for the pipeline that applies to the restart plan.
1
19
1,275
drive.google.com/file/d/1GuN… $SOC Transcript of the June 8 hearing for the motions in the DPA case and the Consent Decree case is attached. No decision in any of the motions. Judge Wilson asked the parties to prepare and file summary briefs that focus on key arguments.
6
4
1
48
17,624
$SOC Judge Wilson has allowed the U.S. to intervene in the Cal. Department of Parks and Rec v. Sable case (Gaviota Park) based on arguments in briefs. Hearing of that motion on June 8 cancelled. Still have June 8 motions in DPA case, CD case, and motion to remand Geck case.
6
3
49
5,282
$SOC Judge Wilson rescheduled hearing for motion for reconsideration of Judge Geck's Prelim. inj. to June 29 at 1:30 p.m.. Still hearing ex parte motion for remand + regular motion for remand June 8. Seems odd. If JW grants either of those, no need for June 29 hearing.
5
2
27
3,300
$SOC Judge Wilson just rescheduled the motion hearing in the Consent Decree case (motion to enforce vs. motion to terminate/modify) from June 1 to June 8. JW has not moved the June 1 hearing date for the Cali motion for a preliminary injunction/stay in the DPA order case.
6
6
38
4,285
$SOC CBD v. OSFM (former Geck case removed to federal court) has been reassigned to Judge Wilson. Expected but still good news. Judge Wilson will decide ex parte Motion to Remand back to Judge Geck, regular Motion to Remand, and, if no remand, motion to dissolve Geck PI.
3
5
40
3,732
$SOC Judge Anderle should release his tentative ruling today for the hearing tomorrow. Grok: any appeal of JA's decision will be to Division 6 of the 2nd Appellate District. There are only 3 justices in Division 6, (continued)
4
3
33
3,776
The hearing tomorrow is for CCC's motion for judgment on the pleadings for the remaining outstanding claims and Sable's motion to file a third amended complaint and amended answer that adds claims and defenses related to PHMSA determinations and DPA order. (continued)
1
7
1,009
If Sable is given leave to file its Third Amended Complaint, it will require JA to reconsider earlier decisions, almost restarting the case. It seems likely Sable would then seek to remove case to federal court (like case formerly before Judge Geck).
3
10
874
$SOC Sable filed a Motion to reconsider and Dissolve Judge Geck's preliminary injunction (which survived the transfer to federal court). Expect enviro groups to file motion to enforce PI/contempt hearing soon. Nothing surprising. Battle rejoined in new federal court setting.
1
2
31
2,625
From Motion: the federal court judge (once assigned) can reconsider existing preliminary injunctions. The preliminary injunction is an attempt to enforce the Consent Decree in the wrong forum, and Cali is already trying to enforce the CD in the CD case before Judge Wilson.
1
12
698
Cali's motion to "enforce" the CD in the CD case will be heard by Judge Wilson on June 1 along with U.S. motion to terminate the CD. That motion will likely determine whether Judge Geck's preliminary injunction is dissolved.
3
2
18
7,618
$SOC Sable filed a Notice of Related Cases in CBD v. OSFM (the newly transferred to federal court former Judge Geck case). I expect that the case (26-cv-5242) will be assigned/reassigned to Judge Wilson. Expected but comforting to see.
1
2
32
2,146
$SOC U.S. and Sable Joint Notice of removal posted on the SB Superior Court website for case 25-cv-2244. Judge Geck ordered Sable not to obey the DPA order. "The United States is therefore removing this case to defend itself in a federal forum." U.S. should be intervening.
4
6
44
3,826
Grok: the removal of the case to federal court halts all state court proceedings. May 22 hearing is cancelled. Once a federal judge is assigned to the case (and the U.S. already noted the case is related to the cases already before Judge Wilson), new judge determines next steps
1
1
2
24
3,606
$SOC Dintzer also said in the hearing on May 14 that 50 to 55k bpd are flowing through the pipeline! Sounds like the first 2 platforms are almost fully online and production is consistent with what Sable said on April 20 in its news release. 3rd plat said to add 10k+ in June.
5
5
37
2,233
This is a link to the archived hearing video. jcc.granicus.com/player/clip… Dintzer says 50K to 55k bpd at approximately 39:05 in the video.
11
566
$SOC "Plaintiff California Department of Parks and Recreation (“State Parks”) intends to oppose the Motion to Intervene by the United States of America (ECF 52). State Parks intends to timely file this opposition on May 18, 2026." (continued)
1
15
2,287
"State Parks does not presently plan to oppose the Motion for Relief from Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 24(c) by the United States of America (ECF 53). Dated: May 8, 2026." @victoryII1
2
9
609